Bruce DeMara of "The Toronto Star" rated it 1.5/4 stars and wrote that the film's humor never rises beyond the French pun used for Fafard's character. Leslie Felperin of "The Guardian" rated it 3/5 stars and wrote, "You can't help but warm to this old-school Canadian horror-comedy about a law enforcer with a snout for crime". Craig Anderson of "Fangoria" rated it 4/5 stars and wrote, "While "Wolfcop" does tend to overreach, and too-often falls back on its predictable buddy-cop formula splatstick shtick, it's still plenty fun". Andrew Mack of Twitch Film wrote, "It is a mix of horror and comedy that does not take off right away but builds momentum to a satisfying conclusion." Scott Hallam of Dread Central rated it 3.5/5 stars and wrote, "If you enjoy a horror-comedy that's just out for a laugh and never takes itself too seriously, you'll enjoy "WolfCop"." The soundtrack was composed by Saskatoon, Saskatchewan instrumental band Shooting Guns and Toby Bond, who joined the band shortly after. The band composed 76 minutes of original material for the score and released the WolfCop Original Soundtrack on vinyl and limited-release cassette through One Way Static in September 2014. The soundtrack was also released digitally in Sept 2014 through RidingEasy Records. In an interview with "Fangoria", director Lowell Dean confirmed a sequel to the film. "Another WolfCop" was filmed in Lumsden, Saskatchewan, in the early months of 2016, featuring most of the same characters, played by the same actors (most of whom are locals of Regina, Saskatchewan). It was released on 1 December 2017.