>

You also have your entire body  for a soccer ball, excluding the hands I guess. With a baseball you gotta kiss it with a few " wide piece of metal.  Smaller point of contact. 
A baseball would be much firmer than a soccer ball. At those speeds a body shot from either would disable you from the game for a while I'd imagine. You'd at least limp.
What percent of shots on goal do goalies save, on average? >

What percent of shots on goal do goalies save, on average? >

Your forgetting a baseball is a lot smaller then a soccer ball and rarely travels in a straight line. >


rarely travels in a straight line.

The same argument can be made (2:40).
Link