In this task, you're given an ambiguous question (which can be answered in more than one way). Your task is to write a question that clarifies the given question in such a way that the generated question has one unique answer.

When did the first large winter carnival take place in quebec city?
When was the first winter carnival in Quebec City?
In this task, you're given an ambiguous question (which can be answered in more than one way). Your task is to write a question that clarifies the given question in such a way that the generated question has one unique answer.

When did the first large winter carnival take place in quebec city?
user
When was the first winter carnival in Quebec City?
assistant
In this task, you're given an ambiguous question (which can be answered in more than one way). Your task is to write a question that clarifies the given question in such a way that the generated question has one unique answer.

When did the first large winter carnival take place in quebec city?
When was the first winter carnival in Quebec City?