Fortunately,  MacIntyre has plenty of integrity. By reporting direct ear-witness evidence of purported conduct regarding a person who, for 3 years, flew out to be with her boyfriend,  to his direct supervisor, even though no police reports accessible to him, not any reports of any arrests corroborating her story, he did all that he could do. He CERTAINLY couldn't have contacted law enforcement, as then the evidence would have become hearsay, even in a preliminary phase, not could he have terminated Tumpkin, as that would have given Tumpkin Carte Blanche to sue the school for unlawful termination, since he was not an at-will employee and had extrajudicial rights to due process embedded in his contract. MacIntyre gets as A+ across the board for doing everything right,regardless of the double talk that the regents just spewed upon him. Had Tumpkin been fired, with only the alleged facts known, people would be complaining of the massive payout which he would have, undoubtedly, reaped.