Central Administrative Tribunal - ErnakulamM.T.Sasidhara Menon vs The Chairman & Managing Director on 28 February, 20111

           CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
                       ERNAKULAM BENCH

             O.A. NO. 548 OF 2010 & OA 426 of 2010

          Monday, this the 28th day of February, 2011

CORAM:
      HON'BLE Mr.JUSTICE P.R.RAMAN, JUDICIAL MEMBER
      HON'BLE Mr. K.GEORGE JOSEPH, ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER

1.    OA 548/10 :

1.    M.T.Sasidhara Menon
      Staying at 30/115, Sarika, Petta
      Poonithura - 682 038
      Ernakulam District
      PA to Deputy General Manager (Radio Planning)
      BSN Mobile Services, 3rd Floor,Telephone Exchange Building
      Panampilly Nagar, Kochi - 36

2.    K.M.Damodaran
      Residing at Cheemeni, Cheemei PO
      Chervathur, Kasargod - 671 313
      PA Office of the Deputy General Manager (NWO
      Payyannur - 670 307

3.    N.Damodaran
      Residing at BSNL Staff Quarters
      Type III/2, Kakkad, Kannur - 670 002
      PA to Deputy General Manager(Planning)
      O/o General Manager Telecom
      BSNL Bhawan, Kannur - 2

4.    K.S.Balachandran
      Residing at Vallath House
      Viyyur PO, Thrissur - 680 010
      PA to Divisional Engineer
      Phones - II (External), Trichur

5.    K.P.Venugopalakrishnan
      Residing at Sreepadmam, Pottore, MG Kave PO
      Thrissur - 680 581
      PA to Chief Accounts Officer (CA)
      Office of the Principal General Manager
      BSNL, Thrissur - 680 022

6.    V.G.Surendran
      Residing at Vellattuparambil House
      Venginissery PO, Thrissur - 680 575
      PA to Vigilance Officer
      Office of Principal General Manager, BSNL, Thrissur

                                     2


7.      Rosy Vareed
        Residing at Perappadan House, East Kombara
        Irinjalakuda - 680 121, Thrissur District
        PA , Office of the Divisional Engineer Telcom
        Irinjaakuda

8.      A.D.Thomas
        Residing at Alamparambil House
        Near Parel Church
        Sanjeevani Hospital Road, Kurisummoodu P.O
        Changanacherry - 686 104
        PA , Office of the Principal General Manager Telecom
        BSNL Kottayam

9.      N.Parameswara Iyer
        Residing at Irupathil madom, Moncompu
        Alleppey District
        PA, Office of the Principal General Manager Telecom
        BSNL Kottayam

10.     Lila Thomas
        Residing at Terry Cottage, Valiyakambiyil
        Thrippilazhikom PO, Kundara
        Kollam District - 691 509
        PA, O/o Area Manager Telecom, BSNL
        Chinnakkada Telephone Exchange,
         Kollam - 691 001

11.     Nandini Pradeep
        Residing at TC 51/529, GUHA, Mankulam Lane
        Pappanamcode3 PO, Thiruvananthapuram - 695 018
        PA, O/o General Manager Telecom, BSNL
        Regional Telecom Training Centre
        Kaimanam PO,
        Thiruvananthapuram - 695 040                    ... Applicants

(By Advocate Mr.Santhosh Mathew )

                            versus

1.      The Chairman & Managing Director
        Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited
        Corporate Office, Harish Chandar Mathur Lane
         New Delhi - 110 011

2.      The Chief General Manager Telecom
        BSNL, Kerala Telecom Circle
        PMG Junction, Trivandrum - 33                .. Respondents

(By Advocate Mr.N.Nagaresh )

                                     3

2.       OA 426/10:

1.       BSNL Personal Staff Association
         Kerala Circle Unit
         represented by its Circle Treasurer
         M.T.Sasidhara Menon
         Staying at 30/115, Sarika, Petta
         Poonithura - 682 038, Ernakulam District
         PA to Deputy General Manager (Radio Planning)
         BSNL Mobile Services, 3rd Floor
         Telephone Exchange Building
         Panampilly Nagar, Kochi - 36

2.       Lisiyama Joseph
         PA, O/o Principal General Manager, Telecom
         Balan K Nair Road, Kozhikode

3.       N.Haridasan
         PA, O/o General manager, Telecom
         Konnola Towers, Down-hill
         Malappuram                            ...     Applicants

(By Advocate Mr.Santhosh Mathew)

                            versus

1.       The Chairman & Managing Director
         Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited
         Corporate Office, Harish Chandar Mathur Lane
         New Delhi - 110 011

2.       The Chief General Manager Telecom
         BSNL, Kerala Telecom Circle
         PMG Junction, Trivandrum - 33

3.       The Senior Accounts Officer (Estt)
         O/o the Principal General Manager Telecom
         Balan K Nair, Kozhikode - 673 001

4.       The Accounts Officer (CA)
         O/o General Manager Telecom,
         Konnola Towers, Down Hill,
         Malappuram - 676 519                       .. Respondents

(By Advocate Mr.N.Nagaresh )


         The applications having been heard on 28.02.2011, the Tribunal
on the same day delivered the following:

                                    4

                               O R D E RHON'BLE Mr.JUSTICE P.R.RAMAN, JUDICIAL MEMBER


           During the pendency of these OAs, the impugned order stood

revived and fresh order passed which is the subject matter of challenge in

OA 142 /2011, now pending. In the light of subsequent development

reliefs against the impugned order has become infructuous and they have

been superseded by the subsequent order. These OAs are accordingly

closed.Dated, the 28th February, 2011.K GEORGE JOSEPH                               JUSTICE P.R.RAMAN
ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER                         JUDICIAL MEMBER




vs