Jessica Morris of Jesus Wired rated the album an eight out of ten stars, calling it "A convoluted yet simple album, "A Night To Remember" sees Shonlock exercising the best of his musical abilities, drawing his audience closer to the truth of God." For the "Billboard" charting week of April 5, 2014, "A Night to Remember" charted at No. 20 on the Top Heatseekers Albums, No. 46 on the Christian Albums, and No. 14 on the Gospel Albums chart.