Gary: The public school do the same things with challenging students that you just accused Marist of doing. Why do you think so many people struggling in public schools go to chartered schools and online schools? Your position that people who earn high levels of income aren't entitled, don't have a right, to their own income is troubling to me because it displays no understanding of the right to property that is fundamental to free people everywhere. So, since I value the right of people to choose what they do and to keep their own stuff, it is hard making sense of arguments that don't value those principles. Like I wrote in another comment, private schools already make efforts and scholarships available to people without high income. Vouchers would increase that.