Nobody can predict the future, the ceiling or floor of a player. It's fluid, it's focus, it's training, it's intelligence, it's many things and any one of them or combination can make huge swings in one direction or the other. Look at McManus, when we first got him, everyone said he was a bust (most were still pining over losing Prater), heck Fox even brought in another kicker for FGs and left Mc in for KOs. McManus got some coaching, took a step off his approach and boom, he was McMoney. Bottom line, the coaches see the players everyday. They have the knowledge, data and proximity to evaluate much better than any fan can hope to - regardless of having GamePass "Coach's Film", it's still not close. The Broncos staff will make the calls and so far, they are solidly behind Siemian. I'll trust them and go with whatever or whoever they decide on... but from my own eye, I like how TS has progressed in 18 starts, especially considering the protection. Plenty of room to improve, we'll see...