IN THE SUPREME COURT OF PAKISTAN 
(Appellate Jurisdiction) 
 
 
Present: 
Mr. Justice Iftikhar Muhammad Chaudhry, CJ 
Mr. Justice Ijaz Ahmed Chaudhry  
Mr. Justice Gulzar Ahmed 
 
 
Criminal Petition No.213 of 2013 
[On appeal against the order dated 17.05.2013, 
passed by the Lahore High Court, Lahore, in 
Crl.Misc.No.701-H/2013] 
 
Mst. Rasoolan 
Petitioner(s) 
VERSUS 
SHO, Head Marala, Sialkot etc 
Respondent(s) 
 
 
Petitioner 
: In person 
For Respondents No.1,3 & 5 
: Mr. Jawwad Hassan, Addl.A.G. 
Mr. Muhammad Gohar Nafees, DPO, Sialkot. 
Mr. Muhammad Shahbaz, DSP (L) 
Mr. Safdar Hussain, Inspector/SHO,  
P.S. Head Marala, Sialkot. 
Mr. Muhamad Zubair, SI, PS Head Marala. 
Ms. Nazia, Lady Constable with the detenues 
Muhammad Ashraf, Muhammad Akram, Aman 
Ullah, Asma Bibi, Uzma Rani, Rafia Rani, Azhra 
Rani and Sufian. 
 
For Respondents No.2 & 4 
: NR 
Date of Hearing 
: 03.07.2013 
 
ORDER 
IFTIKHAR MUHAMMAD CHAUDHRY, CJ.—In response to our 
order dated 27.06.2013, Mr. Gohar Nafees, DPO, Sialkot, 
appeared and produced the alleged abductees namely Aman 
Ullah, Muhammad Akram, Rafia Rani and Azhra Rani (minors) 
aged about 4-5 years.  According to him, they were available on 
the brick Killen of Naveed Elahi Gujjar at Kotli Sattian, Sialkot, 
Crl.P.No.213 of 2013 
- 2 - 
 
where they were living of their free will.  However, when we 
inquired from Aman Ullah, the alleged abductee, as to how he has 
reached at the brick killen of Naveed Elahi Gujjar, he explained 
that he had received an advance (          ) of Rs.200,000/-  from 
one Muhammad Asghar the owner of brick killen at Head Marala, 
Sialkot, who sent him to Gujranwala on the brick killen of Rana 
Mehmood ul Hassan and he paid an amount of Rs.400,000/- to 
Muhamad Asghar.  Subsequent thereto Rana Mehmood ul Hassan 
sent him, his brother and two minors again to Sialkot on the brick 
killen of Naveed Elahi Gujjar, who had paid an amount of 
Rs.400,000/- to Rana Mehmood ul Hassan.  As far as the minors 
are concerned, according to him they were also living with him on 
the same brick killen.  Both the minors have been produced in the 
Court, they seem to be children of 4-5 years old.  Therefore, we 
inquired from a lady namely Mst.Asma, who has also been 
produced in the Court, she stated that she was also living on the 
same brick killen but after some time she changed her statement 
and deposed that she along with her son namely Sufian aged 
about 5-6 years and a suckling daughter namely Uzma as well as 
Muhammad Ashraf, who is brother of Aman Ullah, were recovered 
from Minar-e-Pakistan.  In the report which has been submitted 
by the DPO, there are two contradictions, one of them has been 
mentioned herein above relating to the confinement and 
abduction against payment of paishgi by Aman Ullah and others 
Crl.P.No.213 of 2013 
- 3 - 
 
and second is in respect of the recovery of Muhammad Ashraf 
and Mst. Asma from the jurisdiction of Police Station Lorry Adda, 
Lahore, where according to the report of the DPO, they were 
found near gate No.1 of Minar-e-Pakistan, Lahore. 
2. 
 
Prima-facie, false statement has been placed on record 
under the signatures of the DPO, as the contents of the report are 
not supported by the facts noted herein above including the one 
that how it was possible for him to effect the recovery from gate 
No.1, Minar-e-Pakistan, Lahore, when he himself is saying that 
they are resident of village chharar, Ghazi Road, Lahore Cantt.  
Such statement cannot be accepted which has been filed without 
any basis and apparently is far away from the truth which is now 
coming on record.  On our query, he has placed on record extract 
of report No.36, Police Station Lorry Adda, Lahore, where Safdar 
Hussain, Inspector/SHO Police Station Head Marala, Sialkot 
visited the said Police Station for the purpose of effecting 
recovery of Mst.Asma and others.  The relationships in this report 
have also been written incorrectly.  We inquired from Muhammad 
Akram, who was stated to be with them that how he is happened 
to be at gate No.1 of Minar-e-Pakistan, he stated that he is 
resident of village chharar from where he came along with 
rickshaw driver and Mst. Asma also accompanied them along with 
her suckling child Uzma and Sufian aged about 4/5 years.  
Similarly, he has also placed on record another report compiled 
Crl.P.No.213 of 2013 
- 4 - 
 
by Safdar Hussain, Inspector/SHO, for effecting recovery of 
Muhammad Ashraf, Mst. Asma, Sufian and Uzma from gate No.1 
of Minar-e-Pakistan, Lahore.  The same may be kept on record.  
Apparently contradictory and false statement has been filed 
without conducting thorough inquiry by the DPO, under his 
signatures.   
3. 
 
In such view of the matter, we direct the Inspector 
General of Police, Punjab, to take cognizance of this matter and 
submit a comprehensive report by appearing in person on 8th 
July, 2013.  A copy of this order along with the reports and 
annexures which have been placed on record be sent to him. 
4. 
 
The DPO is also directed to place on record the report 
of departure of Safdar Hussain from his Police Station to Police 
Station Lorry Adda, Lahore, on 29.06.2013. 
5. 
 
As the detenues mentioned hereinabove have been 
recovered, therefore, to their extent no further proceedings are 
called for.  
6. 
 
Adjourned to 08.07.2013. 
 
 
 
 
 
Chief Justice 
 
 
 
 
Islamabad 
Judge 
03.07.2013 
*Hashmi* 
Judge 
Crl.P.No.213 of 2013 
- 5 - 
 
 
