and Bowman (2019); Brunet et al. (2019); Cao
and Daumé (2019); Chaloner and Maldonado
(2019); Cho et al. (2019); Dev and Phillips (2019);
Font and Costa-jussà (2019); Gonen and Goldberg
(2019); James-Sorenson and Alvarez-Melis (2019);
Kaneko and Bollegala (2019); Karve et al. (2019);
Kurita et al. (2019); Lauscher and Glavaš (2019);
Lee et al. (2019); Manzini et al. (2019); Mayﬁeld
Categories
NLP task Stated motivation Motivations Techniques
Language
modeling
(Bordia and
Bowman,
2019)“Existing biases in data can be ampliﬁed by models and the
resulting output consumed by the public can inﬂuence them ,encourage and reinforce harmful stereotypes , ordistort the truth .
Automated systems that depend on these models can take problematic actions based on biased proﬁling of individuals. ”Allocational
harms,
stereotypingQuestionable
correlations
Sentiment
analysis
(Kiritchenko
and
Mohammad,
We survey 146 papers analyzing "bias" in NLP systems, finding that their
motivations are often vague, inconsistent, and lacking in normative reasoning,
despite the fact that analyzing "bias" is an inherently normative process. We
further find that these papers' proposed quantitative techniques for measuring
or mitigating "bias" are poorly matched to their motivations and do not engage
with the relevant literature outside of NLP. Based on these findings, we
describe the beginnings of a path forward by proposing three recommendations
that should guide work analyzing "bias" in NLP systems. These recommendations
rest on a greater recognition of the relationships between language and social
hierarchies, encouraging researchers and practitioners to articulate their
conceptualizations of "bias"---i.e., what kinds of system behaviors are
harmful, in what ways, to whom, and why, as well as the normative reasoning
underlying these statements---and to center work around the lived experiences
of members of communities affected by NLP systems, while interrogating and
reimagining the power relations between technologists and such communities.
Su Lin Blodgett Solon Barocas Hal Daumé III Hanna Wallach