## Comment on ' K d -→ π Σ n reactions and structure of the Λ(1405) ' by S. Ohnishi, Y. Ikeda, T. Hyodo, E. Hiyama, W. Weise

J. R´ evai 1 and N.V. Shevchenko 2

1 Wigner Research Center for Physics, RMI, H-1525 Budapest, P.O.B. 49, Hungary 2 Nuclear Physics Institute, 25068 Reˇ z, ˇ Czech Republic (Dated: August 5, 2014)

PACS numbers:

We are astonished by the main statement of the paper [1]:

'We report on the first results of a full three-body calculation of the ¯ KNN → πY N amplitude for the K d -→ π Σ n reaction, and examine how the Λ(1405) resonance manifests itself in the neutron energy distributions of the K d -→ π Σ n reactions.'

A calculation of the same reaction within the same theoretical framework and with the same goal was reported at several international conferences and published in [2] without being mentioned in [1].

The ¯ KN potentials applied in the two calculations differ from each other, the quality of their reproduction of experimental data favors those of [2]. In addition, a doubtful approximation was used in the potentials of some of the authors of [1] in their previous papers, which, as it seems, were used in [1] too. A discussion on this issue can be found in [3].

The original parts of [1] in comparison with [2] are higher partial waves and an energy-dependent potential. From this point of view [1] seems to be a natural extension of the work done in [2]. However the use of nonrelativistic AGS equations for initial kaon momentum 1 GeV/c is highly questionable. Therefore, the realization of the author's promise to take relativistic corrections into account should have preceded the publication.

- [1] S. Ohnishi, Y. Ikeda, T. Hyodo, E. Hiyama, W. Weise, ' Kd → π Σ n reactions and structure of the Λ(1405)', arXiv:1408.0118 (2014)
- [2] J. R´ evai, 'Signature of the Λ(1405) resonance in neutron spectra from the K -+ d reaction', Few-Body Syst. 54 (2013) 1865
- [3] J. R´ evai, N.V. Shevchenko, 'Faddeev calculations of the ¯ KNN system with chirally-motivated ¯ KN interaction. II. The Kpp quasi-bound state', arXiv:1403.0757 (2014)
J. Révai N. V. Shevchenko
Comment on "K^- d -> pi Sigma n reactions and structure of the Lambda(1405)" by S. Ohnishi, Y. Ikeda, T. Hyodo, E. Hiyama, W. Weise
We strongly doubt the claimed priority of this work as the first full
three-body calculation of the considered reaction.