Her next role was in the 1990 film "Chicago Joe and the Showgirl"; Roger Ebert commented that Lloyd "shows again, in only her fourth role, what a remarkable new talent she is." Shortly thereafter she began dating Gavin Rossdale. According to Lloyd the relationship was troubled, and one night at his apartment alone, she attempted suicide by taking aspirin and slashing her wrists. She was found by one of Rossdale's friends and spent the next six weeks in hospital. She was cast in Woody Allen's 1992 film "Husbands and Wives", but was fired by him after two weeks due to her ill health. Allen complained Lloyd was spending too much time in her trailer; Lloyd later stated that was because she was making herself vomit. Later in 1992, she had a supporting role in Robert Redford's "A River Runs Through It". "The Hollywood Reporter" said that Lloyd provided "another memorable performance", while Malcolm Johnson from the "Hartford Courant" said she and co-star Brad Pitt brought "verve and charm" to the film. In 1995, she was initially cast as the eponymous lead character for the film "Tank Girl". The film's director, Rachel Talalay, states she fired Lloyd for refusing to shave her head for the role. Lloyd, who had spent four months training for the film, disputes this, saying she simply rescheduled her appointment with the film's hair stylist to the following day, after which Talalay ostensibly fired her for "being difficult". Lloyd said she was actually fired due to their personality clashes. Lloyd states she "went to pieces" after "Tank Girl", believing she was cursed. In 1996, she appeared in the Sean Bean football film "When Saturday Comes". In 1997, Lloyd went to India where she consumed the anti-malaria drug mefloquine, which is contraindicated for people with mental disorders. Despite this, she continued to work in film, having a supporting role in the critically acclaimed 1997 film "Welcome to Sarajevo", and also appeared in the film "Boogie Boy" that year. In 1998, she appeared in the film "Brand New World", her last performance until she played the lead role in the independent thriller "The Honeytrap" in 2002, for which she received critical acclaim. The following year, she starred in the film "Riverworld". Lloyd made her début on the stage in 1996 as Bella Kooling in "Max Klapper" at the Electric Cinema.