House GOP Wants Amtrak Out of the Commuter Rail Business
At a highly politicized hearing on Tuesday, House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Chair John Mica slammed "Amtrak's failure to compete with the private sector," arguing that the national rail company should stop bidding to run commuter rail services.
Congressional Democrat Corinne Brown, of Florida, said the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee is no longer bipartisan. Image: House T&I
The hearing centered around a new report from House Republicans [PDF] criticizing Amtrak for competing with private companies for commuter rail contracts. "Amtrak is a highly subsidized, Soviet-style rail system," Mica said, "but despite every ticket being underwritten nearly $50 by the taxpayers, Amtrak is an absolute failure in competing with the cost-effectiveness and level of service provided by the private sector."
But it also seems that Republicans would prefer to see Amtrak become even more of a "Soviet-style" operation. One of the report's major conclusions is that Amtrak should stop trying to compete for commuter rail contracts awarded by local governments. "Amtrak wastes the taxpayers' money bidding on commuter rail contracts that it cannot win," Mica said in a press release. The report cited seven instances where Amtrak entered competition for these contracts and lost or withdrew.
Meanwhile, Florida Democrat Corrine Brown pointed out that Amtrak makes a profit of $15 million annually on its commuter rail service. Brown accused Republicans of orchestrating the hearing to punish Amtrak for suing Veolia Transportation, which nabbed a contract for commuter rail service in Florida after hiring away three Amtrak employees. A jury faulted Veolia for the hirings, but said Amtrak would not have kept the contract even if they had retained those employees.
The Republicans' report concluded that Amtrak should be barred from suing private rail providers over contract disputes, calling the litigation anti-competitive and wasteful.
Another major conclusion of the report is that all states that pay for Amtrak services should consider awarding the contracts to Amtrak's competitors. The report found that states could save $91 million annually by choosing private contractors. Currently, 19 states contract with Amtrak for this service, according to testimony.
Eddie Bernice Johnson, a Texas Democrat, called the report a "senseless attack," following 11 consecutive monthly ridership records for the rail service. Johnson said Republicans have an "ideological obsession" to "destroy Amtrak," pointing out that getting rid of Amtrak is part of the 2012 Republican Party platform.
Brown criticized Republican leadership for failing to offer the report to Democratic committee members before its release. She said the House T&I "is not a bipartisan committee anymore."
Filed Under: Amtrak, John Mica
Think Privatizing Amtrak Services is a Good Idea? Think Again.
By Tanya Snyder | Jun 21, 2011
House Transportation Committee Chair John Mica (R-FL) is moving forward with his plan to hand over the Northeast Corridor to private companies, despite (or because of) the fact that such a move could write Amtrak's obituary. Is privatizing the corridor a good move? Mica and Rep. Bill Shuster (R-PA) say that with the participation of […]
UPDATE: Reminder: Amtrak Subsidies Pale in Comparison to Highway Subsidies
By Tanya Snyder | Sep 21, 2012
UPDATED 9/24 with chart. House Transportation Committee Chair John Mica continued his "holy jihad" against Amtrak yesterday, holding the third full-committee hearing in a series on "Reviewing Amtrak's Operations." He's planning at least three more hearings during the lame duck session after the election. Mica went after subsidies in this one, and he clearly thinks […]
What Would Meaningful Amtrak Reform Look Like?
By Tanya Snyder | Nov 29, 2012
For the past two years, Amtrak has been under constant attack from House Transportation Committee Chair John Mica (R-FL), who has used his gavel to bully the rail company. He likes to call it a "Soviet-style" monopoly and he goads it for losing money on everything from long-distance routes to food service. His vitriolic diatribes […]
GOP Proposal to Privatize the Northeast Corridor Meets Resistance
By Tanya Snyder | May 27, 2011
House Republicans, led by Transportation Committee leaders John Mica (R-FL) and Bill Schuster (R-PA), have a plan to take the Northeast Corridor out of Amtrak's control and privatize it. They've long called Amtrak a "Soviet-style operation" that loses money. Mica said that ridership of the NEC hasn't changed since 1977, the year after Amtrak took […]
What Boondoggle? Private Sector Wants in on HSR Action
President Obama's proposed high speed rail initiative would have the US embarking on the biggest infrastructure project since the interstate highway system. And while the significance of this effort — and the need for more sustainable transportation options — may be lost on a few cranky governors, it is not going unnoticed by the private […]
Mica and Rail Supporters Meet Halfway
By Tanya Snyder | Jul 28, 2011
At a meeting with members of the U.S. High-Speed Rail Association Tuesday, House Transportation Committee Chair John Mica softened his stance somewhat on his plan to privatize the Northeast Corridor. He acknowledged that the proposal is "controversial" and said that was why he framed it in a separate bill, apart from the rest of the […]