The BBC said Gaby's most notable moment was "Surviving a plane crash with Annalise." A writer for "Inside Soap" said "Gorgeous Gaby has had so many job changes she would make a great careers adviser!" The added that if only her love life had been as successful as her employment record. Another writer stated Gaby and Glen had Ramsay Street's biggest on-off romance since Scott (Jason Donovan) and Charlene (Kylie Minogue). During a feature on "Neighbours", Anna Pickard of "The Guardian" tried to choose the characters she would be most starstruck by if she met them. She said "It would have to be the Willis family. All of them. Pam, Doug, Adam, Gaby, Brad and Cody". In September 2014, Mark James Lowe from "All About Soap" called for Gaby's return to "Neighbours" following the reappearances of Brad, Doug and Pam. He commented, "we last saw a glimpse of her almost a decade ago in Annalise's documentary… so we desperately want to know what Gaby's been up to since!" In 2015, Lowe colleague Kerry Barrett placed Gaby at number 26 on the magazine's list of 30 favourite "Neighbours" characters. Barrett quipped "Smart Gaby was clever, stylish, successful and could even fly a plane!". Barrett thought Gaby's had a lot of "unsuitable boyfriends" and her best moment was "crash landing her plane."