&gt; I also struggle with domestic re-distribution through &quot;citizen income&quot;, because it makes life worst for all that pay taxes and those that are not &quot;citizen&quot; (foreigners, immigrants, etc.).<p>It has very little real effect on middle income taxpayers who both pay for and receive it, because in the middle range the benefit cancels the tax.<p>And the consequence for immigrants is hugely advantageous to nearly everyone. The problem we have today is that we have a large number of undocumented immigrants, which consume the capacity we have to absorb immigrants and therefore reduce the number of <i>documented</i> immigrants we can reasonably accept.<p>Something that makes it economically infeasible to be an undocumented immigrant would allow us to accept that many more documented immigrants through official channels and give them the basic income, thereby allowing much the same people to immigrate, modulo the few criminals who can&#x27;t pass the background check and we don&#x27;t want anyway. And then they&#x27;re above board and don&#x27;t have to live in the shadows, which is clearly much better for them. But meanwhile it allows us to affirmatively choose how much immigration we want instead of having people who break the law choose for us.