I've never been more excited for the second half of Season 4." Sydney Bucksbaum of "The Hollywood Reporter" wrote, "Easily one of the best parts of Gotham — used infrequently given his series regular fan-favorite role on Showtime's "Shameless" — Jerome's return came as a true shock in the final moments of the fall finale. There couldn't have been any better way to keep fans on the hook over the long winter hiatus. The idea of Penguin and Jerome teaming to exact their revenge on Gotham is pretty great. Bring on the insanity!" Vinnie Mancuso of "Collider" wrote, "For this episode, all I can say is this: I felt equally devastated when a lost young man fired the one guiding light in his life as I was when a woman shot a flamboyant pig-obsessed serial killer with a southern accent in the back. "Gotham" is great because "Gotham" is...a lot." Lisa Babick of "TV Fanatic" gave the series a 4 star rating out of 5, writing "Girl power! Sofia Falcone showed everyone who was boss on "Gotham" Season 4 Episode 11 as we learned just how far she was willing to go to take control of Gotham's underbelly. Carmine did a better job of teaching his daughter the ins and outs of criminal activity than he could have ever imagined." Marc Buxton of "Den of Geek" gave wrote, "But with an important role for the always awesome Zsasz, the return of Jerome, and the death of Carmine Falcone, let’s call this winter finale a win."