Woman, 59, wanted second IVF baby
By Dr Vivienne Raper
A 59-year-old British woman who conceived her two-year-old daughter by IVF has faced criticism after saying she wants more children. Sue Tollefsen, from Essex, had told makers of a BBC documentary about older mothers to be shown later this month that she was '110 per cent' sure she wanted more treatment.
Last night, Mrs Tollefsen told The Telegraph newspaper: 'I feel as fit as a fiddle approaching 60 and I'm confident that I could have a child, despite my age. Obviously, I do worry that, if I have another child, when he or she reaches their 10th birthday, I will be 70'.
'However, my partner is 11 years younger than me, so I know that even if I am not around in the years to come, Nick would be and so our children would have their father to bring them up'.
Her daughter, Freya, was conceived in Russia after Mrs Tollefsen was refused treatment in the UK due to her age, according to the Mail on Sunday. The private London Women's Clinic also came under fire after Mrs Tollefsen visited it during the filming of 'Too Old To Be A Mum?' Some newspaper reports claimed that the fertility clinic offered Mrs Tollefsen treatment. But Dr Kamal Ahuja, the clinic's Scientific Director, says that they merely kept an open mind. 'We did agree to meet with the lady for the programme and said we have an upper age limit of 50, which we have exceeded on one or two occasions', he told BioNews. He added: 'We said we would be happy to talk to her, but we would have to spend a lot of time discussing the merits of the treatment'.
'We will not say a blanket no to someone because she has exceeded the age of 50. But we are talking from the point of view of women of 51 or 52. That said, we don't have a vast body of patients in that age group queuing up'.
But Mrs Tollefsen didn't come back after filming was over. 'We have had zero contact from her since the day she visited us', he said. She admitted to the Daily Mail yesterday that she had been asked to enquire about fertility treatment at UK clinics by the documentary team and was now tempted. She told the Mail that she plans to discuss it with her partner.
Mrs Tollefsen's attempts to conceive sparked off vigorous debate among fertility experts about whether there should be a fixed age limit to IVF with donated eggs. Tony Rutherford, president of the British Fertility Society, told The Times that, while his own clinic did not treat women over 46, he saw no need for an arbitrary cut-off: 'Society's view is that clinics can take a case-by-case approach. There aren't any right and wrong answers in this situation'.
Allan Pacey, a fertility expert at the University of Sheffield, is against legislation: 'Whatever age limit the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority or parliamentarians choose to make, there will always be cases from time to time where women are a few days older than whatever age is chosen and argue that the law has treated them unfairly', he told The Times.
Tory MP Ann Widdecombe, meanwhile, told The Sun that it set a 'dangerous precedent', adding that: 'This is very, very bad news and simply should not happen. Once you cross this line and let a 60-year-old have treatment, it's right to get Parliament involved'.
A defiance of nature, an abuse of medical skill
Mail on Sunday | 16 January 2010
Doctors reject calls to ban women over 50 from receiving IVF
The Times | 18 January 2010
Storm over second chance at IVF for mother aged 59
Daily Mail | 18 January 2010
Woman, 59, becomes oldest person ever to be offered IVF treatment by a British clinic
Woman, 59, offered IVF
The Sun | 17 January 2010
Woman, 59, 'sought IVF treatment'
The Mirror | 17 January 2010
Woman of 59 offered IVF
The Telegraph | 18 January 2010
The Age-Old Question: The Impact of Age
7 January 2013 - by Ruth Saunders
Progress Educational Trust's 2012 annual conference 'Fertility Treatment: A Life-Changing Event?' concluded with a session entitled 'The Age-Old Question: The Impact of Age'...
TV Review: Too Old to Be a Mum?
1 February 2010 - by Jenny Dunlop
I have a feeling that whether you work in the fertility field or not everyone has a strong point of view about the upper age that a woman should have fertility treatment and become a mother. Maybe this thought was behind the producers of this BBC documentary that they could challenge all our firmly held beliefs? Or maybe they just thought that it would make contentious sexy television?...
66 year old women is Britain's oldest mother-to-be
26 May 2009 - by Dr Sarah Spain
The record for Britain's oldest women to give birth will be broken next month by 66 year old Elizabeth Munro, from Cambridge. It is thought that Ms Munro, who is single and a successful business woman, travelled to the Ukraine to become pregnant using donor eggs and...
60 year-old woman gives birth to twins in Canada after fertility treatment abroad
16 February 2009 - by Sarah Pritchard
A 60 year-old woman has sparked controversy in Canada by travelling to India to receive fertility treatment after years of failed attempts to conceive naturally. Ranjit Hayer, originally from India, has become the oldest woman in Canada to give birth after receiving IVF at Dr Anoop Gupta's Delhi fertility clinic; her twin boys were delivered seven weeks prematurely by Caesarean section at the Foothills hospital in Calgary last week....
70-year-old claimed to be world's oldest mother
7 July 2008 - by MacKenna Roberts
A 70-year-old woman in India is reportedly the world's oldest woman to give birth, when she had twins last week. The girl and boy babies were delivered one month early by emergency caesarean section but are reportedly alive and well after being transferred to specialist neonatal...
60 year old woman gives birth to twins
29 May 2007 - by Danielle Hamm
A sixty year-old woman has become the oldest women in the US to give birth to twins. The two healthy boys were delivered in the US Hackensack University Medical Centre on 22 May. The twins were conceived via IVF in a South African clinic. The couple, Frieda...