_:n10a971c0a0ef4a22b712c382ea009fbfxb0
<http://schema.org/articleBody>
"AFTER much delay the Shah Commission report on mining in Goa is out. It accuses both the state and the Union Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) of allowing illegal mining in the state, putting the region’s environment and ecology at risk. The commission, headed by Justice M B Shah, was set up by the Centre in 2010 to probe into the illegal mining across the country.\r\rIn response to the report, MoEF and the state have suspended environmental clearances and operations of 93 of the 337 mining leases in Goa. About 55 per cent of the iron ore exported from India comes from Goa. The Shah Commission report was submitted to the Union Ministry of Mines (MoM) in April and was made public early-September. \r\rDirty details\r\rThe common illegalities the report points to are mining without licence, mining outside lease area and transport ing minerals illegally. \r\rTo identify lease areas, the Commission used Google Maps. It found that a total of 2,796 hectares (ha) of forestland has been encroached upon; of this  578 ha was being used by mine owners for extracting minerals. More than 127 million tonnes of minerals have been extracted from the encroached area, causing a loss of Rs 35,000 crore to the state. Besides digging pits in the encroached areas, the owners used to extract iron ore from overburden dumps which lie outside the lease area, says the report. Overburden dump is the waste produced while mining. It consists of top soil and low grade iron ore and is used to fill mine pits for closure. \r\r.\r    \r        \r            \r            \r                \r                    \r                           The defaulters \r                         \r                        Some of the many firms that flouted mining and environmental norms\r                        \r                            Sesa Goa\r                            Chowgule and Company\r                            Dempo Group\r                            VM Salgaocar\r                            Timblo Group\r                        \r                        \r                    \r                \r            \r            \r             \r        \r    \r.How much is enough?.If Goa continues to mine at 66 MTPA, its iron ore will exhaust in nine years. The Commission calls for conservation of iron ore for at least 50 years and suggests an annual cap on production at 12.5 million tonnes. But MoM describes the Commission’s cap as “impractical”. “With successive mining, useable resources may be discovered which requires a revision of the mining plan. So does a change in mining technology.”\r\rIgnoring mining rules and regulations is not just restricted to IBM. As many as 62 lease holders were found to be operating under “deemed extension” without the Centre’s approval. All the mine leases in Goa were to apply for their first renewal by November 24, 1988, under the Goa Abolition Act. Many of these lease holders applied for regularisation as late as 2000 and were accepted. As per the Mines and Mineral Development and Regulation Act, all first renewal applications filed with states needed the Centre’s nod till December 1999. Goa state took no such prior approvals, says the Commission. \r\rWhat’s more, all renewal applications were to be disposed of within six months of date of receipt or deemed to have been refused. In the case of first renewals, such lapse may indicate a deemed extension only for a period of a year. But in Goa there are cases of deemed extensions for the past 24 years like that of Chowgule and Company in Sattari taluka. Another irregularity the Commission found was in the granting of the temporary working permits (TWP). A TWP ensures that if renewal of a lease gets delayed in MoEF, a mine owner can still use it for production after taking permission from authorities. On December 4, 2006, the Supreme Court passed an order asking states not to issue TWPs. It also directed MoEF to refer to the standing committee of the National Board for Wild Life (NBWL), the cases where clearance has been granted to mining activities within 10 km buffer zone of eco-sensitive areas. Goa forwarded a list of 74 such leases to MoEF. The ministry has not yet passed the list to NBWL and these leases are still operational. According to the Commission, 61 of the 69 clearances granted after the court order need to be referred to the NBWL committee. The Goa state instead referred these application to the Chief Wildlife Warden who had no authority to grant clearances. \r\rThe Commission recommends halting of these projects till NBWL gives its approval. The iron ore production should be brought equivalent to 2000-2001 to mitigate the impact of mining on the protected area, says the report."
<https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/irongate-opened-39174>