anchor: In the New Republic , Tony Judt calls Sidney Blumenthal's claim in The New Yorker that Whittaker Chambers attacked Alger Hiss because of spurned gay love a smear, 1990s style.
positive: Tony Judt says that Sidney Blumenthal is being disingenuous with the claim in The New Yorker.
negative: Sidney Blumenthal claims that Whittaker Chambers attacked Alger Hiss because of a dispute over the wrong coffee.