For you any commentary critical of the church is "anti-Catholic propaganda." So much for your powers of discernment. You're a knee-jerk apologist incapable of a dispassionate discussion on church history. In lieu of solid argument or a shred of evidence you resort to libel. Yet apparently go crying to the editors about "incivility"! If your delicate sensibilities are so wounded by the commentary at NCR, one wonders why you camp out here.

Where are even two citations from my "inexhaustible supply of anti-Catholic authors," Marty? What is the evidence that Kertzer, who won a Pulitzer for "The Pope and Mussolini," a book you've not even read and know nothing about, is "in it for the money" and "anti-Catholic"? Put up or shut up. False witness is uncivil, and a sin.