" I am still not sure if it is opinion or fact that “Hillary is a criminal” if she has not been convicted. (tongue in cheek)."  And the Court's opinion is seriously unhelpful.  Until we actually define 'criminal',  provability is impossible.  On another thread, several of us used both definitions from two separate dictionaries.  When the Supreme Court says:  “...crooked” does not suggest that Liles was seriously maintaining that Neumann had, in fact, committed a crime", certainty is lost.