Well I've finally figured out why I can't get Club Points. They are scamming us. Basically, every time you cloud save they falsely multiply your magic points so that you are never able to actually break through to start earning again. Tech support said my highest magic was 37,871 and I had to have more than that to earn. Except that is a lie. I JUST unlocked the spot in my garden for 21,000 magic. They falsely pad your magic number, but give you none of the benefits. It's all a scam.