Hsieh Kuo-hsiung, a research fellow at Academia Sinica's Institute of Social Sciences, has doubts. "This approach overlooks a fundamental point: in Taiwan, labor and capital have never been equal in status, and if they are not on an equal footing, how can one expect negotiations between them to be fair?"
中央研究院社會所研究員謝國雄表示質疑：「這種作法忽略了最重要的一點﹘ ﹘台灣的勞資雙方從來沒有對等過；勞資地位不對等，又如何能期望據此做出公平的協商？」