Thursday, January 28, 1999 Published at 19:52 GMT
EU bans battery hen cages
Many battery hens suffer from osteoporosis, the brittle bone condition
The European Union has voted to ban battery hen cages across Europe, starting in 2009.
But MEPs went a step further and agreed by a two-thirds majority to ban such cages altogether by then.
The 10-year delay was necessary, the parliament agreed, to give egg producers time to adapt.
The ban means a massive upheaval in the European egg market as 93% of eggs in the EU come from battery hens.
But Conservative MEP Robert Sturdy warned that the abolition of the battery system must also be backed by rules blocking the import of eggs from countries with weaker animal welfare standards.
Otherwise, he said, EU egg farmers face being put out of business by cheap eggs from elsewhere in the world.
"Consumers will decide which eggs to buy on price as long as they are safe. It is not realistic to expect them to pay perhaps 25% more for eggs which are free-range.
"So we must make sure EU farmers do not suffer as a result of cheap egg imports. We must make sure that egg imports come from countries where welfare rules on hens are just as strong," Mr Sturdy said.
Labour MEP Mark Watts, who tabled the amendment for a total ban on battery farming, said it was still a small price to pay for consumers.
"It is a myth that consumers won't buy free-range eggs. The fact is that 89% of the British public believe keeping hens in small cages is cruel, and almost half now buy barn or free-range eggs.
"Changing from battery to free-range eggs would cost the average consumer less than £2 a year," Mr Watts said.
The vote follows a report also published on Thursday revealing that hens kept in battery cages for long spells develop brittle bones which can lead to fractures and even death.
The authors, Compassion in World Farming, say intensive battery farming results in many hens suffering from the brittle bone condition, osteoporosis. This contributes to about half a million deaths amongst hens in their cages each year.
CIWF's campaigns director, Philip Lymbery said the EU's vote made for a "tremendous day for animal welfare".
"We are delighted that the European Parliament has voted against this system and we now look to the EU agriculture ministers to ensure this system is consigned to the scrap heap of history."
Despite being only the EU's fifth largest egg producer after France, Germany, Spain and Italy, the UK has the highest number of free range hens.
The government has already said it intends to phase out the battery system.
Animal welfare groups will now lobby EU governments to make sure the ban is agreed by the time the issue comes before agriculture ministers of the 15 member states.