I can't claim to know baseball but let's look at the facts here:  Bautista was really average last year, the fans and pundits were totally wrong about cheaping out on Price (average and not worth the money) while the Jays management were totally right about Happ (great value buy), finally the Indians largely built by Shapiro were just totally dominant against the Jays (better in all respects).  Those facts lead me to reserve judgement on Jays Management decisions for now.