Bombay High CourtPhonographic Performance Ltd vs China Gate Group (Deleted) And 4 Ors on 4 November, 2023Author:R. I. ChaglaBench:R. I. ChaglaBoard Sr.No.:-2\n\n         IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY\n             ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION\n\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 363 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd                   ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Bunglow - 9 And 99 Ors                       ....RESPONDENTWITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 1051 OF 2018\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.                  ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Avion Hospitality Pvt. Ltd. And 12 Ors.      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 114 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd                   ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Ymca International Centre And 4 Ors          ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 115 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.                  ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         J W Marriott And 4 Ors.                      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 116 OF 2019Page 1/12::: Uploaded on - 04/11/2023               ::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2023 10:50:25 :::Phonographic Performance Ltd                   ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Mykonos Blu And 4 Others                     ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 117 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd                   ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         Impresario Entertainment And Hospitality Pvt....RESPONDENT\n         Ltd And 4 Ors\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 118 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.                  ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Bhandari Forms And Resort And 4 Ors          ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 121 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.                  ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         Park Hyatt Goa Resort And Spa And 4 Ors      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 122 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd                   ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Neon The Disc And Others                     ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 123 OF 2019Page 2/12::: Uploaded on - 04/11/2023               ::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2023 10:50:25 :::Phonographic Performance Ltd.                 ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Welcom Hotel Rama International(itc) And 4 ....RESPONDENT\n         Ors.WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 126 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd                  ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Olive Bar And Kitchen Private Limited And 4....RESPONDENT\n         Ors\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 147 OF 2023\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd                 ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Snow World Entertainment                   ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 154 OF 2023\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.                ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Ambuja Neotia Holdings Pvt Ltd             ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 156 OF 2023\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd                 ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         Siddhivinayak Hospitality                  ....RESPONDENT\n\n                                       WITHPage 3/12::: Uploaded on - 04/11/2023             ::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2023 10:50:25 :::COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 221OF 2021\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd               ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         Tata Starbucks And2 Ors                 ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 235 OF 2023\n\n         Phonographic Performance Limited           ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         Gujarat Jhm Hotels Limited               ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 292OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.              ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Hotel Madhuban And19 Ors.               ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 303 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.              ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Nocturne And 15 Ors.                     ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 304 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd               ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         Orbis The Passion Hotels And 13 Ors      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                                       WITHPage 4/12::: Uploaded on - 04/11/2023           ::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2023 10:50:25 :::COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 321 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.                 ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         Fortune Select Regina And 3 Ors.            ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 343 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.                 ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         Hotel Radisson Chandigarh And 81 Ors.       ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 345 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd                   ....PETITIONER\n                      V/S\n         Bar District 6 Pub Brewery And Kitchen Prism....RESPONDENT\n         Infracon Ltd And 18 Ors\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 347 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.                 ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         The Raviz And 30 Ors.                       ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 350 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd                  ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         Pragathi Resorts And 23 Ors                 ....RESPONDENTPage 5/12::: Uploaded on - 04/11/2023              ::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2023 10:50:25 :::WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS LODGING NO. 35265\n                           OF 2022\n\n          Phonographic Performance Limited        ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n          Xeco Media Llp And 2 Ors.             ....RESPONDENT\n\n                           WITH\n COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 358 OF 2019\n\n          Phonographic Performance Ltd.           ....PETITIONER\n                       V/S\n          Iron Hill Brewery And 16 Ors.         ....RESPONDENT\n\n                           WITH\n COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 359 OF 2019\n\n          Phonographic Performance Ltd.           ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n          Moksh Lounge And 35 Ors.              ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS LODGING NO. 37130\n                           OF 2022\n\n          Phonographic Performance Limited        ....PETITIONER\n                      V/S\n          Tbse Hotels Private Limited           ....RESPONDENT\n\n                           WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS LODGING NO. 3997\n                          OF 2023\n\n          Phonographic Performance Limited        ....PETITIONERPage 6/12::: Uploaded on - 04/11/2023        ::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2023 10:50:25 :::V/S\n          Lijo Joy                                    ....RESPONDENT\n\n                           WITH\n COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 40 OF 2023\n\n          Phonographic Performance Limited              ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n          Fml Hospitality Private Limited             ....RESPONDENT\n\n                           WITH\n COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 914OF 2018\n\n          Phonographic Performance Ltd.                 ....PETITIONER\n                      V/S\n          The Vision Group (the Crown) And6 Ors      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                           WITH\n COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 938 OF 2018\n\n          Phonographic Performance Ltd.                 ....PETITIONER\n                      V/S\n          City Organisers Pvt. Ltd. And 9 Others      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                           WITH\n COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 966 OF 2018\n\n          Phonographic Performance Ltd.                 ....PETITIONER\n                      V/S\n          Nyati Hotels And Resorts Pvt Ltd. And 20 Ors.....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS LODGING NO. 37964\n                           OF 2022Page 7/12::: Uploaded on - 04/11/2023              ::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2023 10:50:25 :::Phonographic Performance Limited              ....PETITIONER\n                      V/S\n         Sai Skills (kalamandir) Limited             ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 120 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd                 ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         British Brewing Company Pvt Ltd And 4 Ors ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 127 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.                 ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         China Gate Group (deleted) And 4 Ors.       ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 291 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.                 ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         Farzi Cafe And 22 Ors.                      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 290 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd.                   ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Health View Resort Pvt. Ltd. (keys Hotel) And....RESPONDENT\n         27 Ors.WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 319 OF 2019Page 8/12::: Uploaded on - 04/11/2023              ::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2023 10:50:25 :::Phonographic Performance Ltd                 ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n          Rennaissance Lucknow And 31 Ors            ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS LODGING NO. 37136\n                           OF 2022\n\n          Phonographic Performance Limited Cin No    ....PETITIONER\n          U74999mh1941gap142271 Through Jitendra\n          Indalkar\n                     V/S\n          Mgoh Private Limited Cin No             ....RESPONDENT\n          U55101mh2020ptc346259\n\n                           WITH\n COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 922OF 2018\n\n          Phonographic Performance Ltd.                 ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n          Hotel Babylon International And Group And2....RESPONDENT\n          Ors\n\n                           WITH\n COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 306 OF 2019\n\n          Phonographic Performance Ltd.                ....PETITIONER\n                      V/S\n          Hotel Hilton And 10 Ors.                   ....RESPONDENT\n\n                           WITH\n COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 155 OF 2023\n\n          Phonographic Performance Limited             ....PETITIONER\n                     V/SPage 9/12::: Uploaded on - 04/11/2023             ::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2023 10:50:25 :::Vedic Resorts And Hotesl Pvt. Ltd.      ....RESPONDENT\n\n                             WITH\n          INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 4038OF 2023\n\n         Phonographic Performance Limited          ....PETITIONER\n                     V/S\n         Lijo Joy And Ors....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 157 OF 2023\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd              ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         The Byke Hospitality Ltd                ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 148 OF 2023\n\n         Phonographic Perfirmance Ltd              ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Mayfiar Hotels And Resorts Ltd          ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 119OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd              ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Corum Hospitality And4 Ors             ....RESPONDENT\n\n                          WITH\nCOMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 145 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd              ....PETITIONER\n                    V/SPage 10/12::: Uploaded on - 04/11/2023          ::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2023 10:50:25 :::Balaji Agora Mall And 38 Ors               ....RESPONDENT\n\n                            WITH\nNOTICE OF MOTION IN COMMERCIAL DIVISION MATTERS NO. 725 OF 2019\n                              In\n  COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 363 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd                 ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Bunglow - 9 And 99 Ors                     ....RESPONDENT\n\n                           WITH\n            INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1533 OF 2020\n                             In\n  COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 363 OF 2019\n\n         Phonographic Performance Ltd                 ....PETITIONER\n                    V/S\n         Bunglow - 9 And 99 Ors                     ....RESPONDENT\n\n         Mr. Ravi Kadam Sr. Advocate(Through V.C.), Mr. Amogh\n         Singh, Asmant Nimbalkar, Neeraj Nawar, Shivani Rane, Nisha\n         Dubey i/b Mr. D P Singh For Plaintiff in COMIP/363/2019\n         Mr. Amogh Singh, Apurva Manwani, Asmant Nimbalkar,\n         Neeraj Nawar, Shivani Rane, Nisha Dubey i/b Mr. D P Singh\n         for Paintiff in COMIP/221/2021\n         Mr. Sameer Pandit a/w Ms. Sarrah Khambati Mr Mihir Govande\n         i/b Wadia Ghandy & Co. For Defendant in COMIP/157/2023\n         Mr. Abhiraj Parab a/w Anjali Malikar, A. Manjrekar & Pooja\n         Mishra for Defendant No. 18 in COMIP/345/2019\n         Mr. Amit Jamsandekar a/w Mahua Roy Chowdhury, Akshay\n         Kapadia, Jahnavi Singh, Angel Mary Aju i/b Royzz & Co. For\n         Defendant No.1 in COMIP/221/2021, IA(L)/2633/2021\n         Mr. Ashish Kamat Sr. Adv. Mr. Amogh Singh, Asmant\n         Nimbalkar, Neeraj Nawar, Shivani Rane, Nisha Dubey, i/b. Mr.Page 11/12::: Uploaded on - 04/11/2023             ::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2023 10:50:25 :::D P Singh for Applicant/Plaintiff in COMIP/1051/2018\n Mr. Amogh Singh, Asmant Nimbalkar, Neeraj Nawar, Shivani\n Rane Nisha Dubey i/b Mr. D P Singh for Applicant/Plaintiff in\n all Matters.(Part Heard)\n\n\n\n        CORAM :                HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE R. I. CHAGLA J\n        DATE :                 4th November, 2023\n P.C. :S. O. to 07/11/2023 ( at 2.30 pm).( ASSOCIATE )Page 12/12::: Uploaded on - 04/11/2023                         ::: Downloaded on - 05/11/2023 10:50:25 :::