The Educational Value was rated 4/5. The Kid Appeal was rated 4.3. The Ease of Use was rated 4.0. South Coast Today appreciated that the series made the activities amusing as well as educational. TechWithKids felt the series had the right combination of scariness and intrigue. "The ClueFinders' 3rd Grade Adventures" a top ten best-selling educational title in retail stores during the months of March, April, and May. By 2001, the first six games had sold around 3.5 million copies. Since its creation in 1998, the ClueFinders series has won over 50 awards and accolades in three years. The Incrdible Toy Store was an Edutaining Kids General Learning software pick of 2001.