>

Would love a movie with the style and voices from the cartoon
I dont think it would neccesarily suck, if its an animated film I could see it working because you can better capture the atmosphere and elements of the games, however, giving Link a defined personality and a voice would be very bizzarre. >

no Im ok with animated just not western animated unless its by pixar >

Disney is a better choice than Pixar. It's all about what they are going for, but Disney has more experience with fantasy-type settings. The studio that did Arcane was also good. >

You're sitting me right? Disney? The guys who are notorious for going so far away from the original story that it may have well been an original project all along. Tuck Everlasting, Ella Enchanted, artemis Fowl...even when the have brilliant moments like Hell Fire they throw in talking gargoyles who lost after goats. >

Well excuuuuuusssee me Princess! >

Nice job, “hero”. >

Breath of the Wild is basically Princess Mononoke the Video Game, so I don't know if I agree with this. >

If Ghibli did it i would be all for it. >

A TV show would be great but don't do a live action one. >

I've always said this. I don't think it would translate well to film. >

I agree, but I would have said the same thing before seeing how Netflix adapted Arcane and Castlevania. The key is to just loosely use the world to tell your own type of story (instead of worrying about what type of story the games had). >

You comment kind of highlight why a movie adaptation would suck.
It’s too short of a format.
Like I loved both of those shows, but imagine trying to fit season 1 of arcane into a 2 hour movie.  It just wouldn’t work. >

Also, the whole silent protagonist doesn't really work in film. >

If the film was an original story not tied into any games it could just use different-timelines as an excuse for it not to be silent (also maybe it's just me but if a Zelda movie was going to have Link speak I'd want it to go all the way and be a Disney-esque musical and have him sing (and not just because I think Ben Platt would be perfect)) >

all movies based on games suck because you don't get to do anything you just have to sit there and watch.