<a href="http:&#x2F;&#x2F;economictimes.indiatimes.com&#x2F;tech&#x2F;internet&#x2F;aircel-to-offer-free-basic-internet-across-india-in-a-year&#x2F;articleshow&#x2F;49380597.cms" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;economictimes.indiatimes.com&#x2F;tech&#x2F;internet&#x2F;aircel-to-...</a><p>There are better ways of giving out Internet for free. By giving out slower internet. Or internet with a free data cap. Or a way of &quot;earning&quot; Internet data after watching some ads (see: Grameenphone in Bangladesh). I&#x27;d somewhat agree with the &quot;Some Internet is better than No internet&quot; argument, except that there are better ways of doing the &quot;some Internet&quot; which Facebook isn&#x27;t doing.<p>&gt; why not facebook provide free internet access to poor.<p>Facebook isn&#x27;t even paying for the data in Free Basics. The telecom operators are (I assume their business plan is to get more people hooked onto the Internet so eventually more customers for them. A valid plan.). They can use the same business plan (in a net neutral way) for the slower internet or internet with a data cap options; and I believe that&#x27;s what Aircel is doing.<p>(Aside: When you look at it this way it becomes even more obvious how devious Facebook is here -- without putting in money of their own to finance the actual data, they, a third party, jumped in and convinced telecom operators to enact a scheme which <i>Facebook</i> has a lot of control over despite not being the primary financers of the scheme. They get lots of credit <i>and</i> lots of control, without actually doing anything. When framed this way the parallels with the Brits&#x27; takeover of India seem a lot more real.)<p>And really, the &quot;no access&quot; part of your argument isn&#x27;t really well founded either. For most, data plan costs aren&#x27;t the barrier to internet access (in fact, a smartphone capable of working with the modern internet[1] is more expensive than a few years&#x27; worth of basic data).<p>[1]: Fun fact: Facebook&#x27;s mobile app evolves pretty fast and becomes unusable on older phones either due to browser compatibility, OS compatibility, or speed issues. Same with many other sites and apps.