If I were Jeff Bridich, this is what I do:

Prioritize re-signing Lucroy, McGee, Neshek and Blackmon (on an extension). None of those players will break the bank, all seemed good in the clubhouse and all had pretty strong seasons overall.

I loved Cargo and Reynolds and enjoyed watching Holland in the first half, but there's not a super compelling reason to bring any of them back, sorry. Farewell Chatwood and Hanigan.

The Rockies have all the starting pitching they can handle for now (weird, right?) and I think they should choose between McGee, Estevez and Senzatela for the closer role.  Mike Dunn could also be in the mix. A darkhorse: free agent Zach Britton.

I'd like to see a bounce back year from Desmond, but I don't want him affixed to a certain position. He should be the Rockies' Ben Zobrist, starting 3 to 4 games a week in that role bouncing between the outfield, 1st base and shortstop. The starting outfield should be Parra, Blackmon and David Dahl/or Raimel Tapia.