You are telling me Anime! I totally forgot you could chose to do non-lethal damage in Pathfinder with a -4 penalty, until after I had rolled my crit! And by that point, it was too late, the die had been cast. I had atleast hoped Cadrick would have just been knocked down by the slap, not incapacitated by the damage to the tree, and then actually hit with the crit confirmation! >.<