That&#x27;s not an argument. Could you explain why you disagree?<p>It seems that in the absence of a warning, there is no informed consent; asking for a warning allows for freedom of association.<p>If the OP had said &quot;being open to guilt etc is an integral part of our university; as such, anyone refusing to go to this talk will be expelled. However, we will tell people in advance, so they can choose not to go, and then leave.&quot; I would support him. To specifically say &quot;I&#x27;m not telling people about what will happen&quot; means you don&#x27;t want people to know in advance. How is that not deceptive?<p>As I noted above, the argument that the student chose a Christian college and therefore should know about it falls flat, because the student did <i>not</i> know about it. And if knowing was a good thing, then so would a trigger warning on the talk; it&#x27;s literally accomplishing the task of making sure people know.