Rebuttal? a lame excuse - your rebuttal with comments like "so what" or "not relevant" without any explanation
Logical -- you are not
Again, how can you say you have a rebuttal when his family had connections to Al Qaeda and it was plausible/credible he had information that his family may have said to him.  It should be obvious to anyone.
I give up, discussing this any further as you are incapable of caring on a coherent discussion.