With Webster back, Haukar made it to the Úrvalsdeild finals against Njarðvík. Haukar won the series 3-0 after beating Njarðvík 92-91 in double overtime in the third game. Webster scored 6 points in the deciding game and blocked Friðrik Ragnarsson's potential game winning shot at the end of the first overtime. Webster joined KR again for the 1988–1989 season and helped them to the third best record in the Úrvalsdeild while leading the league in rebounds per game. In the playoffs KR surprised many by sweeping top seeded Njarðvík in the semi-finals, paving the way for Webster's second straight trip to the Úrvalsdeild finals. In the finals, KR met Keflavík. After splitting the first two games of the series, KR was no match for Keflavík in the third and deciding game, losing 89-72. In June, Webster left KR and rejoined Haukar once again. Between 1984 and 1987, Webster played 37 games for the Icelandic national basketball team. He was the first foreigner to play for the national team. Webster had a roles in the 1984 film Gullsandur and the 1989 Icelandic film Under the Glacier (Icelandic: Kristnihald undir Jökli) as well as an appearance in the Áramótaskaupið.