It's a very complicated issue that others have already written words on here and elsewhere.  IMHO, comments here are best based on quick points - not big essay, deep topic discussions.  I will say this, the solution involves a lot more than saying whether we should cut more trees or not.  It gets down to the very foundation of how our society believes we should interact with the natural world.  'Give and take' is part of the natural process, but there's a balance.  Our culture (not just the economy and not just forestry) is way beyond that balance.  Unless that changes, it's all band-aids on a bigger issue and I wouldn't expect much change toward the healthier direction.