Your response is nonsense.  
Your first 2 points highlight the usual problems with public provided services,1) bad infrastructure (also see Ontario's SAMS system), and 2) infective management (well protected by ineffective senior management, who are well protected by no effective system of measuring outcomes and no accountability for failures).
I don't see point 3 as being a problem.  The public sector has already proven itself as a failure but nothing is done to fix the problem because no one is held accountable because it makes the Minister look bad.
With a private sector provider accountability can easily  accomplished by the public sector overseeing the private sector.  Poor providers can be replaced.