The newborn child had a deformed right arm. She believed that this was a result of the doctor forcefully pulling the child when she was having a difficult delivery. The following year, she went to Taipei District Court and accused the hospital of malpractice. However, she lost her lawsuit.
住在台北的婦人譚昌蘭，民國八十三年在馬偕醫院生產，產下的新生兒右手殘廢，她認為是接生醫師在她難產時用力拉出嬰兒所致，次年，到法院控告醫院業務過失，但遭敗訴。