## PAPER • OPEN ACCESS

## Model comparison from LIGO-Virgo data on GW170817's binary components and consequences for the merger remnant

To cite this article: B P Abbott et al 2020 Class. Quantum Grav. 37 045006

View the article online for updates and enhancements.

![image](https://ac.marcodsn.me/arxiv-markdown-images/1908.01012v3-figure-3605f8ea-c5b5-43df-9ec6-216f319f80a0.jpg)

![image](https://ac.marcodsn.me/arxiv-markdown-images/1908.01012v3-figure-89bc4109-7c9b-4042-aefd-e0098633f0fc.jpg)

Class. Quantum Grav. 37 (2020) 045006 (43pp)

https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6382/ab5f7c

## Model comparison from LIGO-Virgo data on GW170817's binary components and consequences for the merger remnant

```
<_SQL_>
```

![image](https://ac.marcodsn.me/arxiv-markdown-images/1908.01012v3-figure-0008441b-7128-45ea-b2b3-e0877efcbf3d.jpg)

Original content from this work may be used under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 licence. Any further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the title of the work, journal citation and DOI.

| A F Brooks 1 , J Brooks 29 , D D Brown 57 , S Brunett 1 , A Buikema 14 , T Bulik 74 , H J Bulten 37 , 75 , A Buonanno 76 , 77                                                       |
|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| , D Buskulic 34 , C Buy 26 , R L Byer 51 , M Cabero 9 , 10 , L Cadonati 78 , G Cagnoli 79 , C Cahillane 1 , J Calder ó n Bustillo 6 ,                                               |
| T A Callister 1 , E Calloni 5 , 80 , J B Camp 81 , WACampbell 6 , 59 , 82 83 57 84                                                                                                  |
| M Canepa , K C Cannon , H Cao , J Cao ,                                                                                                                                             |
| G Carapella 68 , 69 , F Carbognani 29 , S Caride 85 , M F Carney 58 ,                                                                                                               |
| G Carullo 20 , 21 , J Casanueva Diaz 21 , C Casentini 32 , 86 ,                                                                                                                     |
| S Caudill 37 , M Cavagli à 87 , 88 , F Cavalier 28 , R Cavalieri 29 ,                                                                                                               |
| G Cella 21 , P Cerd á -Dur á n 22 , E Cesarini 32 , 89 , O Chaibi 65 ,                                                                                                              |
| K Chakravarti 3 , S J Chamberlin 90 , M Chan 46 , S Chao 91 ,                                                                                                                       |
| P Charlton 92 , E A Chase 58 , E Chassande-Mottin 26 ,                                                                                                                              |
| D Chatterjee 24 , M Chaturvedi 60 , K Chatziioannou 93 ,                                                                                                                            |
| B D Cheeseboro 39 , H Y Chen 94 , X Chen 66 , Y Chen 48 ,                                                                                                                           |
| H-P Cheng 30 , C K Cheong 95 , H Y Chia 30 , F Chiadini 69 , 96 ,                                                                                                                   |
| A Chincarini 59 , A Chiummo 29 , G Cho 97 , H S Cho 98 , M Cho 77 ,                                                                                                                 |
| N Christensen 65 , 99 , Q Chu 66 , S Chua 73 , K WChung 95 ,                                                                                                                        |
| S Chung 66 , G Ciani 53 , 54 , M Cie ś lar 56 , A A Ciobanu 57 ,                                                                                                                    |
| R Ciolfi 54 , 100 , F Cipriano 65 , A Cirone 59 , 82 , F Clara 47 , J A Clark 78 ,                                                                                                  |
| P Clearwater 101 , F Cleva 65 , E Coccia 16 , 17 , P-F Cohadon 73 ,                                                                                                                 |
| D Cohen 28 , M Colleoni 102 , C G Collette 103 , C Collins 13 , 44 , 45 104 15                                                                                                      |
| M Colpi , L R Cominsky , M Constancio Jr , L Conti 54 , 13 7 2 105 ,                                                                                                                |
| S J Cooper , P Corban , T R Corbitt , I Cordero-Carri ó n S Corezzi 40 , 41 , K R Corley 106 , N Cornish 55 , D Corre 28 ,                                                          |
| M WCoughlin 1 , S B Coughlin 58 , 107 , J-P Coulon 65 ,                                                                                                                             |
| A Corsi 85 , S Cortese 29 , C A Costa 15 , R Cotesta 76 ,                                                                                                                           |
| S T Countryman 106 , P Couvares 1 , P B Covas 102 , E E Cowan 78 , 66 7 1 108                                                                                                       |
| D M Coward , M J Cowart , D C Coyne , R Coyne , D E Creighton 24 , T D Creighton 109 , J Cripe 2 , M Croquette 73 , G Crowder 110 , T J Cullen 2 , A Cumming 46 , L Cunningham 46 , |
| J S 29 81 111 59 , 82                                                                                                                                                               |
| E Cuoco , T Dal Canton , G D á lya , B DAngelo ' , S L Danilishin 9 , 10 , S DAntonio ' 32 , K Danzmann 9 , 10 , 112 30 46 ,                                                        |
| A Dasgupta , C F Da Silva Costa , L E H Datrier 29 60 28 42                                                                                                                         |
| V Dattilo , I Dave , M Davier , D Davis , E J Daw 113 , D DeBra 51 , M Deenadayalan 3 , J Degallaix 23 , M De                                                                       |
| Laurentis 5 , 80 , S Del é glise 73 , WDel Pozzo 20 , 21 , L M 58 ,                                                                                                                 |
| DeMarchi N Demos 14 , T Dent 114 , R De Pietri 115 , 116 , R De Rosa 5 , 80 , C Rossi 23 , 29 , R DeSalvo 117 , O de Varona 9 , 10 , S Dhurandhar                                   |
| De 3 , 109 37 5 13                                                                                                                                                                  |
| M C D í az , T Dietrich , L Di Fiore , C DiFronzo , C Di                                                                                                                            |
| Girolamo 5 , 80 , A Di Lieto 20 , 21 , B Ding 103 , S Di Pace 33 , 120 , I Palma 33 , 120 , F Di Renzo 20 , 21 , A K Divakarla 30 , A Dmitriev                                      |
| Giorgio , F Di Giovanni , M Di Giovanni , T Di Di                                                                                                                                   |
| 13 , 94 14 87 , 107 3                                                                                                                                                               |
| Z Doctor , F Donovan , K L Dooley , S Doravari , I Dorrington 107 , T P Downes 24 , M Drago 16 , 17 , J C Driggers                                                                  |
| 47 , Z Du 84 , J-G Ducoin 28 , P Dupej 46 , O Durante 68 , 69 , S E Dwyer                                                                                                           |
| 47 ,                                                                                                                                                                                |

| P J Easter 6 , G Eddolls 46 , T B Edo 113 , A Effler 7 , P Ehrens 1 , J Eichholz 8 , S S Eikenberry 30 , M Eisenmann 34 , R A Eisenstein 14 , L Errico 5 , 80 , R C Essick 94 , H Estelles 102 , D Estevez 34 , Z B Etienne 39 , T Etzel 1 , M Evans 14 , T M Evans 7 , V Fafone 16 , 32 , 86 , S Fairhurst 107 , X Fan 84 , S Farinon 59 , B Farr 72 , WMFarr 13 , E J Fauchon-Jones 107 , M Favata 36 , M Fays 113 , M Fazio 121 , C Fee 122 , J Feicht 1 , M M Fejer 51 , F Feng 26 , A Fernandez-Galiana 14 , I Ferrante 20 , 21 , E C Ferreira 15 , T A Ferreira 15 , F Fidecaro 20 , 21 , I Fiori 29 , D Fiorucci 16 , 17 , M Fishbach 94 , R P Fisher 123 , J M Fishner 14 , R Fittipaldi 69 , 124 , M Fitz-Axen 43 , V Fiumara 69 , 125 , R Flaminio 34 , 126 , M Fletcher 46 , E Floden 43 , E Flynn 27 , H Fong 83 , J A Font 22 , 127 , P WFForsyth 8 , J-D Fournier 65 , S Frasca 33 , 120 , F Frasconi 21 , Z Frei 111 , A Freise 13 , R Frey 72 , V Frey 28 , P Fritschel 14 , V V Frolov 7 , G Fronz è 128 , P Fulda 30 , M Fyffe 7 , H A Gabbard 46 , B U Gadre 76 , S M Gaebel 13 , J R Gair 129 , L Gammaitoni 40 , S G Gaonkar 3 , C Garc í a-Quir ó s 102 , F Garufi 5 , 80 , B Gateley 47 , S Gaudio 35 , G Gaur 130 , V Gayathri 131 , G Gemme 59 , E Genin 29 , A Gennai 21 , D George 19 , J George 60 , L Gergely 132 , S Ghonge 78 , Abhirup Ghosh 76 , Archisman Ghosh 37 ,   |
|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| S Ghosh 24 , B Giacomazzo 118 , 119 , J A Giaime 2 , 7 , K D Giardina 7                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  |
| D R Gibson 133 , K Gill 106 , L Glover 134 , J Gniesmer 135 , P Godwin 90 , E Goetz 47 , R Goetz 30 , B Goncharov 6 , G Gonz á lez 2 , J M Gonzalez Castro 20 , 21 , A Gopakumar 136 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   |
| S E Gossan 1 , M Gosselin 20 , 21 , 29 , R Gouaty 34 , B Grace 8 , A Grado 5 , 137 , M Granata 23 , A Grant 46 , S Gras 14 , P Grassia 1 , C Gray 47 , R Gray 46 , G Greco 63 , 64 , A C Green 30 , R Green 107 , E M Gretarsson 35 , A Grimaldi 118 , 119 , S J Grimm 16 , 17 , P Groot 67                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              |
| 107 76 28 63 , 64                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        |
| H Grote , S Grunewald , P Gruning , G M Guidi ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          |
| ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        |
| 112 37 90 1 37                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           |
| H K Gulati , Y Guo , A Gupta , Anchal Gupta , P Gupta                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    |
| 1 138 102 16 , 17                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        |
| E K Gustafson , R Gustafson , L Haegel , O Halim ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| B R Hall 139 , E D Hall 14 , E Z Hamilton 107 , G Hammond 46 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           |
| M Haney 70 , M M Hanke 9 , 10 , J Hanks 47 , C Hanna 90 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                |
| M D Hannam 107 , O A Hannuksela 95 , T J Hansen 35 , J                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   |
| Hanson                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   |
| 65 2 18 16 , 17                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          |
| T Harder , T Hardwick , K Haris , J Harms , G M                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          |
| I WHarry 141 , R K Hasskew 7 , C J Haster 14 , K Haughian 46                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             |
| Harry ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  |
| F J Hayes 46 , J Healy 62 , A Heidmann 73 , M C Heintze 7 , H Heitmann 65 , F Hellman 142 , P Hello 28 , G Hemming 29 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  |
| 46 46 9 , 10                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             |
| M Hendry , I S Heng , J Hennig , Francisco                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               |
| , , ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    |
| Vivanco 6 , M Heurs 9 10 , S Hild 46 , T Hinderer 37 143 144 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           |
| 145 9 , 10 23                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            |
| WCGHo , S Hochheim , D Hofman , A M Holgado                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              |
| 19                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| , 8 7 94 107 24                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          |
| N A Holland , K Holt , D E Holz , P Hopkins , C Horst ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  |
| 46 66 107 14                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             |
| J Hough , E J Howell , C G Hoy , Y Huang , M T H ü                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| 19 28 35 34 102                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          |
| bner                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     |
| 6                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        |
| A Huerta , D Huet , B Hughey , V Hui , S Husa ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          |
| E                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        |
| S H Huttner 46 , T Huynh-Dinh 7 , B Idzkowski 74 , A Iess 32 , 86 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| Hernandez                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                |

| H Inchauspe 30 , C Ingram 57 , R Inta 85 , G Intini 33 , 120 , B Irwin 122 , H N Isa 46 , J-M Isac 73 , M Isi 14 , B R Iyer 18 , T Jacqmin 73 , S J Jadhav 146 , K Jani 78 , N N Janthalur 146 , P Jaranowski 147 , D Jariwala 30 , A C Jenkins 148 , J Jiang 30 , D S Johnson 19 , A WJones 13 , D I Jones 149 , J D Jones 47 , R Jones 46 , R J G Jonker 37 , L Ju 66 , J Junker 9 , 10 , C V Kalaghatgi 107 , V Kalogera 58 , B Kamai 1 , S Kandhasamy 3 , G Kang 38 , J B Kanner 1 , S J Kapadia 24 , S Karki 72 , R Kashyap 18 , M Kasprzack 1 , WKastaun 9 , 10 , S Katsanevas 29 , E Katsavounidis 14 , WKatzman 7 , S Kaufer 10 , K Kawabe 47 , N V Keerthana 3 , F K é f é lian 65 , D Keitel 141 , R Kennedy 113 , J S Key 150 , F Y Khalili 61 , I Khan 16 , 32 , S Khan 9 , 10 , E A Khazanov 151 , N Khetan 16 , 17 , M Khursheed 60 , N Kijbunchoo 8 , Chunglee Kim 152 , J C Kim 153 , K Kim 95 , WKim 57 , WSKim 154 , Y-M Kim 155 , C Kimball 58 , P J King 47 , M Kinley-Hanlon 46 , R Kirchhoff 9 , 10 , J S Kissel 47 , L Kleybolte 135 , J H Klika 24 , S Klimenko 30 , T D Knowles 39 , P Koch 9 , 10 , S M Koehlenbeck 9 , 10 , G Koekoek 37 , 156 , S Koley 37 V Kondrashov 1 , A Kontos 157 , N Koper 9 , 10 , M Korobko 135 , WZKorth 1 , M Kovalam 66 , D B Kozak 1 , C Kr ä mer 9 , 10 , V Kringel 9 , 10 , N Krishnendu 31 , A Kr ó lak 158 , 159 , N Krupinski 24 G Kuehn 9 , 10 , A Kumar 146 , P Kumar 160 , Rahul Kumar 47 , Rakesh Kumar 112 , L Kuo 91 , A Kutynia 158 , S Kwang 24 , B D Lackey 76 , D Laghi 20 , 21 , K H Lai 95 , T L Lam 95 , M Landry 47 P Landry 94 , B B Lane 14 , R N Lang 161 , J Lange 62 , B Lantz 51 , R K Lanza 14 , A Lartaux-Vollard 28 , P D Lasky 6 , M Laxen 7 ,   |
|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| , ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     |
| A Lazzarini 1 , C Lazzaro 54 , P Leaci 120 , 33 , S Leavey 9 , 10 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     |
| Y K Lecoeuche 47 , C H Lee 98 , H K Lee 162 , H M Lee 163 , WLee 153 , J Lee 97 , K Lee 46 , J Lehmann 9 , 10 , A K Lenon 39 , Leroy 28 , N Letendre 34 , Y Levin 6 , A Li 95 , J Li 84 , K J L Li 95 , G F Li 95 , X Li 48 , F Lin 6 , F Linde 37 , 164 , S D Linker 134 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             |
| H N T T B Littenberg 165 , J Liu 66 , X Liu 24 , M Llorens-Monteagudo 22 95 , 1 14 166 , 167 16 , 17                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    |
| , K L Lo , L T London , A Longo , M Lorenzini , Loriette 168 , M Lormand 7 , G Losurdo 21 , J D Lough 9 , 10 , O Lousto 62 , G Lovelace 27 , M E Lower 169 , H L ü ck 9 , 10 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          |
| C D Lumaca 32 , 86 , A P Lundgren 141 , R Lynch 14 , Y Ma 48 , R Macas 107 , S Macfoy 25 , M MacInnis 14 , D M Macleod 107 , A Macquet 65 , I Maga ñ a Hernandez 24 , F Maga ñ a-Sandoval 30                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            |
| V                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| R                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| 90 33 168 60                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            |
| R M Magee , E Majorana , I Maksimovic , A Malik , N Man 65 , V Mandic 43 , V Mangano 33 , 46 , 120 , G L Mansell 14 , 47 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              |
| M Manske 24 , M Mantovani 29 , M Mapelli 53 , 54 , F Marchesoni 34 106 106 19                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           |
| F Marion , S M á rka , Z M á rka , C Markakis ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         |
| 51 1 1 105                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              |
| 41                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| S Markosyan , A Markowitz , E Maros , A Marquina ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| A                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| 26 63 , 64 46 36                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        |
| Marsat , F Martelli , I WMartin , R M Martin ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          |
| S                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| , 52                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    |
| ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |

| E Massera 113 , A Masserot 34 , T J Massinger 1 , M Masso-Reid 46 S Mastrogiovanni 26 , A Matas 76 , F Matichard 1 , 14 , L Matone 106 , N Mavalvala 14 , J J McCann 66 , R McCarthy 47 , D E McClelland 8 S McCormick 7 , L McCuller 14 , S C McGuire 170 , C McIsaac 141 , J McIver 1 , D J McManus 8 , T McRae 8 , S T McWilliams 39 , D Meacher 24 , G D Meadors 6 , M Mehmet 9 , 10 , A K Mehta 18 , J Meidam 37 , E Mejuto Villa 69 , 117 , A Melatos 101 , G Mendell 47 , R A Mercer 24 , L Mereni 23 , K Merfeld 72 , E L Merilh 47 , M Merzougui 65 , S Meshkov 1 , C Messenger 46 , C Messick 90 , F Messina 44 , 45 , R Metzdorff 73 , P M Meyers 101 , F Meylahn 9 , 10 , A Miani 118 , 119 , H Miao 13 , C Michel 23 , H Middleton 101 , L Milano 80 , 5 , A L Miller 30 , 33 , 120 , M Millhouse 101 , J C Mills 107 , M C Milovich-Goff 134 , O Minazzoli 65 , 171 , Y Minenkov 32 , A Mishkin 30 , C Mishra 172 , T Mistry 113 , S Mitra 3 , V P Mitrofanov 61 , G Mitselmakher 30 , R Mittleman 14 , G Mo 99 , D Moffa 122 , K Mogushi 87 , S R P Mohapatra 14 , M Molina- Ruiz 142 , M Mondin 134 , M Montani 63 , 64 , C J Moore 13 , D Moraru 47 , F Morawski 56 , G Moreno 47 , S Morisaki 83 , B Mours 34 , C M Mow-Lowry 13 , F Muciaccia 33 , 120 , Arunava Mukherjee 9 , 10 , D Mukherjee 24 , S Mukherjee 109 ,   |
|---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| Subroto Mukherjee 112 , N Mukund 3 , 9 , 10 , A Mullavey 7 , J Munch 57 , E A Mu ñ iz 42 , M Muratore 35 , P G Murray 46 , A Nag ar 89 , 128 , 173 , I Nardecchia 32 , 86 , L Naticchioni 33 , 120 , R K Nayak 174 , B F Neil 66 , J Neilson 69 , 117 , G Nelemans 37 , 67 , T J N Nelson 7 , M Nery 9 , 10 , A Neunzert 138 , L Nevin 1 , K Y Ng 14 , S Ng 57 , C Nguyen 26 , P Nguyen 72 , D Nichols 37 , 143 , S A Nichols 2 , S Nissanke 37 , 143 , F Nocera 29 , C North 107 , L K Nuttall 141 , M Obergaulinger 22 , 175 , J Oberling 47 , B D OBrien ' 30 , G Oganesyan 16 , 17 , G H Ogin 176 , J J Oh 154 , S H Oh 154 , F Ohme 9 , 10 , H Ohta 83 , M A Okada 15 , M Oliver 102 , P Oppermann 9 , 10 , Richard J Oram 7 , B OReilly ' 7 , R G Ormiston 43 , L F Ortega 30 , R OShaughnessy ' 62 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 |

| I M Pinto 69 , 89 , 117 , M Pirello 47 , M Pitkin 46 , WPlastino 166 , 167 , R Poggiani 20 , 21 , D Y T Pong 95 , S Ponrathnam 3 , P Popolizio 29 , K Porter 26 , J Powell 169 , A K Prajapati 112 , J Prasad 3 , Prasai 51 , R Prasanna 146 , G Pratten 102 , T Prestegard 24 , Principe 89 , 69 , 117 , G A Prodi 118 , 119 , L Prokhorov 13 , Punturo 41 , P Puppo 33 , M P ü rrer 76 , H Qi 107 , V Quetschke 109 , J Quinonez 35 , F J Raab 47 , G Raaijmakers 37 , 143 , H Radkins 47 Radulesco 65 , P Raffai 111 , S Raja 60 , C Rajan 60 , Rajbhandari 85 , M Rakhmanov 109 , K E Ramirez 109 , Ramos-Buades 102 , Javed Rana 3 , K Rao 58 ,   |
|--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
| E K M                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  |
| M                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| P                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| N                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| B                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| A                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| P Rapagnani 33 , 120 , V Raymond 107 , M Razzano 20 , 21 , J Read 27                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   |
| , T Regimbau 34 , L Rei 59 , S Reid 25 , D H Reitze 1 , 30 , 128 , 179 120 , 33 35                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     |
| P Rettegno , F Ricci , C J Richardson , J WRichardson 1 , P M Ricker 19 , G Riemenschneider 128 , 179 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                |
| 138 58 1 , 46 28                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| K Riles , M Rizzo , N A Robertson , F Robinet , A Rocchi 32 , L Rolland 34 , J G Rollins 1 , V J Roma 72 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             |
| M Romanelli 71 , R Romano 4 , 5 , C L Romel 47 , J H Romie 7                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           |
| , C A Rose 24 , D Rose 27 , K Rose 122 , D Rosi ń ska 74 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             |
| S G Rosofsky 19 , M P Ross 180 , S Rowan 46 , A R ü diger 9 , 10                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| , P Ruggi 29 , G Rutins 133 , K Ryan 47 , S Sachdev 90 , T ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           |
| Sadecki 47 M Sakellariadou 148 , O S Salafia 44 , 45 , 181 , L Salconi 29 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            |
| M Saleem 31 , A Samajdar 37 , L Sammut 6 , E J Sanchez 1 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             |
| L E Sanchez 1 , N Sanchis-Gual 182 , J R Sanders 183 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 |
| K A Santiago 36 , E Santos 65 , N Sarin 6 , B Sassolas 23 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            |
| B S Sathyaprakash 90 , 107 , O Sauter 138 , 34 , R L Savage 72 48 58 13 , 67                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           |
| 47 , P Schale , M Scheel , J Scheuer , P Schmidt ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     |
| R Schnabel 135 , R M S Schofield 72 , A Sch ö nbeck 135 , 9 , 10 9 , 10 107                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            |
| E Schreiber , B WSchulte , B F Schutz , J Scott 46 , S M Scott 8 , E Seidel 19 , D Sellers 7 , A S Sengupta 184 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| N Sennett 76 , D Sentenac 29 , V Sequino 59 , A Sergeev 151 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          |
| Y Setyawati 9 , 10 , D A Shaddock 8 , T Shaffer 47 , M S                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               |
| Shahriar 58 , M B Shaner 134 , A Sharma 16 , 17 , P Sharma 60 , P Shawhan 77 , 19 185 14 78                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            |
| Shen , R Shink , D H Shoemaker , D M Shoemaker , Shukla 142 , S ShyamSundar 60 , K Siellez 78 , M Sieniawska 56 , Sigg 47 , L P Singer 81 , D Singh 90 , N Singh 74 , A Singhal 16 , 33 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              |
| H K D 102 109 107                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| A M Sintes , S Sitmukhambetov , V Skliris , B J J Slagmolen 8 , T J Slaven-Blair 66 , J R Smith 27 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   |
| R J E Smith 6 , S Somala 186 , E J Son 154 , S Soni 2 , B Sorazu , F Sorrentino 59 , T Souradeep 3 , E Sowell 85 , A P Spencer 46                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| 46 , M Spera 53 , 54 , A K Srivastava 112 , V Srivastava 42 , K Staats                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 |
| 65 9 , 10 26 9 , 10                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    |
| C Stachie , M Standke , D A Steer , M Steinke , 46 , 135 135 9 , 10                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    |
| J Steinlechner , S Steinlechner , D Steinmeyer S P Stevenson 169 , D Stocks 51 , R Stone 109 , D J Stops 13 ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          |
| 46 64 , 187 61 47                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| K A Strain , G Stratta , S E Strigin , A Strunk ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| 188 189 14                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                             |
| R Sturani , A L Stuver , V Sudhir , T Z Summerscales                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   |
| 190                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    |
| ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| ,                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| 58                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     |

L Sun , S Sunil 1 112 , A Sur 56 , J Suresh 83 , P J Sutton 107 , B L Swinkels 37 , M J Szczepa ń czyk 35 , M Tacca 37 , S C Tait 46 , C Talbot , D B Tanner 6 30 , D Tao , M T 1 á pai 132 , A Tapia 27 , J D Tasson 99 , R Taylor , R Tenorio 1 102 , L Terkowski 135 , M Thomas , P Thomas 7 47 , S R Thondapu 60 , K A Thorne , 7 E Thrane , Shubhanshu Tiwari 6 118 119 , , Srishti Tiwari 136 , V Tiwari 107 , K Toland 46 , M Tonelli 20 21 , , Z Tornasi 46 , A TorresForn é 191 , C I Torrie , D T 1 ö yr ä 13 , F Travasso 29 41 , , G Traylor , 7 M C Tringali 74 , A Tripathee 138 , A Trovato 26 , L Trozzo 21 192 , , K W Tsang 37 , M Tse 14 , R Tso 48 , L Tsukada 83 , D Tsuna 83 , T Tsutsui 83 , D Tuyenbayev 109 , K Ueno 83 , D Ugolini 193 , C S Unnikrishnan 136 , A L Urban , S A Usman 2 94 , H Vahlbruch 10 , G Vajente , G Valdes , M Valentini 1 2 118 119 , , N van Bakel 37 , M van Beuzekom 37 , J F J van den Brand 37 75 , , C Van Den Broeck 37 194 , , D C Vander-Hyde 42 , L van der Schaaf 37 , J V VanHeijningen 66 , A A van Veggel 46 , M Vardaro 53 54 , , V Varma 48 , S Vass , M Vas 1 ú th 50 , A Vecchio 13 , G Vedovato 54 , J Veitch 46 , P J Veitch 57 , K Venkateswara 180 , G Venugopalan , 1 D Verkindt 34 , F Vetrano 63 64 , , A Vicer é 63 64 , , A D Viets 24 , S Vinciguerra 13 , D J Vine 133 , J-Y Vinet 65 , S Vitale 14 ,  T Vo 42 , H Vocca 40 41 , , C Vorvick 47 , S P Vyatchanin 61 , A R Wade , 1 L E Wade 122 , M Wade 122 , R Walet 37 , M Walker 27 , L Wallace , 1 S Walsh 24 , H Wang 13 , J Z Wang 138 , S Wang 19 , W H Wang 109 , Y F Wang 95 , R L Ward , Z A Warden 8 35 , J Warner 47 , M Was 34 , J Watchi 103 , B Weaver 47 , L-W Wei 9 10 , , M Weinert 9 10 , , A J Weinstein , R Weiss 1 14 , F Wellmann 9 10 , , L Wen 66 , E K Wessel 19 , P We /uni00DF els 9 10 , , J W Westhouse 35 , K Wette , 8 J T Whelan 62 , B F Whiting 30 , C Whittle 14 , D M Wilken 9 10 , , D Williams 46 , A R Williamson 37 143 , , J L Willis , B Willke 1 10 9 , , W Winkler 9 10 , , C C Wipf , H Wittel 1 9 10 , , G Woan 46 , J Woehler 9 10 , , J K Wofford 62 , J L Wright 46 , D S Wu 9 10 , , D M Wysocki 62 , S Xiao , R Xu 1 110 , H Yamamoto , C C Yancey 1 77 , L Yang 121 , Y Yang 30 , Z Yang 43 , M J Yap , M Yazback 8 30 , D W Yeeles 107 , Hang Yu 14 , Haocun Yu 14 , S H R Yuen 95 , A K Zadro ż ny 109 , A Zadro ny ż 158 , M Zanolin 35 , F Zappa 76 ,  T Zelenova 29 , JP Zendri 54 , M Zevin 58 , J Zhang 66 , L Zhang , T Zhang 1 46 , C Zhao 66 , G Zhao 103 , M Zhou 58 , Z Zhou 58 , X J Zhu , 6 A B Zimmerman 195 ,  Y Zlochower 62 , M E Zucker 1 14 , , J Zweizig 1 (The LIGO Scientific Collaboration and The Virgo Collaboration)

- 1 LIGO, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA 91125,

United States of America

- 2 Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge, LA 70803, United States of America
- 3 Inter-University Centre for Astronomy and Astrophysics, Pune 411007, India

4 Dipartimento di Farmacia, Universit à di Salerno, I-84084 Fisciano, Salerno, Italy

- 5 INFN, Sezione di Napoli, Complesso Universitario di Monte S.Angelo, I-80126 Napoli, Italy
- 6 OzGrav, School of Physics &amp; Astronomy, Monash University, Clayton 3800, Victoria, Australia
- 7 LIGO Livingston Observatory, Livingston, LA 70754, United States of America
- OzGrav, Australian National University, Canberra, Australian Capital Territory
- 8 0200, Australia
- 9 Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics (Albert Einstein Institute), D-30167 Hannover, Germany
- 10 Leibniz Universit ä t Hannover, D-30167 Hannover, Germany
- 11 Theoretisch-Physikalisches Institut, Friedrich-Schiller-Universit ä t Jena, D-07743 Jena, Germany
- 12 University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 1TN, United Kingdom
- 13 University of Birmingham, Birmingham B15 2TT, United Kingdom
- 14 LIGO, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, United States of America
- 15 Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas Espaciais, 12227-010 S ã o Jos é dos Campos, S o ã Paulo, Brazil
- 16 Gran Sasso Science Institute (GSSI), I-67100 L Aquila, Italy '
- 17 INFN, Laboratori Nazionali del Gran Sasso, I-67100 Assergi, Italy
- 18 International Centre for Theoretical Sciences, Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Bengaluru 560089, India
- 19 NCSA, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, IL 61801, United States of America
- 20 Universit à di Pisa, I-56127 Pisa, Italy
- 21 INFN, Sezione di Pisa, I-56127 Pisa, Italy
- 22 Departamento de Astronom a y Astrof sica, Universitat de Val í í è ncia,
- E-46100 Burjassot, Val è ncia, Spain
- 23 Laboratoire des Mat é riaux Avanc é s (LMA), CNRS/IN2P3, F-69622 Villeurbanne, France
- 24 University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, Milwaukee, WI 53201, United States of America
- 25 SUPA, University of Strathclyde, Glasgow G1 1XQ, United Kingdom
- 26 APC, AstroParticule et Cosmologie, Universit é Paris Diderot, CNRS/IN2P3, CEA/ Irfu, Observatoire de Paris, Sorbonne Paris Cit é , F-75205 Paris Cedex 13, France 27 California State University Fullerton, Fullerton, CA 92831,

## United States of America

- 28 LAL, Univ. Paris-Sud, CNRS/IN2P3, Universit é Paris-Saclay, F-91898 Orsay,

## France

- 29 European Gravitational Observatory (EGO), I-56021 Cascina, Pisa, Italy
- 30 University of Florida, Gainesville, FL 32611, United States of America
- 31 Chennai Mathematical Institute, Chennai 603103, India
- 32 INFN, Sezione di Roma Tor Vergata, I-00133 Roma, Italy
- 33 INFN, Sezione di Roma, I-00185 Roma, Italy
- 34
- Laboratoire d Annecy de Physique des Particules (LAPP), Univ. Grenoble Alpes, '
- Universit é Savoie Mont Blanc, CNRS/IN2P3, F-74941 Annecy, France
- 35 Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University, Prescott, AZ 86301, United States of America
- 36 Montclair State University, Montclair, NJ 07043, United States of America
- 37 Nikhef, Science Park 105, 1098 XG Amsterdam, The Netherlands
- 38 Korea Institute of Science and Technology Information, Daejeon 34141, Republic of Korea
- 39 West Virginia University, Morgantown, WV 26506, United States of America

- 40 Universit à di Perugia, I-06123 Perugia, Italy
- 41 INFN, Sezione di Perugia, I-06123 Perugia, Italy
- 42 Syracuse University, Syracuse, NY 13244, United States of America
- 43 University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN 55455, United States of America
- 44 Universit à degli Studi di Milano-Bicocca, I-20126 Milano, Italy
- 45 INFN, Sezione di Milano-Bicocca, I-20126 Milano, Italy
- 46 SUPA, University of Glasgow, Glasgow G12 8QQ, United Kingdom
- 47 LIGO Hanford Observatory, Richland, WA 99352, United States of America
- 48 Caltech CaRT, Pasadena, CA 91125, United States of America
- 49 Dipartimento di Medicina, Chirurgia e Odontoiatria  Scuola Medica Salernitana , ' ' Universit à di Salerno, I-84081 Baronissi, Salerno, Italy
- 50 Wigner RCP, RMKI, H-1121 Budapest, Konkoly Thege Mikl ó s ú t 29-33, Hungary
- 51 Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305, United States of America
- 52 Universit à di Camerino, Dipartimento di Fisica, I-62032 Camerino, Italy
- 53 Universit à di Padova, Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia, I-35131 Padova, Italy 54
- INFN, Sezione di Padova, I-35131 Padova, Italy
- 55 Montana State University, Bozeman, MT 59717, United States of America
- 56 Nicolaus Copernicus Astronomical Center, Polish Academy of Sciences, 00-716,

## Warsaw, Poland

- 57 OzGrav, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, South Australia 5005, Australia
- 58 Center for Interdisciplinary Exploration &amp; Research in Astrophysics (CIERA),

Northwestern University, Evanston, IL 60208, United States of America

- 59 INFN, Sezione di Genova, I-16146 Genova, Italy
- 60 RRCAT, Indore, Madhya Pradesh 452013, India
- 61 Faculty of Physics, Lomonosov Moscow State University, Moscow 119991, Russia
- 62 Rochester Institute of Technology, Rochester, NY 14623, United States of America
- 63 Universit à degli Studi di Urbino  Carlo Bo , I-61029 Urbino, Italy ' '
- 64 INFN, Sezione di Firenze, I-50019 Sesto Fiorentino, Firenze, Italy
- 65 Artemis, Universit é C ô te d Azur, Observatoire C ' ô te d Azur, CNRS, CS 34229, ' F-06304 Nice Cedex 4, France
- 66 OzGrav, University of Western Australia, Crawley, Western Australia 6009, Australia
- 67 Department of Astrophysics/IMAPP, Radboud University Nijmegen, PO Box 9010, 6500 GL Nijmegen, The Netherlands
- 68 Dipartimento di Fisica  E.R. Caianiello , Universit ' ' à di Salerno, I-84084 Fisciano, Salerno, Italy
- 69 INFN, Sezione di Napoli, Gruppo Collegato di Salerno, Complesso Universitario di Monte S. Angelo, I-80126 Napoli, Italy
- 70 Physik-Institut, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, 8057 Zurich, Switzerland
- 71 Univ Rennes, CNRS, Institut FOTON -UMR6082, F-3500 Rennes, France
- 72 University of Oregon, Eugene, OR 97403, United States of America
- 73 Laboratoire Kastler Brossel, Sorbonne Universit é , CNRS, ENS-Universit  PSL, é Coll è ge de France, F-75005 Paris, France
- 74 Astronomical Observatory Warsaw University, 00-478 Warsaw, Poland
- 75 VU University Amsterdam, 1081 HV Amsterdam, The Netherlands
- 76 Max Planck Institute for Gravitational Physics (Albert Einstein Institute), D-14476 Potsdam-Golm, Germany
- 77 University of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742, United States of America
- 78 School of Physics, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332, United States of America
- 79 Universit é de Lyon, Universit é Claude Bernard Lyon 1, CNRS, Institut Lumi è re Mati re, F-69622 Villeurbanne, France è

- 80 Universit à di Napoli  Federico II , Complesso Universitario di Monte S.Angelo, ' ' I-80126 Napoli, Italy
- 81 NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, Greenbelt, MD 20771, United States of America
- 82 Dipartimento di Fisica, Universit à degli Studi di Genova, I-16146 Genova, Italy
- 83 RESCEU, University of Tokyo, Tokyo, 113-0033, Japan
- 84 Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, People s Republic of China '
- 85 Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX 79409, United States of America
- 86 Universit à di Roma Tor Vergata, I-00133 Roma, Italy
- 87 The University of Mississippi, University, MS 38677, United States of America
- 88 Missouri University of Science and Technology, Rolla, MO 65409, United States of America
- 89 Museo Storico della Fisica e Centro Studi e Ricerche  Enrico Fermi , I-00184 ' ' Roma, Italy
- 90 The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802, United States of America
- 91 National Tsing Hua University, Hsinchu City, 30013 Taiwan, Republic of China
- 92 Charles Sturt University, Wagga Wagga, New South Wales 2678, Australia
- 93 Canadian Institute for Theoretical Astrophysics, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario M5S 3H8, Canada
- 94 University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, United States of America
- 95 The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shatin, NT, Hong Kong
- 96 Dipartimento di Ingegneria Industriale (DIIN), Universit à di Salerno, I-84084 Fisciano, Salerno, Italy
- 97 Seoul National University Seoul 08826, Republic of Korea
- 98 PUnited States of American National University, Busan 46241, Republic of Korea
- 99 Carleton College, Northfield, MN 55057, United States of America
- 100 INAF, Osservatorio Astronomico di Padova, I-35122 Padova, Italy
- 101 OzGrav, University of Melbourne, Parkville, Victoria 3010, Australia
- 102 Universitat de les Illes Balears, IAC3 -IEEC, E-07122 Palma de Mallorca, Spain
- 103 Universit é Libre de Bruxelles, Brussels 1050, Belgium
- 104 Sonoma State University, Rohnert Park, CA 94928, United States of America
- 105 Departamento de Matem ticas, Universitat de Val á è ncia, E-46100 Burjassot, Val è ncia, Spain
- 106 Columbia University, New York, NY 10027, United States of America
- 107 Cardiff University, Cardiff CF24 3AA, United Kingdom
- 108 University of Rhode Island, Kingston, RI 02881, United States of America
- 109 The University of Texas Rio Grande Valley, Brownsville, TX 78520, United States of America
- 110 Bellevue College, Bellevue, WA 98007, United States of America
- 111 MTA-ELTE Astrophysics Research Group, Institute of Physics, E ö tv ö s University, Budapest 1117, Hungary
- 112 Institute for Plasma Research, Bhat, Gandhinagar 382428, India
- 113 The University of Sheffield, Sheffield S10 2TN, United Kingdom
- 114 IGFAE, Campus Sur, Universidade de Santiago de Compostela, 15782 Spain
- 115 Dipartimento di Scienze Matematiche, Fisiche e Informatiche,

## Universit à di Parma, I-43124 Parma, Italy

- 116 INFN, Sezione di Milano Bicocca, Gruppo Collegato di Parma, I-43124 Parma, Italy
- 117 Dipartimento di Ingegneria, Universit à del Sannio, I-82100 Benevento, Italy
- 118 Dipartimento di Fisica, Universit à di Trento, I-38123 Povo, Trento, Italy
- 119 INFN, Trento Institute for Fundamental Physics and Applications, I-38123 Povo, Trento, Italy
- 120 Universit à di Roma  La Sapienza ,  I-00185 Roma, Italy ' ' '

- 121 Colorado State University, Fort Collins, CO 80523, United States of America
- 122 Kenyon College, Gambier, OH 43022, United States of America
- 123 Christopher Newport University, Newport News, VA 23606, United States of America
- 124 CNR-SPIN, c/o Universit à di Salerno, I-84084 Fisciano, Salerno, Italy
- 125 Scuola di Ingegneria, Universit à della Basilicata, I-85100 Potenza, Italy
- 126 National Astronomical Observatory of Japan, 2-21-1 Osawa, Mitaka, Tokyo 181-8588, Japan
- 127 Observatori Astron ò mic, Universitat de Val è ncia, E-46980 Paterna, Val è ncia, Spain
- 128 INFN Sezione di Torino, I-10125 Torino, Italy
- 129 School of Mathematics, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh EH9 3FD, United

## Kingdom

- 130 Institute Of Advanced Research, Gandhinagar 382426, India
- 131 Indian Institute of Technology Bombay, Powai, Mumbai 400 076, India
- 132 University of Szeged, D ó m t é r 9, Szeged 6720, Hungary
- 133 SUPA, University of the West of Scotland, Paisley PA1 2BE, United Kingdom
- 134 California State University, Los Angeles, 5151 State University Dr, Los Angeles,
- CA 90032, United States of America
- 135 Universit ä t Hamburg, D-22761 Hamburg, Germany
- 136 Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Mumbai 400005, India
- 137 INAF, Osservatorio Astronomico di Capodimonte, I-80131 Napoli, Italy
- 138 University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, United States of America
- 139 Washington State University, Pullman, WA 99164, United States of America
- 140 American University, Washington, D.C. 20016, United States of America
- 141 University of Portsmouth, Portsmouth, PO1 3FX, United Kingdom
- 142 University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720, United States of America
- 143 GRAPPA, Anton Pannekoek Institute for Astronomy and Institute for High-Energy Physics, University of Amsterdam, Science Park 904, 1098 XH Amsterdam, The Netherlands
- 144 Delta Institute for Theoretical Physics, Science Park 904, 1090 GL Amsterdam, The Netherlands
- 145 Department of Physics and Astronomy, Haverford College, Haverford, PA 19041, United States of America
- 146 Directorate of Construction, Services &amp; Estate Management, Mumbai 400094 India
- 147 University of Bia ystok, 15-424 Bia ystok, Poland ł ł
- 148 King s College London, University of London, London WC2R 2LS, United '

## Kingdom

- 149 University of Southampton, Southampton SO17 1BJ, United Kingdom
- 150 University of Washington Bothell, Bothell, WA 98011, United States of America
- 151 Institute of Applied Physics, Nizhny Novgorod, 603950, Russia
- 152 Ewha Womans University, Seoul 03760, Republic of Korea
- 153 Inje University Gimhae, South Gyeongsang 50834, Republic of Korea
- 154 National Institute for Mathematical Sciences, Daejeon 34047, Republic of Korea
- 155
- Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology, Ulsan 44919,

## Republic of Korea

- 156 Maastricht University, PO Box 616, 6200 MD Maastricht, The Netherlands
- 157 Bard College, 30 Campus Rd, Annandale-On-Hudson, NY 12504,
- United States of America
- 158 NCBJ, 05-400 Ś wierk-Otwock, Poland
- 159 Institute of Mathematics, Polish Academy of Sciences, 00656 Warsaw, Poland
- 160 Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14850, United States of America

- 161 Hillsdale College, Hillsdale, MI 49242, United States of America
- 162 Hanyang University, Seoul 04763, Republic of Korea
- 163 Korea Astronomy and Space Science Institute, Daejeon 34055, Republic of Korea
- 164 Institute for High-Energy Physics, University of Amsterdam, Science Park 904,

1098 XH Amsterdam, The Netherlands

- 165 NASA Marshall Space Flight Center, Huntsville, AL 35811, United States of America
- 166 Dipartimento di Matematica e Fisica, Universit à degli Studi Roma Tre, I-00146 Roma, Italy
- 167 INFN, Sezione di Roma Tre, I-00146 Roma, Italy
- 168 ESPCI, CNRS, F-75005 Paris, France
- 169 OzGrav, Swinburne University of Technology, Hawthorn VIC 3122, Australia
- Southern University and A M College, Baton Rouge, LA 70813,
- 170 &amp; United States of America
- 171 Centre Scientifique de Monaco, 8 quai Antoine Ier, MC-98000, Monaco
- 172 Indian Institute of Technology Madras, Chennai 600036, India
- 173 Institut des Hautes Etudes Scientifiques, F-91440 Bures-sur-Yvette, France
- 174 IISER-Kolkata, Mohanpur, West Bengal 741252, India
- 175 Institut f ü r Kernphysik, Theoriezentrum, 64289 Darmstadt, Germany
- 176 Whitman College, 345 Boyer Avenue, Walla Walla, WA 99362

## United States of America

- 177 Universit é de Lyon, F-69361 Lyon, France
- 178 Hobart and William Smith Colleges, Geneva, NY 14456, United States of America
- 179 Dipartimento di Fisica, Universit à degli Studi di Torino, I-10125 Torino, Italy
- 180 University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, United States of America
- 181 INAF, Osservatorio Astronomico di Brera sede di Merate, I-23807 Merate, Lecco, Italy
- 182 Centro de Astrof sica e Gravita í çã o (CENTRA), Departamento de F sica, Instituto í Superior T é cnico, Universidade de Lisboa, 1049-001 Lisboa, Portugal
- 183 Marquette University, 11420  W. Clybourn St., Milwaukee, WI 53233, United States of America
- 184 Indian Institute of Technology, Gandhinagar Ahmedabad Gujarat 382424, India
- 185 Universit é de Montr é al/Polytechnique, Montreal, Quebec H3T 1J4, Canada
- 186 Indian Institute of Technology Hyderabad, Sangareddy, Khandi, Telangana 502285, India
- 187 INAF, Osservatorio di Astrofisica e Scienza dello Spazio, I-40129 Bologna, Italy
- 188 International Institute of Physics, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Norte, Natal RN 59078-970, Brazil
- 189 Villanova University, 800 Lancaster Ave, Villanova, PA 19085, United States of America
- 190 Andrews University, Berrien Springs, MI 49104, United States of America
- 191 Max Planck Institute for Gravitationalphysik (Albert Einstein Institute), D-14476 Potsdam-Golm, Germany
- 192 Universit à di Siena, I-53100 Siena, Italy
- 193 Trinity University, San Antonio, TX 78212, United States of America

194

Van Swinderen Institute for Particle Physics and Gravity, University of Groningen,

Nijenborgh 4, 9747 AG Groningen, The Netherlands

- 195 Department of Physics, University of Texas, Austin, TX 78712, United States of America

E-mail: lsc-spokesperson@ligo.org and virgo-spokesperson@ego-gw.it

Received 14 August 2019, revised 28 November 2019

![image](https://ac.marcodsn.me/arxiv-markdown-images/1908.01012v3-figure-a1953677-a801-4f82-8d70-1ae7682799fe.jpg)

Accepted for publication 6 December 2019 Published 16 January 2020

## Abstract

GW170817 is the very  first  observation  of  gravitational  waves  originating from the coalescence of two compact objects in the mass range of neutron stars, accompanied by electromagnetic counterparts, and offers an opportunity to directly probe the internal structure of neutron stars. We perform Bayesian model selection  on  a  wide  range  of  theoretical  predictions  for  the  neutron star equation of state. For the binary neutron star hypothesis, we find that we cannot rule out the majority of theoretical models considered. In addition, the gravitational-wave data alone does not rule out the possibility that one or both objects were low-mass black holes. We discuss the possible outcomes in the case of a binary neutron star merger, finding that all scenarios from prompt collapse  to  long-lived  or  even  stable  remnants  are  possible.  For  long-lived remnants, we place an upper limit of 1.9 kHz on the rotation rate. If a black hole was formed any time after merger and the coalescing stars were slowly rotating, then the maximum baryonic mass of non-rotating neutron stars is at most 3.05 M /circledot , and three equations of state considered here can be ruled out. We obtain a tighter limit of 2.67 M /circledot for the case that the merger results in a hypermassive neutron star.

Keywords: neutron stars, neutron star equation of state, gravitational wave astronomy, compact object mergers

(Some figures may appear in colour only in the online journal)

## 1.  Introduction

On August 17, 2017, the Advanced LIGO [1] and Advanced Virgo [2] observatories detected a gravitational-wave signal, GW170817, from a low-mass compact binary system [3]. The signal was coincident with the gamma-ray burst GRB 170817A [4] and was followed by other observations spanning the electromagnetic spectrum [5]. These electromagnetic observations, coupled with measurements of the component masses from the gravitational-wave observation [6, 7], provide compelling evidence that GW170817 was produced from the merger of two neutron stars.

One of the  key  goals  of  observing  such  neutron  star  mergers  is  to  extract  information regarding the internal structure of neutron stars and to improve our understanding of their highly uncertain equation of state [8, 9]. Information regarding the equation of state is encoded in the variation of the orbital evolution induced by tidal interactions and the deformation of the neutron stars under their own angular momenta [10 -14]. Such interactions are small at low frequencies but rapidly increase in strength in the final tens of gravitational-wave cycles before merger. Additional information about the equation of state is carried in the post-merger signal, as the remnant body can be a black hole, a stable neutron star or a meta-stable neutron star  that  collapses  after  some  delay  [15 -21].  However,  gravitational  waves  from  the  postmerger remnant are expected at higher frequencies where the detectors are less sensitive. No such post-merger signal was observed for GW170817 [6, 20, 22, 23].

The difficulty of computing the equation of state from first principles has led to a wide range of plausible theoretical models based on nuclear theoretical calculations. Astronomical observations of pulsars and x-ray binaries (e.g. [8, 24, 25]) have already been able to rule out a subset of proposed models, most notably by measurements of large neutron star masses [26]. Several studies have derived constraints on the equation of state through direct measurements of the neutron star mass and tidal deformability as inferred from GW170817 [27 -41].

In this paper, we address whether we can rule out specific equations of state from the gravitational-wave data alone and whether we can rule out the possibility that one or both of the coalescing objects was a low-mass black hole. We opt to work with a subset of equations of state representing nuclear matter properties that vary over a wide range of possible values. The correlations between the properties of the neutron star with the underlying equation of state manifests itself in a wide range of macroscopic physical observables, such as the mass, radius or tidal deformability. In practice, we do not expect the true equation of state to be contained in any of the models used in this analysis. By comparing the Bayesian odds ratio for different models, we expect that equations of state that are most similar to the real equation of state will lead to the highest odds ratios whereas equations of state that differ significantly from the data will be down-ranked in the analysis, giving insight into the physical properties of the true equation of state.

We apply Bayesian techniques [42, 43] to compare a large set of equations of state against an alternative hypothesis. The first fully Bayesian study of the feasibility of probing the neutron star equation of state was presented in [44] and expanded upon in [45]. We consider two possible baseline hypotheses: the first hypothesis is that both component objects were lowmass black holes; the second hypothesis is that GW170817 was composed of two neutron stars with an equation of state corresponding to one of the best fit equations of state in our analysis. In order to make quantitative statements about the relative likelihoods of different equations of state, we do not allow the tidal parameters to vary independently and instead enforce that each neutron star obeys a specific equation of state, similar to [38, 39, 44 -46]. This is in direct contrast to the analysis presented in [6], where the tidal parameters were allowed to vary independently implicitly allowing each neutron star to have a different equation of state. By performing parameter estimation using a fixed equation of state, we are able to conveniently incorporate a number of physical prior constraints, as was discussed in detail in [39].

We find that the equations of state yielding excessively large tidal deformabilities are disfavored by the data. For example, the MS1\_PP model [47] is disfavored with a Bayes factor that is less than ∼ 0.005 compared to the most favored equation of state models. However, we find that we cannot comprehensively rule out the majority of equations of state used in this analysis. Instead, we find that many of the equations of state have comparable evidences that are within an order of magnitude. This includes the models with the lowest tidal deformabilities as well as the binary black hole case.

In a previous analysis of GW170817 [39], we computed radii and tidal deformabilities for GW170817 using two methods. The first method links the tidal deformabilities of the two neutron stars by assuming that they obey the same equation of state [48, 49] and the second method utilized a parametrized equation of state [50, 51]. The neutron star radii were found to be no larger than ∼ 13 km, disfavoring large radii and stiffer equations of state. In this paper, we perform a direct model comparison between equation of state models, finding results that are consistent with [39]. The equation of state models that are most preferred by the data in this analysis are the ones that predict radii close to those computed in [39].

In addition, we also explore the inferences that can be made about the fate of the remnant object for each proposed equation of state. The range of maximum neutron star masses for

the equation of state models allows remnants which are indefinitely stable neutron stars, longlived supramassive neutron stars, or short-lived hypermassive neutron stars. Prompt collapse remains a possibility, though it can be ruled out for many models. In other cases, the required mass threshold from numerical relativity is not available or is insufficiently accurate to make a clear statement. For cases resulting in a supramassive neutron star, we use the mass range inferred for each of our equation of state models to derive the maximum rotation rate of the neutron star after it settles into a uniformly rotating state, obtaining an upper limit of 1.9 kHz.

Finally, we investigate constraints for the maximum mass of non-rotating neutron stars that follow from different assumptions about the type of the remnant. This is motivated by one of the possible explanations for the short gamma-ray burst models, which requires the formation of a black hole surrounded by a disk [52]. The other model assumes a rapidly rotating magnetar instead [53]. Which one is the correct description for the case at hand is an open question, but if we do assume the first one, then the presence of a black hole implies that neutron stars with the total baryonic mass inferred for the initial binary cannot be stable. The resulting limit is not very restrictive, but would rule out the three most extreme of our equations of state when assuming that the coalescing stars are slowly rotating. The bound can be further tightened by limiting the lifetime of the remnant to the observed delay of the short gamma-ray burst. The steep gradient of lifetime as function of mass near the maximum rotating neutron star mass then places the remnant mass in (or at least close to) the hypermassive range. Our limits are compatible with similar calculations carried out in [27, 29, 54], but are obtained using the fully consistent probability distributions computed for each equation of state model.

## 2.  Methodology

## 2.1 .   Gravitational-wave Bayesian model comparison

In this work our goal is to perform a direct comparison of theoretical models for the neutron star equation of state against the gravitational-wave data for GW170817. In order to do so, we employ Bayesian model selection to test a specific equation of state against a competing hypothesis. We adopt both the low-mass binary black hole hypothesis and a best fit equation of state as baseline hypotheses and assess the impact this has on the inferences that can be  made from the data. Detailed introductions to  Bayesian  methods  in  gravitational  wave astronomy can be found in [42, 55 -57].

Given the observed gravitational-wave data s and  any  prior  information I ,  the  posterior odds in favor of a given model hypothesis Mi can be expressed using the odds ratio

$$O _ { 1 2 } = \frac { P ( M _ { 1 } | s, I ) } { P ( M _ { 2 } | s, I ) } = \frac { P ( s | M _ { 1 }, I ) } { P ( s | M _ {$$

where Z = P s Mi ( | , I ) is  the  marginalized  likelihood  or evidence and P Mi I ( | )  is  the  prior probability on the model hypothesis. If we assume that the two models are a priori equally likely, P M ( 1 | I ) = P M ( 2 | I ) , then the odds ratio O 12 reduces to the Bayes factor B 12. The evidence is calculated by marginalizing over all parameters weighted by their prior probabilities P ( ξ | Mi , I )

$$\dot { \langle } \xi | M _ { i }, I \rangle & & \mathcal { Z } = P ( s | M _ { i }, I ) \in \int P ( s | \xi, M _ { i }, I )$$

where the likelihood of obtaining the data realization   given a gravitational-wave signal with s physical parameters ξ is

$$P ( s | \xi, M _ { i }, I ) \in e ^ { - \langle s - h ( t, \xi ) \, | \, s - h ( t, \xi ) \rangle / 2 }. \quad \quad \quad$$

Together with a given set of prior probabilities, we have all the information needed to evaluate the evidence in equation (2). In the following subsections, we discuss the waveform models used to describe the gravitational-wave signal h t ( ) and their dependence on the underlying physical parameters ξ .

## 2.2.  Prior probabilities

An important consideration when computing the Bayes factors is the choice of prior probabilities. This choice will enter the analysis in two distinct ways. First, we must make a choice for the relative prior probabilities between any two models; P Mi I ( | ). A wide range of equations of state are still consistent with observations [58], though additional theoretical considerations and observations could allow us to restrict the range of plausible equations of state [3, 6, 59]. Here,  neglecting  such  additional  information,  we  assume  that  the  prior  probability  for  all equations of state is the same. As detailed above, the odds ratio then reduces to the Bayes factor between any two models. The second choice of priors that we must make is the choice of prior probabilities on the parameters that enter a specific model, P ( ξ | Mi , I ) . As the choice of priors will affect the resulting Bayes factors, we explicitly detail the choices made in our analysis below.

The choice of priors that we use in this work is broadly similar to our previous analysis of GW170817 [3, 6]. We assume a priori that the source of GW170817 resides in NGC 4993, allowing us to adopt a fixed sky location. As in [6], although the distance to NGC 4993 is known, we infer the luminosity distance purely from the gravitational-wave data. The distance prior assumes that sources are uniformly distributed in volume up to a maximum distance of 75 Mpc. The coalescence time t c and phase φ c are taken to be uniformly distributed and we assume that the binary orientation and polarization angle are isotropic.

The remaining parameters that we sample are the masses and spins of the two compact objects. The choice of prior ranges for these parameters is not so easily made. Observations of neutron stars in our galaxy can give us indications of the mass and spin distributions of binary neutron star systems [8, 60 -66], but there is some uncertainty in these measurements. Additionally, these observations would not be appropriate to use if we want to assess the possibility that the system might be two black holes.

For these reasons we consider two sets of priors in this work. The first narrow prior  is motivated by observed binary neutron star systems in our galaxy [26, 67]. For this prior, we assume that the prior on the component masses is Gaussian with a mean of 1.33 M /circledot and a standard deviation of 0.09 M /circledot [8]. The prior on the dimensionless spin magnitudes are taken to be uniformly distributed between 0 and 0.05 and the spin directions are assumed to be isotropic. This spin prior is consistent with the observed population of binary neutron stars that will merge within a Hubble time [3, 68]. As many of the waveform models we consider do not allow for spin components perpendicular to the orbital angular momentum, we choose to sample the spin direction and magnitude as described above and then ignore any spin component perpendicular to the orbital angular momentum. In practice, this amounts to choosing a non-uniform distribution on the spin magnitude parallel to the orbital plane, with a peak at 0.

The second broad prior allows for a wider range of masses and spins. Here we assume that component masses are uniformly distributed between 0.7 M /circledot and 3.0 M /circledot with the constraint that m 2 /lessorequalslant m 1 . Priors on the chirp mass M and mass ratio q are determined from the concomitant Jacobian transformation. For computational efficiency, we impose a further cut on the chirp mass of the binary, such that we only consider points with chirp mass between 1.190 and

1.210 solar masses. However, this is wide enough to cover the full range of values supported by the data [3, 6, 38, 39]. In the broad prior, the spin magnitudes are taken to be uniformly distributed between 0 and 0.7. This is narrower than the spin prior used in [6] which extended to 0.89. The broad prior is intended to be a conservative spin prior compatible with the fastestspinning known neutron star, which has a dimensionless spin /lessorequalslant 0.4 [69]. The choice of the limit 0.7 should not influence the results, as we obtain one-sided 95% upper limits for the dimensionless spin posterior which are much lower (below 0.35 for all models).

Non-rotating neutron stars cannot exceed a maximum mass which depends on the equation of state. If the sampler chooses a point in the parameter space where a given equation of state  cannot support a non-rotating neutron star, we assume that the body is a black hole. Although rotation can increase the maximum mass, we do not allow for a scenario in which any neutron star is so massive that it requires rotation to prevent collapse. This choice is made to ensure that the prior volume is equal for all the equations of state. Our exact model assumption for a given equation of state is thus that objects below the maximum mass of non-rotating neutron stars are in fact neutron stars described by the given equation of state, otherwise light black holes. For the narrow prior, the distinction is irrelevant because we find no posterior support above the maximum mass for any equation of state. For the broad prior on the other hand, the posterior has significant support for mixed binaries for some equation of state models, as is further discussed in section 3.

There is also an upper bound on the dimensionless spin possible for uniformly rotating neutron stars, which depends on the equation of state. The maximum spin covered by the broad prior is below the maximum possible spin for some models considered here (compare section 2.4). Thus, the broad prior will contain a fraction of neutron stars rotating impossibly fast for some equations of state. In practice, this issue is not relevant as we find zero posterior support for such rotation rates.

Finally, we also present results where we compare the hypothesis that both bodies are lowmass black holes against the hypothesis that one, or both, bodies are neutron stars, but with a non-specific equation of state model. In this case we are sampling over the tidal deformability of the neutron stars (and deriving all other equation of state specific quantities from this  value  as  explained  below).  For  this  analysis  we  use  the  same  prior  choices  as  above, specifically considering the broad mass prior, except for the following choices on spins and tidal  deformability distributions. Here, a black hole is defined as having a spin magnitude uniformly distributed in [ 0, 0.89 ] and zero tidal deformability, while a neutron star has a spin magnitude uniformly distributed in [ 0, 0.05 ] and a tidal deformability uniformly distributed in [ 0, 5000 ] . The upper spin limit for black holes differs from the broad prior considered above. The specific models we study in this case are:

- (i) Binary Black Hole : χ 1 ∈ [ 0, 0.89 ] , χ 2 ∈ [ 0, 0.89 ] , Λ = Λ 1 2 = 0 .
- (ii) Black  Hole -Neutron  Star : χ 1 ∈ [ 0, 0.89 ] , χ 2 ∈ [ 0, 0.05 ] , Λ = 1 0 , Λ 2 ∈ [ 0, 5000 ] , m BH &gt; m NS .
- iii) ( Neutron  Star -Black  Hole : χ 1 ∈ [ 0, 0.05 ] , χ 2 ∈ [ 0, 0.89 ] , Λ 1 ∈ [ 0, 5000 ] , Λ = 2 0 , m NS &gt; m BH .
- (iv) Binary Neutron Star, no assumptions on equation of state : χ 1 ∈ [ 0, 0.05 ] , χ 2 ∈ [ 0, 0.05 ] , Λ 1 ∈ [ 0, 5000 ] , Λ 2 ∈ [ 0, 5000 ] .
- (v) Binary  Neutron  Star,  neutron  stars  obey  same  equation  of  state : χ 1 ∈ [ 0, 0.05 ] , χ 2 ∈ [ 0, 0.05 ] , Λ s ≡ (Λ 2 +Λ ) 1 / 2 ∈ [ 0, 5000 ] , Λ a ≡ (Λ 2 -Λ ) 1 / 2 = Λ (Λ a s , m 2 / m 1 ) .

where here χ i and Λ i denote  the  dimensionless spin and tidal deformability of the body i respectively. The analysis of model (iv) allows the two component tidal deformabilities to vary independent of each other. In contrast, the analysis of model (v) uses an equation of

state-independent relation between the two tidal deformabilities given the mass ratio of the system [48, 49].

## 2.3.  Waveform models for the gravitational-wave signal

Gravitational-wave signals from binary neutron stars are distinct from signals from binary black holes. The deformation of the neutron star due to tidal effects and a spin-induced quadrupole, as well as the post-merger behavior of the remnant, will all leave an imprint in the emitted gravitational waves. Unfortunately, no waveform model yet exists that can consistently model all three of these effects, as modeling the post-merger behavior requires expensive numerical simulations. Such simulations have been performed by a number of groups in  recent  years,  enabling  an  exploration  of  the  expected  features  of  post-merger  emission [70 -72]. Though this work has not yet reached the stage where one can predict waveforms with arbitrary masses, spins and equation of state, unmodeled analyses can target the expected post-merger signal [73 -75]. Since the post-merger component of the signal occurs at frequencies ∼ 2000 Hz, where Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo sensitivity is decreasing, observing this regime was not possible for GW170817 [3, 6, 22, 76]. For the present analysis, it is therefore safe to ignore the post-merger signal.

We use waveform models that predict gravitational-wave signals for a large range of parameters and include both the effects of the tidal deformation and of the spin-induced quadrupole. In contrast to previous analyses [3, 6], where the individual tidal deformabilities Λ of the neutron stars were treated as independent intrinsic parameters, we assume a specific equation of state model and the tidal deformability is computed as a function of the masses. To construct the functions Λ( m ) , the Tolman -Oppenheimer -Volkoff differential equations [77, 78] for the stellar structure are solved numerically together with those for the tidal deformability [12, 79].

The quadrupole-monopole effects are caused by the quadrupolar deformations induced by the spin [11], and are quadratic in the spins. These effects are parametrized by a quadrupolemonopole parameter κ . Similarly to the tidal deformability, this parameter is treated as a pure function of the masses κ ( m ) , determined in practice from the value of Λ via fits of approximate universal relations for neutron stars [48].

The waveform models used in this study are essentially the same as in the previous analyses  from  the  LIGO -Virgo collaboration [3,  6,  39],  to  which  we  refer  the  reader  for  more details. The TaylorF2 model uses purely post-Newtonian information to generate closed-form waveforms in the Fourier domain, only allowing for spins aligned with the orbital angular momentum. It includes point-particle and spin contributions (see, e.g. [80]) and tidal contributions. In contrast to [6], we consider several variants of TaylorF2, incorporating tidal terms up to the 6, 7 or 7.5 post-Newtonian order [13, 14, 81] 196 .

A  closed-form  tidal  approximant,  denoted  NRTidal,  calibrated  to  binary  neutron  star numerical  relativity  simulations  was  presented  in  [82,  83].  In  this  paper,  EOB + NRT and Phenom + NRT will denote the waveform models constructed from adding this numer  ical relativity tuned approximant for tidal effects onto the underlying point-particle waveform models, SEOBNRv4\_ROM [84] and IMRPhenomPv2 [85 88] respectively. While the EOB -+ NRT model is restricted to aligned spins, Phenom + NRT incorporates an effective representation of  precession  effects  [85,  86]. All  three  models TaylorF2,  Phenom + NRT and EOB + NRT

196 The tidal terms at the 7PN and 7.5PN orders are not strictly complete, with a missing term at 7PN (2PN relative order in the tidal terms) but this missing piece is argued in [14] to be unimportant quantitatively.

include post-Newtonian quadrupole-monopole terms, up to the third PN order in the phasing [11, 89].

In  addition,  we  use  two  time-domain  effective  one  body  models  that  incorporate  tidal effects,  SEOBNRv4T [90, 91] and TEOBResumS [92]. SEOBNRv4T includes dynamical tides and the effects of the spin-induced quadrupole moment. TEOBResumS incorporates a gravitational-self-force re-summed tidal potential and the spin-induced quadrupole moment. Both models have been shown to be compatible with state-of-the-art numerical simulations of binary neutron stars up to merger [92, 93]. Also compare [94, 95] regarding recent extensions.

Lacking a prescription for the post-merger signal, all waveforms have an equation of state dependent termination frequency that is close to the merger frequency. For TaylorF2, the termination frequency is determined according to equation (13) of [45] 197 . For EOB + NRT and Phenom + NRT, the termination frequency is computed following equation (11) of [83]. Thus the NRT waveforms with zero tidal deformabilities are not strictly speaking equivalent to the binary black hole waveforms: in the NRT prescription the merger is cut instead of terminating with a ringdown signal as would be the case in the underlying point-particle model. However, this difference only concerns high frequencies and should not affect our evidence computations. For most of the configurations considered in this analysis, a remnant black hole would have a ringdown frequency above ∼ 4 kHz , justifying the above statement.

It  is  important  to  note  that  all  our  waveform  models  are  imperfect  and  come  with  systematic errors. Without a quantitative model to represent this as a modeling uncertainty, we cannot marginalize over the waveform error in our analysis. Comparisons between different waveform models [83, 96, 97] indicate that TaylorF2  can  produce  small  differences  from Phenom + NRT and EOB + NRT in recovering the tidal parameters, while yielding comparable results for the masses and spins. This was indeed observed in the analysis of GW170817 [3, 6, 38, 39], where the TaylorF2 model yielded larger upper limits for the tidal parameters. In order to obtain a rough estimate how differences between waveform models affect the Bayes factor calculations, we compare results obtained with different waveform families.

## 2.4.  Equations of state

For  this  work,  we  have  collected  24  different  prescriptions  describing  neutron  star  equations of state from the literature, computed by various nuclear physics approximations. The full list together with the relevant citations is given in appendix A.

All equations of state describe zero-temperature matter in β -equilibrium. We require equations of state to respect causality, i.e. the maximum sound speed inside stable neutron stars may not exceed the speed of light at any mass up to the maximum allowed. For compariso  n with previous studies [6, 39], however, we also include some results for the WFF1 [98] equation of state model, which violates causality before reaching the central density of the maximum-mass neutron star. One equation of state model (HQC18 [9]) incorporates a trans  ition between a hadronic phase in the crust and a quark matter phase in the core. The other equation of state models describe purely hadronic matter without significant phase transitions. We deliberately do not use any constraints from previous studies of the detected event [3, 6, 38, 39] to further narrow the equation of state model selection.

The  equation  of  state  properties  most  important  for  our  analysis  of  the  gravitationalwave  signal  are  the  maximum  gravitational  mass  of  non-rotating  neutron  stars  and  their

197 There is a typo in equation (14) of [45], the denominator should be the sum of the two radii cubed , without which the equation is not dimensionally correct.

tidal deformability as a function of gravitational mass. In order to derive implications for the merger remnant, we also require the maximum mass of uniformly rotating neutron stars, as well as the maximum rotation rate and moment of inertia as a function of mass. The maximum dimensionless spin for a given mass is also relevant with regard to the spin prior. We compute all those properties for all equations of state used in this work. Key quantities are tabulated in appendix A.

The properties of non-rotating neutron stars which follow from the equations of state used here are shown in figure 1. For comparison, we also show the credible intervals for the component gravitational masses derived in [6] for different priors on the spin. The maximum gravitational mass covers a range 1.92 M /circledot (BHF\_BBB2) to 2.75 M /circledot (MS1\_PP, MS1B\_PP). The discovery  of  neutron  star  PSR  J0348 + 0432 [26] with mass 2.01 ± 0.04 M /circledot ,  and  the  very recent  observation  of  PSR  J0740 + 6620 [99]  with  mass  of 2.14 + 0.10 -0.09 M /circledot ,  provide  a  lower limit for the maximum mass of neutron stars. However, we also included some models with maximum mass slightly below those constraints in our comparison. Although causality would allow maximum masses even larger than our most massive models (see [100, 101]), the chosen range covers most nuclear physics estimates. The smallest tidal deformability within the mass credible interval [6] for the low spin prior is found for the WFF1 equation of state model, with Λ = 61 , and the largest one for the MS1\_PP equation of state model, with Λ = 3728 . In the same mass range, we find that the dimensionless spin at the mass-shedding limit is between 0.66 (KDE0V1) and 0.76 (SKI5).

## 2.5.  Gravitational-wave data

For our analysis, we follow [7] and use data from the two LIGO observatories with the full frequency-dependent calibration uncertainties described in [102, 103] and following the subtraction of independently measured noise sources as discussed in [104]. As discussed in [3], a non-Gaussian transient occurs in the data recorded by the LIGO Livingston observatory. This non-Gaussian transient is removed from the data as in [3] using the methods discussed in [73]. We have checked that the instrumental transient subtraction does not bias the results of our inference substantially [105]. We also follow [7] in using data from the Virgo observatory using the calibration and noise-subtraction model discussed in [106]. For both the LIGO and Virgo observatories we analyze data between 23 Hz and 2048 Hz.

## 2.6.  Evaluating the Bayes factors

In this work we utilize two different strategies to compute the Bayes factors. We use pre-existing tools in the LALInference [42] and RIFT [43] parameter inference codes to compute the evidence for each equation of state model (equation (2)). For LALInference, this involves performing a distinct detailed Bayesian analysis of the data for each proposed model, using nested sampling [107] and thermodynamic integration [108] to compute the evidence [42]. Both methods have been extensively tested [42] and produce consistent results [109].

For RIFT, this calculation is organized as a two-stage process. The first stage estimates a single marginal likelihood P s x ( | , Λ 1, Λ 2, I ) = ∫ d θ P s ( | θ , x , Λ 1, Λ 2; Mi , I ) P ( θ ) as a function of  the  extrinsic  parameters θ and  the  intrinsic  binary  parameters x = ( m 1, m 2, χ 1, χ 2 ) and (Λ 1, Λ ) 2 without assuming an equation of state. The next stage computes the evidence via P s Mi ( | , I ) = ∫ d xP x P s x ( ) ( | , Λ( m Mi 1 | ) , Λ( m Mi 2 | ) ; Mi , I ) , where Λ( m Mi | ) denotes the deformability as function of mass assuming the equation of state model Mi .  Using a precomputed marginal likelihood, this second stage can be performed very rapidly for any equation of state,

![image](https://ac.marcodsn.me/arxiv-markdown-images/1908.01012v3-figure-11cb5adc-444a-4280-9879-b7fc50a55ca1.jpg)

/circledot

Figure 1. Properties of non-rotating neutron stars for all equations of state considered in this work. Top: dimensionless tidal deformability versus gravitational mass. Bottom: proper circumferential radius. All sequences terminate at the maximum mass model (except WFF1, which is cut where the maximum sound speed reaches the speed of light). The legend entries are sorted by the radius of a 1.36 M /circledot neutron star. For comparison, we show the 90% symmetric credible interval given in [6] for the component masses, with dashed vertical lines for the low-spin prior, dotted lines for the high spin prior, and the solid line for the equal-mass limit 1.36 M /circledot . The shaded vertical area marks the measured mass for pulsar PSR J0348 + 0432 [26].

in seconds to minutes depending on the accuracy required. Unless otherwise noted, all RIFT calculations are performed using the marginalized likelihoods P s x ( | , Λ 1, Λ ) 2 employed in [7].

## 3.  Results

For each equation of state described in section 2.4, the Bayes factors are computed using either  LALInference or RIFT, using both the narrow and broad priors discussed in section 2.6. The Bayes factors for all waveform approximants and the statistical uncertainties are given in appendix B. The Bayes factors calculated adopting the narrow prior are shown in

Figure  2. The  Bayes  factors  for  the  narrow  prior  results  using  different  waveform approximants, as given in table B1. The equations of state have been sorted by the compactness C of the neutron star at a fiducial mass of 1.36 M /circledot . The results show a clear preference for more compact equations of state. We adopt the guidelines of [111] for the interpretation of the Bayes factors. Here Z = P s Mi ( | , I ) is the evidence of a given equation of state or the fiducial binary black hole model. Statistical errors on the Bayes factors from the nested sampling algorithm are negligible.

![image](https://ac.marcodsn.me/arxiv-markdown-images/1908.01012v3-figure-8a907e2c-90fa-4b52-a2dc-4c6c1b2a1643.jpg)

tables B1 and B3 for LALInference and RIFT, respectively. Similarly, for the broad prior, the LALInference results are given in table B2 and the RIFT results in table B4. The Bayes factors for the LALInference runs are quoted with respect to the low-mass binary black hole hypothesis. The RIFT results re-use the analysis presented in [7] and are not normalized with respect to the BBH case due to the way in which the fits are performed. Instead, the RIFT Bayes factors are quoted relative to the arbitrary hypothesis that GW170817 was a binary neutron star with the SLY9 equation of state, which has modest support and shows relatively little dispersion between waveform approximants in the LALInference results.

For the narrow prior, the gravitational-wave data does not favor and nor can it rule out any single equation of state with respect to the low-mass binary black hole hypothesis. This can be seen in figure 2, although the data clearly favors softer equations of state, which predict more compact neutron stars with lower tidal deformabilities. The broad prior case, shown in figure 3, exhibits the same trend. The relation is visualized more directly in figure 4, showing fiducial neutron star properties as a function of the Bayes factor with respect to the KDE0V model, which is the most favored for the narrow prior with TaylorF2 (7.5pN) approximant. The models with largest fiducial radius and tidal deformability are very strongly disfavored (MS1\_PP) or at least strongly disfavored (MS1B\_PP) compared to the numerous models with small fiducial radius and deformability, such as KDE0V.

Figure 4 also shows upper limits for radius and tidal deformability given by parameter estimation studies [6, 38, 39]. For all our equations of state, and mass ratios in the range q &gt; 0.7, the effective tidal deformability and the tidal deformability at the fiducial mass agree better than 6%. To this accuracy, we can compare the upper limits to the values plotted for the fiducial mass models. We find that some of our models with tidal deformabilities above the limits are not strongly disfavored with respect to the most favored equations of state.

Although we can only compute Bayes factors between the models at hand, the Bayes factors exhibit a trend of decreasing with an increasing fiducial radius and tidal deformability. If this trend holds in general, then for a fiducial mass of 1.36 M /circledot models with tidal deformability Λ( M = 1.36 ) /greaterorsimilar 1600 or radius R M ( = 1.36 ) /greaterorsimilar 14.9 km are very strongly disfavored.

Figure 3. As per figure 2 but for the broad prior using different waveform approximants, given in table B2.

![image](https://ac.marcodsn.me/arxiv-markdown-images/1908.01012v3-figure-e631ed37-67e4-4e09-bb78-dd45140aa7fd.jpg)

For the broad prior, the gravitational-wave data alone does not prefer any single equation of state, as was the case for the narrow prior. However, MS1\_PP and MS1B\_PP are now strongly disfavored against the low-mass binary black hole hypothesis, as shown in figure 3. Normalizing the Bayes factors against KDE0V, we find that MS1\_PP is very strongly and MS1B\_PP strongly disfavored with respect to the softer KDE0V equation of state, as shown in figure 4.

In contrast to the narrow prior, we find that for some equations of state there is significant posterior support for a mixed binary where the heavier object is a light black hole. The reason for this is that the mass range is less constrained and exceeds the maximum possible mass of  non-rotating  neutron  stars  for  those  equations  of  state.  Models  BHF\_BBB2,  KDE0V1, HQC18, and KDE0V have 13, 7, 5, and 7 percent posterior probability, respectively, for a mixed binary. The remaining models have support below 5% for mixed binary, in particular MS1\_PP and MS1B\_PP have zero support for mixed binaries. For the broad prior and the WFF1 equation of state, there is a ≈ 14 % posterior probability for a central neutron star density in an unphysical (causality violating) region of the parameter space.

For both sets of priors, we find that the bulk of equations of state considered in this paper produce evidences that are consistent to within an order of magnitude. This is in line with the expectations  for  second-generation  gravitational-wave  detectors,  where ∼ O ( 20 ) detections will allow hypothesis ranking to distinguish between hard, moderate and soft equations of state [44]. Even if the true equation of state were to be one of those considered in this paper, we should not necessarily expect this to be the most preferred equation of state in the hypothesis ranking [45]. For example, this could arise due to the effects of noise or other systematics. More realistically, it is also possible that the true equation of state is not contained in the finite set of models considered here, though we expect the highest ranked hypotheses to share similar macroscopic features to the true neutron star equation of state.

It is important to assess the systematic bias inherent in our waveform models. Such systematic biases could arise from a different treatment of the underlying point particle limit, which can start to become significant at higher frequencies where tidal effects also become more prominent. Additionally, the different waveform models employ different prescriptions for the tidal contribution to the phasing, which can lead to discrepancies in the recovery of tidal parameters. As demonstrated in previous studies [39, 83, 96, 97, 110], the tidal effect calculated in the TaylorF2 waveform models is typically smaller than that predicted using the

Figure 4. The fiducial tidal deformability Λ at 1.36 M /circledot (top) and the fiducial neutron star  radius R at 1.36 M /circledot (bottom)  plotted  as  a  function  of  the  Bayes  factors  for  the narrow prior (left) and broad prior (right). For the binary black hole case, the plotted radius  is  the  Schwarzschild  radius.  The  Bayes  factors  have  been  normalized  with respect to KDE0V, which is the most favored equation of state for the narrow prior with TaylorF2 (7.5pN) waveform model. Compared to the KDE0V model, MS1\_PP is very strongly disfavored ( ln BF /lessorequalslant -5 ) and MS1B\_PP is strongly disfavored ( ln BF /lessorequalslant -3 ) for both priors and all waveform approximants. For comparison, we plot limits from the literature. The solid green horizontal lines mark the upper limit for the coalescing neutron star radii from [39]. Red dashed lines mark the upper limit given for the radius given in [38] (assuming a common radius for the two stars) and the one-sided upper limit for the effective tidal deformability from [38]. The blue dash-dotted lines mark the upper limit (highest posterior density interval) for the effective tidal deformability from [6].

![image](https://ac.marcodsn.me/arxiv-markdown-images/1908.01012v3-figure-75000aaf-3879-476c-9a5a-3cd21c7f7e7b.jpg)

NRTidal prescription. As such, the tidal parameters inferred from the data using the TaylorF2 waveform model will typically be larger in order to compensate for the reduced tidal effect. Consequentially, we find that the Bayes factors calculated using the TaylorF2 model tend to show greater support for stiffer equations of state, which yield larger tidal deformabilities, in comparison to the effective-one-body or phenomenological waveform models. However, as can be seen in figures 2 -4, the Bayes factors between the different waveform approximants still show reasonably good agreement.

Finally,  we  also  ask  if  can  we  rule  out  the  binary  black  hole  hypothesis  by  computing Bayes factors for the binary neutron star hypothesis, or the hypothesis that there was only one neutron star in the binary, without assuming a specific equation of state. We consider both

Table 1. Bayes factors between various hypotheses on the nature of the GW170817 components  obtained  using  different  waveform  approximants  and  two  methods  for computing the evidence. All Bayes factors are given in relation to the  binary neutron ' star  with  independent  equations  of  state   hypothesis.  We  do  not  present  results  for ' Phenom + NRT/Nest when a BH is part of the binary, as the combination of precession and high spins makes this analysis computationally very expensive. We find no clear preference for any hypothesis. The table abbreviations stand for nested sampling (Nest), Markov-chain  Monte-Carlo/thermodynamic  integration  (MCMC),  binary  black  hole (BBH), mixed binary where the neutron star is heavier (NSBH), mixed binary where the black hole is heavier (BHNS), binary neutron star (BNS), equation of state (EoS).

| Waveform/Method       | BBH   | NSBH   | BHNS   |   BNS (common EoS) |
|-----------------------|-------|--------|--------|--------------------|
| Phenom + NRT/Nest     | -     | -      | -      |                5   |
| Phenom + NRT/MCMC     | 1.1   | 0.7    | 1.7    |                9.6 |
| EOB + NRT/MCMC        | 1.7   | 1.6    | 4.0    |                5.5 |
| TaylorF2 (7pN)/Nest   | 1.9   | 1.4    | 3.7    |                4.9 |
| TaylorF2 (7pN)/MCMC   | 1.0   | 1.2    | 3.4    |                4.4 |
| TaylorF2 (7.5pN)/Nest | 1.6   | 1.3    | 3.2    |                4.4 |
| TaylorF2 (7.5pN)/MCMC | 0.9   | 1.0    | 5.5    |                5   |

the hypotheses that the single neutron star is heavier and lighter than its potential black hole companion. The specific priors that we use in these cases were discussed earlier in section 2.2. Table 1 presents the Bayes factors compared to the ' binary neutron star with independent equation of state  hypothesis. We present results with different waveform approximants and ' methodologies to compute the evidence of each model.

From the results in table 1 we can draw a number of conclusions. First, we find that the computed Bayes factors agree closely between different waveform approximants, indicating that uncertainties in the waveform modeling are not compromising our results. Second, we find that both nested sampling and thermodynamic integration return consistent results for the Bayes factors, giving us confidence on the validity of the calculation. Third, and most interesting from a physical perspective, we find that the GW170817 data alone does not strongly favor one hypothesis over the other. All of the Bayes factors we compute are in the range of 1 to 5, suggesting that the gravitational-wave data alone do not show a strong preference for any of the hypotheses considered here.

It may seem strange that the binary neutron star model, assuming no common equation of state, is the least favored hypothesis. Bayes factors depend on the Occam penalty, i.e. how well a model fits the given data (goodness-of-fit) and how many constrained parameters a model includes (dimensionality). We expect all models to be preferred over the binary neutron star model, assuming a common equation of state, if they fit the data equally well. The binary black hole model has two fewer parameters and the neutron star-black hole hypotheses have one  fewer  parameter. A  brief  back-of-the-envelope  calculation  can  be  used  to  support  the Bayes factors seen in table 1. The Occam penalty is given by δθ/ ∆ θ , the posterior width over the prior width, and penalizes a model for each additional constrained parameter it employs, since δθ &lt; ∆ θ . From section 2.2, we see that the width of the prior on the tidal parameters is ∆Λ ∼ 5000 whereas the width on the posterior is on the order of δ Λ ∼ 1000 [6]. From this, we expect the binary neutron star hypothesis with a common equation of state to be preferred over an independent equation of state hypothesis by a factor ∼ 5, as it uses one fewer parameter. This is in agreement with the results found in table 1 and as demonstrated in [49] for simulated binary neutron star signals.

## 4.  Implications

After comparing the relative probabilities of the different equation of state models, we now discuss the implications that follow from assuming any of the equations of state are correct. We also discuss constraints for the maximum mass of neutron stars that follow from assumptions on the fate of the remnant, but without assuming any equation of state.

## 4.1 .   Baryonic mass and central density

The  total  baryonic  mass  (defined  here  as  baryon  number  times  a  fiducial  mass  constant 1.66 × 10 -27 kg )  is  the  most  important  quantity  for  the  evolution  during  the  post-merger phase, including the lifetime of the remnant and the mass of the accretion disk, which are relevant for the short gamma-ray burst and the kilonova. The maximum density inside the initial neutron stars is important to interpret our results properly. The relative probabilities we compute for different equation of state models only signify that in the density range occurring in the coalescing neutron stars , matter is more likely described by one equation of state model than another.

To compute the baryonic mass, we start with the posterior samples obtained assuming a given equation of state model. From the gravitational masses and spins in a given sample, we obtain  the  baryonic  masses  of  the  neutron  stars.  Those  are  computed  using  interpolation tables we build for sequences of non-rotating and maximally rotating neutron stars for each equation of state model. To account for the spin, we expand the gravitational mass at given baryonic mass to second order in the squared dimensionless spin parameter. The zerothand first-order coefficients are determined from the binding energy and moment of inertia of the non-rotating model. The second-order coefficient is then determined from the angular momentum and gravitational mass of the maximally rotating model. The spin corrections are relatively small compared to the statistical error both for narrow and broad priors. To obtain limits for the energy densities that can be reached before merger, we use the central densities of non-rotating neutron stars with baryonic masses computed as described above.

The results for the narrow prior are given in table 2. We find that the pre-merger gravitational-wave  signal  does  not  carry  information  about  matter  at  energy  densities  above 0.5 -1.3 × 10 15 g cm -3 ,  assuming the true equation of state is similar to one of the models considered here. This agrees well with the results by [39] (figure 2 therein) obtained using parametrized equations of state, and also with results in [40] based on Gaussian process models for the equation of state.

## 4.2.  Fate of merger remnant

Next, we assess the fate of the merger remnant, which could either form a black hole directly at merger (prompt collapse), a short-lived hypermassive neutron star, a long-lived supramassive neutron star, or even an unconditionally stable neutron star. This is particularly relevant with regard to the observed short gamma-ray burst and kilonova counterparts. One possible engine for short gamma-ray bursts is given by a black hole submerged in a massive disk [52]. Numerical simulations suggest that prompt black hole formation at merger might be in tension with the production of a short gamma-ray bursts [29, 112], favoring delayed collapse. The other model for the engine consists of a rapidly rotating and strongly magnetized neutron star (magnetar scenario [53, 113, 114]) embedded in a disk. In this model, the remnant needs to survive at least long enough to initiate a jet (however, there can be a delay until the jet produces the observed short gamma-ray burst). The fate of the remnant is also tightly related to the ejection

Table  2. Implications  derived  from  the  equation  of  state  model  specific  parameter estimation  runs  with  narrow  prior  and  TaylorF2  (7.5  PN)  waveform  model. M 0 B is the total initial baryonic mass. We provide the median value and the 90% two-sided credible bounds. Ec is the 90% one-sided upper limit for the central energy density of the heavier neutron star. The normalized mass ˜ m 0 is simply a linear transform of M 0 B defined by equation (4), such that the supramassive mass range for the given equation of state model corresponds to ˜ m ∈ ( 0, 1 ) . The potential impact of mass ejection is given in terms of ∆ 0.1 = ˜ m 0 -˜ m R , computed from equation (5) for a fiducial ejecta mass 0.1 M /circledot (the  given  value  is  the  90%  one-sided  upper  limit).  The ' prompt  collapse   column ' denotes  whether  a  black  hole  can  be  formed  directly  during  the  merger,  based  on available estimates of the corresponding mass threshold, and assuming prompt collapse only occurs for hypermassive systems. Hypermassive cases lacking data on the prompt collapse threshold are denoted with a dash, while ' possibly  refers to the case where ' the available bounds on the threshold are compatible with both outcomes. I max and F max are upper limits (see main text) for moment of inertia and rotation rate for a uniformly rotating remnant. I max is given in geometric units of 4.335 871 × 10 43 g cm 2 .

| Equation of state   | M 0 B ( M /circledot )   |   E c / c 2 ( 10 15 g cm - 3 | ˜ m 0                   |   ∆ 0.1 | Prompt collapse   |   I max ( M 3 /circledot ) |   F max ( kHz ) |
|---------------------|--------------------------|------------------------------|-------------------------|---------|-------------------|----------------------------|-----------------|
| APR4_EPP            | 3.021 + 0.019 0.009      |                         1.05 | 0.883 + 0.041 0.019     |    0.22 | No                |                         84 |            1.79 |
| MS1_PP              | - 2.940 + 0.014 0.008    |                         0.47 | - - 0.608 + 0.023 0.013 |    0.17 | No                |                        153 |            1    |
| MS1B_PP             | - 2.949 + 0.014 0.008    |                         0.49 | - 0.581 + 0.023 0.013   |    0.16 | No                |                        152 |            1.03 |
| KDE0V               | - 3.013 + 0.019 0.009    |                         1.17 | - - 1.859 + 0.050 0.025 |    0.27 | -                 |                         66 |            1.86 |
| SKI6                | - 2.994 + 0.016 0.009    |                         0.82 | - 0.848 + 0.036 0.018   |    0.22 | No                |                         97 |            1.53 |
| H4                  | - 2.978 + 0.015 0.009    |                         0.65 | - 1.385 + 0.035 0.017   |    0.22 | No                |                        104 |            1.36 |
| MPA1                | - 3.004 + 0.016 0.009    |                         0.74 | - - 0.016 + 0.029 0.016 |    0.18 | No                |                        114 |            1.34 |
| SK255               | - 2.968 + 0.015 0.008    |                         0.8  | - 1.120 + 0.038 0.020   |    0.24 | -                 |                         91 |            1.61 |
| SKI2                | - 2.968 + 0.016 0.008    |                         0.72 | - 1.025 + 0.036 0.019   |    0.23 | -                 |                        100 |            1.53 |
| SKI4                | - 2.997 + 0.017 0.008    |                         0.83 | - 0.911 + 0.035 0.018   |    0.22 | No                |                         94 |            1.58 |
| SKOP                | - 2.994 + 0.016 0.009    |                         1.02 | - 1.808 + 0.043 0.022   |    0.26 | -                 |                         73 |            1.7  |
| SLY2                | - 3.005 + 0.018 0.009    |                         1.02 | - 1.401 + 0.043 0.022   |    0.25 | -                 |                         77 |            1.79 |
| SLY9                | - 2.988 + 0.016 0.008    |                         0.86 | - 0.999 + 0.037 0.019   |    0.23 | -                 |                         91 |            1.68 |
| BHF_BBB2            | - 3.021 + 0.020 0.009    |                         1.26 | - 2.032 + 0.053 0.025   |    0.27 | -                 |                         63 |            1.87 |
| HQC18               | - 3.014 + 0.018 0.010    |                         1.03 | - 1.305 + 0.040 0.020   |    0.22 | -                 |                         81 |            1.72 |
| KDE0V1              | - 3.005 + 0.018 0.009    |                         1.13 | - 1.837 + 0.048 0.024   |    0.27 | -                 |                         68 |            1.8  |
| RS                  | - 2.980 + 0.016 0.008    |                         0.8  | - 1.174 + 0.037 0.019   |    0.24 | -                 |                         92 |            1.61 |
| SK272               | - 2.965 + 0.016 0.008    |                         0.75 | - 0.780 + 0.036 0.019   |    0.23 | No                |                        100 |            1.43 |
| SKI3                | - 2.967 + 0.015 0.008    |                         0.68 | - 0.744 + 0.034 0.018   |    0.22 | No                |                        107 |            1.35 |
| SKI5                | - 2.957 + 0.015 0.008    |                         0.63 | - 0.775 + 0.033 0.019   |    0.23 | No                |                        109 |            1.32 |
| SKMP                | - 2.990 + 0.016 0.008    |                         0.86 | - 1.186 + 0.037 0.019   |    0.23 | -                 |                         88 |            1.68 |
| SLY                 | - 3.005 + 0.017 0.009    |                         1.04 | - 1.425 + 0.042 0.021   |    0.25 | Possibly          |                         76 |            1.82 |
| SLY230A             | - 3.007 + 0.017 - 0.009  |                         0.97 | - 1.175 + 0.040 - 0.020 |    0.23 | -                 |                         83 |            1.76 |

of matter and the spectral evolution of the resulting kilonova [5, 115 -118]. For example, the amount, composition and velocity of ejected matter required for the observed kilonova might be in tension with expectations for the prompt collapse case (for a recent review on multimessenger constraints, see [119]). However, the theoretical modeling of the kilonova is a very complex and rapidly evolving field of research (e.g. [120 -123] and the references therein).

The most relevant quantity regarding the remnant type is the baryonic mass M R B of the system, in comparison to the maximum baryonic mass of non-rotating neutron stars, ˆ M TOV B , and the maximum baryonic mass of neutron stars uniformly rotating at the mass-shedding limit, ˆ M ROT B . Since the baryon number is conserved, the remnant mass is given by M R B = M 0 B -M E B , where M E B denotes the baryonic mass expelled from the system dynamically and by winds, and M 0 B the total initial baryonic mass.

For discussing the expected remnant evolution, we introduce a useful dimensionless measure ˜ m defined as

$$\text{re} \, m \, \text{unmenu as} \\ \tilde { m } ( M _ { \text{B} } ) & = k _ { m } \left ( \frac { M _ { \text{B} } } { \hat {$$

The maximum masses ˆ M ROT B and ˆ M TOV B , which we compute for each equation of state model are given in table A1. Based on ˜ m R ≡ ˜( m M R B ) for a given equation of state model, we classify the remnant as hypermassive if ˜ m R &gt; 1 , supramassive if 0 /lessorequalslant ˜ m R /lessorequalslant 1 , and stable if ˜ m R &lt; 0 .

The quantity ˜ m R serves as a rough indication for the remnant lifetime τ R . A stable remnant will never form a black hole, a hypermassive remnant either forms a black hole directly at merger or collapses within a few hundred ms . Within the narrow supramassive mass range, the lifetime decreases sharply. Computing τ R as a function of ˜ m R , however, is a difficult problem beyond the scope of this paper. Although we expect ˜ m R to be the most important parameter, note that τ R might also depend on other factors such as mass ratio, spins, and equation of state.

In table 2, we provide the value ˜ m 0 corresponding to the median value of the total initial baryonic mass inferred for the narrow prior. Applying equation (4) to M R B and M 0 B , we obtain

$$\tilde { m } _ { R } = \tilde { m } _ { 0 } - ( \tilde { m } _ { 0 } + k _ { m } ) \, \frac { M _ { B } ^ { E } } { M _ { B } ^ { 0 } }.$$

In [116], the ejecta mass was estimated from the observed kilonova to around 0.078 M /circledot . If we assume more conservatively that M E B &lt; 0.1 M /circledot , we find that 0 &lt; ˜ m 0 -˜ m R &lt; 0.3 for the equations of state considered here (see table 2). The above ejecta mass limit should be regarded as a fiducial value since modeling the ejecta mass, either by numerical simulations or inferred from the kilonova, is an ongoing field of research.

For the narrow prior, we find that the MS1\_PP, MS1B\_PP, and MPA1 equation of state models lead to a stable remnant and are therefore incompatible with the black hole with disk short gamma-ray burst scenario (technically, the MPA1 also allows marginally supramassive remnants, which can for all practical purposes be considered stable). The H4, SLY, KDE0V, KDE0V1, SKOP, SLY2, BHF\_BBB2, and HQC18 equation of state models result in a shortlived hypermassive remnant. For APR4\_EPP, RS, SLY9, SLY230A, SKI2, SKI4, SK255, and SKMP, the remnant is in the upper supramassive or lower hypermassive mass range, and we cannot predict if the lifetime is longer or shorter than the observed short gamma-ray burst delay. For SKI3, SKI5, SKI6, and SK272 the remnant mass is in the supramassive range with ˜ m R &lt; 0.9 , and likely long-lived.

We now turn to discuss whether the merger can lead to prompt black hole formation for a given equation of state model, based on gravitational-wave data alone. Prompt collapse occurs above some critical mass, which depends on the equation of state. Known examples of prompt collapse in numerical binary neutron star simulations generally involve hypermassive systems. If a parameter estimation run for a given equation of state model yields posterior support only in the supramassive and stable mass range, we assume that no prompt collapse can occur. For hypermassive systems, we use existing thresholds [18] from numerical simulations, given

in terms of total gravitational mass of the binary. We consider a systematic error of 0.1 M /circledot due to the granularity of the simulated systems. The available thresholds are for equal-mass, nonspinning systems. To account for a possible impact of mass ratio and spin, we further increase the error by 0.05 M /circledot . This is a conservative estimate assuming that the main influence is by the change in dynamically ejected mass, which has been computed for many models in [124]. Finally, we express the thresholds for equal mass systems in terms of total baryonic mass and use it as an approximate threshold on M tot B for the generic case.

For  the  narrow  prior,  we  can  rule  out  prompt  collapse  for  the APR4\_EPP,  H4,  MPA1, MS1\_PP, MS1B\_PP, SKI3, SKI4, SKI5, SKI6, and SKI272 equation of state models. The SLY equation of state model is compatible both with prompt and delayed collapse (due to the systematic error of the threshold mass from numerical relativity). For the remaining equations of state, no data on prompt collapse threshold is available.

With improved theoretical modeling, the wealth of electromagnetic observations may yield reliable constraints on the lifetime of the remnant. If prompt collapse could be ruled out, the values of M 0 B obtained from gravitational-wave data could be taken as a lower limit for the prompt collapse threshold. Considering a potential impact of the mass ratio on the actual threshold, one has to take into account that the limits on M 0 B are the result of a marginalization over mass ratio.

## 4.3.  Constraining the maximum neutron star mass

Within the black hole with disk scenario of short gamma-ray bursts, the remnant cannot be stable. This was already exploited in [4] to derive limits on the maximum mass of non-rotating neutron stars. The delay of 1.7 s [4] between merger and short gamma-ray burst would also constrain the lifetime of the remnant. The relatively short lifetime indicates that the remnant either cannot be supported by uniform rotation alone (hypermassive remnant), or that it is at least close to the critical mass (how close exactly is an important open question).

In  the  following,  we  estimate  the  maximum  mass  of  non-rotating  neutron  stars  under the assumption that a black hole was produced in the binary neutron star merger before the observed short gamma-ray burst. For this, we first rewrite equation (4) as

$$\hat { M } _ { B } ^ { \text{TOV} } = M _ { B } ^ { 0 } \frac { 1 - M _ { B } ^ { E } / M _ { B } ^ { 0 } } { 1 + \tilde { m } _ { R } / k _ { m } } \leqslant \frac { M _ { B } ^ { 0 } } { 1 + \tilde { m } _ { R } / k _ { m } }.$$

From table 2, we find that M 0 B varies only slightly with equation of state. Therefore, we take the bound M 0 B &lt; 3.05 M /circledot for the equations of state considered here as a generic bound. In addition, we assume km &lt; 7, as fulfilled by all equations of state considered here. The remaining open question is below which value ˜ m R the remnant lifetime is above the short gamma-ray burst delay. We already know that the lifetime is infinite unless ˜ m R &gt; 0 . Future studies might provide tighter bounds, which will tighten the upper bound obtained for ˆ M TOV B . For example, if we demand ˜ m R &gt; 0.4 , then ˆ M TOV B &lt; 2.9 M /circledot .

Another potential method to limit the maximum mass of non-rotating neutron stars is to limit the angular momentum that needs to be removed before collapse can occur, and which becomes zero for ˜ m R = 1 . In [27], it was argued that the remnant mass must be close to the hypermassive range since the large spindown energy that would otherwise have been deposited in the environment would be incompatible with the observed counterparts (however, there are observational gaps [5], e.g. in x-rays, which could lead to energy output being missed). This assumption corresponds to ˜ m R /greaterorequalslant 1 . From equation (6), we would obtain a corre  sponding limit ˆ M TOV B &lt; 2.67 M /circledot (for  the  narrow  prior).  If  we  further  assume  that  the  maximum

baryonic mass is 15% -23% larger than the maximum gravitational mass, as fulfilled for all equation of state models considered here, we obtain a limit ˆ M TOV G /lessorequalslant 2.32 M /circledot . Based on additional assumptions, excluding prompt collapse and using an approximate expression for the prompt collapse threshold ignoring systematic errors, [27] provides a limit on the maximum neutron star mass which is 6% tighter. Reliable prompt collapse thresholds for a representative selection of equation of state models might hence be useful in this respect.

In [29], a limit ˆ M TOV G /lessorequalslant 2.28 ± 0.23 M /circledot was provided, again based on the assumption of having a hypermassive remnant. The differences to our analysis are mainly the use of gravitational masses instead of conserved baryonic masses, and a more constraining assumption regarding the range of ratios between maximum gravitational masses for uniformly rotating and non-rotating neutron stars. Such effects are included in the systematic error given in [29] for their maximum mass limit, which is therefore compatible with our result.

A similar calculation can be found in [54], yielding a limit ˆ M TOV G /lessorequalslant 2.15 -2.25 M /circledot . It is based again on the detected limits for the total initial gravitational mass, and further assumes a total energy loss of ( 0.15 ± 0.03 ) M /circledot , as well as a fixed difference 0.4 M /circledot between maximum  gravitational  masses  of  uniformly  rotating  and  non-rotating  neutron  stars.  These assumptions  might  explain  the  tighter  limit  compared  to  our  result  (for  example,  we  find ˆ M ROT G -ˆ M TOV G = 0.34 M /circledot for  the  BHF\_BBB2 equation of state). A recent analysis [125], which is not relying on assumptions about ˜ m , indicates that the remnant at the time of collapse might not rotate rapidly, and provides a limit ˆ M TOV G /lessorequalslant 2.3 M /circledot .

By using the detected gravitational-wave signal alone, without assumptions on the remnant fate, [40] inferred a limit ˆ M TOV G /lessorequalslant 2.46 , compatible with our results. This is based on modeling the equation of state using Gaussian processes, trained on a set of seven equations of state and respecting causality by construction. The Gaussian process model is further informed by the gravitational-wave data and then used to extrapolate the equation of state from densities relevant for the inspiral signal up to those required to determine the maximum mass.

## 4.4.  Impact of prior and waveform model

In order to assess the waveform systematics, we repeat the computation of the remnant properties for a representative equation of state model using all waveform approximants. The results are shown in table 3. The differences for M B and ˜ m 0 are  small compared to the statistical uncertainties, and negligible with regard to our conclusions on remnant classification, prompt collapse,  and  the  maximum  neutron  star  mass. This  is  to  be  expected,  since  those  results depend directly only on the initial neutron star masses, but not on the tidal deformabilities, which are most sensitive to the waveform model.

Table 4 shows the results obtained using the broad prior restricted to the binary neutron star case. The restriction is necessary as the heavier object exceeds the maximum mass allowed for a neutron star for parts of the broad prior. Comparing to the narrow prior in table 2, we find that the total initial baryonic mass distributions are broadened towards higher masses. This is a consequence of the wider posterior distribution for the mass ratio; for fixed chirp mass, the total baryonic mass for unequal mass binaries is higher than for equal masses.

The broader distribution leads to differences regarding the fate of the remnant. While we ruled out prompt collapse for the H4 and APR4\_EPP equations of state with the narrow prior, the respective total mass posteriors for the broad prior also have support in the mass range where prompt collapse is allowed according to the thresholds from numerical relativity. This

Table 3. Implications derived assuming the MPA1 equation of state model and narrow prior,  using  different  waveform  approximants. The given quantities are explained in table 2.

| Waveform         | M B ( M /circledot )    |   E c / c 2 ( 10 15 g cm - 3 ) | ˜ m 0                     |   ∆ 0.1 |   I max ( M 3 /circledot ) |   F max ( kHz ) |
|------------------|-------------------------|--------------------------------|---------------------------|---------|----------------------------|-----------------|
| TaylorF2(7.5 PN) | 3.004 + 0.016 0.009     |                           0.74 | - 0.016 + 0.029 0.016     |    0.18 |                        114 |            1.34 |
| TaylorF2(7 PN)   | - 3.004 + 0.016 0.009   |                           0.74 | - - 0.017 + 0.029 0.015   |    0.18 |                        114 |            1.34 |
| TaylorF2(6 PN)   | - 3.004 + 0.016 0.009   |                           0.74 | - - 0.016 + 0.028 0.016   |    0.18 |                        114 |            1.34 |
| EOB + NRT        | - 3.004 + 0.016 - 0.008 |                           0.74 | - - 0.015 + 0.027 0.015   |    0.18 |                        114 |            1.34 |
| Phenom + NRT     | 3.005 + 0.016 - 0.009   |                           0.74 | - - 0.015 + 0.029 - 0.015 |    0.18 |                        114 |            1.34 |

result  might  still  change  with  more  accurate  numerical-relativity  results  for  the  threshold, given its large systematic error.

The KDE0V, SKI3, SKI4, SKI5, SKI6, and SK272 equations of state, which lead to supramassive remnants assuming the narrow prior, might also lead to hypermassive remants when assuming the broad prior. The MS1\_PP, MS1B\_PP equations of state still lead to stable remnants, while the MPA1 equation of state model can also result in a long-lived supramassive remnant for the broad prior. The bound on the maximum Tolman -Oppenheimer -Volkoff mass when assuming the black hole with disk short gamma-ray burst model becomes less strict as well. Using only ˜ m R /greaterorequalslant 0 ,  we  obtain ˆ M TOV B &lt; 3.4 M /circledot . Assuming ˜ m R /greaterorequalslant 1 ,  we  would obtain ˆ M TOV B &lt; 2.98 M /circledot .

Another consequence of the larger mass ratios is that the mass posterior of the heavier neutron star extends to larger values. Therefore, higher central energy densities are reached. Depending on the equation of state, the inspiral gravitational-wave signal might be sensitive to the equation of state at energy densities up to 2 × 10 15 g cm -3 (compare table 4).

## 4.5.  Remnant rotation rate

In case the remnant is long-lived, the maximum rotation rate and moment of inertia are of interest for searches of long-lived gravitational-wave signals from the remnant (see [20, 22]), and might also be relevant for modeling the magnetar short gamma-ray burst scenario. In the following, we estimate upper limits for rotation rate and moment of inertia.

The total angular momentum at merger is not known, although numerical simulations indicate  that  it  typically  exceeds  the  maximum  amount  that  could  be  realized  in  a  uniformly rotating system of the same mass (see [21]). However, the disk can account for a significant fraction of the total angular momentum. Most of the disk angular momentum is transported outwards during accretion (together with a fraction of the mass). The angular momentum of the final remnant could depend on the details of the accretion process and might be less than the critical one (the opposite assumption is made in [21]), and it can decrease further on longer timescales, e.g. by magnetic spindown. The rotation rate of models near the maximum mass can increase with decreasing angular momentum, because the compactness also increases. The maximum rotation rate can in principle exceed the rotation rate at the mass-shedding limit. Here, we use the rotation rate at the mass-shedding limit as an estimate for the maximum rotation rate of the remnant.

From the mass posteriors for each equation of state model, we compute the posteriors for the rotation rate and moment of inertia of uniformly rotating neutron stars with baryonic mass equal to the total baryonic mass and maximum angular momentum. Tables 2 and 4 show the

Table 4. Like table 2, but showing results for the broad prior, again with the TaylorF2 (7.5 PN) waveform model.

| Equation of state   | M 0 B ( M /circledot )      |   E c / c 2 ( 10 15 g cm - 3 ) | ˜ m 0                   |   ∆ 0.1 | Prompt collapse   |   I max ( M 3 /circledot ) |   F max ( kHz ) |
|---------------------|-----------------------------|--------------------------------|-------------------------|---------|-------------------|----------------------------|-----------------|
| APR4_EPP            | 3.084 + 0.316 0.070         |                           1.48 | 1.019 + 0.683 0.150     |    0.22 | Possibly          |                         84 |            1.89 |
| MS1_PP              | - 2.960 + 0.121 0.026       |                           0.53 | - - 0.574 + 0.202 0.044 |    0.17 | No                |                        158 |            1.03 |
| MS1B_PP             | - 2.973 + 0.144 0.030       |                           0.55 | - - 0.542 + 0.231 0.048 |    0.16 | No                |                        159 |            1.05 |
| KDE0V               | - 3.058 + 0.219 0.053       |                           1.8  | - 1.978 + 0.582 0.139   |    0.27 | -                 |                         66 |            1.86 |
| SKI6                | - 3.028 + 0.225             |                           1.08 | - 0.922 + 0.489 0.087   |    0.22 | -                 |                         97 |            1.66 |
| H4                  | - 0.041 3.007 + 0.178 0.035 |                           0.94 | - 1.450 + 0.388 0.077   |    0.22 | Possibly          |                        104 |            1.36 |
| MPA1                | - 3.041 + 0.255 0.043       |                           0.9  | - 0.050 + 0.456 0.077   |    0.18 | No                |                        121 |            1.41 |
| SK255               | - 3.003 + 0.203 0.041       |                           1.1  | - 1.207 + 0.497 0.102   |    0.24 | -                 |                         91 |            1.61 |
| SKI2                | - 3.001 + 0.176 0.038       |                           0.97 | - 1.100 + 0.408 0.089   |    0.23 | -                 |                        100 |            1.53 |
| SKI4                | - 3.028 + 0.228 0.037       |                           1.11 | - 0.978 + 0.494 0.081   |    0.22 | -                 |                         95 |            1.67 |
| SKOP                | - 3.019 + 0.190 0.032       |                           1.45 | - 1.874 + 0.500 0.085   |    0.26 | -                 |                         73 |            1.7  |
| SLY2                | - 3.043 + 0.239 0.045       |                           1.48 | - 1.494 + 0.585 0.110   |    0.25 | -                 |                         77 |            1.79 |
| SLY9                | - 3.018 + 0.234 0.037       |                           1.15 | - 1.068 + 0.537 0.083   |    0.23 | -                 |                         91 |            1.68 |
| BHF_BBB2            | - 3.077 + 0.201 0.063       |                           2.02 | - 2.181 + 0.545 0.168   |    0.27 | -                 |                         63 |            1.87 |
| HQC18               | - 3.064 + 0.253 0.057       |                           1.42 | - 1.418 + 0.561 0.129   |    0.22 | -                 |                         81 |            1.72 |
| KDE0V1              | - 3.049 + 0.216 0.051       |                           1.73 | - 1.953 + 0.580 0.135   |    0.27 | -                 |                         68 |            1.8  |
| RS                  | - 3.016 + 0.216 0.042       |                           1.14 | - 1.259 + 0.507 0.099   |    0.24 | -                 |                         92 |            1.61 |
| SK272               | - 3.003 + 0.209 0.044       |                           1    | - 0.868 + 0.483 0.102   |    0.23 | -                 |                        100 |            1.61 |
| SKI3                | - 3.000 + 0.190 0.039       |                           0.91 | - 0.818 + 0.421 0.087   |    0.22 | -                 |                        107 |            1.53 |
| SKI5                | - 2.975 + 0.116 0.024       |                           0.78 | - 0.816 + 0.262 0.056   |    0.23 | -                 |                        109 |            1.47 |
| SKMP                | - 3.019 + 0.216 0.035       |                           1.19 | - 1.254 + 0.504 0.083   |    0.23 | -                 |                         88 |            1.68 |
| SLY                 | - 3.042 + 0.238 0.044       |                           1.5  | - 1.517 + 0.590 0.109   |    0.25 | Possibly          |                         76 |            1.82 |
| SLY230A             | - 3.044 + 0.251 - 0.044     |                           1.36 | - 1.261 + 0.581 - 0.101 |    0.23 | -                 |                         83 |            1.76 |

numerical results for the narrow and broad priors. For both, we find a maximum rotation rate below 1.9 kHz for all equations of state. We also provide values for remnants in the hypermassive mass range. For those cases, we limit the baryonic mass above to the maximum allowed for uniform rotation. The numbers we obtain can be regarded as estimates for the hypothetical case that the excess mass was somehow lost during merger, or remains in a disk.

## 5.  Conclusions

In this work, we employ Bayesian model selection as a tool to discriminate between different theoretical models for the neutron star equation of state using only the gravitational-wave data. This allows us to make quantitative statements about the relative likelihood of a given equation of state model. This work complements the analysis of tidal effects of GW170817 in [6, 38] and the analysis of the neutron star radii and equation of state in [39]. As in previous studies [6, 38], we assume a priori that the source of GW170817 resides in NGC 4993 and adopt fixed sky location consistent with electromagnetic observations. The distance to GW170817 is determined from the gravitational-wave data alone, as in [6]. We do not allow

tidal  parameters  to  vary  independently  and  instead  enforce  that  each  neutron  star  obeys  a given equation of state model.

The Bayesian evidence is computed using two independent methods that show good agreement and demonstrate the robustness of our results. Under minimal assumptions on the astrophysical priors for the component masses and spins, we find that the models predicting the largest fiducial radii and tidal deformabilities are very strongly disfavored (MS1\_PP) or at least strongly disfavored (MS1B\_PP) with respect to the equations of state that predict a small fiducial radius and tidal deformability, such as KDE0V. In addition, we find that for both priors considered in this work the gravitational-wave data does not favor and nor can it rule out any particular equation of state against the low-mass binary black hole hypothesis.

In  order  to  gauge  waveform systematics, we compare the Bayes factors using different waveform approximants. The results show good agreement between the different waveform models, providing confidence that systematic uncertainties are small compared to statistical uncertainties.

In a broader context, we also address the question as to whether we can exclude the possibility of GW170817 being a binary black hole by computing Bayes factors against the binary neutron star and neutron star-black hole hypotheses. From the gravitational-wave data alone, no single hypothesis is strongly preferred and we are unable to exclude the binary black hole hypothesis. We find that the Bayes factors computed using different waveform approximants are in good agreement, supporting the notion that waveform systematics are small compared to statistical errors.

For some equation of state models, we can predict the outcome of the merger; for two models the remnant has to be a stable neutron star, for some it will be a long-lived supramassive neutron star, and for some a short-lived hypermassive neutron star or black hole. We can further rule out prompt collapse for a number of models. Considering the Bayes factor for each model, we find that only indefinitely stable remnants are disfavored. Based on gravitationalwave data alone, all scenarios from very long-lived remnants to prompt black hole formation at merger remain possible. Further constraints on the outcome will likely have to rely on the electromagnetic counterparts and modeling of the kilonova and the short gamma-ray burst. We find that making the assumption of a short-lived remnant -as required by some short gammaray burst models -would allow us to put further constraints on the equation of state model. In particular, we improve the upper limit on the maximum mass of non-rotating neutron stars, compared to an earlier study [4] (which is based on an analysis that did not assume that both neutron stars obey the same equation of state). We also find that three equation of state models are ruled out if a black hole was formed before the short gamma-ray burst, including the two disfavored by gravitational-wave data alone.

## Acknowledgments

The  authors  gratefully  acknowledge  the  support  of  the  United  States  National  Science Foundation (NSF) for the construction and operation of the LIGO Laboratory and Advanced LIGO  as  well  as  the  Science  and  Technology  Facilities  Council  (STFC)  of  the  United Kingdom, the Max-Planck-Society (MPS), and the State of Niedersachsen/Germany for support of the construction of Advanced LIGO and construction and operation of the GEO600 detector. Additional support for Advanced LIGO was provided by the Australian Research Council. The authors gratefully acknowledge the Italian Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare (INFN), the French Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS) and the Foundation for Fundamental Research on Matter supported by the Netherlands Organisation for Scientific

Research, for the construction and operation of the Virgo detector and the creation and support of the EGO consortium. The authors also gratefully acknowledge research support from these agencies as well as by the Council of Scientific and Industrial Research of India, the Department of Science and Technology, India, the Science &amp; Engineering Research Board (SERB), India, the Ministry of Human Resource Development, India, the Spanish Agencia Estatal  de  Investigaci ó n,  the Vicepresid è ncia i  Conselleria  d Innovaci ' ó ,  Recerca  i Turisme and the Conselleria d Educaci ' ó i Universitat del Govern de les Illes Balears, the Conselleria d Educaci ' ó , Investigaci ó , Cultura i Esport de la Generalitat Valenciana, the National Science Centre of Poland, the Swiss National Science Foundation (SNSF), the Russian Foundation for Basic Research, the Russian Science Foundation, the European Commission, the European Regional Development Funds (ERDF), the Royal Society, the Scottish Funding Council, the Scottish  Universities  Physics  Alliance,  the  Hungarian  Scientific  Research  Fund  (OTKA), the Lyon Institute of Origins (LIO), the Paris Î le-de-France Region, the National Research, Development and Innovation Office Hungary (NKFIH), the National Research Foundation of Korea, Industry Canada and the Province of Ontario through the Ministry of Economic Development and Innovation, the Natural Science and Engineering Research Council Canada, the Canadian Institute for Advanced Research, the Brazilian Ministry of Science, Technology, Innovations,  and  Communications,  the  International  Center  for  Theoretical  Physics  South American Institute for Fundamental Research (ICTP-SAIFR), the Research Grants Council of Hong Kong, the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC), the Leverhulme Trust, the Research Corporation, the Ministry of Science and Technology (MOST), Taiwan and the Kavli Foundation. The authors gratefully acknowledge the support of the NSF, STFC, MPS, INFN, CNRS and the State of Niedersachsen/Germany for provision of computational resources.

## Appendix A.  Equations of state

In the following, we provide details for the equations of state employed in this work, all of which represent estimates from nuclear physics. They employ different estimates for the forces between constituents, for example from nucleon-nucleon scattering experiments. Those forces are often parametrized (e.g. Skyrme forces) before use in equation of state computations. Other important observable parameters to calibrate equation of state models are the nuclear symmetry energy and incompressibility. Further, the many-particle quantum field theory problem is approximately solved using different schemes, such as liquid-drop model, relativistic/nonrelativistic mean field (MF) theory, Hartree -Fock (HF) method, Brueckner -Bethe -Goldstone (BG) methods, or Wigner -Seitz (WS) cells. Some methods apply the simplification of a single microstate, while others consider nuclear statistic equilibrium. One important aspect is which types of constituents are considered, for example if hyperons are included or not. Most equation of state models considered describe hadronic matter, except the HQC18 equation of state model, which assumes a hadronic crust around a quark matter core [9].

For details on the various models, we refer to the references given in table A1, which list all our equation of state models, the respective sources for the numeric tables, and the original publications. Further, we provide the maximum gravitational and baryonic masses of non-rotating neutron stars, and the maximum baryonic mass of uniformly rotating neutron stars. The latter were obtained using the Rapidly Rotating Neutron Star (RNS) code described in [126].

Most of our equations of state were obtained from three catalogs. The CompOSE project [127] provides nuclear physics equation of state data and a supporting software framework.

Table A1. Equations of state used in this work. We provide the original publications introducing the equations of state and the source of the numerical tables or piecewise polytropic  fit  parameters.  For  each  we  computed  the  maximum  gravitational  mass ˆ M TOV G of non-rotating neutron stars and the corresponding baryonic mass ˆ M TOV B , as well as the maximum baryonic mass ˆ M ROT B of uniformly rotating neutron star. The WFF1 equation of state model becomes acausal below the central density of the maximum mass  model,  and  the  reported  values  (in  brackets)  are  the  maxima  of  neutron  star models respecting causality.

| EoS      | References      | Table   | Methods          | ˆ M TOV G ( M /circledot )   | ˆ M TOV B ( M /circledot )   | ˆ M ROT B ( M /circledot )   |
|----------|-----------------|---------|------------------|------------------------------|------------------------------|------------------------------|
| BHF_BBB2 | [131]           | [127]   | Brueckner-BG     | 1.92                         | 2.27                         | 2.64                         |
| WFF1     | [98]            | [128]   | Variational      | (1.92)                       | (2.31)                       | (2.84)                       |
| KDE0V    | [132 - 134]     | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 1.96                         | 2.31                         | 2.69                         |
| KDE0V1   | [132 - 134]     | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 1.97                         | 2.32                         | 2.69                         |
| SKOP     | [132, 133, 135] | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 1.97                         | 2.30                         | 2.69                         |
| H4       | [136]           | [128]   | Relativistic MF  | 2.03                         | 2.34                         | 2.80                         |
| HQC18    | [9]             |         | Hadron-Quark     | 2.05                         | 2.43                         | 2.88                         |
| SLY      | [137]           | [128]   | Potential-method | 2.05                         | 2.43                         | 2.83                         |
| SLY2     | [132, 133]      | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 2.05                         | 2.43                         | 2.84                         |
| SLY230A  | [132, 133, 138] | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 2.10                         | 2.50                         | 2.93                         |
| SKMP     | [132, 133, 139] | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 2.11                         | 2.48                         | 2.91                         |
| RS       | [132, 133, 140] | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 2.12                         | 2.48                         | 2.91                         |
| SK255    | [132, 133, 141] | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 2.14                         | 2.51                         | 2.92                         |
| SLY9     | [132, 133]      | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 2.16                         | 2.55                         | 2.99                         |
| APR4_EPP | [129]           | [130]   | Variational      | 2.16                         | 2.61                         | 3.07                         |
| SKI2     | [132, 133, 142] | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 2.16                         | 2.53                         | 2.96                         |
| SKI4     | [132, 133, 142] | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 2.17                         | 2.58                         | 3.04                         |
| SKI6     | [132, 133, 143] | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 2.19                         | 2.60                         | 3.06                         |
| SK272    | [132, 133, 141] | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 2.23                         | 2.63                         | 3.06                         |
| SKI3     | [132, 133, 142] | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 2.24                         | 2.63                         | 3.08                         |
| SKI5     | [132, 133, 142] | [127]   | Skyrme,WS,HF     | 2.24                         | 2.62                         | 3.06                         |
| MPA1     | [144]           | [128]   | Relativistic HF  | 2.46                         | 3.01                         | 3.57                         |
| MS1B_PP  | [145]           | [47]    | Relativistic MF  | 2.75                         | 3.31                         | 3.93                         |
| MS1_PP   | [145]           | [47]    | Relativistic MF  | 2.75                         | 3.30                         | 3.90                         |

We used this public code (selecting the first-order interpolation option and a resolution of 500 points) to create tables. Another collection of tables is provided by [128]. To obtain the final, continuous equations of state, we employ two different interpolation schemes. The results in section 4 and table A1 are computed using monotonic spline interpolation (PCHIP), while the equation of state related code used during parameter estimation employs standard cubic spline interpolation instead. For all models, we compared sequences of non-rotating neutron stars between the two. Since the low resolution and gaps present in the MS1 and MS1B tables cause significant ambiguities in the tidal deformability and radius, we use well defined piecewise polytropic approximations instead, taken from a third catalog [47] providing analytic fits, and denoted here by MS1\_PP and MS1B\_PP, respectively. When comparing with [6], note that their WFF1, H4, MPA1, SLY and APR4 models also refer to the piecewise polytropic variants from [47], in contrast to this work.

We applied the following adjustments: in general, we removed isolated data points from the original tables that violate thermodynamic constraints for zero temperature equations of state. For the H4 equation of state model from [128], the low-density part ( &lt; 10 13 g cm -3 ) was

36

Table B1. Bayes factors computed using LALInference s nested sampling algorithm for all of the equations of state discussed in section 2.4 ' using the narrow prior discussed in section 2.2. The Bayes factors are computed for a number of waveform models, as discussed in section 2.3. Here the Bayes factors are taken to be the ratio between the evidence for a given equation of state and the corresponding evidence for the hypothesis that both bodies are low-mass black holes. The errors correspond to statistical uncertainty in the calculation of the evidence from the nested sampling algorithm in LALInference, where σ BF = σ Z EOS / Z BBH .

## LALInference nest results

| Equation of state     | TaylorF2 (7.5pN)                                              | Phenom + NRT                                  | EOB + NRT                                                 | TaylorF2 (6pN)                                            | TaylorF2 (7pN)                           |
|-----------------------|---------------------------------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------|------------------------------------------|
| APR4_EPP BBH BHF_BBB2 | ( 1.92 ± 0.07 ) × 10 1 ( 1.00 ± 0.05 ) ( 1.60 ± 0.06 ) × 10 1 | ( 4.39 ± 0.23 ) × 10 1 ( 1.00 ± 0.04 ) 1      | ( 2.02 ± 0.08 ) × 10 1 ( 1.00 ± 0.05 ) ( 2.43 0.07 ) 10 1 | ( 1.76 ± 0.06 ) × 10 1 ( 1.00 ± 0.05 ) ( 1.70 0.07 ) 10 1 | ( 1.78 ± 0.10 ) × 10 1 ( 1.00 ± 0.05 )   |
|                       | ( 1.73 0.08 )                                                 | ( 4.79 ± 0.19 ) × 10                          | ( 1.95 ± 0.12 ) × 10 1 ( 1.90 0.08 ) 10 1                 | ± × ( 1.73 ± 0.08 ) ( 1.73 ± 0.07 ) × 10 1 1              | ( 1.71 ± 0.09 ) × 10 1 ( 1.76 ± 0.09 ) 1 |
| HQC18                 | ± ( 1.94 ± 0.07 ) × 10 1 1                                    | ( 3.84 ± 0.20 ) × 10 1 1                      |                                                           |                                                           |                                          |
| H4                    | ( 1.96 ± 0.11 ) × 10                                          | ( 1.05 ± 0.06 ) ( 3.95 0.17 ) 10              | ± × ( 3.80 ± 0.16 ) × 10 - 1                              | ( 1.80 ± 0.10 ) × 10 1                                    |                                          |
|                       |                                                               |                                               |                                                           |                                                           | ( 1.81 ± 0.09 ) × 10                     |
| KDE0V                 |                                                               | ± ×                                           | ± ×                                                       |                                                           | ( 1.63 ± 0.06 ) × 10 1                   |
| KDE0V1                | ( 1.78 ± 0.09 ) × 10 1                                        | ( 3.28 ± 0.08 ) × 10 1                        | ( 1.54 ± 0.07 ) × 10 1                                    | ( 1.86 ± 0.10 ) × 10                                      | ( 1.53 ± 0.08 ) × 10 1                   |
| MPA1                  | ( 5.56 ± 0.23 )                                               | ( 1.35 ± 0.05 ) × 10 1                        | ( 7.32 ± 0.33 )                                           | ( 4.66 ± 0.20 )                                           | ( 4.36 ± 0.19 )                          |
| MS1B_PP               | ( 3.48 ± 0.13 ) × 10 - 1                                      | ( 1.61 ± 0.07 ) × 10 - 1                      | ( 7.03 ± 0.37 ) × 10 - 2                                  | ( 1.86 ± 0.07 ) × 10 - 1                                  | ( 1.92 ± 0.09 ) × 10 - 1                 |
| MS1_PP                | ( 8.96 ± 0.38 ) × 10 - 2                                      | ( 8.45 ± 0.46 ) × 10 - 2                      | ( 3.36 ± 0.14 ) × 10 - 2                                  | ( 3.44 ± 0.16 ) × 10 - 2                                  | ( 3.44 ± 0.14 ) × 10 - 2                 |
| RS                    | ( 3.66 ± 0.15 )                                               | ( 9.85 ± 0.46 )                               | ( 3.73 ± 0.17 )                                           | ( 3.78 ± 0.15 )                                           | ( 4.05 ± 0.15 )                          |
| SK255                 | ( 3.75 ± 0.19 )                                               | ( 9.56 ± 0.35 )                               | ( 3.79 ± 0.17 )                                           | ( 3.77 ± 0.16 )                                           | ( 3.75 ± 0.15 )                          |
| SK272                 | ( 3.22 ± 0.11 )                                               | ( 5.54 ± 0.22 )                               | ( 2.74 ± 0.11 )                                           | ( 3.65 ± 0.17 )                                           | ( 3.55 ± 0.20 )                          |
| SKI2                  | ( 2.07 ± 0.10 )                                               | ( 4.06 ± 0.18 )                               | ( 1.63 ± 0.05 )                                           | ( 2.13 ± 0.10 )                                           | ( 2.69 ± 0.14 )                          |
| SKI3                  | ( 2.03 ± 0.08 )                                               | ( 3.50 ± 0.13 )                               | ( 1.46 ± 0.08 )                                           | ( 2.23 ± 0.07 )                                           | ( 2.54 ± 0.06 )                          |
| SKI4 SKI5             | ( 7.35 ± 0.32 )                                               | ( 1.35 ± 0.06 ) × 10 1                        | ( 7.66 ± 0.22 )                                           | ( 4.99 ± 0.22 )                                           | ( 4.32 ± 0.19 ) - 1                      |
|                       | ( 1.15 ± 0.05 )                                               | ( 3.40 ± 0.16 ) × 10 - 1                      | ( 1.38 ± 0.05 ) × 10 - 1                                  | ( 6.39 ± 0.26 ) × 10 - 1                                  | ( 7.08 ± 0.29 ) × 10                     |
| SKI6                  | ( 6.38 ± 0.28 )                                               | ( 1.42 ± 0.07 ) × 10 1                        | ( 6.67 ± 0.22 )                                           | ( 4.34 ± 0.20 )                                           | ( 4.24 ± 0.20 )                          |
| SKMP SKOP             | ( 6.80 ± 0.26 ) ( 1.50 ± 0.07 ) × 10 1                        | ( 1.46 ± 0.07 ) × 10 1 ( 1.02 ± 0.06 ) × 10 1 | ( 7.32 ± 0.37 ) ( 4.72 ± 0.14 )                           | ( 4.43 ± 0.16 ) ( 9.46 ± 0.42 )                           | ( 4.15 ± 0.17 ) ( 8.79 ± 0.39 )          |

( Continued )

37

Table B1. ( Continued )

| Equation of state   | TaylorF2 (7.5pN)       | Phenom + NRT           | EOB + NRT              | TaylorF2 (6pN)         | TaylorF2 (7pN)         |
|---------------------|------------------------|------------------------|------------------------|------------------------|------------------------|
| SLY                 | ( 1.85 ± 0.09 ) × 10 1 | ( 1.82 ± 0.09 ) × 10 1 | ( 6.69 ± 0.29 )        | ( 1.55 ± 0.06 ) × 10 1 | ( 1.39 ± 0.06 ) × 10 1 |
| SLY2                | ( 1.68 ± 0.05 ) × 10 1 | ( 2.00 ± 0.07 ) × 10 1 | ( 7.90 ± 0.31 )        | ( 1.53 ± 0.07 ) × 10 1 | ( 1.40 ± 0.09 ) × 10 1 |
| SLY230A             | ( 1.80 ± 0.07 ) × 10 1 | ( 1.47 ± 0.05 ) × 10 1 | ( 6.26 ± 0.28 )        | ( 1.42 ± 0.06 ) × 10 1 | ( 1.18 ± 0.04 ) × 10 1 |
| SLY9                | ( 8.93 ± 0.43 )        | ( 1.42 ± 0.06 ) × 10 1 | ( 8.11 ± 0.28 )        | ( 5.46 ± 0.23 )        | ( 4.76 ± 0.20 )        |
| WFF1                | ( 1.06 ± 0.05 ) × 10 1 | ( 3.49 ± 0.16 ) × 10 1 | ( 2.45 ± 0.11 ) × 10 1 | ( 1.27 ± 0.05 ) × 10 1 | ( 1.34 ± 0.06 ) × 10 1 |

Table  B2. Similarly  to  table  B1,  we  show  the  Bayes  factors  computed  using LALInference s nested sampling algorithm for all of the equations of state discussed ' in section 2.4 using the broad prior discussed in section 2.2.

|                   | LALInference nest results   | LALInference nest results   | LALInference nest results   |
|-------------------|-----------------------------|-----------------------------|-----------------------------|
| Equation of state | TaylorF2 (7.5pN)            | Phenom + NRT                | EOB + NRT                   |
| APR4_EPP          | ( 3.21 ± 0.13 )             | ( 2.56 ± 0.08 )             | ( 1.40 ± 0.06 )             |
| BBH               | ( 1.00 ± 0.05 )             | ( 1.00 ± 0.07 )             | ( 1.00 ± 0.06 )             |
| BHF_BBB2          | ( 3.42 ± 0.18 )             | ( 3.23 ± 0.17 )             | ( 1.86 ± 0.14 )             |
| H4                | ( 1.88 ± 0.10 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 5.21 ± 0.42 ) × 10 - 2    | ( 2.86 ± 0.10 ) × 10 - 2    |
| HQC18             | ( 2.97 ± 0.16 )             | ( 2.06 ± 0.10 )             | ( 1.27 ± 0.06 )             |
| KDE0V             | ( 3.12 ± 0.13 )             | ( 1.98 ± 0.12 )             | ( 1.51 ± 0.10 )             |
| KDE0V1            | ( 2.88 ± 0.13 )             | ( 1.71 ± 0.09 )             | ( 9.97 ± 0.41 ) × 10 - 1    |
| MPA1              | ( 6.15 ± 0.34 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 8.30 ± 0.36 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 5.54 ± 0.41 ) × 10 - 1    |
| MS1B_PP           | ( 3.65 ± 0.19 ) × 10 - 2    | ( 9.71 ± 0.38 ) × 10 - 3    | ( 6.94 ± 0.36 ) × 10 - 3    |
| MS1_PP            | ( 9.68 ± 0.45 ) × 10 - 3    | ( 4.56 ± 0.23 ) × 10 - 3    | ( 2.80 ± 0.15 ) × 10 - 3    |
| RS                | ( 3.89 ± 0.18 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 3.43 ± 0.20 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 2.51 ± 0.14 ) × 10 - 1    |
| SK255             | ( 4.00 ± 0.27 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 3.57 ± 0.22 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 2.49 ± 0.19 ) × 10 - 1    |
| SK272             | ( 3.44 ± 0.15 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 2.63 ± 0.22 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 1.99 ± 0.12 ) × 10 - 1    |
| SKI2              | ( 2.05 ± 0.09 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 1.51 ± 0.13 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 8.66 ± 0.50 ) × 10 - 2    |
| SKI3              | ( 2.09 ± 0.09 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 1.45 ± 0.12 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 8.26 ± 0.53 ) × 10 - 2    |
| SKI4              | ( 8.19 ± 0.42 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 8.30 ± 0.57 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 6.17 ± 0.30 ) × 10 - 1    |
| SKI5              | ( 9.59 ± 0.41 ) × 10 - 2    | ( 1.48 ± 0.07 ) × 10 - 2    | ( 1.35 ± 0.08 ) × 10 - 2    |
| SKI6              | ( 6.02 ± 0.33 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 7.97 ± 0.58 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 5.66 ± 0.44 ) × 10 - 1    |
| SKMP              | ( 6.59 ± 0.33 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 8.27 ± 0.69 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 6.04 ± 0.45 ) × 10 - 1    |
| SKOP              | ( 1.47 ± 0.07 )             | ( 8.09 ± 0.36 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 6.70 ± 0.51 ) × 10 - 1    |
| SLY               | ( 2.32 ± 0.12 )             | ( 9.53 ± 0.59 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 6.93 ± 0.42 ) × 10 - 1    |
| SLY2              | ( 2.20 ± 0.11 )             | ( 1.09 ± 0.08 )             | ( 6.55 ± 0.49 ) × 10 - 1    |
| SLY230A           | ( 2.19 ± 0.13 )             | ( 8.02 ± 0.50 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 6.40 ± 0.38 ) × 10 - 1    |
| SLY9              | ( 7.64 ± 0.34 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 9.46 ± 0.49 ) × 10 - 1    | ( 6.85 ± 0.33 ) × 10 - 1    |
| WFF1              | ( 3.75 ± 0.21 )             | ( 4.32 ± 0.25 )             | ( 3.01 ± 0.19 )             |

missing and filled in using the corresponding values of the H3 equation of state model from the same source. For the equations of state from [129], the sound speed becomes superluminal shortly before the maximum mass model is reached, both for the tabulated versions [128] (AP4) or [127] (APR), and the piecewise polytropic fit from [47] (APR4). We therefore use the modified APR4 (denoted APR4\_EPP here) from [130], which adds additional segments at high density to ensure causality.

Table B3. Bayes factors computed using the RIFT algorithm for all of the equations of state discussed in section 2.4 using the narrow prior discussed in section 2.2. Bayes factors are computed for the costly waveform models discussed in section 2.3. Here the Bayes factors are shown as a ratio between the evidence for the given equation of state model and the corresponding evidence for the hypothesis that both bodies are neutron stars, described by the SLY9 equation of state.

|                   | RIFT results             | RIFT results             |
|-------------------|--------------------------|--------------------------|
| Equation of state | SEOBNRv4T (narrow)       | TEOBResumS (narrow)      |
| APR4_EPP          | ( 2.37 ± 0.06 )          | ( 1.46 ± 0.04 )          |
| BBH               | ( 1.35 ± 0.03 )          | ( 2.76 ± 0.06 ) × 10 - 1 |
| BHF_BBB2          | ( 2.53 ± 0.06 )          | ( 1.38 ± 0.05 )          |
| H4                | ( 1.06 ± 0.02 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 8.26 ± 0.18 ) × 10 - 2 |
| HQC18             | ( 2.38 ± 0.06 )          | ( 1.46 ± 0.04 )          |
| KDE0V             | ( 2.36 ± 0.05 )          | ( 1.49 ± 0.05 )          |
| KDE0V1            | ( 2.30 ± 0.06 )          | ( 1.47 ± 0.04 )          |
| MPA1              | ( 7.43 ± 0.14 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 7.64 ± 0.19 ) × 10 - 1 |
| MS1B_PP           | ( 2.59 ± 0.06 ) × 10 - 2 | ( 1.22 ± 0.02 ) × 10 - 2 |
| MS1_PP            | ( 6.98 ± 0.19 ) × 10 - 3 | ( 2.99 ± 0.07 ) × 10 - 3 |
| RS                | ( 4.43 ± 0.08 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 4.61 ± 0.11 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SK255             | ( 4.61 ± 0.09 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 4.90 ± 0.12 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SK272             | ( 3.42 ± 0.07 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 3.41 ± 0.08 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKI2              | ( 1.67 ± 0.03 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 1.55 ± 0.03 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKI3              | ( 1.64 ± 0.03 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 1.43 ± 0.03 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKI4              | ( 9.07 ± 0.22 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 9.27 ± 0.21 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKI5              | ( 5.95 ± 0.13 ) × 10 - 2 | ( 3.69 ± 0.07 ) × 10 - 2 |
| SKI6              | ( 8.05 ± 0.16 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 8.32 ± 0.21 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKMP              | ( 8.50 ± 0.17 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 8.73 ± 0.23 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKOP              | ( 1.51 ± 0.03 )          | ( 1.29 ± 0.03 )          |
| SLY               | ( 1.92 ± 0.04 )          | ( 1.42 ± 0.04 )          |
| SLY2              | ( 1.96 ± 0.04 )          | ( 1.46 ± 0.04 )          |
| SLY230A           | ( 1.80 ± 0.04 )          | ( 1.42 ± 0.04 )          |
| SLY9              | ( 1.00 ± 0.02 )          | ( 1.00 ± 0.02 )          |
| WFF1              | ( 2.67 ± 0.06 )          | ( 1.16 ± 0.03 )          |

## Appendix B.  Bayes factors

Here we present the explicit values for the Bayes factors computed using the nested sampling algorithm implemented in LALInference and RIFT. We show results for all of the equations of state discussed in section 2.4 for both the wide and narrow priors outlined in section 2.2.

Table B4. Bayes factors computed using the RIFT algorithm for all of the equations of state  discussed  in  section  2.4  using  the  broad  prior  discussed  in  section  2.2.  Bayes factors are computed for the costly waveform models discussed in section 2.3. Here the Bayes factors are shown as a ratio between the evidence for the given equation of state model and the corresponding evidence for the hypothesis that both bodies are neutron stars, described by the SLY9 equation of state.

|                   | RIFT results             | RIFT results             |
|-------------------|--------------------------|--------------------------|
| Equation of state | SEOBNRv4T (broad)        | TEOBResumS (broad)       |
| APR4_EPP          | ( 2.67 ± 0.08 )          | ( 1.64 ± 0.05 )          |
| BBH               | ( 1.22 ± 0.04 )          | ( 2.06 ± 0.09 ) × 10 - 1 |
| BHF_BBB2          | ( 2.89 ± 0.08 )          | ( 1.65 ± 0.06 )          |
| H4                | ( 2.33 ± 0.08 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 1.79 ± 0.06 ) × 10 - 1 |
| HQC18             | ( 2.51 ± 0.08 )          | ( 1.69 ± 0.05 )          |
| KDE0V             | ( 2.50 ± 0.09 )          | ( 1.70 ± 0.05 )          |
| KDE0V1            | ( 2.39 ± 0.07 )          | ( 1.69 ± 0.06 )          |
| MPA1              | ( 7.85 ± 0.25 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 8.06 ± 0.19 ) × 10 - 1 |
| MS1B_PP           | ( 4.82 ± 0.18 ) × 10 - 2 | ( 3.88 ± 0.20 ) × 10 - 2 |
| MS1_PP            | ( 5.42 ± 0.23 ) × 10 - 3 | ( 3.47 ± 0.18 ) × 10 - 3 |
| RS                | ( 4.91 ± 0.15 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 4.54 ± 0.11 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SK255             | ( 4.99 ± 0.14 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 4.66 ± 0.12 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SK272             | ( 4.18 ± 0.14 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 3.63 ± 0.10 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKI2              | ( 2.91 ± 0.09 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 2.18 ± 0.06 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKI3              | ( 2.78 ± 0.09 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 2.18 ± 0.07 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKI4              | ( 9.19 ± 0.26 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 9.53 ± 0.28 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKI5              | ( 1.48 ± 0.05 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 1.17 ± 0.05 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKI6              | ( 8.22 ± 0.24 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 8.38 ± 0.21 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKMP              | ( 8.21 ± 0.28 ) × 10 - 1 | ( 8.36 ± 0.23 ) × 10 - 1 |
| SKOP              | ( 1.50 ± 0.05 )          | ( 1.38 ± 0.04 )          |
| SLY               | ( 2.01 ± 0.06 )          | ( 1.62 ± 0.05 )          |
| SLY2              | ( 1.97 ± 0.07 )          | ( 1.61 ± 0.05 )          |
| SLY230A           | ( 1.87 ± 0.06 )          | ( 1.56 ± 0.05 )          |
| SLY9              | ( 1.00 ± 0.03 )          | ( 1.00 ± 0.03 )          |
| WFF1              | ( 2.89 ± 0.08 )          | ( 1.20 ± 0.04 )          |

## References

- [1] Aasi J et al (LIGO Scientific) 2015 Class. Quantum Grav. 32 074001
- [2] Acernese F et al (Virgo) 2015 Class. Quantum Grav. 32 024001
- [3] Abbott B P et al (Virgo, LIGO Scientific) 2017 Phys. Rev. Lett. 119 161101
- [4] Abbott B P et al (Virgo, Fermi-GBM, INTEGRAL, LIGO Scientific) 2017 Astrophys. J. 848 L13
- [5] Abbott  B  P et  al (GROND,  SALT  Group,  OzGrav,  DFN,  INTEGRAL,  Virgo,  Insight-Hxmt, MAXI Team, Fermi-LAT, J-GEM, RATIR, IceCube, CAASTRO, LWA, ePESSTO, GRAWITA, RIMAS, SKA South Africa/MeerKAT, H.E.S.S., 1M2H Team, IKI-GW Follow-up, Fermi GBM, Pi  of  Sky,  DWF  (Deeper Wider  Faster  Program),  Dark  Energy  Survey,  MASTER, AstroSat Cadmium Zinc Telluride Imager Team, Swift, Pierre Auger, ASKAP, VINROUGE, JAGWAR, Chandra Team at McGill University, TTU-NRAO, GROWTH, AGILE Team, MWA, ATCA, AST3, TOROS, Pan-STARRS, NuSTAR, ATLAS Telescopes, BOOTES, CaltechNRAO, LIGO Scientific,  High  Time  Resolution  Universe  Survey,  Nordic  Optical  Telescope,  Las  Cumbres Observatory Group, TZAC Consortium, LOFAR, IPN, DLT40, Texas Tech University, HAWC,

ANTARES,  KU,  Dark  Energy  Camera  GWEM,  CALET,  Euro VLBI  Team, ALMA)  2017 Astrophys. J. 848 L12

- [6] Abbott B P et al (LIGO Scientific, Virgo) 2019 Phys. Rev. X 9 011001
- [7] Abbott B P et al (LIGO Scientific, Virgo) 2019 Phys. Rev. X 9 031040
- [8] Ö zel F and Freire P 2016 Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 54 401 -40
- [9] Baym G, Hatsuda T, Kojo T, Powell P D, Song Y and Takatsuka T 2018 Rep. Prog. Phys. 81 056902
- [10] Flanagan E E and Hinderer T 2008 Phys. Rev. D 77 021502
- [11] Poisson E 1998 Phys. Rev. D 57 5287 -90
- [12] Hinderer T, Lackey B D, Lang R N and Read J S 2010 Phys. Rev. D 81 123016
- [13] Vines J, Flanagan E E and Hinderer T 2011 Phys. Rev. D 83 084051
- [14] Damour T, Nagar A and Villain L 2012 Phys. Rev. D 85 123007
- [15] Baumgarte T W, Shapiro S L and Shibata M 2000 Astrophys. J. 528 L29
- [16] Shibata M and Taniguchi K 2006 Phys. Rev. D 73 064027
- [17] Baiotti L, Giacomazzo B and Rezzolla L 2008 Phys. Rev. D 78 084033
- [18] Hotokezaka K, Kyutoku K, Okawa H, Shibata M and Kiuchi K 2011 Phys. Rev. D 83 124008
- [19] Baiotti L and Rezzolla L 2017 Rep. Prog. Phys. 80 096901
- [20] Abbott  B  P,  Abbott  R,  Abbott  T  D,  Acernese  F,  Ackley  K,  Adams  C,  Adams  T,  Addesso  P, Adhikari R X and Adya V B 2019 Astrophys. J. 875 160
- [21] Radice D, Perego A, Bernuzzi S and Zhang B 2018 Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 481 3670 -82
- [22] Abbott B P et al (Virgo, LIGO Scientific) 2017 Astrophys. J. 851 L16
- [23] Oliver  M,  Keitel  D,  Miller  A  L,  Estelles  H  and  Sintes  A  M  2019 Mon.  Not.  R.  Astron.  Soc. 485 843 -50
- [24] Baillot  d Etivaux  N,  Guillot  S,  Margueron  J,  Webb  N,  Catelan  M  and  Reisenegger  A  2019 ' Astrophys. J. (arXiv:1905.01081) accepted
- [25] Steiner A W, Heinke C O, Bogdanov S, Li C, Ho W C G, Bahramian A and Han S 2018 Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 476 421 -35
- [26] Antoniadis J et al 2013 Science 340 6131
- [27] Margalit B and Metzger B D 2017 Astrophys. J. 850 L19
- [28] Bauswein A, Just O, Janka H T and Stergioulas N 2017 Astrophys. J. 850 L34
- [29] Ruiz M, Shapiro S L and Tsokaros A 2018 Phys. Rev. D 97 021501
- [30] Annala E, Gorda T, Kurkela A and Vuorinen A 2018 Phys. Rev. Lett. 120 172703
- [31] Zhou E P, Zhou X and Li A 2018 Phys. Rev. D 97 083015
- [32] Fattoyev F J, Piekarewicz J and Horowitz C J 2018 Phys. Rev. Lett. 120 172702
- [33] Paschalidis  V, Yagi  K, Alvarez-Castillo  D,  Blaschke  D  B  and  Sedrakian  A  2018 Phys.  Rev. D 97 084038
- [34] Nandi R and Char P 2018 Astrophys. J. 857 12
- [35] Most E R, Weih L R, Rezzolla L and Schaffner-Bielich J 2018 Phys. Rev. Lett. 120 261103
- [36] Rezzolla L, Most E R and Weih L R 2018 Astrophys. J. 852 L25
- [37] Raithel C, Ö zel F and Psaltis D 2018 Astrophys. J. 857 L23
- [38] De S,  Finstad  D,  Lattimer  J  M,  Brown  D  A,  Berger  E  and  Biwer  C  M  2018 Phys.  Rev.  Lett. 121 091102
- [39] Abbott B P et al (Virgo, LIGO Scientific) 2018 Phys. Rev. Lett. 121 161101
- [40] Landry P and Essick R 2019 Phys. Rev. D 99 084049
- [41] Capano C D, Tews I, Brown S M, Margalit B, De S, Kumar S, Brown D A, Krishnan B and Reddy S 2019 (arXiv:1908.10352)
- [42] Veitch J et al 2015 Phys. Rev. D 91 042003
- [43] Wysocki D, Lange J and O Shaughnessy R 2019 ' Phys. Rev. D 100 043012
- [44] Del Pozzo W, Li T G F, Agathos M, Van Den Broeck C and Vitale S 2013 Phys. Rev. Lett. 111 071101
- [45] Agathos M, Meidam J, Del Pozzo W, Li T G F, Tompitak M, Veitch J, Vitale S and Van Den Broeck C 2015 Phys. Rev. D 92 023012
- [46] Chatziioannou K, Yagi K, Klein A, Cornish N and Yunes N 2015 Phys. Rev. D 92 104008
- [47] Read J S, Lackey B D, Owen B J and Friedman J L 2009 Phys. Rev. D 79 124032
- [48] Yagi K and Yunes N 2017 Phys. Rep. 681 1 -72
- [49] Chatziioannou K, Haster C J and Zimmerman A 2018 Phys. Rev. D 97 104036
- [50] Lindblom L 2018 Phys. Rev. D 97 123019
- [51] Carney M F, Wade L E and Irwin B S 2018 Phys. Rev. D 98 063004
- [52] Shibata M, Duez M D, Liu Y T, Shapiro S L and Stephens B C 2006 Phys. Rev. Lett. 96 031102
- [53] Metzger B D, Quataert E and Thompson T A 2008 Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 385 1455

- [54] Shibata M, Fujibayashi S, Hotokezaka K, Kiuchi K, Kyutoku K, Sekiguchi Y and Tanaka M 2017 Phys. Rev. D 96 123012
- [55] Veitch J and Vecchio A 2010 Phys. Rev. D 81 062003
- [56] Creighton J D E and  Anderson W G 2011 Gravitational-Wave Physics and Astronomy: an Introduction to Theory, Experiment and Data Analysis (Weinheim: Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH &amp; Co)
- [57] Abbott B P et al (LIGO Scientific, Virgo) 2016 Phys. Rev. Lett. 116 241102
- [58] Lattimer J M 2012 Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 62 485 -515
- [59] Hebeler K, Lattimer J M, Pethick C J and Schwenk A 2013 Astrophys. J. 773 11
- [60] Lorimer D R 2008 Living Rev. Relativ. 11 8
- [61] Kramer M and Wex N 2009 Class. Quantum Grav. 26 073001
- [62] Kiziltan B, Kottas A, De Yoreo M and Thorsett S E 2013 Astrophys. J. 778 66
- [63] Lynch R S, Freire P C C, Ransom S M and Jacoby B A 2012 Astrophys. J. 745 109
- [64] Ö zel F, Psaltis D, Narayan R and Villarreal A S 2012 Astrophys. J. 757 55
- [65] Martinez J G, Stovall  K,  Freire  P  C  C,  Deneva  J  S,  Jenet  F  A,  McLaughlin  M  A,  Bagchi  M, Bates S D and Ridolfi A 2015 Astrophys. J. 812 143
- [66] Zhu X, Thrane E, Oslowski S, Levin Y and Lasky P D 2018 Phys. Rev. D 98 043002
- [67] Tauris T M et al 2017 Astrophys. J. 846 170
- [68] Burgay M et al 2003 Nature 426 531 -3
- [69] Hessels J W T, Ransom S M, Stairs I H, Freire P C C, Kaspi V M and Camilo F 2006 Science 311 1901 -4
- [70] Bauswein A and Stergioulas N 2015 Phys. Rev. D 91 124056
- [71] Bernuzzi S, Dietrich T and Nagar A 2015 Phys. Rev. Lett. 115 091101
- [72] Rezzolla L and Takami K 2016 Phys. Rev. D 93 124051
- [73] Cornish N J and Littenberg T B 2015 Class. Quantum Grav. 32 135012
- [74] Klimenko S et al 2016 Phys. Rev. D 93 042004
- [75] Chatziioannou K, Clark J A, Bauswein A, Millhouse M, Littenberg T B and Cornish N 2017 Phys. Rev. D 96 124035
- [76] Torres-Rivas A, Chatziioannou K, Bauswein A and Clark J A 2019 Phys. Rev. D 99 044014
- [77] Tolman R C 1939 Phys. Rev. 55 364 -73
- [78] Oppenheimer J R and Volkoff G M 1939 Phys. Rev. 55 374 -81
- [79] Damour T and Nagar A 2009 Phys. Rev. D 80 084035
- [80] Blanchet L 2014 Living Rev. Relativ. 17 2
- [81] Bini D, Damour T and Faye G 2012 Phys. Rev. D 85 124034
- [82] Dietrich T, Bernuzzi S and Tichy W 2017 Phys. Rev. D 96 121501
- [83] Dietrich T et al 2019 Phys. Rev. D 99 024029
- [84] Boh  A é et al 2017 Phys. Rev. D 95 044028
- [85] Hannam M, Schmidt P, Boh  A, Haegel L, Husa S, Ohme F, Pratten G and P é ü rrer M 2014 Phys. Rev. Lett. 113 151101
- [86] Schmidt P, Ohme F and Hannam M 2015 Phys. Rev. D 91 024043
- [87] Husa S, Khan S, Hannam M, P ü rrer M, Ohme F, Jim é nez Forteza X and Boh é A 2016 Phys. Rev. D 93 044006
- [88] Khan S, Husa S, Hannam M, Ohme F, P ü rrer M, Jim é nez Forteza X and Boh é A 2016 Phys. Rev. D 93 044007
- [89] Bohe A, Faye G, Marsat S and Porter E K 2015 Class. Quantum Grav. 32 195010
- [90] Hinderer T et al 2016 Phys. Rev. Lett. 116 181101
- [91] Steinhoff J, Hinderer T, Buonanno A and Taracchini A 2016 Phys. Rev. D 94 104028
- [92] Nagar A et al 2018 Phys. Rev. D 98 104052
- [93] Dietrich T and Hinderer T 2017 Phys. Rev. D 95 124006
- [94] Nagar A, Messina F, Rettegno P, Bini D, Damour T, Geralico A, Akcay S and Bernuzzi S 2019 Phys. Rev. D 99 044007
- [95] Akcay S, Bernuzzi S, Messina F, Nagar A, Ortiz N and Rettegno P 2019 Phys. Rev. D 99 044051
- [96] Wade L, Creighton J D E, Ochsner E, Lackey B D, Farr B F, Littenberg T B and Raymond V 2014 Phys. Rev. D 89 103012
- [97] Dudi R, Pannarale F, Dietrich T, Hannam M, Bernuzzi S, Ohme F and Br ü gmann B 2018 Phys. Rev. D 98 084061
- [98] Wiringa R B, Fiks V and Fabrocini A 1988 Phys. Rev. C 38 1010 -37
- [99] Cromartie H T et al 2019 Nature Astron. (https://doi.org/10.1038/s41550-019-0880-2)
- [100] Bludman S A and Ruderman M A 1970 Phys. Rev. D 1 3243 -6
- [101] Lattimer J M, Prakash M, Masak D and Yahil A 1990 Astrophys. J. 355 241 -54

- [102] Cahillane C et al 2017 Phys. Rev. D 96 102001
- [103] Viets A et al 2018 Class. Quantum Grav. 35 095015
- [104] Driggers J C et al 2019 Phys. Rev. D 99 042001
- [105] Pankow C et al 2018 Phys. Rev. D 98 084016
- [106] Acernese F et al 2018 Class. Quantum Grav. 35 205004
- [107] Skilling J 2006 Bayesian Anal. 1 833 -59
- [108] Lartillot N and Philippe H 2006 Syst. Biol. 55 195 -207
- [109] Abbott B P et al (LIGO Scientific, Virgo) 2019 Phys. Rev. Lett. 122 061104
- [110] Samajdar A and Dietrich T 2018 Phys. Rev. D 98 124030
- [111] Kass R E and Raftery A E 1995 J. Am. Statist. Assoc. 90 773 -95
- [112] Ruiz M and Shapiro S L 2017 Phys. Rev. D 96 084063
- [113] Dai Z G and Lu T 1998 Phys. Rev. Lett. 81 4301 -4
- [114] Zhang B and Meszaros P 2001 Astrophys. J. 552 L35 -8
- [115] Kasen D, Metzger B, Barnes J, Quataert E and Ramirez-Ruiz E 2017 Nature 551 80
- [116] Villar V A et al 2017 Astrophys. J. Lett. 851 L21
- [117] Cowperthwaite P S et al 2017 Astrophys. J. 848 L17
- [118] Abbott B P et al 2017 Astrophys. J. 850 L39
- [119] Metzger B D 2017 (arXiv:1710.05931)
- [120] Kawaguchi K, Shibata M and Tanaka M 2018 Astrophys. J. 865 L21
- [121] Yu Y W, Liu L D and Dai Z G 2018 Astrophys. J. 861 114
- [122] Kiuchi K, Kyutoku K, Shibata M and Taniguchi K 2019 Astrophys. J. 876 L31
- [123] Radice D, Perego A, Zappa F and Bernuzzi S 2018 Astrophys. J. 852 L29

[124]

Dietrich T and Ujevic M 2017

Class. Quantum Grav.

34

105014

- [125] Shibata M, Zhou E, Kiuchi K and Fujibayashi S 2019 Phys. Rev. D 100 023015
- [126] Stergioulas N and Friedman J L 1995 Astrophys. J. 444 306 -11
- [127] Typel S, Oertel M and Kl ä hn T EoS catalog https://compose.obspm.fr (tables retrieved August 2018)
- [128] Ö zel F EoS catalog http://xtreme.as.arizona.edu/NeutronStars/data/eos\_tables.tar (tables retrieved 17 August 2018)
- [129] Akmal A, Pandharipande V R and Ravenhall D G 1998 Phys. Rev. C 58 1804 -28
- [130] Endrizzi A, Ciolfi R, Giacomazzo B, Kastaun W and Kawamura T 2016 Class. Quantum Grav. 33 164001
- [131] Baldo M, Bombaci I and Burgio G F 1997 Astron. Astrophys. 328 274 -82  (https://ui.adsabs. harvard.edu/#abs/1997A&amp;A...328..274B/abstract)
- [132] Gulminelli F and Raduta A R 2015 Phys. Rev. C 92 055803
- [133] Danielewicz P and Lee J 2009 Nucl. Phys. A 818 36 -96
- [134] Agrawal B K, Shlomo S and Au V K 2005 Phys. Rev. C 72 014310
- [135] Reinhard P G, Dean D J, Nazarewicz W, Dobaczewski J, Maruhn J A and Strayer M R 1999 Phys. Rev. C 60 014316
- [136] Lackey B D, Nayyar M and Owen B J 2006 Phys. Rev. D 73 024021
- [137] Douchin F and Haensel P 2001 Astron. Astrophys. 380 151 -67
- [138] Chabanat E, Bonche P, Haensel P, Meyer J and Schaeffer R 1997 Nuc. Phys. A 627 710 -46
- [139] Bennour L, Heenen P H, Bonche P, Dobaczewski J and Flocard H 1989 Phys. Rev. C 40 2834 -9
- [140] Friedrich J and Reinhard P G 1986 Phys. Rev. C 33 335 -51
- [141] Agrawal B K, Shlomo S and Kim Au V 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 031304
- [142] Reinhard P G and Flocard H 1995 Nucl. Phys. A 584 467 -88
- [143] Nazarewicz W, Dobaczewski J, Werner T R, Maruhn J A, Reinhard P G, Rutz K, Chinn C R, Umar A S and Strayer M R 1996 Phys. Rev. C 53 740 -51
- [144] M ther H, Prakash M and Ainsworth T L 1987 ü Phys. Lett. B 199 469 -74
- [145] M ller H and Serot B D 1996 ü Nucl. Phys. A 606 508 -37
The LIGO Scientific Collaboration the Virgo Collaboration B. P. Abbott R. Abbott T. D. Abbott S. Abraham F. Acernese K. Ackley C. Adams V. B. Adya C. Affeldt M. Agathos K. Agatsuma N. Aggarwal O. D. Aguiar L. Aiello A. Ain P. Ajith G. Allen A. Allocca M. A. Aloy P. A. Altin A. Amato S. Anand A. Ananyeva S. B. Anderson W. G. Anderson S. V. Angelova S. Antier S. Appert K. Arai M. C. Araya J. S. Areeda M. Arène N. Arnaud S. M. Aronson K. G. Arun S. Ascenzi G. Ashton S. M. Aston P. Astone F. Aubin P. Aufmuth K. AultONeal C. Austin V. Avendano A. Avila-Alvarez S. Babak P. Bacon F. Badaracco M. K. M. Bader S. Bae J. Baird P. T. Baker F. Baldaccini G. Ballardin S. W. Ballmer A. Bals S. Banagiri J. C. Barayoga C. Barbieri S. E. Barclay B. C. Barish D. Barker K. Barkett S. Barnum F. Barone B. Barr L. Barsotti M. Barsuglia D. Barta J. Bartlett I. Bartos R. Bassiri A. Basti M. Bawaj J. C. Bayley M. Bazzan B. Bécsy M. Bejger I. Belahcene A. S. Bell D. Beniwal M. G. Benjamin B. K. Berger G. Bergmann S. Bernuzzi C. P. L. Berry D. Bersanetti A. Bertolini J. Betzwieser R. Bhandare J. Bidler E. Biggs I. A. Bilenko S. A. Bilgili G. Billingsley R. Birney O. Birnholtz S. Biscans M. Bischi S. Biscoveanu A. Bisht M. Bitossi M. A. Bizouard J. K. Blackburn J. Blackman C. D. Blair D. G. Blair R. M. Blair S. Bloemen F. Bobba N. Bode M. Boer Y. Boetzel G. Bogaert F. Bondu R. Bonnand P. Booker B. A. Boom R. Bork V. Boschi S. Bose V. Bossilkov J. Bosveld Y. Bouffanais A. Bozzi C. Bradaschia P. R. Brady A. Bramley M. Branchesi J. E. Brau M. Breschi T. Briant J. H. Briggs F. Brighenti A. Brillet M. Brinkmann P. Brockill A. F. Brooks J. Brooks D. D. Brown S. Brunett A. Buikema T. Bulik H. J. Bulten A. Buonanno D. Buskulic C. Buy R. L. Byer M. Cabero L. Cadonati G. Cagnoli C. Cahillane J. Calderón Bustillo T. A. Callister E. Calloni J. B. Camp W. A. Campbell M. Canepa K. C. Cannon H. Cao J. Cao G. Carapella F. Carbognani S. Caride M. F. Carney G. Carullo J. Casanueva Diaz C. Casentini S. Caudill M. Cavaglià F. Cavalier R. Cavalieri G. Cella P. Cerdá-Durán E. Cesarini O. Chaibi K. Chakravarti S. J. Chamberlin M. Chan S. Chao P. Charlton E. A. Chase E. Chassande-Mottin D. Chatterjee M. Chaturvedi K. Chatziioannou B. D. Cheeseboro H. Y. Chen X. Chen Y. Chen H. -P. Cheng C. K. Cheong H. Y. Chia F. Chiadini A. Chincarini A. Chiummo G. Cho H. S. Cho M. Cho N. Christensen Q. Chu S. Chua K. W. Chung S. Chung G. Ciani M. Cie{ś}lar A. A. Ciobanu R. Ciolfi F. Cipriano A. Cirone F. Clara J. A. Clark P. Clearwater F. Cleva E. Coccia P. -F. Cohadon D. Cohen M. Colleoni C. G. Collette C. Collins M. Colpi L. R. Cominsky M. Constancio Jr. L. Conti S. J. Cooper P. Corban T. R. Corbitt I. Cordero-Carrión S. Corezzi K. R. Corley N. Cornish D. Corre A. Corsi S. Cortese C. A. Costa R. Cotesta M. W. Coughlin S. B. Coughlin J. -P. Coulon S. T. Countryman P. Couvares P. B. Covas E. E. Cowan D. M. Coward M. J. Cowart D. C. Coyne R. Coyne J. D. E. Creighton T. D. Creighton J. Cripe M. Croquette S. G. Crowder T. J. Cullen A. Cumming L. Cunningham E. Cuoco T. Dal Canton G. Dálya B. D'Angelo S. L. Danilishin S. D'Antonio K. Danzmann A. Dasgupta C. F. Da Silva Costa L. E. H. Datrier V. Dattilo I. Dave M. Davier D. Davis E. J. Daw D. DeBra M. Deenadayalan J. Degallaix M. De Laurentis S. Deléglise W. Del Pozzo L. M. DeMarchi N. Demos T. Dent R. De Pietri R. De Rosa C. De Rossi R. DeSalvo O. de Varona S. Dhurandhar M. C. Díaz T. Dietrich L. Di Fiore C. DiFronzo C. Di Giorgio F. Di Giovanni M. Di Giovanni T. Di Girolamo A. Di Lieto B. Ding S. Di Pace I. Di Palma F. Di Renzo A. K. Divakarla A. Dmitriev Z. Doctor F. Donovan K. L. Dooley S. Doravari I. Dorrington T. P. Downes M. Drago J. C. Driggers Z. Du J. -G. Ducoin P. Dupej O. Durante S. E. Dwyer P. J. Easter G. Eddolls T. B. Edo A. Effler P. Ehrens J. Eichholz S. S. Eikenberry M. Eisenmann R. A. Eisenstein L. Errico R. C. Essick H. Estelles D. Estevez Z. B. Etienne T. Etzel M. Evans T. M. Evans V. Fafone S. Fairhurst X. Fan S. Farinon B. Farr W. M. Farr E. J. Fauchon-Jones M. Favata M. Fays M. Fazio C. Fee J. Feicht M. M. Fejer F. Feng A. Fernandez-Galiana I. Ferrante E. C. Ferreira T. A. Ferreira F. Fidecaro I. Fiori D. Fiorucci M. Fishbach R. P. Fisher J. M. Fishner R. Fittipaldi M. Fitz-Axen V. Fiumara R. Flaminio M. Fletcher E. Floden E. Flynn H. Fong J. A. Font P. W. F. Forsyth J. -D. Fournier S. Frasca F. Frasconi Z. Frei A. Freise R. Frey V. Frey P. Fritschel V. V. Frolov G. Fronzè P. Fulda M. Fyffe H. A. Gabbard B. U. Gadre S. M. Gaebel J. R. Gair L. Gammaitoni S. G. Gaonkar C. García-Quirós F. Garufi B. Gateley S. Gaudio G. Gaur V. Gayathri G. Gemme E. Genin A. Gennai D. George J. George L. Gergely S. Ghonge Abhirup Ghosh Archisman Ghosh S. Ghosh B. Giacomazzo J. A. Giaime K. D. Giardina D. R. Gibson K. Gill L. Glover J. Gniesmer P. Godwin E. Goetz R. Goetz B. Goncharov G. González J. M. Gonzalez Castro A. Gopakumar S. E. Gossan M. Gosselin R. Gouaty B. Grace A. Grado M. Granata A. Grant S. Gras P. Grassia C. Gray R. Gray G. Greco A. C. Green R. Green E. M. Gretarsson A. Grimaldi S. J. Grimm P. Groot H. Grote S. Grunewald P. Gruning G. M. Guidi H. K. Gulati Y. Guo A. Gupta Anchal Gupta P. Gupta E. K. Gustafson R. Gustafson L. Haegel O. Halim B. R. Hall E. D. Hall E. Z. Hamilton G. Hammond M. Haney M. M. Hanke J. Hanks C. Hanna M. D. Hannam O. A. Hannuksela T. J. Hansen J. Hanson T. Harder T. Hardwick K. Haris J. Harms G. M. Harry I. W. Harry R. K. Hasskew C. J. Haster K. Haughian F. J. Hayes J. Healy A. Heidmann M. C. Heintze H. Heitmann F. Hellman P. Hello G. Hemming M. Hendry I. S. Heng J. Hennig Francisco Hernandez Vivanco M. Heurs S. Hild T. Hinderer W. C. G. Ho S. Hochheim D. Hofman A. M. Holgado N. A. Holland K. Holt D. E. Holz P. Hopkins C. Horst J. Hough E. J. Howell C. G. Hoy Y. Huang M. T. Hübner E. A. Huerta D. Huet B. Hughey V. Hui S. Husa S. H. Huttner T. Huynh-Dinh B. Idzkowski A. Iess H. Inchauspe C. Ingram R. Inta G. Intini B. Irwin H. N. Isa J. -M. Isac M. Isi B. R. Iyer T. Jacqmin S. J. Jadhav K. Jani N. N. Janthalur P. Jaranowski D. Jariwala A. C. Jenkins J. Jiang D. S. Johnson A. W. Jones D. I. Jones J. D. Jones R. Jones R. J. G. Jonker L. Ju J. Junker C. V. Kalaghatgi V. Kalogera B. Kamai S. Kandhasamy G. Kang J. B. Kanner S. J. Kapadia S. Karki R. Kashyap M. Kasprzack W. Kastaun S. Katsanevas E. Katsavounidis W. Katzman S. Kaufer K. Kawabe N. V. Keerthana F. Kéfélian D. Keitel R. Kennedy J. S. Key F. Y. Khalili I. Khan S. Khan E. A. Khazanov N. Khetan M. Khursheed N. Kijbunchoo Chunglee Kim J. C. Kim K. Kim W. Kim W. S. Kim Y. -M. Kim C. Kimball P. J. King M. Kinley-Hanlon R. Kirchhoff J. S. Kissel L. Kleybolte J. H. Klika S. Klimenko T. D. Knowles P. Koch S. M. Koehlenbeck G. Koekoek S. Koley V. Kondrashov A. Kontos N. Koper M. Korobko W. Z. Korth M. Kovalam D. B. Kozak C. Krämer V. Kringel N. Krishnendu A. Królak N. Krupinski G. Kuehn A. Kumar P. Kumar Rahul Kumar Rakesh Kumar L. Kuo A. Kutynia S. Kwang B. D. Lackey D. Laghi K. H. Lai T. L. Lam M. Landry P. Landry B. B. Lane R. N. Lang J. Lange B. Lantz R. K. Lanza A. Lartaux-Vollard P. D. Lasky M. Laxen A. Lazzarini C. Lazzaro P. Leaci S. Leavey Y. K. Lecoeuche C. H. Lee H. K. Lee H. M. Lee H. W. Lee J. Lee K. Lee J. Lehmann A. K. Lenon N. Leroy N. Letendre Y. Levin A. Li J. Li K. J. L. Li T. G. F. Li X. Li F. Lin F. Linde S. D. Linker T. B. Littenberg J. Liu X. Liu M. Llorens-Monteagudo R. K. L. Lo L. T. London A. Longo M. Lorenzini V. Loriette M. Lormand G. Losurdo J. D. Lough C. O. Lousto G. Lovelace M. E. Lower H. Lück D. Lumaca A. P. Lundgren R. Lynch Y. Ma R. Macas S. Macfoy M. MacInnis D. M. Macleod A. Macquet I. Magaña Hernandez F. Magaña-Sandoval R. M. Magee E. Majorana I. Maksimovic A. Malik N. Man V. Mandic V. Mangano G. L. Mansell M. Manske M. Mantovani M. Mapelli F. Marchesoni F. Marion S. Márka Z. Márka C. Markakis A. S. Markosyan A. Markowitz E. Maros A. Marquina S. Marsat F. Martelli I. W. Martin R. M. Martin V. Martinez D. V. Martynov H. Masalehdan K. Mason E. Massera A. Masserot T. J. Massinger M. Masso-Reid S. Mastrogiovanni A. Matas F. Matichard L. Matone N. Mavalvala J. J. McCann R. McCarthy D. E. McClelland S. McCormick L. McCuller S. C. McGuire C. McIsaac J. McIver D. J. McManus T. McRae S. T. McWilliams D. Meacher G. D. Meadors M. Mehmet A. K. Mehta J. Meidam E. Mejuto Villa A. Melatos G. Mendell R. A. Mercer L. Mereni K. Merfeld E. L. Merilh M. Merzougui S. Meshkov C. Messenger C. Messick F. Messina R. Metzdorff P. M. Meyers F. Meylahn A. Miani H. Miao C. Michel H. Middleton L. Milano A. L. Miller M. Millhouse J. C. Mills M. C. Milovich-Goff O. Minazzoli Y. Minenkov A. Mishkin C. Mishra T. Mistry S. Mitra V. P. Mitrofanov G. Mitselmakher R. Mittleman G. Mo D. Moffa K. Mogushi S. R. P. Mohapatra M. Molina-Ruiz M. Mondin M. Montani C. J. Moore D. Moraru F. Morawski G. Moreno S. Morisaki B. Mours C. M. Mow-Lowry F. Muciaccia Arunava Mukherjee D. Mukherjee S. Mukherjee Subroto Mukherjee N. Mukund A. Mullavey J. Munch E. A. Muñiz M. Muratore P. G. Murray A. Nagar I. Nardecchia L. Naticchioni R. K. Nayak B. F. Neil J. Neilson G. Nelemans T. J. N. Nelson M. Nery A. Neunzert L. Nevin K. Y. Ng S. Ng C. Nguyen P. Nguyen D. Nichols S. A. Nichols S. Nissanke F. Nocera C. North L. K. Nuttall M. Obergaulinger J. Oberling B. D. O'Brien G. Oganesyan G. H. Ogin J. J. Oh S. H. Oh F. Ohme H. Ohta M. A. Okada M. Oliver P. Oppermann Richard J. Oram B. O'Reilly R. G. Ormiston L. F. Ortega R. O'Shaughnessy S. Ossokine D. J. Ottaway H. Overmier B. J. Owen A. E. Pace G. Pagano M. A. Page G. Pagliaroli A. Pai S. A. Pai J. R. Palamos O. Palashov C. Palomba H. Pan P. K. Panda P. T. H. Pang C. Pankow F. Pannarale B. C. Pant F. Paoletti A. Paoli A. Parida W. Parker D. Pascucci A. Pasqualetti R. Passaquieti D. Passuello M. Patil B. Patricelli E. Payne B. L. Pearlstone T. C. Pechsiri A. J. Pedersen M. Pedraza R. Pedurand A. Pele S. Penn A. Perego C. J. Perez C. Périgois A. Perreca J. Petermann H. P. Pfeiffer M. Phelps K. S. Phukon O. J. Piccinni M. Pichot F. Piergiovanni V. Pierro G. Pillant L. Pinard I. M. Pinto M. Pirello M. Pitkin W. Plastino R. Poggiani D. Y. T. Pong S. Ponrathnam P. Popolizio E. K. Porter J. Powell A. K. Prajapati J. Prasad K. Prasai R. Prasanna G. Pratten T. Prestegard M. Principe G. A. Prodi L. Prokhorov M. Punturo P. Puppo M. Pürrer H. Qi V. Quetschke P. J. Quinonez F. J. Raab G. Raaijmakers H. Radkins N. Radulesco P. Raffai S. Raja C. Rajan B. Rajbhandari M. Rakhmanov K. E. Ramirez A. Ramos-Buades Javed Rana K. Rao P. Rapagnani V. Raymond M. Razzano J. Read T. Regimbau L. Rei S. Reid D. H. Reitze P. Rettegno F. Ricci C. J. Richardson J. W. Richardson P. M. Ricker G. Riemenschneider K. Riles M. Rizzo N. A. Robertson F. Robinet A. Rocchi L. Rolland J. G. Rollins V. J. Roma M. Romanelli R. Romano C. L. Romel J. H. Romie C. A. Rose D. Rose K. Rose D. Rosińska S. G. Rosofsky M. P. Ross S. Rowan A. Rüdiger P. Ruggi G. Rutins K. Ryan S. Sachdev T. Sadecki M. Sakellariadou O. S. Salafia L. Salconi M. Saleem A. Samajdar L. Sammut E. J. Sanchez L. E. Sanchez N. Sanchis-Gual J. R. Sanders K. A. Santiago E. Santos N. Sarin B. Sassolas B. S. Sathyaprakash O. Sauter R. L. Savage P. Schale M. Scheel J. Scheuer P. Schmidt R. Schnabel R. M. S. Schofield A. Schönbeck E. Schreiber B. W. Schulte B. F. Schutz J. Scott S. M. Scott E. Seidel D. Sellers A. S. Sengupta N. Sennett D. Sentenac V. Sequino A. Sergeev Y. Setyawati D. A. Shaddock T. Shaffer M. S. Shahriar M. B. Shaner A. Sharma P. Sharma P. Shawhan H. Shen R. Shink D. H. Shoemaker D. M. Shoemaker K. Shukla S. ShyamSundar K. Siellez M. Sieniawska D. Sigg L. P. Singer D. Singh N. Singh A. Singhal A. M. Sintes S. Sitmukhambetov V. Skliris B. J. J. Slagmolen T. J. Slaven-Blair J. R. Smith R. J. E. Smith S. Somala E. J. Son S. Soni B. Sorazu F. Sorrentino T. Souradeep E. Sowell A. P. Spencer M. Spera A. K. Srivastava V. Srivastava K. Staats C. Stachie M. Standke D. A. Steer M. Steinke J. Steinlechner S. Steinlechner D. Steinmeyer S. P. Stevenson D. Stocks R. Stone D. J. Stops K. A. Strain G. Stratta S. E. Strigin A. Strunk R. Sturani A. L. Stuver V. Sudhir T. Z. Summerscales L. Sun S. Sunil A. Sur J. Suresh P. J. Sutton B. L. Swinkels M. J. Szczepańczyk M. Tacca S. C. Tait C. Talbot D. B. Tanner D. Tao M. Tápai A. Tapia J. D. Tasson R. Taylor R. Tenorio L. Terkowski M. Thomas P. Thomas S. R. Thondapu K. A. Thorne E. Thrane Shubhanshu Tiwari Srishti Tiwari V. Tiwari K. Toland M. Tonelli Z. Tornasi A. Torres-Forné C. I. Torrie D. Töyrä F. Travasso G. Traylor M. C. Tringali A. Tripathee A. Trovato L. Trozzo K. W. Tsang M. Tse R. Tso L. Tsukada D. Tsuna T. Tsutsui D. Tuyenbayev K. Ueno D. Ugolini C. S. Unnikrishnan A. L. Urban S. A. Usman H. Vahlbruch G. Vajente G. Valdes M. Valentini N. van Bakel M. van Beuzekom J. F. J. van den Brand C. Van Den Broeck D. C. Vander-Hyde L. van der Schaaf J. V. VanHeijningen A. A. van Veggel M. Vardaro V. Varma S. Vass M. Vasúth A. Vecchio G. Vedovato J. Veitch P. J. Veitch K. Venkateswara G. Venugopalan D. Verkindt F. Vetrano A. Viceré A. D. Viets S. Vinciguerra D. J. Vine J. -Y. Vinet S. Vitale T. Vo H. Vocca C. Vorvick S. P. Vyatchanin A. R. Wade L. E. Wade M. Wade R. Walet M. Walker L. Wallace S. Walsh H. Wang J. Z. Wang S. Wang W. H. Wang Y. F. Wang R. L. Ward Z. A. Warden J. Warner M. Was J. Watchi B. Weaver L. -W. Wei M. Weinert A. J. Weinstein R. Weiss F. Wellmann L. Wen E. K. Wessel P. Weßels J. W. Westhouse K. Wette J. T. Whelan B. F. Whiting C. Whittle D. M. Wilken D. Williams A. R. Williamson J. L. Willis B. Willke W. Winkler C. C. Wipf H. Wittel G. Woan J. Woehler J. K. Wofford J. L. Wright D. S. Wu D. M. Wysocki S. Xiao R. Xu H. Yamamoto C. C. Yancey L. Yang Y. Yang Z. Yang M. J. Yap M. Yazback D. W. Yeeles Hang Yu Haocun Yu S. H. R. Yuen A. K. Zadrożny A. Zadrożny M. Zanolin F. Zappa T. Zelenova J. -P. Zendri M. Zevin J. Zhang L. Zhang T. Zhang C. Zhao G. Zhao M. Zhou Z. Zhou X. J. Zhu A. B. Zimmerman Y. Zlochower M. E. Zucker J. Zweizig
Model comparison from LIGO-Virgo data on GW170817's binary components and consequences for the merger remnant
GW170817 is the very first observation of gravitational waves originating
from the coalescence of two compact objects in the mass range of neutron stars,
accompanied by electromagnetic counterparts, and offers an opportunity to
directly probe the internal structure of neutron stars. We perform Bayesian
model selection on a wide range of theoretical predictions for the neutron star
equation of state. For the binary neutron star hypothesis, we find that we
cannot rule out the majority of theoretical models considered. In addition, the
gravitational-wave data alone does not rule out the possibility that one or
both objects were low-mass black holes. We discuss the possible outcomes in the
case of a binary neutron star merger, finding that all scenarios from prompt
collapse to long-lived or even stable remnants are possible. For long-lived
remnants, we place an upper limit of 1.9 kHz on the rotation rate. If a black
hole was formed any time after merger and the coalescing stars were slowly
rotating, then the maximum baryonic mass of non-rotating neutron stars is at
most 3.05 $M_\odot$, and three equations of state considered here can be ruled
out. We obtain a tighter limit of 2.67 $M_\odot$ for the case that the merger
results in a hypermassive neutron star.