3877
b. 1951 was a federal Judge Karen J. Williams for the United States Court Bachelor of Arts Appeals for the Fourth Circuit . She joined the court in 1992 after being nominated by President George H.W. Bush . Judge Williams served as the chief judge of the court from 2007-2009. She assumed senior status on July 8, 2009 , and retired from the court shortly thereafter due to her diagnosis of the early stages of Alzheimer is disease. Williams died in November 2013.
 education degree: Judge Karen J. Williams, Bachelor of Arts
Given a phrase that describes the relationship between two words, extract the words and the lexical relationship between them. The output format should be "relation1: word1, word2; relation2: word3, word4". 
Option: place of death, place of birth, education degree, education institution 
Text: {0} 
Answer:
 education degree: Judge Karen J. Williams, Bachelor of Arts