1. e2e4  1... e7e6 \"I surprised him in the opening for sure.\" (Caruana) 2. d2d4  2... d7d5  3. b1c3  3... g8f6  4. e4e5  4... f6d7  5. f2f4  5... c7c5  6. g1f3  6... b8c6  7. c1e3  7... c5d4  8. f3d4  8... d8b6 Caruana goes for the pawn grab. 9. d1d2  9... b6b2  10. a1b1  10... b2a3  11. c3b5  11... a3a2 Grabbing a second pawn. 12. b1d1  12... a8b8  13. b5c7  13... e8d8  14. c7b5  14... d7c5  15. f1d3  15... c5d3  16. d2d3  16... c8d7  17. b5d6 [%c_effect d6;square;d6;type;Mistake;persistent;true] Caruana criticized this move. \"I was happy with a draw, and then he played Nd6.\" 17... f8d6  18. e5d6  18... a2c4  19. d3d2  19... f7f6 Paving the way for the king to f7. 20. d4c6  20... b7c6  21. d2a5  21... d8e8  22. a5a7  22... b8b2  23. a7a8 Losing, but at least White wins the rook. It's better to die with a full stomach. 23... e8f7  24. a8h8  24... c4c2 Black is a full rook down, but the white king is unsafe. 25. e3d2  25... c2e4  26. e1f1  26... e4d3  27. f1e1  27... c6c5 Black also has three pawns for the rook. Look at that pawn chain $1 28. h2h4  28... d7b5  29. e1f2  29... b2d2  30. d1d2  30... d3d2 Black wins material. He has two pawns for the exchange and an attack. 31. f2g3  31... d2e3  32. g3h2  32... e3f4 Another pawn. 33. h2g1  33... f4d4  34. g1h2  34... d4h4  35. h2g1  35... h4d4 Four pawns for the exchange. 36. g1h2  36... d4e5 