That's ___!” (angry denial)
nyt	2004	ALIE	Live ___ (be someone you're not)
nyt	2004	ALIEN	Being from beyond Earth
nyt	2004	ALIEN	Faraway
nyt	2004	ALIEN	Native's opposite
nyt	2004	ALIEN	Non-earthling
nyt	2004	ALIEN	Not natural
nyt	2004	ALIEN	Roswell crash victim, supposedly
nyt	2004	ALIEN	Roswell crash victim, supposedly
nyt	2004	ALIEN	Story penned by an extraterrestrial (5)
nyt	2004	ALIEN	Unearthly
nyt	2004	ALIEN	Unfamiliar
nyt	2004	ALIEN	Unfamiliar
nyt	2004	ALIEN	Venusian, e.g.
nyt	2004	ALIENEE	Heir, in legal terminology
nyt	2004	ALIENEE	Legal heir, at times
nyt	2004	ALIENEE	Property receiver, in law
nyt	2004	ALIENOR	Property seller
nyt	2004	ALIENRACES	Vulcans and others
nyt	2004	ALIENRACES	Vulcans and others
nyt	2004	ALIENS	Saucers may hold them
nyt	2004	ALIFE	Get ___!" ("Stop being so dweebish!"): 2 wds.
The 4th letter is E
The 1st letter is A
The 3rd letter is I