eective local minimum ), but that diculty can be overcome if another agent provides hints
of the importance of learning other, intermediate-level abstractions which are relevant to the
task.
Many interesting questions remain open. Would a network without any guiding hint eventually nd the solution with a enough training time and/or with alternate parametrizations?
To what extent is ill-conditioning a core issue? The results with LBFGS were disappointing but
changes in the architectures (such as standardization of the intermediate level) seem to make
training much easier. Clearly, one can reach good solutions from an appropriate initialization,
pointing in the direction of an issue with local minima, but it may be that good solutions are
also reachable from other initializations, albeit going through a tortuous ill-conditioned path
in parameter space. Why did our attempts at learning the intermediate concepts in an unsupervised way fail? Are these results specic to the task we are testing or a limitation of the
unsupervised feature learning algorithm tested? Trying with many more unsupervised variants and exploring explanatory hypotheses for the observed failures could help us answer that.
Finally, and most ambitious, can we solve these kinds of problems if we allow a community
of learners to collaborate and collectively discover and combine partial solutions in order to
obtain solutions to more abstract tasks like the one presented here? Indeed, we would like to
We explore the effect of introducing prior information into the intermediate
level of neural networks for a learning task on which all the state-of-the-art
machine learning algorithms tested failed to learn. We motivate our work from
the hypothesis that humans learn such intermediate concepts from other
individuals via a form of supervision or guidance using a curriculum. The
experiments we have conducted provide positive evidence in favor of this
hypothesis. In our experiments, a two-tiered MLP architecture is trained on a
dataset with 64x64 binary inputs images, each image with three sprites. The
final task is to decide whether all the sprites are the same or one of them is
different. Sprites are pentomino tetris shapes and they are placed in an image
with different locations using scaling and rotation transformations. The first
part of the two-tiered MLP is pre-trained with intermediate-level targets being
the presence of sprites at each location, while the second part takes the
output of the first part as input and predicts the final task's target binary
event. The two-tiered MLP architecture, with a few tens of thousand examples,
was able to learn the task perfectly, whereas all other algorithms (include
unsupervised pre-training, but also traditional algorithms like SVMs, decision
trees and boosting) all perform no better than chance. We hypothesize that the
optimization difficulty involved when the intermediate pre-training is not
performed is due to the {\em composition} of two highly non-linear tasks. Our
findings are also consistent with hypotheses on cultural learning inspired by
the observations of optimization problems with deep learning, presumably
because of effective local minima.
Çağlar Gülçehre Yoshua Bengio