## Hexagonal High-Entropy Alloys

Michael	
  Feuerbacher * ,	
  Markus	
  Heidelmann	
  and	
  Carsten	
  Thomas Peter	
  Grünberg	
  Institut	
  PGI-­-5,	
  Forschungszentrum	
  Jülich	
  GmbH,	
  D-­-52425	
  Jülich,	
  Germany

Accepted	
  for	
  publication	
  in	
  Materials	
  Research	
  Letters	
  1.	
  August	
  2014 Submission	
  Date:	
  6.	
  May	
  2014 DOI:10.1080/21663831.2014.95149

We	
   report	
   on	
   the	
   discovery	
   of	
   a	
   high-­-entropy	
   alloy	
   with	
   a	
   hexagonal	
   crystal	
   structure. Equiatomic	
   samples	
   in the alloy system	
   Ho-­-Dy-­-Y-­-Gd-­-Tb were found to solidify as homogeneous	
   single-­-phase	
   high-­-entropy	
   alloys.	
   The	
   results	
   of	
   our	
   electron	
   diffraction investigations and high-­-resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy are consistent	
   with a Mg-­-type hexagonal	
   structure.	
   The possibility of hexagonal	
   high-­entropy	
  alloys	
  in	
  other	
  alloy	
  systems	
  is	
  discussed.

## Keywords: High-­-Entropy	
  Alloy,	
  Structure,	
  Transmission	
  Electron	
  Microscopy

High-­-entropy	
  alloys	
  (HEAs)	
  constitute	
  a	
  novel	
  field	
  in	
  materials	
  science,	
  currently attracting	
  increasing	
  research	
  interest.	
  The	
  basic	
  idea,	
  pioneered	
  by	
  Yeh	
  in	
  2004,	
  [1]	
  is to study	
   alloys	
   composed	
   of	
   multiple	
   principal	
   elements	
   solidifying	
   as	
   metallic	
   solid solutions	
   on	
   a	
   simple	
   crystal	
   lattice.	
   Usually,	
   alloys	
   with	
   4	
   to	
   9,	
   occasionally	
   up	
   to	
   20 components	
  [2]	
  are	
  considered.

In	
  a	
  multicomponent	
  alloy,	
  the	
  total	
  free	
  energy	
  is	
  largely	
  determined	
  by	
  the	
  free energy	
   of	
   mixing, ∆ 𝐺 !"# = ∆ 𝐻 !"# -𝑇 ∆ 𝑆 !"# , where Δ Hmix is the mixing	
   enthalpy	
   and Δ Smix the mixing	
   entropy.	
   In	
   equimolar	
   or	
   near	
   equimolar	
   compositions,	
   the	
   mixing entropy	
   can	
   become	
   dominant,	
   stabilizing	
   a	
   random	
   solid	
   solution,	
   if	
   the	
   elements	
   are chosen such that the mixing enthalpy is neither too high positive (leading to segregation)	
  nor	
  too	
  high	
  negative	
  (leading	
  to	
  the	
  formation	
  of	
  ordered	
  structures).	
  In the	
  ideal	
  case	
  the	
  resulting	
  material	
  is	
  a	
  perfectly	
  disordered	
  solid	
  solution	
  with	
  a	
  simple average	
  crystal	
  structure.	
  HEAs	
  are	
  thus	
  related	
  to	
  metallic	
  glasses,	
  but	
  in	
  contrast	
  to	
  the latter,	
  they	
  are	
  thermodynamically	
  stable,	
  in	
  particular	
  at	
  high	
  temperatures.

Up	
   to	
   now	
   numerous	
   alloy	
   systems	
   have	
   been	
   reported	
   in	
   which	
   HEAs	
   exist. Without	
  exception	
  only	
  HEAs	
  with	
  body-­-centered	
  or	
  face	
  centered	
  cubic	
  structures	
  have been	
   found.	
   In	
   this	
   paper,	
   we	
   report	
   on	
   the	
   observation	
   of	
   a	
   HEA	
   with	
   a	
   hexagonal crystal	
   structure.	
   We	
   have	
   prepared	
   samples	
   of	
   equiatomic	
   composition	
   in	
   the	
   rare earth	
   (RE)	
   system	
   Ho-­-Dy-­-Y-­-Gd-­-Tb	
   and	
   characterized	
   them	
   by	
   means	
   of	
   transmission electron	
   microscopy	
   (TEM),	
   scanning	
   electron	
   microscopy	
   (SEM),	
   energy	
   dispersive	
   x-­ray	
  diffraction	
  (EDX),	
  and	
  scanning	
  transmission	
  electron	
  microscopy	
  (STEM).

* Corresponding	
  author.	
  Email:	
  m.feuerbacher@fz-­-juelich.de

Figure 1. (a) SEM micrograph	
   using a backscattered-­-electron detector and (b) HAADF-­-STEM	
  overview	
  of	
  a	
  FIB	
  sample	
  of	
  equiatomic	
  Ho-­-Dy-­-Y-­-Gd-­-Tb.	
  The	
  material	
  is perfectly homogeneous;	
   no features due to composition variation, precipation, dendrite	
   formation	
   etc.	
   can	
   be	
   seen.	
   In	
   both	
   micrographs	
   sample	
   edges	
   (dark)	
   are visible.

![image](https://ac.marcodsn.me/arxiv-markdown-images/1408.0100v3-figure-1d3fe1c8-547a-4793-a3b7-d3d122a85304.jpg)

We have prepared	
   ingots	
   of equiatomic	
   Ho-­-Dy-­-Y-­-Gd-­-Tb in a high-­-frequency levitation	
  furnace	
  under	
  1	
  bar	
  Ar	
  atmosphere	
  using	
  3N	
  high-­-purity	
  elements.	
  Each	
  ingot was	
   remelted	
   four	
   times	
   to	
   ensure	
   to	
   achieve	
   proper	
   homogenization	
   of	
   the	
   sample. Specimens	
  for	
  microstructural	
  characterization	
  were	
  prepared	
  by	
  means	
  of	
  a	
  dual-­-beam FEI	
   Helios	
   Nanolab	
   400S	
   focused	
   ion-­-beam	
   (FIB)	
   from	
   the	
   centres	
   of	
   the	
   ingots.	
   TEM was	
  carried	
  out	
  using	
  a	
  Philips	
  CM20	
  transmission	
  electron	
  microscope	
  operated	
  at	
  200 kV,	
   SEM	
   work	
   using	
   a	
   JEOL	
   840	
   equipped	
   with	
   an	
   EDAX	
   energy	
   dispersive	
   analytical system,	
  and	
  STEM	
  work	
  using	
  a	
  probe	
  corrected	
  FEI	
  Titan	
  80	
  -	
  300	
  operated	
  at	
  300	
  kV and	
  equipped	
  with	
  a	
  high-­-angle	
  annular	
  dark-­-field	
  (HAADF)	
  detector.

Fig. 1 (a) displays a scanning	
   electron micrograph	
   of the material using a composition-­-sensitive backscattered-­-electron detector. Fig. 1(b) displays a STEM micrograph	
   of	
   the	
   thin	
   part	
   of	
   a	
   typical	
   FIB	
   sample	
   taken	
   using	
   a	
   Z-­-contrast	
   sensitive HAADF	
  detector.	
  Both	
  images	
  demonstrate	
  that	
  the	
  sample	
  is	
  perfectly	
  homogeneous,	
  in particular	
  there	
  are	
  no	
  composition	
  variations,	
  no	
  precipitates	
  or	
  secondary	
  phases	
  and no	
  dendrites.	
  We	
  obtain	
  these	
  results	
  consistently	
  with	
  FIB	
  samples	
  taken	
  from	
  various positions in the ingots. Note also that the cooling rate after levitation melting is sufficiently	
  slow	
  to	
  allow	
  for	
  the	
  formation	
  of	
  a	
  homogeneous	
  single	
  phase.	
  The	
  average composition	
  measured	
  by	
  EDX	
  at	
  eight	
  different	
  specimen	
  positions	
  is	
  Ho	
  19.8	
  at.%,	
  Dy 20.0	
   at.%,	
   Y	
   20.4	
   at.%,	
   Gd	
   20.1	
   at.%,	
   Tb19.7	
   at.%.	
   Within	
   the	
   experimental	
   uncertainty this	
  corresponds	
  to	
  the	
  nominal	
  equiatomic	
  sample	
  composition,	
  and	
  hence	
  we	
  conclude that	
  the	
  material	
  solidifies	
  congruently.

Fig.	
   2(a)	
   is	
   an	
   electron	
   diffraction	
   pattern	
   taken	
   at	
   the	
   [0	
   0	
   0	
   1]	
   zone	
   axis.	
   The pattern	
  displays	
  perfect	
  hexagonal	
  symmetry,	
  a	
  number	
  of	
  reflections	
  are	
  indexed.

Figure	
   2.	
   Electron	
   diffraction	
   patterns	
   along	
   different	
   zone	
   axes	
   of	
   the	
   hexagonal structure:	
   (a)	
   [0	
   0	
   0	
   1]	
   zone	
   axis.	
   (b)	
   [1	
   1 2 ! 1] zone	
   axis:	
   overlay	
   of	
   a	
   short-­-time-­exposure	
   displaying zero-­-order Laue zone reflections and a long-­-time-­-exposure (inverted	
  to	
  enhance	
  the	
  weak	
  spots)	
  including	
  first-­-order	
  Laue	
  zone	
  reflections.	
  (c) [1	
  1 2 ! 0]	
  zone	
  axis.	
  (d)	
  [4	
  1 5 ! 0]	
  zone	
  axis.	
  (e)	
  [1	
  0 1 ! 0]	
  zone	
  axis.

![image](https://ac.marcodsn.me/arxiv-markdown-images/1408.0100v3-figure-e046197e-f3ce-4d09-8f8a-55a2b41bb858.jpg)

In	
   order	
   to	
   determine	
   the	
   space	
   group	
   we	
   follow	
   a	
   procedure	
   described	
   in	
   [3]. Fig.	
   2	
   (b)	
   is	
   an	
   overlay	
   of	
   two	
   electron	
   diffraction	
   patterns	
   at	
   the	
   [1	
   1 2 1]	
   zone	
   axis,	
   a short-­-time-­-exposure to display zero-­-order Laue zone reflections and a long-­-time-­exposure (inverted to enhance the weak spots) including first-­-order Laue zone reflections.	
   The	
   whole	
   pattern	
   has	
   an m symmetry,	
   which	
   corresponds	
   to	
   the	
   point group	
  6/ mmm in	
  a	
  hexagonal	
  system.	
  Figs.	
  2	
  (c)	
  to	
  (e)	
  show	
  diffraction	
  patterns	
  at	
  the	
  [1 1 2 0],	
  [4	
  1 5 0],	
  and	
  [1	
  0 1 0]	
  zone	
  axes,	
  respectively,	
  which	
  are	
  all	
  perpendicular	
  to	
  [0	
  0 0	
  1].

Figure	
   3.	
   Arrangement	
   of	
   zone	
   axes	
   and	
   corresponding	
   electron	
   diffraction	
   patterns, indexed	
   according	
   to	
   a	
   hexagonal	
   Mg-­-type	
   structure.	
   The	
   lines	
   correspond	
   to	
   Kikuchi lines	
  as	
  seen	
  in	
  the	
  TEM.	
  Only	
  half	
  of	
  the	
  patterns	
  surrounding	
  [0	
  0	
  0	
  1]	
  are	
  shown.	
  The indicated	
  angle	
  between	
  [ 1 2 1 3 ]	
  and	
  [ 1 2 1 6 ]	
  is	
  not	
  to	
  scale	
  as	
  indicated	
  by	
  the	
  broken lines.

![image](https://ac.marcodsn.me/arxiv-markdown-images/1408.0100v3-figure-723a064f-7233-43af-86fa-c7e50927960c.jpg)

The	
  (0	
  0	
  0	
  1)	
  reflection	
  is	
  visible	
  at	
  the	
  [1	
  1 2 0]	
  zone	
  axis	
  but	
  diminishes	
  when	
  tilting	
  to [4	
   1 5 0] and	
   essentially	
   vanishes	
   when	
   tilting	
   further	
   to	
   [1	
   0 1 0]. This	
   indicates	
   the presence	
   of	
   a	
   6 3 screw	
   axis	
   parallel	
   to	
   [0	
   0	
   0	
   1].	
   In	
   the	
   [1	
   1 2 0]	
   pattern	
   the	
   (1 1 0 1) reflections	
  are	
   present,	
   which	
   rules	
   out	
   the	
   P6 3/ mcm case	
   [4].	
   Consequently	
   the	
   space group	
  must	
  be	
  P63/ mmc .	
   Under	
  stern	
  scrutiny,	
  an	
  extremely	
  weak	
  residual	
  intensity	
  of

| Zone        | Angle	
  to	
  [0	
  0	
  0	
  1]	
   exp./deg       | Angle	
  to	
  [0	
  0	
  0	
  1]	
   calc./deg       | R hkil 	
  ratio	
   exp.         |       Inverse	
   d hkil ratio	
  calc. |
|-------------|-------|-------|---------|-------|
| 1 ! 	
  1	
  0	
  4             | 15.24 | 15.36 | 1.192 a | 1.198 |
| 1 ! 	
  2	
   1 ! 	
  6             | 16.90 | 17.60 | 1.853 b | 1.817 |
| 1 ! 2 1 ! 3 | 32.00 | 32.39 | 1.151 c | 1.141 |
| 1 ! 2 1 ! 3 | '     | '     | 1.000 d | 1     |

Table 1: Comparison between experiment and calculations on the basis of a hexagonal	
   Mg-­-type	
   structure	
   with	
   lattice	
   parameters	
   a	
   =	
   361	
   pm	
   and	
   c	
   =	
   569	
   pm. First	
  and	
  second	
  row:	
  tilting	
  angle	
  of	
  zone	
  with	
  respect	
  to	
  [0	
  0	
  0	
  1].	
  Third	
  row:	
  ratio of R hkil values of reflections spanning the diffraction patterns. Fourth row: corresponding	
  inverse d hkil ratios. a 	
   2 2 ! 0	
  1	
  and	
  1	
  1 2 ! 0 reflections; b 1 ! 2 1 ! 1 ! and	
  1	
  0 1 ! 0 reflections; c 0	
  1 1 ! 1 ! and	
  1	
  0 1 ! 0	
  	
  reflections; d 	
  0	
  1 1 ! 1 ! and	
  1 1 ! 0	
  1	
  reflections.

the	
   (0	
   0	
   0	
   1)	
   reflection	
   in	
   the	
   [1	
   0 1 0]	
   zone	
   can	
   be	
   seen.	
   This	
   may	
   be	
   due	
   to	
   a	
   minor deviation	
  from	
  perfect	
  disorder	
  and	
  is	
  neglected	
  in	
  our	
  analysis.

We	
  have	
  carried	
  out	
  tilting	
  diffraction	
  experiments	
  on	
  a	
  single	
  grain	
  to	
  determine the	
   symmetry	
   and	
   angular	
   distance	
   of	
   zone	
   axes	
   around	
   [0	
   0	
   0	
   1].	
   The	
   results	
   are summarized	
   in Fig. 3, which displays the zone axes relevant for structure type determination	
   within	
   reach	
   of	
   the	
   double-­-tilt	
   goniometer	
   stage.	
   The	
   [0	
   0	
   0	
   1]	
   zone	
   is surrounded	
  by	
  six	
  &lt; 1 1	
  0	
  4&gt;	
  and	
  six	
  &lt; 1 2 1 6&gt;	
  zone	
  axes	
  (only	
  half	
  of	
  which	
  are	
  shown).

The	
   [ 1 1 0 4] zone	
   is	
   tilted	
   by	
   15.24°	
   with	
   respect	
   to	
   [0	
   0	
   0	
   1]	
   and	
   shows	
   a rectangular	
  pattern	
  that	
  is	
  repeated	
  by	
  five	
  further	
  zone	
  axes	
  rotated	
  by	
  60°	
  around	
  [0	
  0 0	
   1].	
  The	
  [ 1 2 1 6]	
   zone	
  is	
  tilted	
  by	
  17.60°	
  with	
  respect	
  to	
  [0	
  0	
  0	
  1]	
  and	
  shows	
  a	
  pattern with	
  a	
  different	
  aspect	
  ratio	
  of	
  the	
  two	
  reflections	
  spanning	
  the	
  rectangular	
  pattern.	
  Five further	
  equivalent	
  zone	
  axes	
  are	
  arranged	
  around	
  [0	
  0	
  0	
  1]	
  rotated	
  by	
  angles	
  of	
  60°.	
  The dark	
  lines	
  represent	
  the	
  Kikuchi	
  lines	
  as	
  seen	
  in	
  the	
  TEM.	
  The	
  arrangement	
  of	
  the	
  zone axes	
  as	
  well	
  as	
  the	
  Kikuchi	
  lines	
  perfectly	
  reproduces	
  the	
  hexagonal	
  structure.	
  	
  A	
  further zone	
   axis	
   displaying	
   an	
   almost	
   hexagonal	
   pattern,	
   [ 1 2 1 3 ],	
   which	
   is	
   tilted	
   by	
   32°	
   with respect	
  to	
  [0	
  0	
  0	
  1]	
  was	
  recorded.	
  Note	
  that	
  some	
  of	
  the	
  diffraction	
  patterns	
  contain	
  very weak	
  additional	
  reflections,	
  the	
  origin	
  of	
  which	
  is	
  not	
  clear.	
  They	
  may	
  be	
  due	
  to	
  double diffraction,	
  minor	
  deviations	
  from	
  perfect	
  disorder,	
  or	
  electron	
  diffraction	
  taking	
  place in	
  neighboured	
  grains.	
  These	
  reflections	
  were	
  not	
  taken	
  into	
  account	
  in	
  our	
  analyses.

All	
   zone	
   axes,	
   Kikuchi	
   lines	
   and	
   reflections	
   can	
   consistently	
   be	
   indexed	
   on	
   the basis	
  of	
  a	
  hexagonal	
  structure.	
  We	
  compared	
  calculated	
  and	
  experimental	
  tilting	
  angles of	
   different	
   zone	
   axes	
   as	
   well	
   as	
   distances	
   of	
   reflections	
   from	
   the	
   direct	
   beam R hkil . For the	
   latter,	
   we	
   compared	
   the	
   ratio	
   of R hkil values	
   of	
   reflections	
   spanning	
   a	
   diffraction pattern	
   to	
   the	
   corresponding	
   calculated d hkil ratio.	
   Due	
   to	
   the	
   relationship R hkil d hkil = const,	
   where	
   the	
   imprecisely	
   known	
   constant	
   is	
   given	
   by	
   the	
   electron	
   wavelength	
   and the	
   camera	
   length	
   of	
   the	
   microscope,	
   these	
   ratios	
   should	
   inversely	
   correspond.	
   Good agreement	
  could	
  be	
  achieved	
  using	
  the	
  lattice	
  parameters	
  a	
  =	
  361	
  pm	
  and	
  c	
  =	
  569	
  pm. These	
  lattice	
   parameters	
  correspond	
  to	
  the	
  weighted	
  average	
  of	
  the	
  parameters	
  of	
  the

Figure 4. HAADF-­-STEM micrographs of equiatomic Ho-­-Dy-­-Y-­-Gd-­-Tb with insets displaying	
  the	
  corresponding	
  FFTs.	
  (a)	
  along	
  the	
  [0	
  0	
  0	
  1]	
  direction.	
  (b)	
  along	
  the	
  [1	
  1 2 ! 0]	
  direction.

![image](https://ac.marcodsn.me/arxiv-markdown-images/1408.0100v3-figure-6bd280c2-78a0-4d84-91af-5a46d87446f6.jpg)

constituting	
  elements.	
  A	
  comparison	
  of	
  the	
  experimental	
  and	
  calculated	
  quantities	
  using these	
  parameters	
  is	
  presented	
  in	
  Table	
  1.

Fig. 4 shows	
   STEM	
   micrographs,	
   which	
   were	
   slightly FFT-­-filtered for high-­frequency	
   noise	
   reduction.	
   Fig	
   4(a)	
   was	
   taken	
   along	
   the	
   [0	
   0	
   0	
   1]	
   direction	
   and	
   in consistency	
   with a Mg-­-type structure displays a pattern of interconnected	
   hollow hexagons.	
   The	
   inset	
   is	
   a	
   FFT	
   of	
   the	
   image	
   also	
   reflecting	
   the	
   hexagonal	
   structure.	
   Fig. 4(b)	
   was	
   taken	
   along	
   [1	
   1 2 0]	
   and	
   the	
   FFT	
   in	
   the	
   inset	
   corresponds	
   to	
   the	
   diffraction pattern	
   in Fig. 2(c). The image	
   is also in consistency	
   with	
   a	
   Mg-­-type	
   structure.	
   In particular,	
   the atomic	
   arrangement	
   along	
   this	
   direction	
   excludes	
   a	
   P63/ mcm space group,	
   which	
   would	
   lead	
   to	
   a	
   pattern	
   of	
   paired	
   atomic	
   rows	
   parallel	
   to	
   the	
   [0	
   0	
   0	
   1] direction.	
  This	
   significantly	
  differs	
   from	
   the	
   almost	
   hexagonal	
   pattern	
   expected	
   for	
   the P63/ mmc space group, which	
   directly corresponds	
   to	
   the experimentally	
   observed HAADF-­-STEM	
  image.	
  This	
  observation	
  is	
  consistent	
  with	
  our	
  electron	
  diffraction	
  results. Both	
   images,	
   which	
   were	
   taken	
   with	
   a	
   Z-­-contrast	
   sensitive	
   HAADF	
   detector,	
   show	
   that also	
  on	
  this	
  small	
  scale	
  the	
  material	
  is	
  perfectly	
  homogeneous.	
  There	
  is	
  no	
  indication	
  of precipitation	
  or	
  ordering.

The	
   lattice	
   parameters	
   directly	
   measured	
   from	
   the	
   image	
   amount	
   to	
   a	
   =	
   (363	
   ± 30)	
  pm	
  and	
  c	
  =	
  (566	
  ±	
  20)	
  pm,	
  which	
  is	
  in	
  agreement	
  with	
  the	
  weighted	
  average	
  of	
  the parameters	
   of	
   the constituting	
   elements.	
   It	
   was	
   observed	
   earlier	
   that the a-­-lattice constant	
  in	
  cubic	
  HEAs	
  follows	
  a	
  rule	
  of	
  mixtures.[5]	
  Our	
  results	
  indicate	
  that	
  a	
  rule	
  of mixtures	
  also	
  applies	
  to	
  the	
  c-­-lattice	
  parameter	
  and	
  the	
  c/a	
  ratio.

Our electron diffraction and STEM results are consistent with a Mg-­-type hexagonal	
  structure.	
  That	
  is,	
  the	
  unit	
  cell	
  has	
  space	
  group	
  P63/mmc	
  (No.	
  194)	
  and	
  two

atoms	
   per	
   unit	
   cell,	
   on	
   the	
   (1/3,	
   2/3,	
   1/4)	
   position	
   and	
   its	
   symmetric	
   equivalent.	
   The structure	
  of	
  the	
  HEA	
  is	
  identical	
  to	
  the	
  structures	
  of	
  the	
  constituting	
  elements,	
  which	
  are also	
  of	
  Mg-­-type.

Criteria	
   for	
   the	
   formation	
   of	
   HEAs	
   are	
   commonly	
   discussed	
   in	
   terms	
   of	
   radius differences	
   and	
   a	
   parameter Ω referring	
   to	
   the	
   thermodynamic	
   properties	
   of	
   the	
   alloy [6].	
   The	
   radius	
   difference 𝛿𝑟 = 𝑐 ! ( 1 -𝑟 ! 𝑟 ) ! ! , where r i are	
   the	
   element	
   radii, c i the mole	
  percentages,	
  and 𝑟 is	
  the	
  weighted	
  average	
  radius,	
  should	
  be	
  as	
  small	
  as	
  possible.	
  A value	
  below	
  about	
  6.5	
  %	
  for	
  HEAs	
  in	
  general	
  and	
  below	
  3.8	
  %	
  for	
  single-­-phase	
  HEAs	
  [7] is required. In our case δ r = 0.77 %. The thermodynamic parameter Ω = 𝑇 ! Δ 𝑆 !"# Δ 𝐻 !"# , where Tm is the weighted average melting temperature, Δ 𝑆 !"# the mixing	
   entropy,	
   and Δ 𝐻 !"# = 𝑐 ! 𝑐 ! 𝐻 !" ! , ! , ! ! ! ,[6] should	
   exceed	
   1.1 (which means	
  that	
  the	
  entropy	
  contribution	
  to	
  the	
  free	
  energy	
  should	
  dominate	
  the	
  enthalpy).

Since	
  the	
  alloy	
  investigated	
  is	
  equiatomic, Δ 𝑆 !"# reaches	
  the	
  maximum	
  value	
  1.61 R,[1]	
  where	
  R=	
  8.314	
  J	
  K -1 	
  mol -1 	
  is	
  the	
  gas	
  constant. Δ 𝐻 !"# calculated	
  using	
  values	
  from the	
   tables	
  provided	
  by	
  Takeuchi	
  and	
  Inoue	
  [8]	
  amounts	
  to	
  0	
  kJ	
  mol -1 .	
   For	
   Ho-­-Dy-­-Y-­-Gd-­Tb not only the sum of the mutual	
   mixing	
   enthalpies	
   is	
   zero but each individual component Hij = 0 kJ mol -1 for all i and j . The	
   alloy	
   thus	
   fulfills	
   an even	
   stronger formation	
   criterion.	
   Formally,	
   taking	
   the	
   calculated	
   values	
   for Δ 𝐻 !"# [8] into	
   account, the	
  parameter Ω in	
  our	
  case	
  diverges.

Further	
   criteria	
   supporting	
   HEA	
   formation	
   are	
   equal	
   crystal	
   structures,	
   a	
   high mutual	
  solubility	
  in	
  the	
  binary	
  phase	
  diagrams	
  of	
  all	
  constituting	
  elements,	
  and,	
  from	
  a practical	
  point	
  of	
  view,	
  close	
  melting	
  points.	
  All	
  formation	
  criteria	
  are	
  ideally	
  fulfilled	
  for the	
  system	
  investigated.

Note	
   that	
   the	
   same	
   is	
   true	
   for	
   numerous	
   further	
   RE	
   elements.	
   Similarly	
   positive conditions	
   are	
   present	
   for	
   La,	
   Er,	
   Tm,	
   Lu,	
   Pr,	
   Pm	
   and	
   Nd.	
   If	
   we	
   exclude	
   Pm	
   due	
   to	
   its radioactivity,	
   in	
   total	
   we	
   are	
   left	
   with	
   11	
   practically	
   useable	
   elements	
   for	
   which	
   we expect the formation of hexagonal HEAs. Hence HEAs with higher numbers of components	
  up	
   to	
   11	
   and	
   numerous	
   combinations	
   should	
   be	
   possible.	
   The	
   number	
   of possible	
  equiatomic	
  five-­-element	
  HEAs	
  is	
  462,	
  and	
  altogether	
  1486	
  different	
  HEAs	
  with five	
  to	
  11	
  different	
  elements	
  can	
  be	
  combined.	
  The	
  elements	
  Ho,	
  Dy,	
  Y,	
  Gd,	
  and	
  Tb	
  used for	
  the	
  alloy	
  investigated	
  in	
  this	
  work,	
  which	
  can	
  be	
  considered	
  a	
  feasibility	
  study,	
  were chosen	
   more	
   or	
   less	
   arbitrarily	
   from	
   the	
   potential	
   candidates	
   due	
   to	
   their	
   immediate availability	
  in	
  our	
  stock.	
  We	
  should	
  point	
  out	
  that	
  some	
  of	
  the	
  elements	
  used	
  undergo	
  a high-­-temperature	
  transition	
  from	
  hexagonal	
  to	
  cubic	
  structure	
  at	
  95	
  %	
  (Gd	
  and	
  Tb)	
  and 98	
   %	
   (Dy	
   and	
   Y)	
   of	
   their	
   melting	
   point.	
   The	
   exclusive	
   use	
   of	
   elements	
   that	
   have	
   a hexagonal	
   structure	
   up	
   to	
   their	
   melting	
   point	
   may	
   lead	
   to	
   a	
   larger	
   grained	
   structure. This	
  however	
  would	
  limit	
  the	
  system	
  to	
  the	
  four	
  elements	
  Er-­-Tm-­-Lu-­-Ho.

The	
   list	
   can	
   probably	
   be	
   further	
   extended	
   by	
   taking	
   into	
   account	
   elements	
   that have	
  a	
   different	
   crystal	
   structure	
  but	
  also	
   similar	
   radii	
   and	
   low	
   mixing	
   enthalpies	
   with the elements	
   mentioned	
   above.	
   Ce,	
   for	
   example,	
   shows	
   high	
   solubility	
   with	
   all	
   RE elements	
   (with	
   the presence	
   of a miscibility	
   gap, however)	
   and	
   mixing	
   enthalpies

between	
  0	
  and	
  1	
  kJ/mol.	
  The	
  same	
  seems	
  to	
  hold	
  for	
  Sm,	
  as	
  far	
  as	
  phase	
  diagrams	
  are available.

We	
   have	
   chosen	
   an	
   equiatomic	
   alloy	
   composition	
   for	
   the	
   present	
   work	
   but	
   we expect	
   that due to the similarity	
   of the constituting	
   elements	
   and	
   hence	
   generous compliance	
   of	
   the	
   formation	
   criteria,	
   the	
   existence	
   ranges	
   of	
   the	
   HEAs	
   are	
   very	
   wide. The	
  production	
  of	
  single-­-phase	
  ingots	
  with	
  different	
  compositions	
  should	
  therefore	
  also be possible. This expected tolerance to composition variation may open up the possibility	
   to form single-­-phase	
   HEAs	
   using Mischmetall,	
   which	
   is a more	
   or less undefined alloy of RE elements in various naturally occurring proportions. Since Mischmetall	
   is	
   considerably	
   cheaper	
   than	
   high-­-purity	
   single	
   RE	
   elements,	
   this	
   would eliminate	
  the	
  economical	
  disadvantage	
  of	
  the	
  RE-­-systems	
  under	
  consideration.

The hexagonal HEAs presented may offer a unique chance to study the magnetism	
   of RE-­-systems. Mainly related to their 4f electron configurations, RE-­elements possess highly complex magnetic behavior displaying a wide variety of properties	
  [9].	
  The	
  systems	
  presented	
  are	
  unique	
  in	
  the	
  sense	
  that	
  they	
  are	
  topologically ordered	
  but	
  possess	
  random	
  bonds.	
  In	
  the	
  present	
  HEA	
  systems	
  the	
  included	
  elements and	
   the	
   composition	
   can	
   most	
   freely	
   be	
   varied	
   at	
   constant	
   structure,	
   which	
   may	
   allow for	
   insightful	
   comparative	
  measurements.	
  Furthermore,	
  hexagonal	
  HEAs	
  including	
  Tm, Yb,	
  and	
  Ce	
  may	
  provide	
  a	
  way	
  to	
  study	
  heavy-­-fermion	
  behavior	
  in	
  a	
  disordered	
  system.

The	
   hexagonal	
   high-­-entropy	
   systems	
   also	
   include	
   the	
   possibility	
   to	
   incorporate intentional second phases, i.e. for the increase of strength, high-­-temperature applicability,	
  etc.	
  Potential	
  candidates	
  are	
  Yb,	
  Eu,	
  Zr,	
  and	
  Hf,	
  which	
  have	
  a	
  high	
  melting temperature	
  and	
  a	
  high	
  positive	
  mixing	
  enthalpy	
  with	
  the	
  RE	
  elements	
  considered.	
  The mixing	
  enthalpies	
  with	
  these	
  elements	
  are	
  between	
  6	
  and	
  18	
  kJ	
  mol -­-1 ,	
   which	
  will	
  lead	
  to segregation.

We should also point out that recently Gao and Alman	
   [10] predicted	
   the existence	
  of	
   a	
   hexagonal	
   HEA	
   in	
   the	
   system	
   Co-­-Os-­-Re-­-Ru.	
   In	
   this	
   system	
   the	
   formation criteria	
  are	
  indeed	
  well	
  fulfilled	
  and	
  all	
  constituting	
  elements	
  are	
  mutually	
  soluble.	
  The drawback	
  of	
  this	
  system	
  is	
  that	
  Os	
  reacts	
  with	
  oxygen	
  at	
  room	
  temperature	
  forming	
  the highly	
   toxic	
   osmium	
   tetroxide.	
   Furthermore	
   for	
   the	
   elements	
   proposed,	
   the	
   melting points are strongly different (1768 K (Co) vs. 3459 K (Re)) making the growth procedure	
  practically	
  difficult.	
  Further	
  candidates	
  along	
  these	
  lines	
  are	
  Co-­-Re-­-Ru-­-Tc	
  or the	
  five-­-element	
  system	
  Co-­-Re-­-Ru-­-Tc-­-Os,	
  both	
  of	
  which	
  involve	
  the	
  radioactive	
  element Tc.

In conclusion,	
   in this paper	
   we report	
   on the observation	
   of	
   a HEA	
   in the HoDyYGdTb	
   alloy	
   system.	
   Our	
   samples	
   are	
   homogeneous	
   and	
   single	
   phased,	
   and	
   of hexagonal	
  Mg-­-type	
  structure.

Acknowledgments The authors thank Ms D. Meertens for focused ion-­-beam preparation	
  of	
  the	
  TEM	
  samples,	
  and	
  W.	
  Steurer,	
  J.	
  Dolinsek,	
  and	
  M.	
  Heggen	
  for	
  inspiring discussions.

## References

- [1] Yeh JW, Chen SK, Lin SJ, Gan JY, Chin TS, Shun TT, Tsau CH, Chang SY. Nanostructured	
  high-­-entropy	
  alloys	
  with	
  multiple	
  principal	
  elements:	
  novel	
  alloy	
  design concepts	
  and	
  outcomes.	
  Adv.	
  Eng.	
  Mater.	
  2004;6:299	
  -	
  303.
- [2] Cantor B, Chang ITH, Knight P, Vincent AJB. Microstructural development	
   in equiatomic	
  multicomponent	
  alloys.	
  Mat.	
  Sci.	
  Engng	
  A	
  2004;375-­-377:213	
  -­-	
  218.
- [3] Wei	
   Q, Wanderka,	
   N,	
   Schubert-­-Bischoff	
   P,	
   Macht	
   MP,	
   Friedrich	
   S.	
   Crystallization phases	
   of	
   the	
   Zr41Ti14Cu12.5Ni10Be22.5	
   alloy	
   after	
   slow	
   solidification.	
   J.	
   Mater.	
   Res. 2000;15:1729-­-1734.
- [4]	
  Morniroli	
  JP,	
  Steeds	
  JW.	
  Microdiffraction	
  as	
  a	
  tool	
  for	
  crystal	
  structure	
  identification and	
  determination.	
  Ultramic.	
  1992;45:219-­-239.
- [5] Senkov	
   ON,	
   Scott	
   JM, Senkova	
   SV,	
   Miracle	
   DB,	
   Woodward	
   CF.	
   Refractory	
   high-­entropy	
  alloys.	
  Intermetallics	
  2010;18:1758-­-1765.
- [6]	
  Yang	
  X,	
  Zhang	
  Y.	
  Prediction	
  of	
  high-­-entropy	
  stabilized	
  solid-­-solution	
  multicomponent alloys.	
  Mat.	
  Chem.	
  Phys.	
  2012;	
  132:	
  233	
  -	
  238.
- [7]	
   Miracle	
   DB,	
   Miller	
   JD,	
   Senkov	
   ON,	
   Woodward	
   C,	
   Uchic	
   MD,	
   Tiley	
   J.	
   Exploration	
   and development	
   of	
   high	
   entropy	
   alloys	
   for	
   structural	
   applications.	
   Entropy	
   2014;16:494-­525.
- [8]	
  Takeuchi	
  A,	
  Inoue	
  A.	
  Classification	
  of	
  bulk	
  metallic	
  glasses	
  by	
  atomic	
  size	
  difference, heat	
  of	
  mixing	
  and	
  period	
  of	
  constituent	
  elements	
  and	
  its	
  application	
  to	
  characterization of	
  the	
  main	
  alloying	
  element.	
  Mat.	
  Trans.	
  2005;46:	
  2817	
  -	
  2829.
- [9]	
   Jensen	
   J,	
   Mackintosh	
  AR.	
  Rare	
  earth	
  magnetism:	
  Structures	
  and	
  excitations.	
  Oxford: Clarendon	
  press;	
  1991.
- [10] Gao MC, Alman DE. Searching for next single-­-phase high-­-entropy alloy compositions.	
  Entropy	
  2013;	
  15:	
  4504	
  -	
  4519.
Michael Feuerbacher Markus Heidelmann Carsten Thomas
Hexagonal High-Entropy Alloys
We report on the discovery of a high-entropy alloy with a hexagonal crystal
structure. Equiatomic samples in the alloy system Ho-Dy-Y-Gd-Tb were found to
solidify as homogeneous single-phase high-entropy alloys. The results of our
electron diffraction investigations and high-resolution scanning transmission
electron microscopy are consistent with a Mg-type hexagonal structure. The
possibility of hexagonal high-entropy alloys in other alloy systems is
discussed.