The Doom of Devorgoil
On April 26, 1829, after Scott had spent several days working on "Anne of Geierstein", he sought to distract himself with something else. According to Scott's account:
The play was written "for the purpose of obliging the late Mr. Terry, then Manager of the Adelphi Theatre, for whom the Author had a particular regard". However, it was not performed, because "[t]he manner in which the mimic goblins of Devorgoil are intermixed with the supernatural machinery, was found to be objectionable, and the production had other faults, which rendered it unfit for representation". In April 1830, Scott further wrote of the play: The "Edinburgh Literary Journal", in its review of the play, summarized the plot as follows: The play was poorly received, with the "Edinburgh Literary Journal" suggesting that Scott should have thrown both "Doom of Devorgoil" and "Auchindrane" into the fire rather than publishing them. The "Journal" reported that for both plays the plot was "exceedingly bare and meagre", and that "Doom of Devorgoil" was "in particular wofully deficient in interest", with a catastrophic event central to the plot "clumsily and abruptly brought about". The "Journal" further stated that "[n]one of the characters are well, or fully, drawn. The three females are positively disagreeable, for they are made to talk in a petulant and unbecoming manner, quite foreign to the gentleness usually belonging to their sex, and consequently effectually checking our interest in them".
History
The play was one of Scott's few critical failures.