 When I reviewed Facebook's Oculus Rift in 2016, I thought it might be the start of something huge. But VR hasn't blown up the way a lot of fans hoped. Superdata estimated that around 354,000 Rifts shipped in 2018, and around 4.2 million headsets shipped across all the major brands. For contrast, Sony alone shipped more than 17 million PlayStation 4s that year. VR had a long history in training, medicine, design, and research before the Oculus Rift, and it's still big in those fields. But home entertainment is another matter. A lot of VR headsets are still expensive, or they're not very comfortable, or they're just sort of weird and isolating. But Facebook, of course, thinks it has the answer with the Oculus Quest, a completely standalone VR system that doesn't need wires, tracking cameras, or a separate computer, and can play full-fledged immersive games. The Quest is basically Facebook's vision of an ideal VR gaming console right now. It solves some of the problems that have kept VR on the margins, but it's also a compromise. The Oculus Quest's first big selling point is something called the Insight System. It uses four built-in cameras to track your head motion and a pair of hand controllers, instead of making you set up a whole VR room with mounted cameras. But there's a new Oculus Rift that uses Insight too, so the Quest's big unique selling point is that it's self-contained. The Quest isn't connected to a computer, and you can use it basically anywhere indoors, as long as you're not completely in the dark. Oculus thinks this makes a huge difference, and I agree. I've been using VR for a long time, and I've gotten used to stepping around wires. But not having to worry about tripping while I'm jumping around a sports game, or pausing an adventure game to face the cameras, feels even better than I thought it would. The battery lasts around two hours playing games nonstop, which is longer than most of my VR sessions. Oculus already has an all-in-one headset called the Oculus Go, but it doesn't have the Quest's sophisticated tracking, and it's meant more for watching movies in VR, which people keep telling me they like, but I still just can't get into. The Quest supports some of the best games for just moving your body, like the rock climbing game The Climb, the awesome rhythm game Beat Saber, which is like Dance Dance Revolution with lightsabers, and a new VR version of the Kinect game Dance Central. There were a lot of questions about whether the Quest's tracking and latency would work as well as the Rift. After all, you need to keep your controllers in view of the Quest's wide-angle cameras, and you don't have a powerful gaming PC to run the games. But my experience has been good so far. The Quest has been responsive and precise enough to play a fast-moving game like Beat Saber. My controllers have occasionally lost tracking for a moment, but that also happened with the Rift's old external cameras. A lot of companies have either released or announced self-contained headsets, but in our experience, they're rough around the edges. They're mostly geared toward businesses where people don't always need to have fun using them. If you are using VR for fun, you want a seamless experience, and that's what Oculus is trying to deliver here. It's simplified things that used to be annoying. You can just draw a line to set up virtual boundaries, for instance, instead of physically walking around the room. Like the Oculus Go, once the setup's done, you can pretty much just pick it up and start playing. But unfortunately, the Quest still has some problems that basically no VR company has cracked. The screen is higher resolution than the Rift, but it's still a little grainy. There's a whole computer and four cameras in the headset, so it weighs substantially more than the Rift. If I don't adjust it just right, my head starts hurting very quickly. And look, I've used VR a lot, but I still feel silly and socially awkward wearing the Quest. Oculus has tried to make the experience more natural by adding a casting feature so people can see what you're seeing through a Chromecast or Nvidia Shield. That doesn't change the fact that you're jumping around a room with something strapped to your face so you can't see other people. I'm not sure anything can change that, and it's still a legitimate barrier. Another problem is that Oculus is owned by Facebook, which is constantly accused of invading users' privacy. Oculus says it's got a strong privacy policy, but VR is by definition tracking your every move. And people might be rightfully hesitant to give that data up. Maybe it doesn't matter, if the content's good enough. The Quest is launching with about 50 titles, and it's bringing over some of the Rift's greatest hits. But it doesn't include some of the Rift's biggest, most gorgeous upcoming games. It's still got the computing power of a mobile headset, and if you want to guarantee that you'll get all the latest and best VR experiences, it still seems like the Rift is your only option. Oculus seems to be betting that a lot of people will be happy with a convenient, lower-powered headset that plays a smaller number of smaller games. That's a bet that honestly very few companies are making right now. HTC and Microsoft are mostly focused on selling to businesses, and Google hasn't said much about its Daydream platform lately. Nintendo just released a very cool VR headset kit for the Switch, but it's more of a clever toy than a whole new platform. Sony is the one company that's making the same play as Oculus. It's pushed out a lot of games for the PlayStation VR, which isn't the most powerful tethered headset, but is the most successful. It's sold more than 4 million units since 2016. Oculus could tap into that market with something that's even more convenient, and at $399, the Quest doesn't cost too much more than the PlayStation VR. I like using the Quest, and I think it's a good compromise headset for people who want several of the best VR games on the market that aren't worried about missing some titles. But I'm not sure it's overcome some of VR's basic clunkiness and social awkwardness, and that makes it hard to see as the next big gaming platform. So what's the non-VR game that you really, really want to play in VR? For me, it's the fighting game Xeno Clash, because that game's incredibly weird, and I love punching things in VR. But let me know what you think.