en en en en fr en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en fr en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en sv en en en en vi en en en en vi en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en de en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en lv en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en fi ca en es es en en zh cv en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en
State senators push to end secrecy in filling empty court seats as controversial pick is approved · Spotlight PA
Investigations Events Newsletters Staff Tips State College SearchSupport Us
by Angela Couloumbis | Dec. 18, 2019
A group of Democratic state senators said a news conference Wednesday they want to reform the largely-secret nomination process for filling judicial vacancies. Pictured from right-to-left: Sen. Katie Muth (D., Montgomery), Sen. Maria Collett (D., Montgomery), Sen. Anthony Williams (D., Philadelphia), Sen. Lindsey Williams (D., Allegheny) and Maida Milone, president and CEO of Pennsylvanians for Modern Courts.
HARRISBURG — The state Senate on Wednesday confirmed Gov. Wolf’s controversial pick to fill a vacancy on a statewide appellate court, even as a group of senators criticized the secrecy surrounding the judicial nominating process and said they will introduce a bill to make it more transparent.
Drew Crompton, 51, the top lawyer and strategist to the lead Republican in the Senate, cleared the final hurdle to fill a vacant spot on the state’s Commonwealth Court, which hears cases involving government agencies, including state agencies.
His nomination last month sparked an outcry among some Democrats who criticized it as a blatantly political choice and questioned his qualifications and impartiality. The pick renewed concerns about Pennsylvania’s judicial nominating process, which unfolds almost entirely behind closed doors.
“It is a system that is dangerous, corrosive, antiquated and doesn’t meet the standard if we want the best people on the bench,” Sen. Anthony Williams (D., Philadelphia) said at an afternoon news conference.
Williams is one of four senators who said they will introduce a bill to make the process more transparent. The measure would require the governor’s office to publicly post on its website the names of all applicants for a judicial vacancy, as well as the extensive paperwork they must fill out when they apply.
The public would then have 30 days to comment on the applications before the governor decides who to nominate. That would be followed by a televised public hearing that includes a question-and-answer session with the nominees.
As it stands now, when a vacancy occurs on the bench, the governor solicits applications to fill the positions, but does not make them public. Instead, the administration, together with the top Senate leaders from both parties, eventually hammer out a deal behind closed doors — and with no public input — on who to ultimately nominate to fill the spots.
By the time the nominations are sent to Senate, which must approve them, the votes have been shored up and the confirmation process becomes largely ceremonial. Crompton was confirmed by a 42-7 vote.
“Becoming a judge should not involve who you know, and it should not involve backdoor deals, and it should not involve getting something handed to you. You should be judged on merit, your ethics and your moral compass,” said Sen. Katie Muth (D., Montgomery), one of the supporters of changing the nominating process.
It is unclear whether the Democratic senators’ proposal has a chance of passing. Jennifer Kocher, the spokesperson for Senate Majority Leader Jake Corman (R., Centre), said Republicans would review the measure once it is formally introduced. Wolf’s office said it is “open” to discussing reforms.
But historically, the legislature has turned a deaf ear to calls for changing the system for how judges are chosen.
Wolf has been largely silent on why he chose Crompton, a Republican lawyer who has worked in the Senate for 26 years. For much of that time, Crompton has been a key strategist for both the Senate Republican caucus’ policy and politics, serving as both chief counsel and chief of staff to Senate President Pro Tempore Joe Scarnati (R., Jefferson).
In his position, Crompton weighs in on nearly every significant piece of legislation pushed by Republicans in the chamber. He has helped draft hundreds of key policies on everything from the environment to education to elections.
He has also been deeply involved in handling some of the Senate’s messiest personnel problems, including a recent sexual harassment scandal in which Republicans, in a controversial move, quietly decided to pay the legal bills of the person accused of harassment.
During his years in the Capitol, Crompton has amassed both loyal supporters and fierce critics. The former believe he is smart and will bring a thoughtful, reasoned approach to the bench. His critics take aim at his lack of judicial experience and believe it will be difficult for him to be impartial.
During a hearing in the Senate Judiciary committee Wednesday, Crompton said he would recuse himself “when warranted.” Pressed to elaborate, he said he would step away from deciding any cases involving laws or policies he has been closely involved in drafting.
He also pushed back on criticisms that he is too partisan, saying much of his work in the Senate involved “bipartisan work on behalf of the institution of the Senate, on behalf of the legislative branch and sometimes in conjunction with the executive branch, Republican or Democrat.”
“Some of this does, in fact, come down to integrity," Crompton told members of the committee. “… I believe the people who have worked closest with me understand the integrity that I have operated with for two decades. And I plan on taking my personal integrity to the judicial branch and separating myself from my prior life.”
Once he is sworn in, Crompton will serve through 2021, at which point he will have to decide whether to run for a full term.
Spotlight PA receives funding from nonprofit institutions and readers like you who are committed to investigative journalism that gets results. Become a Founding Donor today at spotlightpa.org.
THIS IS JUST THE BEGINNING...
We believe everyone in Pennsylvania should have access to trusted public-service and investigative journalism. That’s why we don’t have a paywall on our site, charge a subscription fee, or clutter our articles with ads that have nothing to do with our state.
Instead, we use the honor system.
Each of our stories costs hundreds if not thousands of dollars to produce. If you learned something today, do your part and join our effort to rebuild reliable, high-quality local journalism in Pennsylvania by making a tax-deductible contribution of any amount. We can’t do this work without you.
Support Spotlight PA »
I am a robot
Never Miss a Story
Sign up for PA Post and get a free daily email with top news from across PA, plus some fun, too.
You’re invited! Pennsylvania’s top election official answers your voting questions live
by Spotlight PA Staff
Photo Courtesy Chris Harter
Talk of a tax increase is driving a wedge between leaders of a growing Pa. township and its fire company
by Min Xian of Spotlight PA State College
Tom Gralish / Philadelphia Inquirer
A complete guide and amendment tracker for proposed changes to Pennsylvania’s Constitution
by Danielle Ohl of Spotlight PA
Leise Hook / For Spotlight PA
Pa. law protects workers who are approved for medical marijuana — but once they use it, it’s a different story.
by Ed Mahon of Spotlight PA
THE LATEST ON COVID-19
Dan Nott / For Spotlight PA
Pa. COVID updates: Your guide to finding resources on cases, vaccines, and tests
by Spotlight PA Staff
THOMAS HENGGE & STEVEN M. FALK / Philadelphia Inquirer
Pa. election 2022: Your complete guide to the candidates for governor
by Stephen Caruso of Spotlight PA, Ethan Edward Coston of Spotlight PA and Angela Couloumbis of Spotlight PA
More Stories from Spotlight PA
Sex offender registry law in Pa. facing life-or-death test at Supreme Court
Secrecy, deal-making rule in process to pick Pa.'s interim judges
Citing Spotlight PA/Caucus probe, top lawmaker pushes limits on campaign donations, stricter disclosure rules
by Sam Janesch, The Caucus and Angela Couloumbis, Spotlight PA
Sara Simon / Spotlight PA
She’s paid by taxpayers. So why is top Pa. Senate aide wining and dining on a campaign credit card?
by Angela Couloumbis of Spotlight PA and Alyssa Biederman of The Inquirer
Kalim A. Bhatti/Philadelphia Inquirer
Pa. lawmakers abruptly abandon attempt to limit public access to campaign expenses
Courtesy of The Philadelphia Inquirer
Mystery trip to Europe with ‘donors’ by Pa. state senators followed expansion of wine law
by Angela Couloumbis of Spotlight PA and Brad Bumsted and Sam Janesch of The Caucus
Kalim A. Bhatti/Philadelphia Inquirer
Hours after investigation reveals millions in hidden campaign spending, Pa. lawmakers push for less oversight
by Angela Couloumbis of Spotlight PA and Sam Janesch of The Caucus
SARA SIMON / Spotlight PA
How we uncovered nearly $3.5M in dark spending by Pa. lawmakers
by Angela Couloumbis of Spotlight PA and Brad Bumsted of The Caucus
Andre Schönherr / St. Peter Stiftskulinarium
Lavish dinners, sports tickets, and nearly $3.5 million in other expenses by Pa. lawmakers you’ve never seen
by Angela Couloumbis of Spotlight PA and Mike Wereschagin, Brad Bumsted, Paula Knudsen, Sam Janesch and Alyssa Biederman of The Caucus
Courtesy of The Inquirer
Racial profiling in traffic stops? We won’t know, because Pa. State Police no longer track racial data.
by Angela Couloumbis and Daniel Simmons-Ritchie
Spotlight PA relies on funding from foundations and readers like you who are committed to accountability journalism that gets results.
If you value this reporting, please give a gift today at spotlightpa.org/donate.
Special Projects & Investigations
This site is powered by Netlify
228 Walnut St., #11728
Could not load results. ${error.message}
Sign Up For Our Free Newsletters
Get every Spotlight PA story and
the best investigative journalism from across Pa.
PA Post (Daily): Top news every weekday morning, plus a daily puzzle.
The Investigator (Weekly): Best accountability journalism every Thursday, plus a weekly riddle.
PA Local (Weekly): A fresh look at the incredible people, places, and food of Pa. every Friday, plus events, guides, best-of, and more.