Vincent Wan, a doctoral candidate at the Sun Yat-sen Academic Institute if the Chinese Culture University, whose dissertation is on Taiwan's television culture, wrote a letter to the newspaper accusing the producers and hosts of Red and White Victory of "false charity."
以台灣電視文化為研究主題的中國文化大學中山學術研究所博士班研究生汪子錫，就曾針對《紅白勝利》投書報社，指責節目製作單位與主持人「偽善」。