NITRO08, judges are not infallible.  They frequently make the wrong call which is why we have an appeal courts.  Many decisions are overturned on appeal.  I did not go to law school, but I learned to look at issues objectively, read and listen to what legal scholars have to say about them, and then apply common sense to arrive at my own conclusions.  In this case, my conclusion is that Judge Watson errored and that his ruling will be overturned.