method_name
string
results
list
baseline_patching
[ { "model_id": "LlamaForCausalLM", "task_scores": { "MCQA": [ { "layer": "0", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "1", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "2", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "3", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "4", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "5", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "6", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "7", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "8", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "9", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "10", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "11", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "12", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.125 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "13", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "14", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "15", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.875 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "16", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.875 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "17", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.875 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "18", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "19", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.125 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.375 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.875 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.625 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "20", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.75 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.25 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "21", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.75 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.25 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "22", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.75 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.125 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.25 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.875 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "23", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.75 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.125 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.25 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0.875 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "24", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "25", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "26", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "27", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "28", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "29", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "30", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] }, { "layer": "31", "layer_scores": [ { "intervention": [ "output_token" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 } ] }, { "intervention": [ "output_location" ], "counterfactual_scores": [ { "counterfactual": [ "symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "randomLetter_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_counterfactual" ], "score": 1 }, { "counterfactual": [ "answerPosition_symbol_counterfactual" ], "score": 0 } ] } ] } ] } } ]