Goldschmidt replied in a pamphlet, ""Die Recension des Herrn Dr. D. Hoffmann über Meine Talmudausgabe im Lichte der Wahrheit"," Charlottenburg, 1896. See also ""Theologische Literaturzeitung"," 1896, pp. 477-479, and 1897, pp. 631-633. His translation of the Babylonian Talmud appeared from Leipzig 1897 to completion in London 1935.