Arizona Citizens Defense League
stated on April 10, 2013 in an email to supporters:
Says a gun bill before the Senate would make it a federal felony to "leave town for more than seven days, and leave someone else at home with your firearms."
By Becky Bowers April 16, 2013
Gun-rights group says bill would criminalize leaving gun at home with someone else for more than a week
As gun legislation works its way through the U.S. Senate, gun rights groups warn that some proposals in the original bill could create accidental felons.
One such email warning, from an Arizona group, says, "You would be committing a federal felony if you leave town for more than seven days, and leave someone else at home with your firearms."
Could hosting a house-sitter become a crime? Could your unsuspecting roommates face a felony?
The bill, known as the Safe Communities, Safe Schools Act of 2013, faces votes on a series of amendments, most prominently one proposed by Sens. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., and Pat Toomey, R-Pa.
So all bets are off on the bill's final language.
Still, as the debate unfolds, we were curious: Does Senate Bill 649 make felons of vacationing gun owners with roommates or house guests?
Gun transfers
As introduced in the Senate in March, S. 649 requires background checks for all gun sales, with a limited set of exceptions.
And it's not just sales that are subject to the law — but gun "transfers." In general, it would be illegal to give your gun to someone else without seeking a federal background check.
But there are a series of exceptions that seek to loosen the requirement in some situations — for example, handing your gun to a friend at a shooting range or while hunting legally together, giving a gun as a gift to a close relative or leaving a gun in a will.
It's also okay under the bill to lend your gun to someone in your own home or yard — as long as that "temporary transfer" lasts less than seven days.
Thus, the issue raised by the Arizona Citizens Defense League.
"While the proposed legislation contains limited exceptions for transfers such as between family members," says the email, sent to supporters April 10, "a little digging shows that you would be committing a federal felony if you ... leave town for more than seven days, and leave someone else at home with your firearms."
So, what happens if a buddy house-sits or a roommate stays home during your eight-day vacation?
The answer: It would likely depend on the circumstances.
"I would say it should be changed to 'you might be committing a federal felony if you leave town for more than seven days, and leave someone else at home with your firearms,'" said Clark Neily, who helped represent security guard Dick Heller in his successful Supreme Court challenge to D.C.'s handgun ban.
If you locked up your guns and expressly forbade others from using them, you would have a pretty good argument that you hadn't transferred possession, attorneys told us.
But say your weapons were available to guests or roommates — that nothing would prevent them from using your guns while you were out of town. Then you might have a problem.
The federal government tends to have an expansive definition of "possession," under various laws, Neily said.
"I would say there is a real possibility that someone could be convicted under S. 649 for leaving town for more than seven days while someone else is at home with their guns," he said.
Still, a house guest's mere "access" to your weapons wouldn't necessarily qualify as possession, said Larry Rosenthal, a law professor at Chapman University School of Law who has worked as a federal prosecutor and argued before the Supreme Court as an attorney for the City of Chicago.
He pointed to a 2012 case decided by the U.S. Court of Appeals' Seventh Circuit, United States vs. Griffin, in which a felon had been convicted of illegally possessing firearms and ammunition because he lived with his dad, who had hunting gear around the house.
The court overturned the conviction, explaining the government's argument "confuses access with possession," Rosenthal said.
Meanwhile, just staying in a home with weapons — especially if the house-sitter or roommate didn't know they were there — wouldn't plausibly qualify as a "transfer" of a firearm, Rosenthal said. There would have to be a "knowing passage of control."
So leaving your roommate home alone for weeks, oblivious to the shotgun under your bed, likely wouldn't violate the bill's provisions.
An Arizona group says a gun bill before the Senate would make it a federal felony to "leave town for more than seven days, and leave someone else at home with your firearms."
Indeed, S. 649, as introduced in the Senate, allows for "temporary transfers" of guns in your own home that last less than seven days. But leaving a house-sitter or roommate with access to weapons while you're away for a longer stretch, attorneys explained to PolitiFact, could raise the possibility of violating federal law under the bill's provisions. Still, experts told us a gun owner might avoid such a consequence by locking up weapons and denying permission to use them. And it's not clear courts would interpret mere access as a transfer of possession.
The claim is just partially accurate. We rate it Half True.
Arizona Citizens Defense League, email with subject line "Stop Federal Universal Firearms Registration!" April 10, 2013
Email interview with Larry Rosenthal, Chapman University School of Law, April 12, 2013
Interview with Adam Winkler, professor, University of California at Los Angeles School of Law, April 12, 2013
Email interview with Clark Neily, senior attorney, Institute for Justice, April 12, 2013
Email interview with Robert Levy, chairman, Cato Institute, April 12, 2013
Library of Congress' Thomas, "Safe Communities, Safe Schools Act of 2013," March 21, 2013
Sen. Pat Toomey, "Sen. Toomey Offers Full Text Of Public Safety And Second Amendment Rights Protection Act Online," April 11, 2013
Cornell University Law School, District of Columbia vs. Heller, Justice Scalia, Opinion of the Court, accessed April 12, 2013
United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, United States vs. Griffin, July 5, 2012
More by Becky Bowers
Chain email
stated on October 15, 2013 an email and social media posts:
Congressional lawmakers earn their salaries "FOR LIFE," which for House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi would add up to "$803,700 Dollars a year for LIFE including FREE medical."
By Becky Bowers • October 17, 2013
Louise Slaughter
stated on October 9, 2013 an interview on MSNBC:
"Eighty percent of the antibiotics in this country are fed to livestock."
stated on September 27, 2013 blog posts:
"Obama Declares November National Muslim Appreciation Month."
By Becky Bowers • October 3, 2013
stated on September 22, 2013 a roundtable on ABC's "This Week":
Under economic sanctions, "now Iran is suffering 30 percent inflation, 20 percent unemployment."
By Becky Bowers • September 27, 2013
Betsy McCaughey
stated on September 15, 2013 the New York Post:
"Obamacare will question your sex life."
S.E. Cupp
stated on September 13, 2013 a discussion on CNN's "Crossfire":
"The CDC issued a report commissioned by President Obama just earlier this year, and it found some very inconvenient facts. Armed citizens are less likely harmed by attackers. Effectiveness of gun control laws is mixed. Gun buybacks don't work."
stated on September 13, 2013 posts on the Internet:
Warren Buffett recently said "Scrap Obamacare and Start All Over."
stated on September 5, 2013 an interview on MSNBC's "All In":
Says he "opposed the president's decision to go into Iraq" in 2003.
Ted Yoho
stated on September 4, 2013 an interview on Fox Business Network:
Chemical weapons have been used "probably 20 times" since the Persian Gulf War.
Debbie Wasserman Schultz
stated on September 2, 2013 a CNN interview:
Says there's a "100-year-old international norm not to use chemical weapons."
By Becky Bowers • September 5, 2013
stated on August 15, 2013 blog posts:
Obamacare provision will allow "forced home inspections" by government agents.
By Becky Bowers • August 21, 2013
stated on August 10, 2013 a speech to the Family Leadership Summit in Ames, Iowa:
Says "President Obama just granted all of Congress an exception" to Obamacare.
Ted Deutch
stated on August 1, 2013 a letter with other Florida lawmakers to HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius:
Says Florida refused to allow the insurance commissioner to "negotiate lower rates with companies or refuse rates that are too high" under Obamacare.
By Becky Bowers • August 8, 2013
stated on July 30, 2013 an MSNBC interview:
Says about NSA data collection: "Every member in both parties who served on the Intelligence Committee voted in favor of this."
stated on July 25, 2013 a FoxNews.com op-ed:
Under Obamacare, "75 percent of small businesses now say they are going to be forced to either fire workers or cut their hours."
By Becky Bowers • July 29, 2013