This judgement is base on opinion.  Judges are not God nor are they always correct.  Unfortunately they can never be held accountable which is why they can make any decision they want in favor of anyone they so desire....as long as they feel they can justify the decision with words.  Decisions and empty words that may have terrible ramifications later.  Look at the arguments on both sides for yourselves and decide if this judgement was based on logic and rationality or emotion and politics.