She also appeared with much success as Mary Wolf in Balfe's opera "The Puritan's Daughter", produced by the Carl Rosa Company  In 1887 she sang Donna Anna in "Don Giovanni". In 1888, "The Pall Mall Gazette" commented that her fine voice seemed entirely to pervade the great space of the Albert Hall with its piercing and sympathetic quality. The "Musical Times" wrote: "She was everywhere known for her graceful acting, which, apart even from the careful manipulation of her pure and beautiful voice, had always made her a favourite with opera-goers." During her career, Cole sang 21 roles. Cole died of dropsy at age 37 at her London home.