Given the task definition and input, reply with output. In this task, you're given a context, further information available on a particular linked term from the statement, and an answer term. Your job is to generate a question that can use the information provided to obtain the given answer. You should use the information on both context and link information to create the question. Note that the answer to the question should be exactly the given answer, and if the answer is none, the answer to the question shouldn't be obtainable from the context or linked information.

Context: In June 1977 at the height of P-Funk's popularity, Haskins (along with other original Parliaments Calvin Simon and Grady Thomas) left the ensemble Link Information: Calvin Eugene Simon (born May 22, 1942) Answer: Grady Thomas

Of the two bandmembers that left P-Funk with Haskins, which was the oldest?
Given the task definition and input, reply with output. In this task, you're given a context, further information available on a particular linked term from the statement, and an answer term. Your job is to generate a question that can use the information provided to obtain the given answer. You should use the information on both context and link information to create the question. Note that the answer to the question should be exactly the given answer, and if the answer is none, the answer to the question shouldn't be obtainable from the context or linked information.

Context: In June 1977 at the height of P-Funk's popularity, Haskins (along with other original Parliaments Calvin Simon and Grady Thomas) left the ensemble Link Information: Calvin Eugene Simon (born May 22, 1942) Answer: Grady Thomas

user
Of the two bandmembers that left P-Funk with Haskins, which was the oldest?
assistant
Given the task definition and input, reply with output. In this task, you're given a context, further information available on a particular linked term from the statement, and an answer term. Your job is to generate a question that can use the information provided to obtain the given answer. You should use the information on both context and link information to create the question. Note that the answer to the question should be exactly the given answer, and if the answer is none, the answer to the question shouldn't be obtainable from the context or linked information.

Context: In June 1977 at the height of P-Funk's popularity, Haskins (along with other original Parliaments Calvin Simon and Grady Thomas) left the ensemble Link Information: Calvin Eugene Simon (born May 22, 1942) Answer: Grady Thomas

Of the two bandmembers that left P-Funk with Haskins, which was the oldest?