Wow. What a shallow, one-sided analysis. Alberta has screwed up their economy by not heeding the obvious roller-coaster history of oil that they've been through before and now we need to take on a risk to all of B.C.'s coastal economy to bail them out? Where is the calculus on that? With any luck oil demand will plummet anyway further throwing this idea into question. One good thing he mentions: if all the oil sands workers have to get rid of their trucks, boats, snowmobiles, ATVs and dirt bikes, that might significantly impact positively on Alberta's and Canada's carbon budget.