This is another example of where we are so divided in this country and stuck like super glue to our opinions that no constructive discussion can occur.   The premise of the one payer group is that all people should have health care and that it is the government's responsibility to provide it (and therefore it is another entitlement paid for by everyone).  I have not seen thoughtful discussions that address whether this is really our government's responsibility or what exactly government's responsibility is.   I am frankly sick of the emotions and  hysteria on both sides.