You're right - it doesn't, and I never said it did. The problem wasn't that he addressed her as a citizen, it's that he was addressing her as a citizen despite claiming equal authority (eg: used his job as proof he's right, even though that's not actually relevant to the issue of her - as you say - lying). It doesn't invalidate HIS argument, but it bolsters Ms. Mencke's, which is what's at the top of this page.
Smoking drugs, accusing an attorney of making up laws, "elitist", "from Seattle", sipping Kool-Aid, "Euro-socialist", "bogus interpretation", calling her a kid, "bastardizing" rights, "propagating legal myths", demanding that a lawyer show "legal integrity" - those are the personal shots I'm referring to. They have no relation to the issue at hand, which is that Sen. Kuderer shouldn't have called it a 'right'.
And being against calling it a right is all Mr. Jared brought up - he was curiously silent about being FOR healthcare at all.