once he 's gotten the tune , he closes his eyes , opens his arms , and sings : i thought you ' d make my dreams come true but it was n't you , it was n't you i thought this time it would all be new but it was n't you , it was n't you i pictured all the things we ' d do but it was n't you , it was n't you and now i feel my heart is through but it is n't true , it is n't true i may be big-boned and afraid but my faith in love wo n't be mislaid !