What's so crazy about Manning being rated higher in some areas? He was the 1st pick of the 2004 draft (to Trevor's 250th), he's started for his 14th season (to Trevor's 2nd),Eli has 204 starts (to TS' 18) and to top it off, their stats aren't all that dissimilar, either this year or if you compare apples to apples, Eli's 2nd year starting to Trevor's 2nd year starting. In fact, Trevor's 2nd year compared to Eli's is much better. It's still pretty early in the season and a few numbers can swing stats a lot. Right now I'm more worried about winning and scoring TDs than any single player's stats - those will fall into line by the end of the season and form a much more accurate picture.