Patna High Court - OrdersThe Bihar Staff Selection Commission vs Nirdosh Kumar Nirala on 8 November, 2023Bench:Chief Justice,Rajiv RoyIN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA\n              Letters Patent Appeal No.296 of 2021\n======================================================\nSurjit Kumar\n\n                                                        ... ... Appellant/s\n                                 Versus\nThe State of Bihar\n\n                                          ... ... Respondent/s\n======================================================\n                                   with\n            Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 10905 of 2016\n======================================================\nNawal Kishore and Ors\n\n                                                        ... ... Petitioner/s\n                                 Versus\nThe State Of Bihar and Ors\n\n                                          ... ... Respondent/s\n======================================================\n                                   with\n                Letters Patent Appeal No. 345 of 2021\n                                   In\n             Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.7175 of 2020\n======================================================\nShardindu Kumar Pranesh\n\n                                                        ... ... Appellant/s\n                                 Versus\nThe State of Bihar\n\n                                          ... ... Respondent/s\n======================================================\n                                   with\n               Letters Patent Appeal No. 372 of 2021\n                                  In\n            Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.7175 of 2020\n======================================================\nSujit Kumar\n\n                                                        ... ... Appellant/s\n                                 Versus\nThe State of Bihar\n\n                                          ... ... Respondent/s\n======================================================\n                                   with\n                  Letters Patent Appeal No. 374 of 2021\n                                     In\n               Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.6761 of 2020\n Patna High Court L.P.A No.296 of 2021(23) dt.08-11-2023\n                                             2/7\n\n\n\n\n       ======================================================\n       Bihar Staff Selection Commission, Patna\n\n                                                          ... ... Appellant/s\n                                                Versus\n       Sudisht Kumar Mahato\n\n                                                 ... ... Respondent/s\n       ======================================================\n                                                   with\n                           Letters Patent Appeal No. 376 of 2021\n                                             In\n                       Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.7175 of 2020\n       ======================================================\n       Bihar Staff Selection Commission Patna\n\n                                                          ... ... Appellant/s\n                                                Versus\n       Kumar Praveen Pratap\n\n                                                 ... ... Respondent/s\n       ======================================================\n                                                   with\n                           Letters Patent Appeal No. 387 of 2021\n                                             In\n                       Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.7406 of 2020\n       ======================================================\n       Bihar Staff Selection Commission\n\n                                                          ... ... Appellant/s\n                                                Versus\n       Braj Kishore Sharma\n\n                                                 ... ... Respondent/s\n       ======================================================\n                                                   with\n                           Letters Patent Appeal No. 413 of 2021\n                                             In\n                       Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.9874 of 2020\n       ======================================================\n       Bihar Staff Selection Commission\n\n                                                          ... ... Appellant/s\n                                                Versus\n       Md. Parvez Alam\n\n                                                 ... ... Respondent/s\n       ======================================================\n                                                   with\n                     Letters Patent Appeal No. 414 of 2021\n                                        In\n                  Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.7414 of 2020\n       ======================================================\n Patna High Court L.P.A No.296 of 2021(23) dt.08-11-2023\n                                             3/7\n\n\n\n\n       Bihar Staff Selection Commission\n\n                                                           ... ... Appellant/s\n                                                Versus\n       Sanjay Kumar Singh\n\n                                                 ... ... Respondent/s\n       ======================================================\n                                                   with\n                          Letters Patent Appeal No. 608 of 2021\n                                            In\n                      Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.7673 of 2020\n       ======================================================\n       The Bihar Staff Selection Commission\n\n                                                           ... ... Appellant/s\n                                                Versus\n       Muntazir Alam Massum\n\n                                                 ... ... Respondent/s\n       ======================================================\n                                                   with\n                       Letters Patent Appeal No. 609 of 2021\n                                           In\n                    Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.7266 of 2020\n       ======================================================\n       The Chairman Bihar Staff Selection Commission\n\n                                                           ... ... Appellant/s\n                                                Versus\n       Sanjay Kumar Pandey\n\n                                                 ... ... Respondent/s\n       ======================================================\n                                                   with\n                        Letters Patent Appeal No. 621 of 2021\n                                            In\n                     Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.7322 of 2020\n       ======================================================\n       The Chairman, Bihar Staff Selection Commission\n\n                                                           ... ... Appellant/s\n                                       Versus\n       Rashtriya Swasthya Mission Karmachari Sangh Bihar\n\n                                                 ... ... Respondent/s\n       ======================================================\n                                                   with\n                          Letters Patent Appeal No. 663 of 2021\n                                            In\n                      Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.7567 of 2020\n       ======================================================\n       The Bihar Staff Selection Commission\n Patna High Court L.P.A No.296 of 2021(23) dt.08-11-2023\n                                             4/7\n\n\n\n\n                                                                    ... ... Appellant/s\n                                                Versus\n       Nirdosh Kumar Nirala\n\n                                                 ... ... Respondent/s\n       ======================================================\n                                                   with\n                        Letters Patent Appeal No. 84 of 2022\n                                          In\n                     Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.465 of 2021\n       ======================================================\n       Shashi Bhushan Kumar\n\n                                                                    ... ... Appellant/s\n                                                Versus\n       Bihar Staff Selection Commission\n\n                                                 ... ... Respondent/s\n       ======================================================\n                                                   with\n                       Letters Patent Appeal No. 399 of 2023\n                                          In\n                    Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.6761 of 2020\n       ======================================================\n       Priyanka Kumari\n\n                                                                    ... ... Appellant/s\n                                                Versus\n       The State of Bihar\n\n                                                 ... ... Respondent/s\n       ======================================================\n       Appearance :\n       (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 296 of 2021)\n       For the Appellant/s       :       Mr. Y. V. Giri, Senior Advocate\n                                         Mr. Sumit Kr. Jha, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Riya Giri, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Bivutosh Kumar, Advocate\n       For the State             :       Mr. Sanjay Kumar Ghosarvey, AC to AAG-3\n       For the BSSC              :       Mr. Lalit Kishore, Senior Advocate\n                                         Mr. Satyabir Bharti, Advocate\n       For the Interveners       :       Mr. Ajay Kumar Sinha, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Uday Pratap Singh, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Prashant Singh, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Shailesh Kumar, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Apurva Kumar, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Vishwanand Upadhayay, Advocate\n       (In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 10905 of 2016)\n       For the Petitioner/s      :       None\n       For the Respondent/s      :       Mr. S. D. Yadav, AAG-9\n                                         Mr. B. B. Mishra, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Prem Ranjan Kumar, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mrs. Binita Singh, Advocate\n Patna High Court L.P.A No.296 of 2021(23) dt.08-11-2023\n                                             5/7\n\n\n\n\n       (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 345 of 2021)\n       For the Appellant/s      :        Mr. Mukesh Kumar, Advocate\n       For the Respondent/s     :        Mr. S. D. Yadav, AAG-9\n                                         Mr. B. B. Mishra, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Prem Ranjan Kumar, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Anil Kumar Verma, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Arup Kumar Chongdar, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Eesha, Advocate\n       For the Interveners      :        Mr. Sanjay Kumar Singh, Advocate\n       (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 372 of 2021)\n       For the Appellant/s      :        Mr. Mukesh Kumar, Advocate\n       For the Respondent/s     :        Mr. S. D. Yadav, AAG-9\n                                         Mr. B. B. Mishra, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Prem Ranjan Kumar, AC to AAG-9\n       For the Intervenors      :        Mr. Arup Kumar Chongdar, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Eesha, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Md. Fazle Karim, Advocate\n       (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 374 of 2021)\n       For the Appellant/s      :        Mr. Lalit Kishore, Senior Advocate\n                                         Mr. Satyabir Bharti, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Abhishek Anand, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Sushmita Sharma, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Kanu Priya, Advocate\n       For the Respondent/s     :        Mrs. Nivedita Nirvikar, Senior Advocate\n                                         Mr. Arup Kumar Chongdar, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Mankeshwar Tiwari, AC to AAG-3\n       (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 376 of 2021)\n       For the Appellant/s      :        Mr. Lalit Kishore, Senior Advocate\n                                         Mr. Satyabir Bharti, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Abhishek Anand, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Sushmita Sharma, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Kanu Priya, Advocate\n       For the Respondent/s     :        Mr. S. D. Yadav, AAG-9\n                                         Mr. B. B. Mishra, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Prem Ranjan Kumar, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mrs. Nivedita Nirvikar, Senior Advocate\n       For the Intervenors      :        Mr. Arup Kumar Chongdar, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Eesha, Advocate\n       (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 387 of 2021)\n       For the Appellant/s      :        Mr. Lalit Kishore, Senior Advocate\n                                         Mr. Satyabir Bharti, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Abhishek Anand, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Sushmita Sharma, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Kanu Priya, Advocate\n       For the Respondent/s     :        Mr. Mankeshwar Tiwari, AC to AAG-3\n                                        Mrs. Nivedita Nirvikar, Senior Advocate\n                                         Mr. Arup Kumar Chongdar, Advocate\n        (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 413 of 2021)\n       For the Appellant/s      :        Mr. Lalit Kishore, Senior Advocate\n                                         Mr. Satyabir Bharti, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Abhishek Anand, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Sushmita Sharma, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Kanu Priya, Advocate\n       For the Respondent/s     :        Mr. S. D. Yadav, AAG-9\n                                         Mr. B. B. Mishra, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Prem Ranjan Kumar, AC to AAG-9\n       For the Intervenors      :        Mr. Arup Kumar Chongdar, Advocate\n Patna High Court L.P.A No.296 of 2021(23) dt.08-11-2023\n                                             6/7\n\n\n\n\n                                         Ms. Eesha, Advocate\n       (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 414 of 2021)\n       For the Appellant/s      :        Mr. Lalit Kishore, Senior Advocate\n                                        Mr. Satyabir Bharti, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Abhishek Anand, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Sushmita Sharma, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Kanu Priya, Advocate\n       For the Respondent/s     :        Mr. Prabhat Kumar Verma (AAG-3)\n       (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 608 of 2021)\n       For the Appellant/s      :        Mr. Lalit Kishore, Senior Advocate\n                                        Mr. Satyabir Bharti, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Abhishek Anand, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Sushmita Sharma, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Kanu Priya, Advocate\n       For the Respondent/s     :        Mr. S. D. Yadav, AAG-9\n                                         Mr. B. B. Mishra, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Prem Ranjan Kumar, AC to AAG-9\n       For the Intervenors      :        Mr. Arup Kumar Chongdar, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Eesha, Advocate\n       (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 609 of 2021)\n       For the Appellant/s      :        Mr. Lalit Kishore, Senior Advocate\n                                        Mr. Satyabir Bharti, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Abhishek Anand, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Sushmita Sharma, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Kanu Priya, Advocate\n       For the Respondent/s     :        Mr. S. D. Yadav, AAG-9\n                                         Mr. B. B. Mishra, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Prem Ranjan Kumar, AC to AAG-9\n       (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 621 of 2021)\n       For the Appellant/s      :        Mr. Lalit Kishore, Senior Advocate\n                                        Mr. Satyabir Bharti, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Abhishek Anand, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Sushmita Sharma, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Kanu Priya, Advocate\n       For the Respondent/s     :        Mr. S. D. Yadav, AAG-9\n                                         Mr. B. B. Mishra, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Prem Ranjan Kumar, AC to AAG-9\n       (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 663 of 2021)\n       For the Appellant/s      :        Mr. Lalit Kishore, Senior Advocate\n                                        Mr. Satyabir Bharti, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Prachi Pallavi, Advocate\n                                         Mr. Abhishek Anand, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Sushmita Sharma, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Kanu Priya, Advocate\n       For the Respondent/s     :        Mr. S. D. Yadav, AAG-9\n                                         Mr. B. B. Mishra, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Prem Ranjan Kumar, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Shiv Pratap, Advocate\n                                         Mrs. Nivedita Nirvikar, Senior Advocate\n                                         Mr. Arup Kumar Chongdar, Advocate\n                                         Ms. Eesha, Advocate\n       For the Interveners      :        Mr. Sanjay Kumar Singh, Advocate\n       (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 84 of 2022)\n       For the Appellant/s      :        Mr.Vishwajeet Kumar Mishra, Advocate\n       For the Respondent/s     :        Mr. S. D. Yadav, AAG-9\n                                         Mr. B. B. Mishra, AC to AAG-9\n                                         Mr. Prem Ranjan Kumar, AC to AAG-9\n           Patna High Court L.P.A No.296 of 2021(23) dt.08-11-2023\n                                                       7/7\n\n\n\n\n                  (In Letters Patent Appeal No. 399 of 2023)\n                  For the Appellant/s      :       Mr. Jagjit Roshan, Advocate\n                  For the Respondent/s     :       Mr. S. D. Yadav, AAG-9\n                                                   Mr. B. B. Mishra, AC to AAG-9\n                                                   Mr. Prem Ranjan Kumar, AC to AAG-9\n                  For BSSC                 :       Mr. Ravi Kumar, Advocate\n                  ======================================================\n                  CORAM: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE\n                          and\n                          HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJIV ROY\n                                        ORAL ORDER\n\n                  (Per: HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE)\n\n23   08-11-2023Pursuant to order dated 07.11.2023, learned counsel\n\n                    for the writ petitioners/appellants have filed the lists clarifying\n\n                    the position of individual petitioners whether they were\n\n                    continuing on contractual appointment when the Notification of\n\n                    2015 came and the specific qualification under which they\n\n                    claimed appointment and the nature of such qualification.Heard learned counsel for the parties.\n\n                                 Judgment is reserved.(K. Vinod Chandran, CJ)\n\n\n                                                    (Rajiv Roy, J)\nSunil/-U