The band toured the Southeast region of the United States in early 2005, before returning to Jersey to open for Blowfly on 14 April at Asbury Lanes. Barry and the Penetrators performed at the 2008 Bamboozle music festival. Barry and the Penetrators signed with Suburban Noize Records, and released their third full length album, entitled "Tales from Dirty Jersey", in 2008. "Asbury Park Press" calls the record "their most mature album to date," with Peterson saying that "I've grown up a lot." By 2011, their first record had sold over ten-thousand copies, and the group was recognized as "dominating the Jersey coastline with a blend of dub reggae that you didn't know existed anymore, combining it with loud, dynamic punk rock and turning any old show into a full-on party." They released the single "Wicked Game" in 2011, along with a music video, which contains footage of the band at the beach, swimming in a pool, and riding along the coastline. Barry and the Penetrators have won several Asbury Music Awards throughout the years. They have shared the stage with the Bouncing Souls, the Descendents, Dick Dale,  Burning Spear, Fishbone, Pepper, Eek-A-Mouse, Slightly Stoopid, The English Beat, Third World, Yellowman and the Wailers.