<https://www.17thshard.com/forums/topic/85853-inconsistencies-in-wor/#comment-886897>
<http://schema.org/text>
"Well, then shouldn't Szeth be happy about this revelation? Toward the end of the Everstorm fight, even though he admitted the truth, he still wanted to kill Kaladin really bad. How about stopping &amp; shaking hands with Kal, and ask him for more information so he'd be truly free from the curses?\n \n\n\n\n\n\tFrom every mention in the 1st 2 books, it worked in a way that the damage is done 1st and the repairing comes after. No shielding effect. So it's easy to conclude that if someone is dead fast then there's no chance to heal. Now, we remember that Adolin expected to kill a full Shardbearer just by pushing her down the chasm. There's no indication of the chasm's height where Eshonai fell &amp; where the pair fell. By just the pictures of the Plains, I assume that they're roughly the same height.\n \n\n\n\tOTOH, Kal's bond with Syl was put on hold at that time. Right before &amp; after the incident, he did try really hard to breathe in but to no avail. There's no reason to believe there was Light for him. \n \n\n\n\n\n\tWelp, I can't really counter this argument, lol\n \n\n\n\t \n \n\n\n\n\n\tThis one makes sense! Now that you mentioned it, everything can be solved by the deus-ex word \"soulcast\". I always find it funny to imagine the giant black canvas covering the soulcaster company moves slowly to toward the soulcasted latrines filled up with excrement, then opens up, swallows the structures, and closes trapping all the incredible smells within. After a minute, it's like BAM! and a huge column of smoke rises up from inside the canvas. Then it moves away, and soldiers can only see a bare ground where their latrine last night were. My thought is that they guess the weird canvas bring it with them.\n \n\n\n\tAfter some hours and some marching, it's time for lunch! Now the monster canvas march out again to the center of the 3 armies. 3 battalions of runners with big pots and pans come near, submit their things to some weird people in robes. They receive them and disappear into the canvas. Then BAM!, they return outside, lumbering with pots full of food, give those to the runners and get more empty ones. These runners then spread out to distribute the meals to the army, meanwhile more BAMs! continue to pop out from the canvas. Well, after seeing what happened in the morning, I can only wonder what the soldiers think where their food come from.\n \n\n\n\n\n\tWhile this, again, makes lots of sense, it also proves Sadeas' stupidity.\n \n\n\n\t \n \n\n\n\n\n\tThat's another good point. I don't really know Alethi, but I assume they have physiology very similar to humans. If that's true, then cheap trick or not, I'd still be so impressed. Let's imagine those shardbearers as very, very fat sumo with katana. If I ever saw a 1v4 match, it'd be quite a display. But then, suddenly a tiny, lean sumo with a stick jumps in and draws 2 or 3 big guys out, then somehow manages to survive... Eventually he loses his stick, but then he kicks a fat sumo away!? This new scene is so novel I'd not pay much attention to the other 1v1 or occasionally 1v2 fight of \"Adolin-kun\" anymore. You know, simple human psychology  \n \n\n\n\tOh, I have some more questions:\n \n\n\n\t8. The unmasking of Amaram. Kaladin wasn't supposed to be able to appear there, being injured &amp; exhausted after the fall. Then Dalinar led him to Amaram and the story happened as it was. Did Dalinar decide to do it on the fly?\n \n\n\n\t9. Szeth's source of Light. Coppermind says spheres go dun after a week. It's been 2 weeks into the Weeping. WoR also states that even the most valued spheres (emerald broams?) were barely visible at that moment. In every assassination, we're told that Szeth used spheres. This time what powered him? He couldn't carry those big, rough stones like inside the army lanterns because his body would bloat like a hippo, not to mention his clothes can't carry them and they'd hinder his movements so much.\n \n"
<https://www.17thshard.com/forums/topic/85853-inconsistencies-in-wor/>