41562
Senator Liz Krueger , a Manhattan Democrat , and Assemblyman Thomas Kirwan , a Republican from Newburgh , have now taken the state 's political leaders to court -- arguing before Justice Jane Solomon of State Supreme Court that their ability to represent their constituents had been unfairly and in some cases unconstitutionally limited by Gov. George Pataki ; the Senate majority leader , Joseph Bruno ; and the Assembly speaker , Sheldon Silver .
 place lived: Sheldon Silver, Manhattan
Given options, please tell me the relationships of all the listed entity pairs.Output format is "relation1: word1, word2; relation2: word3, word4". 
Option: ethnicity, place lived, geographic distribution, company industry, country of administrative divisions, administrative division of country, location contains, person of company, profession, ethnicity of people, company shareholder among major shareholders, sports team of location, religion, neighborhood of, company major shareholders, place of death, nationality, children, company founders, company founded place, country of capital, company advisors, sports team location of teams, place of birth 
Text: {0} 
 Entity Pairs:  Sheldon Silver, Manhattan 
Answer:
 place lived: Sheldon Silver, Manhattan