The implied consent law, which Utah no longer has, but Colorado does - only applies to drunk driving suspects. The patient in this scenario was NOT a suspect. There was NO need for the police to request a blood draw. Obtaining a warrant for a blood draw or medical records first require that the officer have probable cause of a crime. The patient in this scenario was not a suspect in any crime. Had the blood test been drawn it wouldn't have provided evidence of the patient committing a crime. The detective and lieutenant are way out of line.