29717
 Because of an editing error , the Metro Matters column yesterday , about the removal of Rashid Khalidi , a Columbia University professor , from a course that advises New York City teachers on how to talk about the Middle East gave an incorrect title in some copies for Ari L. Goldman of Columbia 's Graduate School of Journalism , who criticized the action against Professor Khalidi . 
 place lived: Rashid Khalidi, New York City; company: Ari L. Goldman, Columbia University; place of birth: Rashid Khalidi, New York City; company: Rashid Khalidi, Columbia University
Given options, please tell me the relationships of all the listed entity pairs.Output format is "relation1: word1, word2; relation2: word3, word4". 
Option: nationality, country capital, place of death, children, location contains, place of birth, place lived, administrative division of country, country of administrative divisions, company, neighborhood of, company founders 
Text: {0} 
 Entity Pairs:  Rashid Khalidi, New York City; Ari L. Goldman, Columbia University; Rashid Khalidi, New York City; Rashid Khalidi, Columbia University 
Answer:
 place lived: Rashid Khalidi, New York City; company: Ari L. Goldman, Columbia University; place of birth: Rashid Khalidi, New York City; company: Rashid Khalidi, Columbia University