Lisa, 1. as I recall the City Ethics executive director Chuck Totto cleared the luau from any ethics violations. 2. The list of donors was disclosed because I saw it in the StarAdvertiser or Civil Beat. 3. PRP's involvement four years ago was not pay to play. PRP was not going after non-bid city contracts. 4. Can you please name one pay to play non-bid contract handed out by the city during the past four years.