Kerala High CourtVinod P.B vs District Collecor on 9 November, 2020Author:N.NagareshBench:N.NagareshIN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM\n\n                         PRESENT\n\n           THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.NAGARESH\n\nMONDAY,THE 09TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2020/18TH KARTHIKA,1942\n\n                 WP(C).No.5703 OF 2014(K)\n\n\nPETITIONERS:\n\n     1      VINOD P.B.,S/O.P.K.BHASKARAN,\n            AGED 33 YEARS,PUTHENKALATHIL HOUSE,\n            GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n            KOCHI 8.\n\n     2      K.K.SADANANDAN, S/O.KUNJAN,\n            KALATHIL HOUSE,AGED 48 YEARS,\n            GANAPATHIKADU,NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n            KOCHI 8.\n\n     3      C.N.SURESH, S/O.NARAYANAN,\n            AGED 45 YEARS,\n            CHAKKUMKALPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n            GANAPATHIKADU,\n            NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n            KOCHI 8.\n\n     4      SARASU SREEDHARAN,\n            W/O.SREEDHARAN,\n            AGED 67 YEARS,\n            PUTHENCHIRAYIL HOUSE,\n            GANAPATHIKADU,\n            NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n            KOCHI 8.\n\n     5      VINOD KUMAR C.S.,\n            S/O.SREENIVASAN,\n            AGED 36 YEARS,\n            CHAKKUMKAPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n            GANAPATHIKADU,\n            NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n            KOCHI 8.\n WP(C)No.5703/2014\n\n                             2\n\n\n\n      6      C.N.SULOCHANA, D/O.NARAYANAN,\n             AGED 63 YEARS,\n             CHAKKUMKALPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      7      K.E.CHINNAN, S/O.EESUKUTTY,\n             AGED 45 YEARS,\n             KURISUPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      8      A.A.SEBASTIAN, S/O.ANTONY,\n             AGED 46 YEARS,\n             ALUMKAL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      9      P.K.SURESHBABU,\n             S/O.KUMARAN,\n             AGED 37 YEARS,\n             PUTHENCHIRAYIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      10     V.L.SANDHYAVU, S/O.LONAN,\n             AGED 66 YEARS,\n             VALIYAVEETTIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST, KOCHI 8.\n\n      11     P.K.SREEDHARAN,S/O.KUNJAN,\n             AGED 67 YEARS,\n             PUTHENCHIRAYIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      12     K.T.KOCHUPENNU, W/O.VELUTHA,\n             AGED 62 YEARS, KALATHIL HOUSE,\n WP(C)No.5703/2014\n\n                             3\n\n\n\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      13     BEENA SURENDRAN,\n             W/O.SURENDRAN,\n             AGED 37 YEARS,\n             ARAYIRIPPUPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      14     RENJINI BABU, W/O.BABU,\n             AGED 36 YEARS,\n             ARAYIPPUPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      15     CHADRALEKHA SURESH, W/O.SURESH,\n             AGED 39 YEARS,\n             CHAKKUMKAPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      16     K.T.GOPALAKRISHNAN, S/O.THEVAN,\n             AGED 67 YEARS,\n             KALATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      17     RADHAKRISHNAN, W/O.SADANANDAN,\n             AGED 45 YEARS,\n             KALATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      18     M.S.VASANTHAKUMAR, S/O.SREENIVASAN,\n             AGED 34 YEARS, MAVUNKAPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      19     K.T.VELUTHA,S/O.THEVAN,\n             AGED 75 YEARS, KALATHIL HOUSE,\n WP(C)No.5703/2014\n\n                             4\n\n\n\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST, KOCHI 8.\n\n      20     RATHIKA AJAYAGHOSH,\n             W/O.AJAYAGHOSH,\n             AGED 33 YEARS,\n             PUTHENKALATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      21     P.K.BHASKARAN, S/O.KAKAN,\n             AGED 65 YEARS,\n             PUTHENKALATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      22     P.K.SUDARSANAN, S/O.KUMARAN,\n             AGED 40 YEARS,\n             PUTHENCHIRAYIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      23     P.B.SUNIL, S/O.BHASKARAN,\n             AGED 31 YEARS,\n             PUTHENKALATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      24     K.A.MATHEW, S/O.ANTHO,\n             AGED 53 YEARS,\n             KALIPPRAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      25     CHEERAMMA BHASKARAN,\n             AGED 61 YEARS,\n             PUTHENKALATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST, KOCHI 8.\n WP(C)No.5703/2014\n\n                             5\n\n\n\n\n      26     K.V.HARIHARAN, S/O.VELUTHA,\n             AGED 45 YEARS,\n             KALATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      27     SANITHA GIREESH,\n             W/O.GIREESH,\n             AGED 33 YEARS,\n             PURANCHIRAYIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      28     PARVATHIKUMARAN,\n             W/O.KUMARAN,\n             AGED 73 YEARS,\n             PURANCHIRAYIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      29     PARIMALA SUDHARSHANAN,\n             W/O.SUDARSHANAN,\n             AGED 30 YEARS,\n             PURANCHIRAYIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      30     PRAVEENKUMAR K.G.,\n             S/O.GOPALAKRISHNAN,\n             AGED 32, KALATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      31     K.T.MURALEEDHARAN,\n             S/O.THEVAN,\n             AGED 64 YEARS,\n             KALATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n WP(C)No.5703/2014\n\n                             6\n\n\n\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      32     RAJAMMA MURALEEDHARAN,\n             W/O.MURALEEDHARAN,\n             AGED   YEARS,\n             KALATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      33     SHEELA SEBASTIAN,\n             W/O.SEBASTIAN,\n             AGED 40 YEARS,\n             ALUNGAL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      34     KOCHUPENNU ISHNATHI,\n             W/O.ISHNATHI,\n             AGED 75 YEARS,\n             KALATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      35     AJAYAGHOSH P.B.,\n             S/O.P.K.BHASKARAN,\n             AGED 37 YEARS,\n             PUTHANKALATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      36     M.M.RAJU, S/O.MADHAVAN,\n             AGED 42 YEARS,\n             MAVUNGAPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      37     M.N.LAKSHMANAN, S/O.NAGU,\n             AGED 74 YEARS,\n WP(C)No.5703/2014\n\n                             7\n\n\n\n             MAVUNGAPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      38     M.L.MOHANDAS, S/O.LAKSHMANAN,\n             AGED 49 YEARS, MAVUNGAPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      39     T.X.JOLLY, S/O.XAVIER,\n             AGED 48 YEARS, THAIKOODATHIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU,NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      40     A.K.BABU,S/O.KRISHNAN, AGED 43 YEARS,\n             ARAYIRIPPUPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      41     A.L.GOPALAN, S/O.LAKSHMANAN,\n             AGED 62 YEARS, ARAYIRIPPUPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      42     A.G.SURESHBABU, S/O.GOVINDAN,\n             AGED 37 YEARS, ARAYIRIPPUPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      43     M.R.GOVINDAN, S/O.RAMAN,\n             AGED 65 YEARS, MAVUNGAPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      44     K.V.JACOB CHALS, S/O.VARGHESE,\n             AGED 43 YEARS, KOCHUPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      45     A.H.RATHEESH, S/O.HANUMANTHAN,\n             AGED 42 YEARS, ARACKAPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n WP(C)No.5703/2014\n\n                             8\n\n\n\n\n      46     A.X.JOHNY, S/O.XAVIER, AGED 44 YEARS,\n             AZHINACKAL HOUSE, GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST, KOCHI 8.\n\n      47     A.H.BALAMANI, S/O.HANUMANDAN,\n             AGED 47 YEARS, ARACKAPARAMBU HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      48     K.F.ANTONY, S/O.FRANCIS, AGED 41 YEARS,\n             KURUSUPARAMBU HOUSE, GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST, KOCHI 8.\n\n      49     GEETHA SUBRAHMANYAN, W/O.SUBRAHMANYAN,\n             AGED 48, ARAYIRIPPUPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU, NORTH CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n      50     A.K.MOHANAN, S/O.KRISHNAN, AGED 51 YEARS,\n             ARAYIRIPPUPARAMBIL HOUSE, GANAPATHIKADU,\n             NORTH CHELLANAM POST, KOCHI 8.\n\n             BY ADVS.\n             SRI.DENIZEN KOMATH\n             SMT.ANNIES MATHAI\n             SRI.P.J.YESUDAS\n\nRESPONDENTS:\n\n      1      DISTRICT COLLECOR,\n             ERNAKULAM 682 011.\n\n      2      DISTRICT LABOUR OFFICER,\n             ERNAKULAM 682 035.\n\n      3      ASSISTANT LABOUR OFFICER,\n             FORT KOCHI 682 001.\n\n      4      SUB INSPECTOR OF POLICE,\n             KANNAMALI POLICE STATION,\n             KOCHI 682 010.\n\n      5      INSPECTOR OF FISHERIES,\n             NEAR HIGH COURT OF KERALA,\n WP(C)No.5703/2014\n\n                             9\n\n\n\n             ERNAKULAM 682 031.\n\n      6      K.I.RAJENDRAN, SECRETARY,\n             GANAPATHIKADU 'A' BLOCK,\n             PADASEKHARA KARSHAKA SANGHOM,\n             REG.NO.ER.1561/90, GANAPATHIKADU NORTH,\n             CHELLANAM POST, KOCHI 8.\n\n      7      C.N.MOHANDAS, SECRETARY,\n             GANAPATHIKADU B BLOCK PADASEKHARA\n             NELLULPADHAKA KARSHAKA SANGHOM,\n             REG.NO. ER.156/10, GANAPATHIKADU NORTH,\n             CHELLANAM POST, KOCHI 8.\n\n      8      PAUL CHARLES, S/O.CHARLES,\n             LENTHAPARAMBIL HOUSE,\n             GANAPATHIKADU NORTH, CHELLANAM POST,\n             KOCHI 8.\n\n             R1-R5 BY GOVERNMENT PLEADER SMT. POOJA\n             SURENDRAN\n             R6 BY ADV. SRI. SREELYKUMAR K.S.\n             R7 BY ADV. SRI.K.V.BINOD\n             R6 BY ADV. SRI.LAL K.JOSEPH\n             R7 BY ADV. SRI.T.MADHU\n             BY ADV. SMT.M.C.SANITHA\n             BY ADV. SRI.V.S.SHIRAZ BAVA\n             R6 BY ADV. SRI.A.A.ZIYAD RAHMAN\n\n     THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY\nHEARD ON 09.11.2020, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY\nDELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:\n WP(C)No.5703/2014\n\n                               10\n\n\n\n\n                         JUDGMENTDated this the 9th day of November, 2020\n\n\n\n      The learned counsel for the petitioner Sri.Denizen\n\nKomath seeks leave to withdraw the writ petition.The writ petition is dismissed as withdrawn.Sd/-N. NAGARESH\n                                                  JUDGE\nncdWP(C)No.5703/201411APPENDIX\nPETITIONERS' EXHIBITS:EXHIBIT P1          TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF THE\n                    REGISTERED TRADE UNION WHEREIN THESE\n                    PETITIONERS ARE MEMBERS.EXHIBIT P2          TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT PREFERRED\n                    BY SOME OF THE PETITIONERS BEFORE\n                    THE 4TH RESPONDENT SUB INSPECTOR OF\n                    POLICE, DATED 25/03/2013.EXHIBIT P3          TRUE COPY OF THE COMPLAINT PREFERRED\n                    BY THE PETITIONERS THROUGH THEIR\n                    TRADE UNION BEFORE THE RESPONDENTS 1\n                    TO 3 HEREIN DATED 26/08/2013.EXHIBIT P4          TRUE COPY OF THE REMINDER DATED\n                    03/01/2014 PREFERRED BY THE\n                    PETITIONER BEFORE THE RESPONDENTS 1\n                    TO 3 AND 5 HEREIN.