Lewis performed "One More Sleep" live at the semi-finals of the tenth series of "The X Factor" on 8 December 2013. The album received generally favourable reviews from critics, with some praising Leona for her vocals but not the material produced. Alexis Petridis from "The Guardian" gave the album two out of five stars and praised its three original songs. He called "Your Hallelujah" a "spectral ballad", and said that "One More Sleep" and "Mr Right" were "enjoyable", but said that covers of songs such as "Christmas (Baby Please Come Home)" and "Winter Wonderland" were "tinged with a sense of pointlessness". AllMusic gave the album four out of five stars, saying "she gets a greater chance to sing here than she did on her third album, "Glassheart", which is reason enough to enjoy the album, but better still is that the Spector salute largely works." and commenting "It's one of the best modern Christmas albums in memory." In Ireland, "Christmas, with Love" debuted at number 45 for the week ending 5 December 2013, and rose to number 36 the following week. In the United Kingdom, "Music Week" writer Paul Williams released a midweek chart reveal on 5 December stating that the album was currently at number 18 on the UK Albums Chart. Williams wrote that the album would be Lewis' lowest charting release to date, following "Spirit", number one in 2007; "Echo", number one in 2009; and "Glassheart", number three in 2012. However, the album officially debuted at number 25 on the chart on 8 December, and at number 10 on the UK Digital Chart on the same day. In its second week, "Christmas, With Love" rose to number 13 on the UK Albums Chart. In Scotland, the album debuted at number 29, and number 42 in Switzerland. "Christmas, With Love" debuted at 113 on the US "Billboard" 200 chart, and number 37 on the US Holiday Albums chart. The album has sold 23,000 copies in the US as of August 2015. All songs produced by Richard "Biff" Stannard and Ash Howes, with vocal production from Stannard, Howes and Leona Lewis.