Caedrin's rising anger at the thief accompanied by Brinn's actions made for an extremely awkward situation, but he did his best to ignore the fingers poking and prodding him in various ways, keeping his focus on the thief. He was about to deny her request, but reconsidered when she mentioned coming quietly. Considering the girl was a shapeshifter, it was very possible that whatever item she wanted had some kind of special property that would aid in her future escape, so he considered his options carefully. "Exactly what item is it you want, and why do you feel you deserve any sort of mercy and kindness after what you have done?" he asked with a sneer. Of course, mercy was something he offered any person or creature, no matter their transgression, but he still wanted to hear her reasoning.