"Free trade has brought us affordable consumer goods..." Affordable if you have more money than is required just to survive. A benefit to the middle class, not so much for the working class, which has lost jobs and got stuck with low wages.

Yes automation has destroyed jobs and will probably destroy many more, but the trade deals have also done damage and I don't think they were ever necessary. I'm glad the TPP appears to be dead. I also think that "free trade" has really been more about increasing the power of transnational corporations than about trade. 

One of the few things Trump said that I agree with is that trade deals like NAFTA have allowed US corporations to move their factories to other, low-wage countries and then import the goods back into the US. That's not trade with other countries, it's "trade" with ourselves.