  Matija Cuk et.al (2016) have proposed a new model for the birth and tidal
evolution of our natural satellite Moon, born from impact generated terrestrial
debris in the equatorial plane of high obliquity, high angular momentum Earth.
This paper examines their findings critically in the light of advanced
kinematic model (AKM) which includes Earth's obliquity (\phi), Moon's orbital
plane inclination (\alpha) , Moon's obliquity (\beta) and lunar's orbit
eccentricity (e). For the real Earth-Moon (E-M) system, the history of
evolution of \phi, \alpha, \beta, e and (length of month)/(length of day) or
LOM/LOD is traced from 45R_{E} to 60.33R_{E} where R_{E} is Earth Radius. It is
shown that AKM's valid range of application is from 45R_{E} to 60.33R_{E} . The
evolution of {\alpha}, \beta, e is in correspondence with the simulation
results of Matija Cuk et.al (2016) but evolution of Earth's obliquity has a
break at 45R_{E} . According to AKM , earlier than 45RE Earth should achieve
zero degree obliquity in order to achieve the modern value of 23.44{\deg}
obliquity. Cuk et al (2016) do not explain how this can be achieved.AKM stands
vindicated because using protocol exchange algorithm (described in S6 SOM), AKM
has successfully given precise theoretical formalism of Observed LOD curve for
the last 1.2Gy time span opening the way for early warning and forecasting
methods for Earth-quake and sudden volcanic eruptions(See S7 of SOM).

Earth and Planetary Astrophysics