76.6%
75.4%
71.1%77.7%
77.3%
76.7%
73.9%
no position
with position
Figure 4. Effect of relative position embeddings as the ratio
of attentional channels increases on our Attention-Augmented
ResNet50.
Importance of position encodings: In Figure 4, we show
the effect of our proposed two-dimensional relative position encodings as a function of the fraction of attentional
channels. As expected, experiments demonstrate that our
relative position encodings become increasingly more important as the architecture employs more attentional channels. In particular, the fully self-attentional ResNet-50 gains
2.8% top-1 ImageNet accuracy when using relative position
encodings, which indicates the necessity of maintaining position information for fully self-attentional vision models.
We additionally compare our proposed two-dimensional
Architecture Position Encodings top-1 top-5
AA-ResNet-34 None 74.4 91.9
AA-ResNet-34 2d Sine 74.4 92.0
AA-ResNet-34 CoordConv 74.4 92.0
AA-ResNet-34 Relative (ours) 74.7 92.0
AA-ResNet-50 None 77.5 93.7
Convolutional networks have been the paradigm of choice in many computer
vision applications. The convolution operation however has a significant
weakness in that it only operates on a local neighborhood, thus missing global
information. Self-attention, on the other hand, has emerged as a recent advance
to capture long range interactions, but has mostly been applied to sequence
modeling and generative modeling tasks. In this paper, we consider the use of
self-attention for discriminative visual tasks as an alternative to
convolutions. We introduce a novel two-dimensional relative self-attention
mechanism that proves competitive in replacing convolutions as a stand-alone
computational primitive for image classification. We find in control
experiments that the best results are obtained when combining both convolutions
and self-attention. We therefore propose to augment convolutional operators
with this self-attention mechanism by concatenating convolutional feature maps
with a set of feature maps produced via self-attention. Extensive experiments
show that Attention Augmentation leads to consistent improvements in image
classification on ImageNet and object detection on COCO across many different
models and scales, including ResNets and a state-of-the art mobile constrained
network, while keeping the number of parameters similar. In particular, our
method achieves a $1.3\%$ top-1 accuracy improvement on ImageNet classification
over a ResNet50 baseline and outperforms other attention mechanisms for images
such as Squeeze-and-Excitation. It also achieves an improvement of 1.4 mAP in
COCO Object Detection on top of a RetinaNet baseline.
Irwan Bello Barret Zoph Ashish Vaswani Jonathon Shlens Quoc V. Le