I think I am not alone in this assessment of the current federal poliscape by erstwhile Liberal supporters:

- Liberals and PM Trudeau:  we were taken in by a skillfully executed con.  Major disappointment and disillusionment, tinged with some animosity.
- Conservatives and Scheer: Reform lite, repackaged.  Been there, done that.  Don't need a re-run.
- NDP and ???:  a lot of formerly Liberal votes will be mobile in 2019 and could migrate to the NDP, IF they present themselves with a new leader as prudent, predictable and reliable, even within the context of their left of centre policies.

IMO Singh is not the leader they need to effect that, and there are only two possible contenders who could pull it off, both of whom are not currently in contention and probably don't want the gig anyway:  Premier Rachel Notley and former Premier and US Ambassador Gary Doer.  Either of them, but especially Notley, would give Trudeau and the Liberals a very hard run in 2019.

Draft Notley!