It currently has a score of 59/100 on review aggregator Metacritic. David Hinkley of the "New York Daily News" gave the show a positive review, giving the show 4/5 stars, and calling it a "winner". Brian Lowry of "Variety" was doubtful of the series, stating "barring a dramatic leap in quality" it probably wouldn't last on pay cable. Mark Perigard of the "Boston Herald" wrote critically, saying "this sad sack of a show plays like an East Coast, economically challenged version of his HBO hit "Entourage".” Randee Dawn of "The Hollywood Reporter" said the show "isn't as textured and riveting as it thinks it is". Other reviews, however, favored the show in comparison to "Entourage". The second season did not get much positive reception on Metacritic and currently does not hold a Metascore because of lack of enough reviews (However the only two existing reviews are positive). Maureen Ryan of "Huffington Post" wrote the show has "a little more discipline and focus than they did in season 1." Phillip Maciak of "Slant Magazine" also added that the show is "anchored by gorgeous production design and the pop naturalism of its performances, How to Make It in America dramatizes this particular cultural moment with uncommon style and a little grace as well."