{Not at all! In this case, Samantha specified her action - ‘get him to attempt to seduce me’, and attacked. Had she succeeded, you would’ve been compelled to attempt to seduce her (i.e, make sexual attacks against her). She failed, so you get to do what you will… since you’re under attack, some kind of response is indicated… that could be to run (physical attack against her with success being a successful flight), to rationally talk her into not seducing you (mental attack), or straightforwardly to try to seduce her… normally you can’t make two attacks in one round (you did sexual and mental), but on this occasion I’ll let it stand}.<br/><br/><span style="font-weight: bold">Samantha Belweather</span><br/><br/><span style="font-weight: bold">Sam’s Mental Defence prevents 1 damage, she is reduced to 2 mental HP<br/><br/>“Why Jules,” Samantha <span style="font-style: italic">bats her eyelashes</span> at you, “how sweet of you. Tell me… is this a practice date, or a real one?” She continues, running one fingertip down the line of her blouse, well onto the soft full curve of her breasts. “A boy could get into serious trouble seducing his boss, you know.” <br/><br/>[b]Sexual attack to fluster Jules, rolled 1 and a 2… </span>I had in mind that if she defeated Jules here, she would pick the date, which could be to Jules disadvantage. Jules defeating her could allow him to pick the date (but originally, this conflict was about going on a date at all, so we’ll see where it goes!)