Huang thinks that such a punishment is unjust: "There are dangerous elements in society, and children have to learn how to get along with every kind of personality. Especially when education is a right, you can't strip a child of the right to study with others because he or she hit another child."
洪儷瑜認為，這樣的判決似乎不太妥當，「社會上本來就處處有危險份子，每個人都要學會和各種性格的人相處；何況教育是天賦人權，不能因為孩子打人，就剝奪他與其他人一起受教的權利。」