He doesn't really meet the first of my criteria, nor the second.  I have nothing against Scheer, and he'd be the easy 5th person on my ballot.  Lacks a bit of charisma, which is fine but may impact his ability to broaden the tent nationally.  I'm skeptical of lifelong politicians, and Scheer seemingly has only limited experience in private industry (as an insurance broker).  Never served in cabinet.   Hasn't released any policy yet to my knowledge (compared to Chong and Bernier who have both essentially released economic platforms).  Finally, he treads a bit too close to social conservatism to gain my absolute support.