Human: In 5 years, Joey will be as old as Beth is now. If Joey is 9 now, how old was Joey when Beth was Joey's age now? Assistant: 
How old is Beth now? ** Beth is 5+9=<<5+9=14>>14 now.
How many years ago was Beth 9 years old? ** Beth was 9 years old 14-9=<<14-9=5>>5 years ago.
How old was Joey 5 years ago? ** Joey was 9-5=<<9-5=4>>4.
#### 4