Clearing Up a Few Things About Facebook’s Partners
I assume someone at Facebook, hopefully the person that wrote this, or someone who has more influence over this issue, is reading.I am an engineer. I understand technology better than most of the general population. When I sign in to my Facebook account to use Spotify, I am absolutely not expecting that Spotify will now have access to read every single one of my private messages. This is a gross violation of trust, and if this is what happened, then the fact that you not only made this mistake, but also then published this blog post defending it, marks a low point for Facebook. Perhaps irrecoverably so for me."After signing in to your Facebook account in Spotify’s desktop app, you could then send and receive messages without ever leaving the app. Our API provided partners with access to the person’s messages in order to power this type of feature."This is a write permission. So you needed to give Spotify permission to create a message. It seems that your system combines the read and write permissions, since you just grouped them together by saying "access to the person's messages". It also seems from your defense that you see absolutely no issue with this. In order to share a song through Spotify, you are giving them access to every single private message the user has ever written.I find it hard to believe that Facebook refuses to acknowledge any fault in this: The initial product decision, the upholding of this decision through previous privacy investigations, and this PR response. Am I misinterpreting the facts or scale of this?