[null, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/award1_fpo.width-200.png", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/award1_fpo.width-200.png", "formatted_filename": "award fpo", "alt_text": "avvo"}, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/award_4_fpo.width-200.png", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/award_4_fpo.width-200.png", "formatted_filename": "award fpo", "alt_text": "advocates forum"}, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/superlawyers.width-200.png", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/superlawyers.width-200.png", "formatted_filename": "superlawyers", "alt_text": "Superlawyers"}, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/award_2_fpo.width-200.png", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/award_2_fpo.width-200.png", "formatted_filename": "award fpo", "alt_text": "client"}, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/award_3_fpo.width-200.png", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/award_3_fpo.width-200.png", "formatted_filename": "award fpo", "alt_text": "legal speciality"}, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/american-justice-association.width-200.png", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/american-justice-association.width-200.png", "formatted_filename": "american justice association", "alt_text": "AAFJ"}, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/av-rating-full.width-200.png", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/av-rating-full.width-200.png", "formatted_filename": "av rating full", "alt_text": "AV rating"}, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/john_avvo.width-200.png", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/john_avvo.width-200.png", "formatted_filename": "john avvo", "alt_text": "john_avvo_rating"}, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/ClientChampion_Platinum_MDH_250px_Mech.width-200.png", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/ClientChampion_Platinum_MDH_250px_Mech.width-200.png", "formatted_filename": "ClientChampion Platinum MDH px Mech", "alt_text": "Client Champion"}, null, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/rinehardt_quote.original.original.png", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/rinehardt_quote.original.original.png", "formatted_filename": "rinehardt quote", "alt_text": "video quote"}, null, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/CACY.width-150.png", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/CACY.width-150.png", "formatted_filename": "CACY", "alt_text": "CACY"}, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/DARE.original3.width-150.jpg", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/DARE.original3.width-150.jpg", "formatted_filename": "DARE", "alt_text": "DARE"}, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/EndDD.original3.width-150.jpg", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/EndDD.original3.width-150.jpg", "formatted_filename": "EndDD", "alt_text": "EndDD"}, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/Humane_Society.width-150.png", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/Humane_Society.width-150.png", "formatted_filename": "Humane Society", "alt_text": "Humane Society"}, null, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/thanksgiveaway-2_resize.b45c2c02.fill-550x200.jpg", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/thanksgiveaway-2_resize.b45c2c02.fill-550x200.jpg", "formatted_filename": "thanksgiveaway resize", "alt_text": "thanksgiveaway"}, null, {"document_url": "https://www.rinehardtlawfirm.com/", "unformatted_src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/med-mal_resize.2e16d0ba.fill-550x200.jpg", "src": "https://d2725vydq9j3xi.cloudfront.net/production/media/lawyer_rinehardt/images/med-mal_resize.2e16d0ba.fill-550x200.jpg", "formatted_filename": "med mal resize", "alt_text": "medical malpractice"}, null]
Small Town Values. Big City Results.
Available to our clients 24/7
Schedule A Free Consultation

Your case is as important to us as it is to you.  Because we limit the number of cases we accept, we are able to give our clients individual attention.  We are proud that our clients tell us that we make them feel like family.


Experience leads to results.  With decades of handling injury cases, we have seen every trick in the insurance company playbook.  We use the lessons learned to get the best possible settlements for our clients.


Our use of the latest technology and professional support staff ensures that we will move your case to a successful outcome as quickly as possible.

Learn More about us

Personal Injury Attorneys in Mansfield, Ohio

Highly Skilled Lawyers Working for You

If you’ve suffered serious injury, you need attorneys who have the experience and determination to fight for you.  Our job is to look out for your best interests.

Melanie Sue Fahey Caring for the people we serve

Solid Relationships

We started practicing law due to our passion about caring for people. With each new client we take on, we treat them like a member of our family.

Proven Experience

Our attorneys have earned accolades such as entry into the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum, an honor less than 1% of attorneys achieve.


With a strong team of attorneys, firm administrators, and litigation case managers, we are always available for any questions our clients have.

Bringing Justice the LeFevre Family We felt like we were not just clients to them. We were treated like we were family."
The Rinehardt Law Firm


Having spent many years working in the Law Enforcement / Criminal Justice system, I am familiar with many local attorneys. I chose your law firm and am very glad I did. Your entire staff is very professional, friendly and paid a great deal of attention to detail. I highly recommend this team of professionals.


I am so blessed that I found the Rinehardt law Firm and that they took my case. They are an amazing team to have on your side when you're in need of a lawyer.


John Rinehardt was retained by my father regarding a legal matter that no one else would touch. John listened to my father (unlike others), agreed to take the case and successfully obtained a settlement.


John was sympathetic and wanted to do the best possible job for me that he could. The staff was helpful and always took the time to answer questions or just listen when I was having a rough time. John was always prepared and would take the time to explain things to me.



Workplace Injuries
Nursing Home Neglect Injuries

Need An Attorney?



Nursing Home Neglect Case

90 year old suffered fractures in fall. Case resolved for $342,500.

Workplace Injury Case

38 year old injured by industrial press, the case resolved for $1.2 million.

Auto/Truck Collision Case

20 year old suffered severe injuries, the case resolved for $3.1 million

Medical Malpractice/Wrongful Death

Delay in diagnosis of rectal cancer of 35 year old man. Jury verdict of $5.2 million.

See More Results
 We don't get paid until you do

We work on a contingency fee basis.

When you’re suffering from a personal injury, the last thing you need to worry about is how you’ll cover attorney fees for your case. At Rinehardt Law Firm, we want you to feel confident pursuing your recovery. You can schedule a no fee, no obligation consultation with our team, and you won’t owe a cent until you get compensated.

Telling our Clients' Stories

Important steps to take after an injury occurs

One step we emphasize to all of our clients is to track your treatment and your pain. In the stressful period of calling insurance companies and visiting the doctor, many personal injury victims forget just how much suffering they endure by the time their case makes it to court. But it’s those forgotten details that can make all the difference in how the case proceeds. When you’ve been injured — whether it’s due to a driver’s negligence on the road or a defective product in the workplace — it’s crucial that you keep a detailed record of your day-to-day pain and medical treatments.

We often encourage clients to ask close family members to help with this step. Doing so will not only present a stronger case in court, but it can help you stand your ground when insurance companies try to downplay your pain.

We’ve helped people who have suffered from workplace injuries, motor vehicle accidents, medical malpractice, slip and fall accidents, dog bites, and more. We serve clients in Mansfield and communities across central and north central Ohio. If you aren’t sure what the next steps should be in your case, contact us for a consultation.
 Hillary Rinehardt 10.17.18

Rinehardt Law Firm’s 2nd Annual ThanksGIVEaway

We have reached our capacity of 150 submissions. Please try again next year!
 Hillary Rinehardt 09.14.18


John Rinehardt and Melanie Fahey of Rinehardt Law Firm achieved Franklin County Ohio’s largest jury verdict of 2017. The verdict was the largest medical malpractice verdict statewide and the fifth largest jury verdict of any kind statewide.






419-LAW-2020 Get Directions Contact Us 24/7 Leave A Review


STE 200