After an extensive decade of being in front of audiences, McGill decided to follow his true passion for choreographing and directing. McGill was Associate Choreographer of the Broadway production of "Hedwig and the Angry Inch" starring Neil Patrick Harris, Andrew Rannells, Michael C Hall, John Cameron Mitchell, Darren Criss, and Taye Diggs. His job was to teach and tailor the choreography for each new Hedwig performer. Upon receiving an honorary Tony Award, the show's writer and original star, John Cameron Mitchell, publicly thanked Paul among other members of the creative team. Shortly thereafter, McGill choreographed three Off-Broadway plays in one season. "The Legend of Georgia McBride", written by Matthew Lopez, directed by Mike Donahue, and produced by MCC Theater, played at the Lucille Lortel Theatre and at the Geffen Playhouse in Los Angeles in 2017. Following its success, He choreographed "Steve", written by Marc Gerard, directed by Cynthia Nixon, and produced by the New Group at the Signature Theatre Company. The final play of the season, which he also associate directed, was "The School for Scandal" written by Richard Brinsley Sheridan, directed by Marc Vietor, and produced by the Red Bull Theater Company again at the Lucille Lortel Theatre. Because of his flying experience in "", McGill choreographed for the aerial dance company, Grounded Aerial, as well as "Filament", a new circus work by Joseph Pinzon's company, Short-Round Productions. He has also choreographed the feature film called "Diamond Soles", which has yet to be released. In 2017, he trained Laverne Cox in Los Angeles for her role as Dr. Frank-N-Furter in "The Rocky Horror Picture Show" on Fox. In 2016, McGill started Broadway Masters with internet entrepreneur Marcus Lovingood. The program is an online streaming digital masterclass series bringing together Broadway stars and their advice on how to make it on Broadway. The first season of masterclasses include Taye Diggs, Anthony Rapp, Laura Osnes, Jon Rua, Courtney Reed, Charlotte D'Amboise, Nick Adams, Lindsay Mendez, Kurt Froman and McGill himself. The program was launched on November 10, 2016 to worldwide audiences.