Aligned LLMs Are Not Aligned Browser Agents
Priyanshu Kumar Elaine Lau Saranya Vijayakumar Tu Trinh Elaine T Chang Vaughn Robinson Shuyan Zhou Matt Fredrikson Sean M. Hendryx Summer Yue Zifan Wang
For safety reasons, large language models (LLMs) are trained to refuse harmful user instructions, such as assisting dangerous activities. We study an open question in this work: does the desired safety refusal, typically enforced in chat contexts, generalize to non-chat and agentic use cases? Unlike chatbots, LLM agents equipped with general-purpose tools, such as web browsers and mobile devices, can directly influence the real world, making it even more crucial to refuse harmful instructions. In this work, we primarily focus on red-teaming browser
agents – LLMs that leverage information via web browsers. To this end, we introduce Browser Agent Red teaming Toolkit (BrowserART), a comprehensive test suite designed specifically for red-teaming browser agents. BrowserART consists of 100 diverse browser-related harmful behaviors (including original behaviors and ones sourced from HarmBench (Mazeika et al., 2024) and AirBench 2024 (Zeng et al., 2024b)) across both synthetic and real websites. Our empirical study on state-of-the-art browser agents reveals that while the backbone LLM refuses harmful instructions as a chatbot, the corresponding agent does not. Moreover, attack methods designed to jailbreak refusal-trained LLMs in the chat settings transfer effectively to browser agents. With human rewrites, GPT-4o and o1-preview -based browser agents pursued 98 and 63 harmful behaviors (out of 100), respectively. Therefore, simply ensuring LLM’s refusal to harmful instruc-
tions in chats is not sufficient to ensure that the downstream agents are safe. We publicly release BrowserART and call on LLM developers, policymakers, and agent developers to collaborate on improving agent safety.
LLM, agents, red teaming, safety, adversarial robustness, alignment, jailbreak
We find LLM browser agents are incredible unsafe, even if the the base LLMs are safety-aligned.