The Dance Resource Center of Greater Los Angeles presented the 1995 Lester Horton Dance Award to Diavolo Dance Theater for outstanding achievement in performance/company. The Carpenter Performing Arts Center CSULB honored Diavolo Dance Theater as the Arts in Education Hero of the year 2006 presented for Diavolo's support and dedication to bringing the arts to young people. On September 28, 2007, Diavolo was recognized as a cultural treasure of Los Angeles and was presented the Certificate of Recognition from the City of Los Angeles. Los Angeles Times dance critic Lewis Segal reviewed Diavolo's 2007 and 2010 Hollywood Bowl performances with the LA Philharmonic, saying that Diavolo exemplifies one of "those rare events that define the art of this city, when the levels of vision and support are equally exceptional….[Diavolo] makes precisely coordinated feats look improvisational, even reckless….To say Diavolo is exciting is redundant." In 2017, Diavolo performed in Season 12 of America's Got Talent, debuting in Week 3 as the only acrobatic dance group among several dance troupes. In week 2 of the Semi Finals, Diavolo won the Judges' Choice Award to advance to the Finals, where they finished in the bottom 5 of the top 10.