In 2012, she had a supporting voice role in the animated feature film "The Lorax" and a small appearance in "The Dictator". In 2013, Pedrad had another supporting voice role in "Despicable Me 2". In the autumn of 2014, she left "Saturday Night Live" to star in a new Fox sitcom, "Mulaney". On October 18, 2014, Fox shut down production of the series by reducing the 16-episode order by three episodes. Filming for the thirteenth episode had just been completed prior to the order reduction, and the fourteenth episode was about to enter production. Beginning in 2015, Pedrad has a recurring guest role as LAPD officer Aly Nelson on the Fox sitcom "New Girl". She portrayed Gigi Caldwell in season one of Fox horror-comedy "Scream Queens". In 2016, she appeared in a commercial for Old Navy alongside comedian Kumail Nanjiani and other "SNL" cast members Cecily Strong and Jay Pharoah. In 2017, she joined the cast of season two of the TBS comedy series "People of Earth". Later that same year, she also made guest appearances on "Curb Your Enthusiasm" and "Brooklyn Nine-Nine".