After appearing in just one game with Carolina, Trudeau retired following the 1995 season. Trudeau finished his ten-year NFL career with 10,243 passing yards, 42 touchdowns, 69 interceptions, and a 63.3 passer rating in 67 games. He is married to wife (Lisa), with a daughter (Danielle) and three sons (John, Beau, and Trey). His brother, Kevin Trudeau, was drafted at age 18 as a pitcher for the New York Yankees organization. Also, after retirement from football, Jack invested to be a co-owner of Wolf Run Golf Club in Indiana. . He was a weekly guest on The Bob and Tom Show, broadcast out of Indianapolis, for many seasons, discussing the Colts and other happenings in the NFL. On June 2, 2007, Trudeau was arrested and charged with contributing to the delinquency of a minor when he hosted a Park Tudor high school graduation party for his daughter, who was not arrested, but was breathalyzed along with her three younger brothers (none of whom tested positive for any alcohol). Depositions further prove that some of the graduating students brought concealed alcohol into the party. On August 10, 2007, Trudeau was offered a plea agreement, in which he was to accept responsibility for the party. On December 14, 2007, Trudeau and his wife accepted an agreement where they will each have to pay a $2,500 fine. However, neither of them had to plead guilty to their charges. In 2010, Trudeau began hosting a local sports talk morning show with Zakk Tyler on WNDE in Indianapolis. The next year, the show (called "Zakk and Jack") was picked up for national syndication by Fox Sports Radio to replace the departing Stephen A. Smith. The show was cancelled by FSR later that same year, as the pair were replaced by Andy Furman and former NFL defensive back Artrell Hawkins. Trudeau was involved in a controversial exchange in August 2011 with then first-year Indiana Hoosiers football head coach Kevin Wilson. During the interview, Wilson responded to Trudeau's mocking of Indiana's football team by pointing out the former quarterback's criminal history. Trudeau was arrested for his second DUI in Indiana in July 2015 along with allegations of intimidating a police officer after testing 0.31 on a breath test and threatening to kill an Indiana officer. He was arrested previously in 1990.