Overdrive is better. The only real improvement was being able to listen to audiobooks at 3x speed (Overdrive only goes up to 2x) & being able to see all your holds across all your libraries without having to switch between them. Everything else Libby has made more difficult, downloads take forever and often have to be deleted and restarted. And even when successfully downloaded, listening offline will get you an error message please reconnect to the internet, so what's the point of downloading?