Tampa Catholic's latest title came in 2009, as the Crusaders won the district 3A-11 title. Tampa Catholic is currently coached by Ty Griffin. Their baseball program has produced many top players, such as Denard Span (Tampa Bay Rays), Kenny Kelly (Tampa Bay Rays and other teams) and Charles Cleveland (Florida State University). TC has retired the number 19 in baseball. Tampa Catholic Crew is a co-ed sport that competes against other high school and youth rowing teams. The team began in the 1999-2000 school year. The program has grown each year, adding boats, training equipment, and soon a new boat house. At the Southeast Regional Championship Regatta held May 9-10th 2009 in Oak Ridge, Tennessee, the girls' novice four captured a silver medal. In the qualifying heat, the girls rowed the 2000 meter course in a time of 7 minutes 56 seconds, which was fast enough to capture both second place and a spot in the finals. In the finals the girls again took second place. In 2009 and 2010, the women's lightweight double, with Caitlin Mooney and Gabriella Gonzalez, qualified for and attended Scholastic Nationals in Camden, New Jersey (2009) and Saratoga, New York (2010). In 2011, the men's varsity 4+ placed 6th scholastically at the Florida State Championship Regatta. They then qualified and attended Scholastic Nationals in Camden, New Jersey. In January 2014, Tampa Catholic was the subject of illegal recruiting allegations when sophomore football player Nate Craig transferred from Pasco High School. One day after Craig began classes, Pasco football coach Tom McHugh alleged in an email to the FHSAA that Craig had "told him a Hillsborough County coach had asked him and his mother to change schools because he 'would fit perfectly into their team.'" Craig's mother responded that her had son transferred for "academic reasons." Soon after, Sunlake High School also accused Tampa Catholic of recruiting after two of its players allegedly approached and told Sunlake officials that Crusaders coaches had asked them about transferring. The players also stated that a Tampa Catholic coach had come to their homes with scholarship offers, and said they would have better scholarship opportunities by leaving Pasco County. In March 2015, the investigation ended after the FHSAA found insufficient evidence to support the claims. In June 2019, a custodian at Tampa Catholic was arrested on charges of sexually abusing a student.