AEC Forensics
Dissecting the Built Environment with Brian L. Hill
Follow @AECforensics on Twitter
About Brian L. Hill
Buildings so ugly, only an architect could love them
Brian L. Hill	Quality and Risk Management	 June 9, 2015 June 27, 2020 1 Minute
In the New York Times Magazine recently, Alexandra Lange asked several of the world's most famous architects to defend the architectural designs of some of the most hated buildings to blight the skyline of world class cities.
Completed in 1973, the Tour Montparnasse stands at a defiant 758 ft above the city of Paris. The design was so jarring, and so out of place with the surrounding architecture, that the city enacted a height ban as a result.
Noted architect Daniel Libeskind on the building:
It's legendary for being the most hated building in Paris. I want to defend it not because it's a particularly beautiful tower, but because of the idea it represents. Parisians panicked when they saw it, and when they abandoned the tower they also abandoned the idea of a high-density sustainable city. Because they exiled all future high rises to some far neighborhood like La Défense, they were segregating growth. Parisians reacted aesthetically, as they are wont to do, but they failed to consider the consequences of what it means to be a vital, living city versus a museum city. People sentimentalize their notions of the city, but with the carbon footprint, the waste of resources, our shrinking capacity, we have no choice but to build good high-rise buildings that are affordable. It's not by coincidence that people are going to London now not just for work but for the available space. No young company can afford Paris. Maybe Tour Montparnasse is not a work of genius, but it signified a notion of what the city of the future will have to be.
Source: New York Times Magazine
Judge for yourself. Here is the Tour Montparnasse shown with the Eiffel Tower:
Image courtesy Wikipedia
The image below shows the magnificent view afforded by the building:
Published by Brian L. Hill
As Director of Consulting Services for Xpera Group, Brian L. Hill connects clients to the diverse range of experts, technical specialists, tools and other resources that the firm has to offer in order to solve complex building performance issues. He is also the editor and publisher of AECforensics.com, which dissects the latest news and information impacting quality and risk management in the built environment.	View all posts by Brian L. Hill
Published June 9, 2015 June 27, 2020
Previous Post From 41 Shades of Blue to Material Design: The Evolution of Google's Design Sensibilities
Next Post What were the top 10 conspiracy theories from 2015?
Search more than 2,000 posts:
Browse by Topic:
Best Of... building science business business development California Construction construction defect construction legal issues Consulting feature green building insurance law Lawsuit marketing Marketing Professional Services miscellaneous sustainability technology work-life balance
Follow AEC Forensics via Email
Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email:
Connect with Brian L. Hill: