Travis,

That isn't "right wing logic," it's just logic. Do you have any evidence of a -positive- case for registries of firearm owners? Can you point to statistically significant, or even numerically meaningful, cases in any country where such registries were ever used for any public safety purpose other than allowing for confiscation?

Can you point to a Federal government database of personal information that hasn't been compromised in recent years? Often multiple times? Do you acknowledge that such databases can and have been politicized and weaponized against those out of favor with the powers that be even recently?

Heck, take a look at the Small Arms Survey estimates of compliance in countries with invasive gun control laws and show me how there is enough compliance to make them useful.

As for "no one wants your guns," fact is, confiscation is -exactly- what such registries were used for in the UK and AUS, whose laws gun-controllers say are "reasonable" and we should emulate.