Democrats also won three Republican held congressional seats, all in Upstate New York. Democrat Michael Arcuri won the open seat of retiring Republican Sherwood Boehlert in the 24th Congressional District, which stretches across Central New York from Utica to Oneonta to the Finger Lakes. Democrat Kirsten Gillibrand defeated Republican incumbent John Sweeney in the 20th Congressional District, which includes Saratoga Springs and Glens Falls and takes in most of the upper Hudson Valley. Democrat John Hall defeated Republican incumbent Sue Kelly in the 19th Congressional district in the Lower Hudson Valley outside New York City. Of the nine Republican incumbents up for reelection in 2006, only one, John McHugh in the 23rd district (the far northern region of the state) won reelection with over 60% of the vote. Republicans James Walsh of Syracuse, Tom Reynolds of Clarence and Randy Kuhl of Bath all won re-election by narrow margins. Democratic Senator Hillary Clinton was re-elected to a 2nd 6-year term. She was first elected in 2000. Eliot Spitzer, a Democrat, was elected to replace retiring George Pataki, a Republican. Andrew Cuomo was elected to replace fellow Democrat Eliot Spitzer, who was elected governor. Democratic Comptroller Alan Hevesi was re-elected. He then resigned.