SUBREDDIT: r/askwomenadvice
TITLE: Can women read guys this easily?
POST: Let me apologize beforehand, this might be a bit unorganized and long but I'm just going off the top of my head because this just happened.

Hi gals, I just got done talking with a girl I work with (we're both 21). Let's call her Karen. To preface the question, here's some background information. I have another friend named Aaron[20/M] who likes a girl named Taylor[22/F] at our workplace. 

Aaron just told a few of us that he had feelings for this girl, which shocked a lot of us, except Karen(she's the only girl in the group, while Taylor's in a different group). Karen apparently knew from the first day that Aaron had feelings for the other girl because of "the way he directed his conversation to her". That's a direct quote. THE FIRST DAY. 

I've made some possible conclusions in my mind already but I would love to hear some feedback 

1) Logical - Karen's quite pretty and has a great personality in my opinion so maybe she has more exposure and knowledge of these situations 

2) Karen made a guess on the first day and it translated into reality, or this was a fluke. (But she did say she was 100% sure)

3) woman's intuition?

4) Karen's an evil witch with unholy magic.
 

In my life, I've been in fights and I've been around gunfire, but NOTHING has scared/shocked me more than what I was just told. I'm just really shocked that she could notice something so subtle so fast because nobody else knew.
TL;DR: 
To all the women on here, I need help understanding how this works. Can y'all really read a guy that easily?