Donald Knuth was framed (2020)
(2020)It seems to me that both McIlroy’s original critique and this blog post miss the point by a mile. It’s completely meaningless to compare the relative merits of the two solutions, because Knuth’s ultimate goal isn’t to produce a solution.Doing a presentation on literate programming has to deal with two more or less contradictory concerns — you need a sufficiently simple problem that your audience can follow along, but you need your solution to be complex enough that you can actually illustrate LP.A sorted frequency table is a simple enough problem statement, a trie is a sufficiently elaborate solution that doesn’t feel too contrived while also being familiar enough that the audience can follow along. Knuth’s approach was pretty much the perfect way to hit both of those requirements!