en en it en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en pl en en en en en sv fr de de fr fr fr sv en fr en ja fr de fr es nb fr de en en sv de de fr en fr it fr en fr en ar en en en en en en
In late August, occupation authorities in the eastern Ukrainian town of Kupyansk held celebrations to mark Russian Flag Day.
A few dozen people — including both pro-Kremlin activists and locals who had stayed in the town after it was captured by Russian forces six months ago — unfurled an enormous 60mx40m Russian tricolour on the main square, then waved flags and danced to a medley of patriotic tunes.
Just a few weeks later, the Russian occupying forces were gone after a surprise Ukrainian attack forced them to surrender more than 3,000 sq km of territory, leaving tanks, armoured vehicles and supplies.
Syrian Civil War Fast Facts | CNN
READ: The Meadows text messages from January 6
Track changes between the Supreme Court abortion decision…
The stunning reversal has shattered the mantra, repeated by senior officials visiting occupied territories over the spring and summer, that “Russia is here forever” in southeastern Ukraine.
Backed by western weapons and intelligence, Ukraine’s lightning counter-offensive across the Kharkiv region has shifted the momentum of the war, laying bare the vulnerability of Russia’s overstretched invasion forces and shattering the illusion of normalcy at home the Kremlin has worked to sustain.
The dramatic retreat on the battlefield is only one of a number of Ukraine setbacks that Russian leader Vladimir Putin has faced this week.
Russia’s budget surplus for the year has almost evaporated, according to figures published this week, due to weaker oil prices and dwindling gas deliveries to Europe — potentially putting even greater pressure on the economy. The EU is mobilising for an energy war with Moscow with no sign of weakening resolve over western sanctions against Russia.
Ukrainian soldiers on a rooftop in Kupyansk. Ukraine’s counter-offensive in the Kharkiv region has shifted the momentum of the war © Telegram @kuptg via REUTERS
Non-western leaders who have until now stood by Moscow have begun to distance themselves from the Kremlin’s war. The Russian president acknowledged at a summit on Thursday in Uzbekistan that his Chinese counterpart Xi Jinping had “questions and concerns” about the invasion. On Friday, India’s Narendra Modi publicly rebuked Putin at the same summit, saying “today’s era is not an era of war”.
Since Putin ordered the invasion of Ukraine in February, the Russian leader has maintained the public stance that it is a “special military operation” — a term designed to introduce a sense of business as usual in domestic life, evoking far-off conflicts in places like Syria rather than Russians’ traumatic memories of bloody, grinding wars in Chechnya and Afghanistan.
But that position is becoming increasingly untenable — both from a military point of view and in terms of domestic politics.
Some military analysts believe he has little choice but to order a significant escalation of the conflict.
“By the end of this year, the Kremlin will lose almost all of its artillery ammunition, almost all of its armoured vehicles, battle tanks and the main part of its ground forces,” says Pavel Luzin, an expert on the Russian military. “How can you continue the war without artillery and troops?”
He also finds himself being under pressure at home not just from the liberal opposition, much of which has either fled the country or is too fearful to criticise the invasion, but also from the right, including some of the most prominent cheerleaders of the war who are urging him to escalate.
Alexei Venediktov, the editor of liberal radio station Ekho Moskvy, says Putin is playing a very dangerous game © AFP via Getty Images
With no victory in sight, it is becoming increasingly difficult to shield Russians from the war’s blowback.
“He’s playing a very dangerous game,” says Alexei Venediktov, the longtime editor of liberal radio station Ekho Moskvy, which was closed down in March.
“It’s a battle of resources, and the most important resource is time. Now either he waits out longer than Europe [during the winter], or the Russian people get tired,” Venediktov adds. “And it’s unclear what collapses first — Putin, or everyone else.”
Shadowy drive for recruits
On Wednesday, a video emerged online of Yevgeny Prigozhin, a caterer-turned-warlord known as “Putin’s chef”, addressing convicts in a Russian prison yard.
Prigozhin urged the prisoners to fight on the front lines in Wagner, a shadowy paramilitary group the US says he runs. If they survived six months, they would get amnesty; if they deserted, he said, they would be executed.
The video highlighted how Russia has been forced to adapt as the war drags on with no victory in sight.
You are seeing a snapshot of an interactive graphic. This is most likely due to being offline or JavaScript being disabled in your browser.
Russia’s covert operations are now overt: Wagner advertises on billboards across Russia. Prigozhin appeared to confirm the video’s authenticity after denying the group’s very existence for years.
The apparent drive to recruit prisoners for Prigozhin’s militia has made Russia’s manpower problems starker still. “Either mercenaries and inmates [fight], or your children do — decide for yourselves,” Prigozhin wrote in a subsequent social media post.
Russia’s problems only begin there. By cutting off Russia’s main north-south supply line and occupying a vital staging ground for Moscow’s troops, Ukraine has in effect scuppered the Kremlin’s stated objective of “liberating” the entire Donbas region, say analysts. It has given Kyiv’s forces battlefield momentum and Ukraine’s western allies reassurance that it will prevail with their support.
“This counter-offensive shows very well that the Russian armed forces are exhausted,” says Luzin.
Russia’s defense ministry acknowledged the retreat but described it as a “regrouping”.
Moscow’s setback in Kharkiv has stirred criticism from the most virulent pro-war camp at home, which has openly bemoaned the defeat and raced to find someone to blame.
This more radical, sabre-rattling group has long criticised the Kremlin for not going far enough in its assault on Ukraine. It wants Putin to declare a full-scale war, propelling Russia’s large conscript army into battle and mobilising the wider population and economy.
“For the first half-year of the conflict Russia has been waging war like Britain once did in its colonies,” says Alexander Borodai, a Russian MP who commands three volunteer battalions currently fighting in Ukraine. “The brave little English soldiers in red are fighting somewhere in India. And the metropole is going on as usual with its balls, society galas and salons.”
Russian MP Alexander Borodai: ‘For the first half-year of the conflict Russia has been waging war like Britain once did in its colonies’ © AFP via Getty Images
Borodai, who previously led a Moscow-backed Donbas separatist government, adds: “Sometimes a sun-tanned, hopped-up Rudyard Kipling comes to read his romantic poetry about blood, dust and sand. They applaud, donate to charity, and then he goes back and life goes on.”
This ultranationalist camp is a minority, existing on the fringes of Russian politics, and is mostly made up of military bloggers and other commentators writing on the Telegram messaging app.
However, it can still have political resonance. “History is made by the minorities,” says Tatiana Stanovaya, founder of Moscow political consultancy R.Politik.
The hyperactivity of the ultranationalist group, and its highly vocal and emotional response to the defeat in Kharkiv, is affecting the mainstream pro-Kremlin elite, from the TV anchors to the technocrats, making its members nervous, says Stanovaya.
“If before, their fears were around the war dragging on, and potentially lasting years . . . Now, fears have appeared that Russia could lose,” she says. “This raises questions about the future of everyone who plays a role and whose fate is tied up with that of the government.”
The ultranationalist critique has not gone unnoticed in the Kremlin. Spokesperson Dmitry Peskov on Tuesday sent a barely veiled threat, warning them to not take the clamouring too far — a rare admission that criticism may be unsettling Russia’s leadership.
“When it comes to other points of view, critical ones, when these stay within the bounds of the existing legislation, it’s pluralism,” Peskov said. “But the line is very, very thin. One has to be very careful here.”
For the time-being, the ultranationalist group’s views do not align with those of the wider population. The majority of Russians appear happy to passively support Putin and the war, but prefer to pay as little attention to it as possible. Their support is predicated on them not having to escalate their involvement.
These “laymen”, as Greg Yudin, head of Political Philosophy at the Moscow School of Social and Economic Sciences, has termed them, are “completely depoliticised” and don’t want to engage in any way with the war.
Some of the war’s supporters have proposed half-measures to boost the war effort without alienating what Venediktov calls the “indifferently loyal” bulk of the population.
Borodai suggests a partial mobilisation of up to 400,000 men and declaring martial law only on Russia’s border. “It’s long past time to admit we are at war. And everything else follows from that,” he says.
Ramzan Kadyrov, the strongman leader of Chechnya, suggested that the government try a “self-mobilisation” approach instead.
This would put the burden of mobilisation on regional leaders, rather than on the Kremlin or ministry of defence. Moscow has deployed this tactic for unpopular policies before, most notably during the pandemic, when Putin wanted to introduce lockdowns without taking responsibility for them.
Putin’s response to the setbacks in Ukraine remains a mystery. Even six months after Russia’s troops swarmed over all of eastern and central Ukraine, Putin has attempted to keep his options open. In public, he speaks repeatedly about efforts to gain control of the whole of Donbas but rarely mentions other hotspots such as Kharkiv and Kherson.
But as a result, “nobody knows why we need Kharkiv, as opposed to the Donbas,” a person close to the Kremlin says. “Putin might know what he wants, but the rest are all guessing. He’s been in power for 20 years and has become this godlike figure. So we assume he must know what he wants. But he’s not explaining it to the people who are actually doing the work.”
Ramzan Kadyrov, centre, the strongman leader of Chechnya, suggested that the Russian government try a ‘self-mobilisation’ approach © Chingis Kondarov/Reuters
Speaking on Friday, Putin insisted that Russia would not change its operational plans and that its main goal remained “liberating all of the Donbas.” He claimed Russia’s offensive operations were bringing more territory under its control.
“We are not fighting with the whole army, but only part of it,” Putin said, according to the RIA Novosti news agency. “We are not in a rush.”
Putin could choose to escalate the conflict. This week Russia stepped up missile strikes on Ukraine’s critical infrastructure, hitting the power network, district heating plants and hydroelectric installations, in what Ukrainian prime minister Denys Shmyhal described as an attempt to terrorise the Ukrainian population as winter approaches.
Though Russian radicals reacted with glee, “revenge is an act of helplessness”, the person close to the Kremlin says. “The most dangerous situation is if Russia loses, because then Putin might turn to more unconventional means.”
Putin could also try to expand the conflict by provoking a clash with Nato, says Luzin, thereby justifying a full mobilisation at home to expand the armed forces. But military experts say it would take several months to produce trained men integrated into military units with commanders and equipment.
Such a move would also make the war impossible to ignore for ordinary Russians — with potential consequences for Putin’s popularity. Yet as Ukraine advances, the radicals are urging him to go further.
“Most Russians want us to stop playing at the ‘special military operation,’ take our white gloves off, and really hit Kyiv where it hurts. We haven’t been doing this so far out of politeness,” Borodai says.
He insists the retreat will only prove a minor setback. “At the start of the second world war, Russia and the Soviet Union suffered the most terrible defeats on the battlefield, but ended the war in Berlin,” Borodai says. “So maybe this campaign will end like that one, too — perhaps right there, in Berlin?”
Quoted from Various Sources
You may also like
Japan’s Shionogi says COVID pill reaches Phase III milestone By Reuters
Wall Street banks to pay $1.8bn over messaging violations
Hockey players’ scoring after learning their teammates’ pay could show the pitfalls of knowing what your coworkers make
Cathie Wood’s new fund gives small investors access to the VC market for just $500
Farmers threaten to quit NFU as leader backs scrapping of “Brexit bonus” nature subsidies
Gold Rises From Two-Year Low as Dollar’s Steep Increase Stalls
Japan’s Shionogi says COVID pill reaches Phase III milestone By Reuters
Wall Street banks to pay $1.8bn over messaging violations
Hockey players’ scoring after learning their teammates’ pay could show the pitfalls of knowing what your coworkers make
Cathie Wood’s new fund gives small investors access to the VC market for just $500
Farmers threaten to quit NFU as leader backs scrapping of “Brexit bonus” nature subsidies
Categories Select Category @Nordstrom #EQUALITY • 7 of 8 People Are Clueless About This Trillion-Dollar Market • Motley Fool Issues Rare Triple-Buy Alert • This Stock Could Be Like Buying Amazon in 1997 $230 billion in cash 000 medical trainees from foreign countries 2017 6 AAN AAPL according according to Ariely AMZN annual sales anti-Trump protest in Mexico City bailout agreed in 2015 behavioral economist Dan Ariely BIG biometric payments brought back unlimited plans earlier last year Business Administration Business Analyst Business Center Business Class Business Consultant Business Development Business Digital Business Economics Business Environment Business Executive Business Global Business Goals Business Growth Business Idea Business Inquiries Business Intelligence Business Journal Business Kit Business Knowledge Business Logic Business News Business Plan Business Risk BuzzFeed noted last December. CHTR clashing with Apple CNNMoney’s own Fear & Greed Index COKE compliance cut its CEO’s pay deal immediately boosted prices described eliminated its version of an unlimited usage plan in 2011 EQIX February 12 February 8 finally disappear in 2017 General Article GOOG Health hinted that Tesla may soon come to India. INFY intraday trading high is scheduled for a final vote before the full Senate IWM JJSF jumped 7{3b930a6ca12a59604e1bbadfc55b7d1b7a0aa8613f1ab9377cace0d5afcb5fb9} in the first two days JWN KAMN knocked the department store on Twitter in retaliation LeBron James M made their own bids to attract customers MAS MSFT NAFTA Nearly all NYC subways get cell service one of the top buyers pic.twitter.com/ki5NaJN12d Qapital Visa Debit Related: ‘Without NAFTA’ we’d be out of business Related: A startup that makes pencils that grow into vegetables Related: Apple stock nears a record high Related: Charter shares popped on report of possible Verizon takeover Related: Elon Musk’s surprising secret weapon: Trump? Related: Here’s why the world’s largest money manager is worried Related: How Europe’s elections could be hacked Related: India freaks out over U.S. plans to change high-skilled visas Related: Is Ivanka Trump’s brand losing its bling? Related: Kellyanne Conway unrepentant for Ivanka Trump plug Related: Mexican farmer’s daughter: NAFTA destroyed us Related: Mexico doubles down on Trump ‘contingency plan’ Related: Obamacare’s impact on this Alaska town with only one doctor’s office Related: OPEC has pulled off one of its ‘deepest’ production cuts Related: Oreo make is worried about rise of populism Related: Possible pick for Treasury secretary makes his film debut Related: Pro-Trump boycott calls follow Super Bowl ads Related: Rare streak for U.S. stocks: Long stretch without a 1{3b930a6ca12a59604e1bbadfc55b7d1b7a0aa8613f1ab9377cace0d5afcb5fb9} dive Related: Remember Smoot-Hawley: America’s last major trade war Related: Stocks have avoided a 1{3b930a6ca12a59604e1bbadfc55b7d1b7a0aa8613f1ab9377cace0d5afcb5fb9} dive for an unusually long period of time Related: T-Mobile and Sprint offer new ‘unlimited’ data plans — sort of Related: Tech industry braces for Trump’s visa reform Related: Tesla reveals what it will charge for a charge Related: The company turning 4 billion plastic bottles into clothes Related: Those Reagan tariffs Trump loves to talk about Related: Tim Cook: ‘Apple would not exist without immigration’ Related: Trump furious after court upholds block on travel ban Related: Trump isn’t killing the bull market Related: Trump travel ban and what you need to know Related: Uber CEO drops out of Trump’s business advisory council Related: Uber suspends its service in Taiwan as fines mount Related: Uber’s rivals are teaming up in Asia Related: Verizon brings back unlimited data plans Related: Visa ban could make doctor shortage in rural America even worse Related: Wall Street has powerful seat at Trump’s table renegotiate NAFTA research S said Jan. 13 sales Saudi oil minister: I don’t lose sleep over shale Sears spokesman Brian Hanover told Reuters Serena Williams similarly eliminated overage fees for customers in September smartphone recall woes Smoot-Hawley Act. Speaking with The Daily Telegraph newspaper T teased plans temporarily halted temporary immigration ban tenth anniversary TIF TJX TMUS to go green Trump has often slammed TSLA TWX VG VIX VZ why it decided to stop carrying Ivanka Trump’s clothing and accessories label YHOO
Archives Select Month September 2022 August 2022 July 2022 June 2022 May 2022 April 2022 March 2022 February 2022 January 2022 December 2021 November 2021 October 2021 August 2021 July 2021 May 2021 March 2021 January 2021 December 2020 November 2020 October 2020 September 2020 August 2020 July 2020 June 2020 May 2020 April 2020 March 2020 February 2020 December 2019 November 2019 October 2019 September 2019 August 2019 July 2019 June 2019 May 2019 April 2019 March 2019 February 2019 January 2019 December 2018 September 2018 February 2017 January 1970