over successive time-steps, so later time-steps are normalized over all present and previous timesteps. This also proved ineffective and greatly complicated backpropagation.
We ﬁnd that sequence-wise normalization [37] overcomes these issues. The recurrent computation
is given by !hl
t=f(B(Wlhl1
t) + !Ul !hl
t1). (8)
For each hidden unit, we compute the mean and variance statistics over all items in the minibatch
over the length of the sequence. Figure 2 shows that deep networks converge faster with sequencewise normalization. Table 1 shows that the performance improvement from sequence-wise normalization increases with the depth of the network, with a 12% performance difference for the deepest
network. When comparing depth, in order to control for model size we hold constant the total
6
50 100 150 200 250 300
Iteration ( ⇥103)2030405060Cost5-1 BN
5-1 No BN
9-7 BN
9-7 No BNFigure 2: Training curves of two models trained with and without BatchNorm. We start the plot after the ﬁrst
epoch of training as the curve is more difﬁcult to interpret due to the SortaGrad curriculum method mentioned
in Section 3.3
Train Dev
We show that an end-to-end deep learning approach can be used to recognize
either English or Mandarin Chinese speech--two vastly different languages.
Because it replaces entire pipelines of hand-engineered components with neural
networks, end-to-end learning allows us to handle a diverse variety of speech
including noisy environments, accents and different languages. Key to our
approach is our application of HPC techniques, resulting in a 7x speedup over
our previous system. Because of this efficiency, experiments that previously
took weeks now run in days. This enables us to iterate more quickly to identify
superior architectures and algorithms. As a result, in several cases, our
system is competitive with the transcription of human workers when benchmarked
on standard datasets. Finally, using a technique called Batch Dispatch with
GPUs in the data center, we show that our system can be inexpensively deployed
in an online setting, delivering low latency when serving users at scale.
Dario Amodei Rishita Anubhai Eric Battenberg Carl Case Jared Casper Bryan Catanzaro Jingdong Chen Mike Chrzanowski Adam Coates Greg Diamos Erich Elsen Jesse Engel Linxi Fan Christopher Fougner Tony Han Awni Hannun Billy Jun Patrick LeGresley Libby Lin Sharan Narang Andrew Ng Sherjil Ozair Ryan Prenger Jonathan Raiman Sanjeev Satheesh David Seetapun Shubho Sengupta Yi Wang Zhiqian Wang Chong Wang Bo Xiao Dani Yogatama Jun Zhan Zhenyao Zhu