22590
 In the 1990 's , the town passed an ordinance stipulating that second-floor space in commercial buildings would be made available , cheap , to artists , and many moved in some local , some New York City transplants , including a former Balanchine set designer-turned-painter Alain Vaes ; a virtuoso printmaker and art historian Carol Wax ; and a sculptor whose work brings Herman Melville together with Hildegard of Bingen , and Emily Dickinson with Marcel Duchamp Carla Rae Johnson . 
 place of birth: Herman Melville, New York City; place of death: Herman Melville, New York City; place lived: Herman Melville, New York City
Given options, please tell me the relationships of all the listed entity pairs.Output format is "relation1: word1, word2; relation2: word3, word4". 
Option: nationality, country capital, place of death, children, location contains, place of birth, place lived, administrative division of country, country of administrative divisions, company, neighborhood of, company founders 
Text: {0} 
 Entity Pairs:  Herman Melville, New York City; Herman Melville, New York City; Herman Melville, New York City 
Answer:
 place of birth: Herman Melville, New York City; place of death: Herman Melville, New York City; place lived: Herman Melville, New York City