With a background in the history of the Liao, Chin, and Yuan dynasties, he indicates that, because there is only this one existing family history, which leaves many key questions unanswered, it is impossible to determine whether Taiwan's Niens are or are not Jurchen descendants. Perhaps it would be possible to make a judgment if there were more relevant historical materials and more in-depth research.
他認為，因為粘氏族譜僅此一本，有些關鍵問題記載又十分簡略，因此，他也很難斷定粘氏是或不是女真族的後代，或許等材料更多、有更深入的研究時才能斷言。是不是女真族，沒關係！