Things You Should Never Do, Part I (2000)
If I had superpowers that allowed me to delete one website from the in internet forever, it would be this article.I find the "complete code rewrite" to be the most powerful programming technique I have in my repertoire.In 2007 I wrote an application called FlightLogg.in. It was basically a clone of logshare.com that I wrote in my spare time with PHP. It was my first really 'big' project. You can see the code here: https://github.com/priestc/old-flightlogginIf you look around that codebase, you'll see nothing but spaghetti. I starting writing the app in late 2007, back when you could say I was a 'noob' (so noobish in fact, I didn't even use source control). At the time I thought I was writing the most awesome code ever. By the middle of 2008, that project had reached a state where it was pretty much 'done'. I then stopped working on that codebase, and moved on to other projects.Then by late 2008, FlightLogg.in's traffic had kept growing, and there was a list of bugs and really cool features that I had thought up since I last touched the codebase a few months earlier. I set out to continue development on the PHP codebase. The problem was that in the past few months I've been away, I had become a better programmer, and the sight of that spaghetti code made me vomit.It was less about the code being 'bad', and more about me not remembering how things worked. The small set of fetures and fixes I wanted to make would have taken me a few hours to do back when I was first working on this codebase. Since a few months time had passed, it was taking me much longer.Eventually I decided to do a complete code rewrite. This was before I ever saw that Joel Spolsky article. The new codebase is here: https://github.com/priestc/flightloggin2 It took me roughtly the same amount of time to build the new codebase as it did the old codebase.Ever since, each and every project I take on, I accept the reality of doing a complete code rewrite might come up. For my own personal projects, I do complete code rewrites all the time. On the other hand, at the various jobs I've had over the years, its a much different story. If I came into work today and brought up the idea of doing a complete code rewrite, I'd either get laughed out of the room, or even worse, threatened with being fired, thanks to this Joel Spolsky article. Thanks Joel.