Xarithe is technically an outsider actually, so by the rules is immune to such spells as well.<br/><br/>Spell resistance still comes into play of course :3<br/><br/>It could understandably be difficult to remember what spells effect what characters. ((for instance reduce person was used on Ambrosia earlier in the fight, it failed but by the book wouldn't have effected her......I actually think her final sheet ended up being an outsider as well, could be mistaken about this.))<br/><br/>It's not like Gorun is deceptive about what he is, so his appearance couldn't be assumed to dupe the kitsune into using a spell designed to effect only humanoids....and had she known what he was the kitsune could just as easily substitute a number of other spells to produce a similar if not worse effect on Gorun.......<br/><br/>The way I see it there are three possible solutions. #1 it works (( and is either house ruled, or shall not work again in the future, a freebie if you will ))  , #2 it doesn't work and the kitsune has effectively wasted another turn (( liberating command is only an immediate action, as such she could have used another spell or action in that turn. )) , or #3 she simply swaps the spell for something else entirely.<br/><br/>Alternatively she could fail to get through the spell resistance XD<br/><br/>Sansuki's call ultimately of course.