Mr. Earth, is it possible to have a discussion that doesn't involve disparaging comments? I have a 12 year old male lab that weighs 80lbs and I honestly don't think he would fit or enjoy the space designated for feet. I don't fly first class and I don't request a bulkhead seat. I think the question is a reasonable accommodation based on the current fare structure that allows a service animal to fly for free. I mentioned that airlines sell space, this is how they make a living. I think Peggy below answer in part the question of reasonableness, but it does not address the situation with larger breeds. Personally, I wouldn't mind sitting next to a lab, but not a pony or a bird. People purchase a seat on a commercial flight and that is their space. I don't know why the airline acted the way it did but I'm sure we'll find out the rest of the story in court.