  Heyl (2000) made an interesting suggestion that the observed shifts in QPO
frequency in type I X-ray bursts could be influenced by the same geometrical
effect of strong gravity as the one that causes centrifugal force reversal
discovered by Abramowicz and Lasota (1974). However, his main result contains a
sign error. Here we derive the correct formula and conclude that constraints on
the M(R) relation for neutron stars deduced from the rotational-modulation
model of QPO frequency shifts are of no practical interest because the correct
formula implies a weak condition R* > 1.3 Rs, where Rs is the Schwarzschild
radius. We also argue against the relevance of the rotational-modulation model
to the observed frequency modulations.

Astrophysics