Lamont, we are not speaking of economic right and wrong here, we're speaking about economic realities in the real world. This is not ethics class. If, in your respective industry, all other competitors receive state subsidies and you do not, your company will go bankrupt. It's a question of survival. If you want to lobby all the aerospace industries to stop taking subsidies then hold annual audits to ensure compliance, have at it Lamont. Then, and only then, can you regard this as a matter of right or wrong.  Till then, Bombardier and the Quebec and Federal Governments, are simply conducting business under actual economic conditions and constraints.