Antisocial personality disorder (ASPD) is among the most damaging and costly mental disorders, yet little research has sought to address the root causes of this disorder. Indeed, many clinicians consider ASPD to be untreatable, and have largely relegated the management of this challenging disorder to the criminal justice system, effectively relinquishing responsibility for understanding and treating ASPD. Although a number of interventions are utilized by the criminal justice system, these interventions have typically focused on specific problem behaviors, such as anger management and substance abuse. These interventions, along with the more broad-based approaches occasionally studied (e.g., criminal cognitions) focus primarily on cognitive processing, effectively ignoring core elements of ASPD such as impulsivity and emotion dysregulation. Recently, however, growing interest has centered on Dialectical Behavior Therapy as a potential intervention approach, particularly given the emphasis on tangible behaviors and the acquisition of skills to address the core elements of APSD. The proposed study builds upon an innovative rehabilitative program developed by the U.S. District Court in New York. Beginning in 2020, the Fordham Community Mental Health Clinic has provided a DBT-based intervention to participants in this rehabilitation program. This population is comprised of repeat criminal offenders who are deemed at high risk for reoffending by the Probation Department, the vast majority of whom meet diagnostic criteria for ASPD. This intervention, which builds on the researcher team's past work treating offenders with a history of stalking and intimate partner violence, has the potential to advance the utility of DBT for treatment of this challenging population. The present application proposes to advance this goal, by adapting DBT to target core symptoms of ASPD, including impulsivity, difficulties in emotional processing, and problem solving deficits. By adapting traditional DBT, this intervention hopes to demonstrate increased success in retaining and engaging this challenging population in treatment, decreasing the extent of problematic behaviors, and reducing the rates of violent and criminal reoffense. Most importantly, this application takes an experimental therapeutics approach, by identifying potential mediators of successful change in ASPD and quantifying the extent to which DBT impacts these traits and behaviors. Although DBT is not expected to cure ASPD, even modest improvements in the treatability of this challenging population would translate into substantial benefits given the high social, economic and health care costs associated with this disorder. Given these goals, the present application seeks to a) demonstrating the feasibility and acceptability of this intervention, b) reduce problematic character traits and behaviors (e.g., decreased impulsivity, increased emotion recognition), and c) reduce the rates of re-offending.
This pilot study is intended to adapt and refine an intervention grounded in the principles of Dialectical Behavior Therapy, for the treatment of repeat criminal offenders with antisocial personality disorder. This study will be open to individuals participating in an intensive supervision program operated by the U.S. District Court of the Southern District of New York (the RISE Court program).