text: I am in a very similar situation with a guy. We have never talked before, but we are constantly making eye contact every day at each other. It's like, whenever I look over at him, he is looking at me. You cant really tell if a girl LIKES you if you have never talked, but you can tell if a girl is attracted to you. There is a difference. If you catch her looking at you, then quickly turning away or acting shy around you, its a good sign that she is attracted to you.