Kadokawa Media Factory's book and manga news magazine "Da Vinci" ranked the series number 19 on its 2017 "Book of the Year" list. "Tokyo Tarareba Girls" was nominated for the 9th Manga Taishō in 2016, finishing in ninth place with 29 points. It was also nominated for Best General Manga at the 40th Kodansha Manga Awards in 2016. The manga won an Eisner Award in the category "Best U.S. Edition of International Material—Asia" in 2019.