Sonia Teodoriu, Florentina Hariton, Alexandra Stroe and Adrian Țofei are so convincing that, at times, it’s uncomfortable to watch." Dean Bertram from A Night of Horror described "Be My Cat: A Film for Anne" as "the most revolutionary addition to the found footage genre since The Blair Witch Project and infinitely more convincing and frightening" and Lloyd Kaufman from TromaDance wrote that it's "a new masterpiece in horror". Audiences Everywhere named it "dangerous and progressive" and added that "the film is fascinating, challenging and essential for the evolution of found footage horror." Mondo Exploito wrote that it "totally transcends the trappings of the found footage subgenre to create a truly unique experience that will be talked about for years to come." Addicted to Horror Movies said it's ""the rare original horror film that fans scream for"", PopHorror wrote, "I couldn't take my eyes off the screen" and Cinehouse called it a "cinematic miracle". Found Footage Critic rated the movie 9.7 out of 10 and wrote that it's "a near perfect horror/thriller found footage film that sets itself apart in acting, cinematography, plot, tone, execution and production value. Found footage fan or not, this is a film you won’t want to miss! The acting of Adrian Țofei and the three supporting cast, Sonia Teodoriu, Florentina Hariton and Alexandra Stroe, is nothing short of exceptional, resulting in a genuineness that I have yet to encounter in any other found footage film to date.". Adrian Țofei received praise for his acting performance as well, which has been described by critics as “incredible", “exceptionally strong", “authentic", “excellent throughout", “complex”, “powerfully convincing”, "captivating", "shockingly good", "haunting" and “frighteningly natural“. PopHorror included it "Top 5 Must-See Indie Horror Performances of the Decade" and Artsploitation said that Țofei did "the most believable movie psychopath since Norman Bates."