Nate:  I always take questions seriously...opinions too.  Therefore, I did a quick google on "agnostic"  Here's a common definition I found: "a person who believes that nothing is known or can be known of the existence or nature of God or of anything beyond material phenomena; a person who claims neither faith nor disbelief in God."  

Donald Rumsfeld famously said "There are things we know and know we know.  There are things we know and don't know we know. There are things we don't know and know we don't know. There are things we don't know and don't know we don't know.  For me, the existance or non existence of God, god or gods is something I "don't know and know I don't know.".......sure sounds a lot like being an agnostic to me.  

Regards, and may God,god or gods (if there is one...or more) bless you,  Gary Crum