My position regarding subsidies is not based on prejudice. My position regarding subsidies is based on economics. 

I'm struggling to see either baby or bathwater in Transnet. 

If the MTR is a public/private corporation, and it runs its show for profit, and it works, why don't we try the same thing here? Would that be throwing out the baby with the bathwater, or would that be solving a similar problem with a similar solution than they did over there?