Latest on DanceTabs
DanceTabs Contributors
A sharp eyed look at Dance & Ballet Across the World
Some News Items
Only Selective News Here – much more on Twitter
DanceTabs News
Sarasota Ballet – Digital Program 3: work by Darrell, Wright, Walsh, Wheeldon, Bourne & MacMillan
Stuttgart Ballet – The Sleeping Beauty – streamed from Stuttgart
Dance Memories of 2020 – London
English National Ballet – Echoes by Russell Maliphant, Michael Nunn and William Trevitt – streamed film
Birmingham Royal Ballet – Aladdin – London
Lynette Halewood
Cesar Morales, Iain Mackay and Nao Sakuma in Aladdin.
© Bill Cooper. (Click image for larger version)
Birmingham Royal Ballet
London, Coliseum
www.brb.org.uk
BRB Aladdin page
BRB have already toured their new production of Aladdin extensively round the UK this season. Now they bring it to the Coliseum. The work was originally made by David Bintley, BRB's Artistic Director, for a Japanese company five years ago. Now staged for his own company, it has new designs to fit the UK's smaller stages.
Bintley sets out his stall very clearly in the programme notes. Aladdin is "the least 'deep' ballet I have ever made…a ballet that does what is says on the tin. It tells the story". He does rather set your expectations almost defiantly low here. Don't expect big emotional highs and lows or deeply defined characters, just a clear narration of a story that everyone knows. So if we judge it on these terms how does it do?
The Act 1 Cave of Riches in Aladdin.
Plus points must start with the gorgeous designs in eye-popping colours (sets by Dick Bird) and attractive costumes (Sue Blane). We move from a cave of riches/jewels in the first act, where the stalactites and stalagmites change colour to match the jewels that are dancing, to a dreamingly gorgeous bathhouse (with real water in the fountain) for the Princess in the second, ravishingly lit by Mark Jonathan. There are cleverly-judged special effects for the appearance of the Djinn from the lamp and a neatly-done flying carpet.
The storytelling is clear and easy to follow, and packed with dancing episodes. There is fine dancing from the two leads. César Morales is cheerfully tireless as Aladdin. Nao Sakuma always looks refined and elegant as Princess Badr al-Budur, working her way through countless costume changes. Tzu-Chao Chou has a fine time of it spinning and leaping as the blue-skinned The Djinn of the lamp. All of these characters are very lightly sketched: Sakuma is just required to look beautiful, which indeed she does. We know it's all just a story: nothing ever seems at stake. We never worry that Aladdin will in fact get his head cut off by the Sultan's guards. There is no dramatic tension. Iain Mackay as the evil Mahgrib (another fabulous costume, but not much dancing) does his best to bite the scenery and is rewarded with some panto-style booing at the curtain calls.
Ambra Vallo and Tyrone Singleton as Rubies in Aladdin.© Bill Cooper. (Click image for larger version)
The first act is packed with divertissements for the jewels Aladdin finds in the cave. (Though there was something odd about having this display in the first act, it felt rather more like the kind of material you might expect in the third). The audience particularly liked the Rubies couple, where a bare-chested Tyrone Singleton threw Ambra Vallo high in the air and wound her round him like a scarf. Natasha Oughtred had a warm and flirtatious stage presence as Sapphire.
In Act 2 Bintley gives us a touch of Busby Berkeley Hollywood-style glamour in the massed ranks of the Djinn's blue and gold retinue. There a lot of dancing, an endless flow of steps, though after a while it does have a rather generic feel. The cast work hard. Bintley scores high on the productivity stakes but the quality control department may be undermanned.
The Lion Dance in Aladdin.
On the minus side must come the music. Carl Davis's score sounds like film music, and a particularly forgettable film at that. Don't expect to come out humming any tunes. Overall, it's a colourful spectacle but with little emotional investment. The princess, though decorative, is a bit wet for most girls today to identify with. Marion Tait is possibly the finest and most subtle female character dancer in the UK's ballet companies and it is a shame that Aladdin's mother is painted as such a cliché: even she can't make it the role more than a cartoon.
It may do what is says on the tin by way of sketching out a narrative, but that doesn't mean it's a satisfying overall experience. Bintley and BRB are both capable of much more fulfilling work than this.
Cesar Morales and Nao Sakuma in Aladdin.
So why go for such a simplistic approach ? The justification for mounting what is intended as an uncomplicated crowd pleaser may be that BRB needs a big box office-friendly production to keep the cash coming in. However, the company already has a number of audience-friendly full length works in its repertoire, but which offer something more substantial. These include their very fine Nutcracker, Beauty and the Beast, and Bintley's recent production of Cinderella (another beautifully designed work, but much more going for it than Aladdin in terms of music, dance and drama). BRB's season concludes with Coppelia and Giselle. Triple bills seem to have shrunk drastically.
Birmingham Royal Ballet in Aladdin.
The production has been funded by generous support from sponsors and BRB's audience and is a co-production with Houston Ballet. This approach is very enterprising but it is a little sad that the thinking appears to be that what the public wants is something as slick and unchallenging as this. Despite its ostensible appeal, Aladdin doesn't seem to be selling as well in London as must have been hoped. Yet down the road at the Opera House, Wheeldon's Alice (a production initially viewed as somewhat shallow and over reliant on visual effects) is still packing them in. Working out how to achieve that exercises the minds of all the other UK ballet companies considerably, but no one seems to have cracked it yet.
TagsAladdin Alice's Adventures in Wonderland Ambra Vallo Beauty and the Beast Birmingham Royal Ballet Busby Berkeley Carl Davis Cesar Morales Christopher Wheeldon Cinderella Coliseum Coppelia David Bintley Dick Bird Giselle Iain Mackay London Mark Jonathan Nao Sakuma Natasha Oughtred Nutcracker Royal Ballet Royal Opera House Sue Blane Tyrone Singleton Tzu-Chao Chou
Words needed.
Paul Arrowsmith says:
Pointless to criticise David Bintley's Aladdin for what it is not. Shamelessly it is a piece of fun, a danced extravaganza of a familiar tale that I last saw as a panto, some 45 years ago.
There is – however – an element of seriousness that elevates Bintley's ballet but I do wonder how clear the narrative is for first-timers, Birmingham Royal Ballet's intended family audience. The motivation of Bintley's mahgrib is unclear, as is Aladdin's acquisition of the jewels in the subterranean cave – and why are we there anyway?
We are treated to a subterranean vision of the princess – but dramatic logic expects we next see more of the ballet's heroine, not an extended display of aqueous jewels. We are denied princess as the diamond variation, crowning display of Aladdin's jewel vision, which would have made the scene more dramatically cohesive.
Maureya Lebowitz is the real deal – as princess and ballerina. Beautifully expressive arms – shaming BRB's women – with regal poise and gracious presence. She eclipsed the bland Mathias Dingman in the title role. The other characters are no more than dancing costumes – with no sense of character or narrative, apparently deliberately so according to Bintley.
Best as a series of the choreographer's typically effective theatrical effects and danced diversions, Bintley's flowing choreography will threaten nobody unfamiliar with ballet – but Aladdin suffers from a lack of dramatic propulsion. However brilliantly performed (dancers not credited) the lion dance is gratuitous but the cod-Schéhérazade ensemble reveals the company at its energetic best.
For adults there are plenty nods to other ballets, Ondine, Scènes de ballet, and the glorious pas de deux for Aladdin and the princess (Carl Davis' score pulling at every heart string like the best schmaltzy romcom) is crocheted with quotations from The Dream, La Bayadère and Sleeping Beauty. Extracted and combined with the jewels scene, BRB would have a wonderful one-acter on its hands.
The sets by Dick Bird do their work wittily and economically – though framed in black the production looks lost on the wide stage of the London Coliseum. Sue Blane's new costumes are shiny and sadly often unflattering: the ruby is got up in a Hilda Ogden headscarf, the dancing pearls are encrusted in places that bring Barbara Windsor's assets to mind – and if you think that Ashton's Scènes de ballet should be redesigned, the diamonds' diamante costumes here should make you reconsider.
So – pointless to criticise Bintley for creating so polishedly what he set out to do. Even in the jewels divertissement, Bintley displays more theatrical warmth and flair than Balanchine did in his abstraction – which is entirely the point of company like BRB. Like Alice's Adventures, currently sold out at Covent Garden, this is ballet as entertainment, ballet the West End Show.
But sad to see that audiences are not flocking to BRB's current comfortable programming. A hint there that audiences want to be challenged more by the expressive powers of ballet?
Lizzie Maitland says:
I saw Aladdin in Birmingham and it has to be said that at the end of the (very) long first act, I was left absolutely cold. There was none of the emotion or feeling that is present in every other Bintley ballet I have seen (and I have seen every one since his residency started in Birmingham) and there were a number of issues with the dancing that really should have been avoided, as a principal Natasha Oughtred really should be able to pirouette without almost falling over. The standout performances were definitely Tyrone Singleton and Ambra Vallo but I had no emotional investment in Aladdin as a character. The second and third acts were better but still rather empty and Iain McKay was criminally wasted as the Mahgrib (as well as looking like he was an extra from Wicked, the green makeup was a touch de trop). As for the Emeralds costumes, the phrase "search and destroy" springs to mind. They managed to make the fabulous and svelte Delia Matthews and Callie Roberts look rather chunky and as for the swimming cap headpieces…
There was also the small issue of cultural confusion. Aladdin and his mother were both pitched as chinese, there was a chinese lion dance and dragon but the setting and costumes were middle East in inspiration. It was a ballet that hadn't quite found where or what it wanted to be.
As for the issue of ticket sales compared to the Royal, it's a bit like comparing apples and oranges. Whilst both fruit, that's where the similarities end. Yes, the Royal sells out but that has less to do with the ballets they are performing or the quality of the dancing and more to do with the fact that it's the Royal and they perform at the Opera House. People pay for the name and the kudos. Please don't get me wrong, there are some wonderful dancers at the Royal but I have seen sold out ballets performed there which I would have thought had been performed by amateurs, the dancing was that bad. Alice in Wonderland has hardly been critically received in an entirely positive light and I have only managed to see half of the first act as the ridiculous sets and lighting managed to make me feel so sick I had to stop watching. Moreover, the media hugely raised the profile of Alice when it was originally produced with features in most papers as it was the first full length ballet the Royal had produced in 15 years. Th fact that BRB had created 4 or 5 in that period, despite having significantly less cash to work with, was completely ignored.
This trend has continued with the appointment of Kevin O'Hare whose management technique seems to be a direct parallel of David Bintley's rather than that of Monica Mason and yet the fact that O'Hare danced exclusively with SWRB/BRB has been ignored in pretty much every profile that has been written about him. How much of that is the media's slant and how much is O'Hare's is anyone's guess…
So please don't try and compare a company that is prolifically creative, that takes ballet all over the country, from big theatres to some really small ones, to one that sits in state in London, never having to fight for tickets, safe in the knowledge that they can trade on their name. Because what the BRB lose in ticket sales they more than make up for in integrity.
Bill Boyd says:
I go to see splendid dancing. That's what I got.
Bruce Marriott says:
My own feeling re the audience not turning out is that Aladdin is seen very much as a Christmas/Pantomime story and we only recently finished with all that for last Christmas. It should do better toured before and after a Christmas.
In comparison Alice, although for families as well, is not associated with Christmas and hence works better at the moment. Although I don't think either ballet is a knockout at all, Alice has fresher production thinking in it of course – it was a moving forward for RB in that respect (if not appreciated by all!). Aladdin is very traditional, if done well.
I'm pleased with what Kevin O'Hare is doing for the Royal Ballet but I think the comparison with Bintley is not so flattering for Bintley – O'Hare is commissioning a variety of choreographers at a variety of levels to do work for the company whereas David spends most of the BRB new work budget on himself. I think it better if choreographing directors follow the Helgi Tomasson model in San Francisco Ballet and give the lions share of the budget to others. The result is a wonderful rep where the work is not all seen through the same choreographic lens. The audience gets variety and the art moves forward more strongly – I feel. Bintley is a truly great choreographer and I'm not suggesting he should stop creating – just that his creations are seen in more companies and Birmingham isn't automatically filled with them all. Heresy for some I know! But even Balanchine had Robbins around at NYCB.
Claudia Bauer | Deborah Weiss | Foteini Christofilopoulou | Graham Watts | Heather Desaulniers | Jann Parry | Josephine Leask | Lauren Gallagher | Lynette Halewood | Margaret Willis | Marina Harss | Oksana Khadarina | Sara Veale | Siobhan Murphy | Susanna Sloat | Valerie Lawson | Bruce Marriott (Ed)
The above list is composed of those whose work we feature regularly and have generally contributed in the last few months.
>> Complete list of DanceTabs Contributors and more info.
DanceTabs Tweets
Birmingham Royal Ballet's Aladdin Premiere in February 2013 – Full Deatils
Birmingham Royal Ballet – Prince of the Pagodas (Bracewell/Roberts) – London
Birmingham Royal Ballet – Daphnis & Chloe, Two Pigeons – London
Birmingham Royal Ballet – La Fin du jour, Miracle in the Gorbals, Flowers of the Forest – London
Akram Khan (110) Alexei Ratmansky (221) American Ballet Theatre (280) Bach (105) Balanchine (121) Birmingham Royal Ballet (168) Bolshoi Ballet (181) Christopher Wheeldon (239) Coliseum (180) David H. Koch Theater (167) Don Quixote (151) English National Ballet (303) Frederick Ashton (273) George Balanchine (284) Giselle (232) Jerome Robbins (150) Kenneth MacMillan (258) Liam Scarlett (108) London (1705) Marianela Nunez (107) Mariinsky Ballet (149) Natalia Osipova (130) New York (545) New York City Ballet (325) Paris Opera Ballet (131) Petipa (143) Pina Bausch (122) Rambert (114) Romeo and Juliet (202) Royal Opera House (455) Rudolf Nureyev (109) Sadler's Wells (661) San Francisco (187) San Francisco Ballet (182) Scottish Ballet (120) Swan Lake (288) Tamara Rojo (128) Tchaikovsky (183) The Nutcracker (133) The Place (185) The Royal Ballet (636) The Sleeping Beauty (130) Vadim Muntagirov (108) Wayne McGregor (191) William Forsythe (133)
Jann Parry
Deborah Weiss
Birmingham Royal Ballet – The Nutcracker at The REP – live streamed from Birmingham
Archives Select Month January 2021 (2) December 2020 (12) November 2020 (9) October 2020 (14) September 2020 (5) August 2020 (7) July 2020 (11) June 2020 (14) May 2020 (5) April 2020 (8) March 2020 (13) February 2020 (33) January 2020 (15) December 2019 (20) November 2019 (33) October 2019 (46) September 2019 (13) August 2019 (17) July 2019 (27) June 2019 (35) May 2019 (37) April 2019 (27) March 2019 (32) February 2019 (24) January 2019 (12) December 2018 (18) November 2018 (30) October 2018 (42) September 2018 (20) August 2018 (9) July 2018 (12) June 2018 (33) May 2018 (34) April 2018 (32) March 2018 (40) February 2018 (42) January 2018 (20) December 2017 (26) November 2017 (29) October 2017 (54) September 2017 (16) August 2017 (11) July 2017 (21) June 2017 (35) May 2017 (32) April 2017 (35) March 2017 (39) February 2017 (37) January 2017 (25) December 2016 (19) November 2016 (41) October 2016 (52) September 2016 (21) August 2016 (26) July 2016 (27) June 2016 (30) May 2016 (49) April 2016 (44) March 2016 (33) February 2016 (46) January 2016 (36) December 2015 (32) November 2015 (46) October 2015 (49) September 2015 (38) August 2015 (23) July 2015 (32) June 2015 (35) May 2015 (50) April 2015 (40) March 2015 (55) February 2015 (27) January 2015 (32) December 2014 (31) November 2014 (38) October 2014 (52) September 2014 (36) August 2014 (17) July 2014 (45) June 2014 (30) May 2014 (43) April 2014 (37) March 2014 (37) February 2014 (36) January 2014 (26) December 2013 (33) November 2013 (45) October 2013 (60) September 2013 (23) August 2013 (16) July 2013 (34) June 2013 (36) May 2013 (42) April 2013 (44) March 2013 (44) February 2013 (40) January 2013 (20) December 2012 (45) November 2012 (41) October 2012 (45) September 2012 (34) August 2012 (14) July 2012 (35) June 2012 (35) May 2012 (34) April 2012 (33) March 2012 (41) February 2012 (17) January 2012 (14)
DanceTabs © 2021. All here is copyright DanceTabs and the author concerned. Do not steal our words or pictures, please. Thank you.