Red star over Hungary? Heineken may see trademark banned
By Krisztina Than | BUDAPEST
BUDAPEST Heineken beer's trademark red star may
be about to fall foul of Hungary's attempts to purge itself of
totalitarian symbols related to the years of Nazi occupation
and, in this case, the 40 years of communist rule.
The rightist government of Prime Minister Viktor Orban,
which faces an election in April 2018, says it is a "moral
obligation" to ban the commercial use of symbols such as the
swastika, arrow cross, hammer and sickle, and the red star.
Parliament began discussing the proposed ban on Monday. The measure would fit with Orban's style of unorthodox policy
making, which has seen specific, mostly foreign-owned business
sectors, targeted with special taxes and regulation.
Heineken has had a star logo on its beer for most of the
years since it was first brewed in the second half of the 19th
century, changing to a red one in the 1930s. The star is thought
to represent a brewers symbol or the various stages of the
brewing process.
But the red star was also a major symbol of Soviet communism
and used to appear on the crest of communist-era Hungary.
Under the new law, businesses using these symbols could be
fined up to 2 billion forints ($6.97 million) and jail sentence.
A Heineken spokeswoman declined comment on the draft bill.
Hungarian government spokesman Zoltan Kovacs also declined
comment, but did not rule out the possibility that based on the
law, Heineken beer with its current logo could be banned.
Last week Deputy Prime Minister Zsolt Semjen, who jointly
submitted the bill with Orban's chief of staff Janos Lazar, was
quoted as saying that the red star in Heineken's logo was "obvious political content".
At the same time, Semjen did not deny that the ban was
linked to Heineken's legal battle with a small, partly
locally-owned beer maker in Romania's Transylvania — home to
hundreds of thousands of ethnic Hungarians — over the use of a
popular brand name there.
After the World War Two Heineken changed its star from red
to white with only a small red border. Over the years the red
border of the star of all export labels gradually became more
prominent, until 1991, when it became completely red again.
Unlike Nazi symbols, communist symbols are not banned in the
Czech Republic or in Romania. In Poland, there was a discussion
regarding communist symbols, but the Constitutional Tribunal
ruled the symbols could be used.
The red star also features in badges of famous soccer teams
like French club Red Star FC or the famous Red Star Belgrade
club.
($1 = 286.97 forints) (Additional reporting by Peter Muller in Prague, Radu Marinas
in Bucharest and Marcin Goclowski in Warsaw)
Posted in Legal News, News, Reuters, US Legal News