If I recall correctly, Councilor Brown has rated the City Manager unsatisfactory for at least the last two annual evaluations.

I believe Councilor Taylor has also rated him low.

The Mayor and other councilors have rated him highly and given him raises. 

What I've heard is that the "Executive Session" reviews are pure "aura fluffing" with no accountability for Crapstone, South Willamette, City Hall, etc.