Madhya Pradesh High CourtRamesh Chandra Kushwah vs The State Of Madhya Pradesh on 12 October, 2018THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
                        1
                  WP.24623.2018
(Ramesh Chandra Kushwah & Ors Vs. State of MP & Ors)

Gwalior, Dated : 12.10.2018
     Shri Devesh Sharma, learned counsel for
the petitioners.
     Heard on admission.
     Petitioners, male staff nurses, posted in
Government Medical Colleges at Sagar, Indore
and Gwalior, take exception to the advertisement
dated 03.10.2018, issued at the instance of
Superintendent, Government Medical College
Datia   for    appointment       of   Medical   and
Paramedical    Staff     under    Madhya   Pradesh
Swashasi      Chikitsa      Mahavidyalaya       Me
Chikitsakiya, Paricharika Evam Sah-Chikitsakiya
Samvarg Ke Liye Aadarsh Sewa Bharti Niyam,
2018.
     The precise grievance raised is against the
stipulation in the advertisement that the post of
nursing sister and staff nurse is reserved for the
women candidates, as a result whereof the
petitioners are denied of equal opportunity in the
matter of recruitment. It is also contended that
the 100% reservation of posts in favour of the
female candidates which, it is urged, it not
permissible under law.
     Evidently, the recruitment is as per the
stipulations in the Rules of 2018, as per Rules 5
and 6 thereof which stipulate:-
        THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
                        2
                  WP.24623.2018
(Ramesh Chandra Kushwah & Ors Vs. State of MP & Ors)

     ^^5- fjDr inksa ij fu;qfDr &

     fjDr in rFkk Hkfo"; esa gksus okys fjDr inksa ij fu;qfDr
     fuEukuqlkj gksxh%&
     5-1 fjDr inksa esa ls lh/kh Hkjrh ds in vkSj inksUufr ds
     in dh x.kuk layXu vuqlwph& nks vuqlkj dh tk,xhA
     5-2 fjDr inksa dh iwfrZ ds vko';d U;wure vgZrk
     vuqlwph&rhu vuqlkj gksxh U;wure vgZrk ds ekin.M esa
     dk;Zdkfj.kh lfefr ladYi ikfjr dj vko';drkuqlkj
     o`f) dj ldsxh rFkk vfrfjDr vgZrk fu;r dj ldsxhA
     6       lh/kh Hkjrh dh izfØ;k &
     6-1 lh/kh Hkjrh ds inksa dh iwfrZ ds fy, dk;Zdkfj.kh
     lfefr foKfIr tkjh djrs gq;s ikjn'khZ izfØz;k viuk,xhA
     6-2 lh/kh Hkjrh ds fjDr inksa dh iwfrZ ds fy,
     dk;Zdkfj.kh lfefr ladYi ikfjr dj ;Fkko';d fyf[kr
     ijh{kk vFkok lk{kkRdkj vFkok nksuksa fu;r dj ldsxhA
     6-3 p;u lfefr esfjV ds vk/kkj ij ,oa esfjV Øe esa
     vH;kfFkZ;ksa ds ;pu gsrq vuq'kalk nsxhA
     6-4 p;u lwph ds ojh;rk Øe esa fu;qfDr izFker% ,d
     o"kZ dh vof/k ds fy, ifjoh{kk ij vuqca/k ij dh tk,xhA
     6-5 ifjoh{kk vof/k esa lacaf/kr O;fDr ds }kjk laikfnr
     dk;kZs ds ewY;kadu ds vk/kkj ij p;u lfefr lacaf/kr
     O;fDr dks fu;qDr djus vFkok vU;Fkk dh vuq'kalk djsxh
     vkSj rn~kuqlkj vkns'k tkjh fd;k tk,xkA
     6-6 egkfo|ky; esa lsokjr O;fDr] tks lh/kh Hkjrh ds
     in ds fy, vgZrk/kkjh gks] lh/kh Hkjrh ds in ds fo:)
     vkosnu nsus ds fy, Lora= gksxk vkSj ,sls vkosnu ds fy,
     mls fu;ksDrk ls vukifRr ugh ysuk gksxh A
     6-7 egkfo|ky; esa lsokjr O;fDr dk vuqlwph&,d esa
     fofufnZ"V fdlh in ds fo:) p;u fd;k tkus dh n'kk esa
     ,sls O;fDr dk osru fu/kkZj.k] mlds }kjk egkfo|ky; esa
     nh xbZ iwoZ lsok vof/k dks x.kuk esa ysdj fd;k tk,xkA^^

     Thus, it is for filling up the vacant posts of
various medical and paramedical discipline the
advertisement is issued. As regard to Nursing
        THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
                        3
                  WP.24623.2018
(Ramesh Chandra Kushwah & Ors Vs. State of MP & Ors)

Sister and Staff Nurse, vacant posts in said cadre
are being advertised and not of nursing brother,
which is, as not disputed by the learned counsel
for the petitioner is a separate cadre post than
nursing sister. The petitioners for the reasons
best known to them have not filed the schedules
appended to Rules of 2018 which would be
indicating the fact that there exists the different
cadre of Nursing Sister and Nursing Brother.
     In    view      whereof       since      the        employer
intended to fill the vacancies of Nursing Sisters
and female staff nurses, it cannot be said that
100% posts are reserved for the nursing sister.
The petitioners, therefore, cannot be said to be
discriminated        in     the      matter         of     public
employment. The reference to Madhya Pradesh
Public Health and Family Welfare Department
(Gazetted) Service Recruitment Rules 2007 is of
no assistance in view of Rule 17 of the Rules of
2018 which mandates:
     ^^17- fujlu vkSj O;ko`fRr&
           bu fu;eksa ds rRLFkkuh rFkk muds izkjaHk gksus ds
           iwoZ izo`Rr lHkh fu;e bu fu;eksa ds vUrxZr vkus
           okys fo"k;ksa ds laca/k esa ,rn~ }kjk fujLr fd;s tkrs
           gSaA

           ijUrq] bl izdkj fujLRk fu;eksa ds v/khu fd;k
           x;k dksbZ vkns'k ;k dh xbZ dk;Zokgh bu fu;eksa ds
           rRLFkkuh mica/kksa ds v/khu fd;k x;k vkns'k ;k dh
           xbZ dk;Zokgh le>h tk;sxhA^^
                      THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
                                      4
                                WP.24623.2018
              (Ramesh Chandra Kushwah & Ors Vs. State of MP & Ors)

              Even under the Rules of 2007, there are different
              cadres of Nursing Sister (Female) and Nursing
              Brother.
                   Taking any view of the matter, this Court
              does not perceive any illegality on the part of the
              respondents, as would warrant any indulgence.Consequently, petition fails and is dismissed.
                   No costs.(Sanjay Yadav)
                                                 Judge
pd
     PAWAN
     DHARKAR
     2018.10.2
     5 12:19:26-07'00'