Perhaps. Certainly one <i>could</i> make the argument. My point was more that it would be a major uphill battle to get <i>damages in excess of a total refund</i> from the seller<p>Among the many issues, another raised here is the presence of specifically enumerated remedies:<p>&gt;  Failure to fulfill your orders will lead to charges as stated in the Seller Policies.<p>Which could well be interpreted as limiting the liability of the seller to the fines specified in the seller policies.<p>Clearly there&#x27;s some kind of contract here to give money in exchange for the ticket -- the question is <i>how high are the damages</i> in the event of non performance of the contract, and what <i>further</i> remedies are available once a refund has been issued.