Alex Henderson of Allmusic gave "Allroy Saves" two and a half stars out of five, remarking that it "has its moments but could have been much stronger. Some of the songs are fun and catchy enough, most notably 'Just Like Them', 'Educated Idiot', and the goofy 'Frog'. But most of the material is disposable, and when you look at the CD on the whole, you realize how unfocused and generally disappointing it is. "Allroy Saves" is an album that only completists will find of interest."