Bombay High CourtUnion Of India vs K.R.Mirchandani on 22 July, 2022Bench: G.S. Patel, Gauri Vinod GodseIN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY\n      APPELLATE SIDE CIVIL JURISDICTION\n\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 455 OF 1994\n                               In\n                    FIRST APPEAL 533 OF 1994\n\n The Union Of India And Other.             ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Mohamad Mashal M.mohsin Bhaiji And Others.\n                                        ....RESPONDENTWITH\n                 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1441 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Dosu A. Bhiwandiwalla                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl. Land Acq. Officer, Uran.           ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\n                 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1442 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Manekbhai D. Bhiwandiwalla.               ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl. Land Acq. Officer, Uran.           ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 274 OF 1994\n\n Juma Masjid Trust,uran And Anr.                 ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Spl.land Acq.officer,metro Centre No.ii,uran ....RESPONDENT\n And Anr\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 277 OF 1994\n\n\n                                                                           Page 1/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022              ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::Juma Mashjid Trust,uran Through                 ....APPELLANT\n A.h.m.i.tungekar.V/S\n Spl.land Acq.officer,metro Centre,no.uran And....RESPONDENT\n Anr.WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 476 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India.                               ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Shri Ardeshir H.bhiwandiwala                ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 481 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India                                ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n K.r.mirchandani                             ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 495 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                    ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Mohamad Yusuf Abdul Hamid Mulla (dec)       ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 501 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                    ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Shri Harkisandas R. Shroff And Others       ....RESPONDENT\n\n                               WITH\n\n\n                                                                           Page 2/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022              ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::FIRST APPEAL NO. 526 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Smt.mohini Motiram Vaswani And Anr.        ....RESPONDENT\n\n                                WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 740 OF 1995\n                                  In\n                      First Appeal 755 OF 19951.mainuddin M. Ashraf Bhaiji And Ors.        ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The State Of Maha. And Ors.                ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 749 OF 1995\n\n Mahadeo Sinaa Thakur                         ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The State Of Maharashtra And Others.       ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 751 OF 1995\n\n Mohamod Yusuf Abdul Hamid Mulla (dec) L.r.....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The State Of Maharashtra And Others.   ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 489 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                   ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Ardeshir Hormusji Bhiwandiwalla (dec) Through\n                                           ....RESPONDENT\n\n\n                                                                          Page 3/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 486 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India                               ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Smt.jayshree Narayan Mhatre.               ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 518 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India                               ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Maneckbai Dossabhoy Bhiwandiwalla          ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 492 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India                               ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Smt Jayshree Narayan Mhatre                ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 515 OF 1994\n\n The Union Of India                           ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Mrs.vasanti Sitaram Thakur.                ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 502 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra And Ors.            ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Maneckbai Dossabhoy Bhiwandiwala           ....RESPONDENT\n\n\n\n                                                                          Page 4/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 520 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India                               ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Mainuddin M.ashraf Bhaiji And Ors.         ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 533 OF 1994\n\n The Union Of India And Ors.               ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Mohammed Jaffer Gulam Hussain Tungekar ....RESPONDENT\n And Ors.WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 523 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra                   ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Ardeshir Hormasji Bhiwandiwala And Anr. ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 504 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Shri Ardeshir Hormasji Bhiwandiwalla And Ors.....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 459 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others                    ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n K.r.mirchandani And Others.                ....RESPONDENT\n\n\n                                                                          Page 5/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 276 OF 1994\n\n Juma Masjid Trust(masjid Dargah Turst)uran ....APPELLANT\n And Ors.V/S\n Spl.land Acq.officer,metro Centre No.ii,uran ....RESPONDENT\n And Anr\n\n                            WITH\n                 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1448 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Manekbhay D. Bhiwandiwalla                ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl.land Acq. Officer, Uran.             ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 272 OF 1994\n\n Smt. Naima Begam                             ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl. Land Acquisition Officer And Anr ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 519 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                   ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Ardeshir Hormusji Bhiwandiwalla (dec) Throug\n                                           ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 750 OF 1995\n\n Tikamdas Tilakchand Mirchandani (dec) L.r.    ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n\n\n                                                                          Page 6/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::The State Of Maharashtra And Others           ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 141 OF 1994\n\n Smt. Halimabibi Mohamed Yusuf Tungekar    ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl.land Acquisition Officer,      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 507 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                      ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Shri Manohar Pandharinath Chavate (dec).      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\n                 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1451 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Dasu A. Bhiwandiwalla.                      ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl. Land Acq. Officer, Uran.             ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 503 OF 1994\n\n Union Of Inida And Others.                      ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Jama Masjid Trust, Uran And Others.           ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 308 OF 1994\n\n A.h.m.i.tungekar(d.h.)m.s.tungekar And Ors.     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n\n\n                                                                             Page 7/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022                ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::The Spl.land Acquisition Officer,raigad.      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 470 OF 1994\n\n The Union Of India                           ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Shri Manohar Pandharinath Chavathe (deceased)\n                                           ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 477 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India Through Dy.salt Commissioner ....APPELLANT\n And Anr.V/S\n K.a.h. Bhaiji And Ors.                   ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 527 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra                        ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Ardeshir Hormasji Bhiwandiwala                ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 529 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra And Others.            ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Badrinarayan Rampratap Gododia.               ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 472 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra                        ....APPELLANT\n\n\n                                                                             Page 8/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022                ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::V/S\n Badrinarayan Rampratap Gadodia And Ors. ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 473 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                   ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Shri Mahadeo Sina Thakur                   ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 488 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Maneckbai Dossabhoy Bhiwandiwalla.         ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 457 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                   ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Shri Ardeshir H.bhiwandiwaala (dec).       ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 483 OF 1994\n\n The Union Of India                           ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Rabia Bibi Mohammad Hussan Tungekar        ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 478 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                   ....APPELLANT\n\n\n                                                                          Page 9/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::V/S\n Abdul Rashid Abdul Ramaman And Others. ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 494 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Prakash Dhirajlal Parekh                   ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 475 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                    ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Tikamadas Tilikchand Mirchandani (dec) L.r.....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 500 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Shri Puranmal Lalchand Mundada             ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\n                 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1450 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Dasu A. Bhiwandiwalla                    ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl.land Acq. Officer, Uran.           ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\n                 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1445 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Desu A. Bhiwandiwalla.                   ....APPELLANT\n\n\n                                                                         Page 10/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::V/S\n The Spl. Land Acq. Officer, Uran.          ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\n                 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1447 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Manekbhai D. Bhiwandiwalla.              ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl. Land Acq. Officer, Uran.          ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 532 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                   ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Smt. Jamilabibi W/o Mohammed Jaffar        ....RESPONDENT\n Tungekar.WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 510 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others                    ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Shri Bhalchandra Jaskaran Mandada          ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 524 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                     ....APPELLANT\n              V/S\n Shri Dhirajlal Gulabchand Parekh And Others.....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 485 OF 1994\n\n\n\n                                                                         Page 11/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::The State Of Maharashtra                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Nandlal L. Agarwal And Ors.                ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 462 OF 1994\n\n The Union Of India And Another            ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Smt. Halimabibi Mohamed Yusuf Tungekar ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 474 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Abdul Hamid Mohamad Ibrahim Tangekar (dec).....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 480 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others                    ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Jama Masjid Trust, Uran                    ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 508 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Ors.                      ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Mahadev Sina Thakur.                       ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 521 OF 1994\n\n\n\n                                                                         Page 12/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::Union Of India And Others                ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Mohammed Hami Abdul Hami Bhaiji (dec) ....RESPONDENT\n Through L.r\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 464 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Shri Ramesh Girdhandas Mehta And Ors.      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 490 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India                             ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Shri Mohamed Jafar Gulam Hussein Tungekar.....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 463 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Ardeshir Hormasji Bhiwandiwalla.           ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 493 OF 1994\n\n The Union Of India                           ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Shri Ahmed M.h.saleh Mohamad               ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 468 OF 1994\n\n\n                                                                         Page 13/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::Union Of India                               ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Shri Ahmed Mohamed H.s.mohomed             ....RESPONDENT\n Namakwala.WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 506 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                   ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Badrinarayan Rampratap Gododia And Others.....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 530 OF 1994\n\n The Union Of India                           ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Abdul Samed Kadir Thakur                   ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 528 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                  ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Abdul Majid Abdul Hamid Mulla And Others.....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 466 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India                               ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Sayyad Alam Shah Kadri.                    ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 511 OF 1994\n\n\n                                                                         Page 14/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::The State Of Maharahstra                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Juma Masjid Trust And Ors.                 ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 747 OF 1995\n\n Harkisandas R Shroff And Others.             ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The State Of Maharashtra                   ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 525 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                   ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Jama Masijid Trust And Others.             ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 514 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others                ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Mohammad Tayyab Mohammad Ismail Bhaiji....RESPONDENT\n And Others\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 456 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Maneckabai Dossabhoy Bhiwandiwalla And ....RESPONDENT\n Others\n\n                               WITH\n\n\n                                                                         Page 15/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::FIRST APPEAL NO. 487 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                   ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Maneckbai Dossabhoy Bhiwandiwalla And      ....RESPONDENT\n Others.WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 460 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Ors.                      ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Dosu Ardeshir Bhiwandiwala.                ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 479 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra And Ors.        ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Mohammed Nazir A.majid Sonde And Ors. ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 458 OF 1994\n\n The Union Of India                           ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Abdul Majid Mohammed Yusuf Mukhari         ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 482 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                   ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Bakiate Salehate Mariam Trust, Through Abdul\n                                           ....RESPONDENT\n And\n\n\n                                                                         Page 16/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 471 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                    ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Ardeshir Hormasji Bhiwandiwalla (dec)       ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 273 OF 1994\n\n Juma Masjid Trust Uran Through                  ....APPELLANT\n A.h.m.i.tungekar.V/S\n Spl.land Acq.officer,metro Centre No.1 Uran 7....RESPONDENT\n Anr.WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 531 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India                                ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Kulsumbibi And Ors.                         ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 517 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra And Ors.             ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Mohamed Nasir Mohamed Ali Tungekar          ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 270 OF 1994\n\n Smt. Rabia Bibi Mohaamed Hassan Tungekar ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n\n\n                                                                          Page 17/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022              ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::The Spl. Land Acqusition Officer And Anr      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 461 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.               ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Abdul Hamid Mohammad Ibrahim Tungekar ....RESPONDENT\n (dec)\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 467 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India                                  ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Shri Abdul Hamid Mohammad Ibrahim             ....RESPONDENT\n Tungekar.WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 469 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra                 ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Mohamed Ibrahim Mohamed Yusuf Tungekar....RESPONDENT\n And Ors.WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 484 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.               ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Mohamed Yusuf Mohamed Abdulla Bhaiji And\n                                       ....RESPONDENT\n Ohters.WITH\n\n\n                                                                            Page 18/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022                ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::FIRST APPEAL NO. 505 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India                               ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Abdul Rahim Mehammed Hanan                 ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 271 OF 1994\n\n 1a.rahiman Abdul Rashid Tungekar And Anr ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n He Spl. Land Acqusition Officer And Anr ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\n                 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1449 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Manekbhai D. Bhiwandiwalla.              ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl. Land Acq. Officer, Uran.          ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\n                 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1438 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Dosu Ardeshir Bhiwandiwalla              ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Special Land Acq.officer, Uran         ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 837 OF 1995\n\n Abdul Majid Abdul Hamid Mulla And Others. ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n State Of Maharashta.                    ....RESPONDENT\n\n                               WITH\n\n\n                                                                         Page 19/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::FIRST APPEAL NO. 202 OF 1994\n\n Abdul Samad Abdul Kadir Thakur.              ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Spl.land Acquisition Officer And Anr.      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 465 OF 1994\n\n The Union Of India                           ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Smt Halimabibi And Others                  ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\n                 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1440 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Dosu A. Bhiwandiwala.                    ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl. Land Acq. Officer, Uran.          ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\n                 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1443 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Dosu A. Bhiwandiwalla.                   ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl.land Acq Officer, Uran.            ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\n                 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1444 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Dosu A. Bhiwandiwalla                    ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl. Land Acq. Officer, Uran.          ....RESPONDENT\n\n                               WITH\n\n\n                                                                         Page 20/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::FIRST APPEAL NO. 1446 OF 1996\n\n Mr. Manekbhai D. Bhiwandiwalla                  ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl. Land Acq.officer, Uran.              ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 184 OF 1994\n\n Mohomed Yusuf Mahomed Abdulla And Anr ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl. Land Acquisition Officer And Anr ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 305 OF 1994\n\n Smt.h.m.y.tungekar And Ors.                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The Spl Land Acq.officer,raigad And Anr.      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 491 OF 1994\n\n State Of Maharashtra                            ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Muhammad Ismail Bhaiji                        ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 496 OF 1994\n\n Union Of Inida And Others.                   ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Juma Masjid Trust ,uran, Through Abdul Hamid\n                                           ....RESPONDENT\n\n                               WITH\n\n\n                                                                            Page 21/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022                ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::FIRST APPEAL NO. 499 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others                   ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Abdul Majid Abdul Hamid Mulla And Others.....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 509 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others                    ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Smt.naima Begum D/o.mohamed Hasan          ....RESPONDENT\n Tungekar\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 512 OF 1994\n\n Union Of India And Others.                   ....APPELLANT\n            V/S\n Moinuddin Malik Yusuf Thakur (dec) Through....RESPONDENT\n L/h\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 516 OF 1994\n\n The State Of Maharashtra                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n Chandrakant R. Shroff And Ors.             ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n                  FIRST APPEAL NO. 748 OF 1995\n\n Prakash Dhirajlal Parekh                     ....APPELLANT\n             V/S\n The State Of Maharashtra And Others.       ....RESPONDENT\n\n\n                                                                         Page 22/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022             ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::Mr. Nikhil Sakhardande Sr. Adv. a/w Mr. Pralhad Paranjape a/w\n Shubhra Swami i/b M.S. Bodhanwalla & Co. For Appellant in\n FA/741/1995\n For Respondent in FA/455/1994,\n FA/490/1994,FA/532/1994,FA/533/1994,\n FA/497/1994, FA/507/1994, FA/470/1994\n\n Mr. Vivek Sharma and Mr. Arya Bile i/b Soloman & Co. For\n Applicant in IA/672/2020 In FA/275/1994 and IA/673/2020 in\n FA/466/1994\n\n Pranil Sonawane for Union of India in FA/455/1994 & ors.\n Mr. Kaiwan Kalyaniwalla a/w Ms. Sanidhaa Vedpathak i/b\n Maneksha & Sethna For the Appellant in FA/1440/1996,\n FA/1441/1996, FA/1443/1996, FA/1444/1996, FA/1445/1996,\n FA/1446/1996, FA/1447/1996, FA/1448/1996, FA/1449/1996,\n FA/1450/1996 AND 1451/1996\n Ibrahim Merchant Advocate for Respondent No. 1 (A) to 1 (C)\n in FA/516/1994\n Mr. Ashutosh Kumbhakoni, Adv. General a/w Mr. Milan Bhise,\n Mr. Amit Bhave i/b Milan Bhise & Co. Adv. For Appellant No.\n 3 (JNPT)\n Mr. Kunal Katariya a/w Mr. Vishesh Malviya, Adv. Azraa\n Millwala a/w Mr. Tejas Popat i/b Rashmikant & Partners for\n Respondents in FA/477/1994, FA/491/1994, FA/514/1994\n Adv. Chintan Shah for Respondent No. 1 & 2 In FA/529/1994\n Bruno Castellino for Appellants in FA/475/1994 and\n FA/750/1995\n\n        CORAM :                HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE G.S. PATEL &\n                               HON'BLE JUSTICE MS. GAURI GODSE, JJ\n        DATE :                 22nd July, 2022\n\n\n\n\n                                                                                 Page 23/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022                     ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::P.C. :Not before the Bench of which Justice Hon'ble Ms. Gauri Godse\n     is a member.( FOR REGISTRAR JUDICIAL - I )\n\n\n\n\n                                                                           Page 24/24::: Uploaded on - 25/07/2022               ::: Downloaded on - 26/07/2022 02:20:06 :::