No, it doesn't.  

When you have to spread falsehoods in order to push a point,  …you're only demonstrating your own failure on top of the failure in policy you're pushing.

The state doesn't realize 3 cents on the dollar value taken out of state.

That's a non-renewable resource.  Once it's gone, it's gone.

The fishing industry is Alaska’s largest private-sector employer and fish are the state’s main export product generating about 6 billion dollars in economic impact per year.

Fisheries contributes more revenue to the state.   A lot more.

And we don't 'lose' the resource, it's renewable, meaning that revenue is available again and again.

There's absolutely no comparison.