Kate was beside herself. She brought this from the brink of death and he seemed to welcome death that come on the field of honor. Kate stood before her brother, "I beg you do not challenge him. He wants to die. Johh I am sworn by oath as a healer to let him live. I gave my work he would be safe. He speaks the truth. Malora gave him to me and I have a letter. Please don't fight him. He deserves the same chance Papa had. "<br/><br/>Johh at first stood up and after hearing Kate plea he sits down. "For now Kate he lives. It will up to Father to decide his fate. I hope all our sakes he can be trusted." The knight walks out and calls forth his father's Captain of the guard. "I want this man under guard. Not for what he may do. For what I and other men my do to end his life. Against better judgement this man may live under Kate's care. He is not to be harm."<br/><br/>The captain salutes him and two guards walk in after Johnathan. "You are under my sister's protection. No one will harm and these men are for your protections."<br/><br/>Kate sits down and motions for Mathis to sit next to her. Ann hands him another plate of venison with fresh fruit. "Eat dear."