I was part of a human subject research study without my consent
Can someone help me understand the ethical problem here? If I as an ordinary citizen contacted the webmaster with a similar worded email, the result would have been the same. The fact is that this “experiment” did not create any more or additional stress than is created for normal citizens/businesses simply engaging in normal legal activities. If submitting such a request has the potential to cause such undue stress, shouldn't society create protections or disallow such requests?Edit: It's not that hard to see that there are potentially some social problems here e.g. "the message is easily construed as a legal threat" or "the message was mass mailed in a spam-like nature". However, my comment is in response to the title of the blog post which implies that the webmaster believes there's an ethical problem that this "experiment" was even run in the first place. For the purpose of this thread, assume the email was worded perfectly and the university was very thoughtful and deliberate in who they contacted. I'm interested in discussing the ethics behind how a perfectly legal and reasonable thing can in one case be ethical and another case be unethical simply by virtue of the context in which the action was carried out.