Well, a fair share will be something more than nothing. Currently there are hundreds of North Slope workers who take their money back to the lower 48, Puerto Rico, Mexico, Thailand.  These folks may buy a hamburger and a beer in the Anchorage airport, but that's the only money they leave in Alaska.  Same thing with the Bristol Bay salmon fishers, and the factory processors and trawlers.  All of these migrant workers benefit from Alaska and do nothing to support it.  Why not impose an income tax that is equal to the PFD?  Everybody pays but Alaskan residents get it refunded via the PFD.  With some skin in the game people will be less inclined to ask the State to fund every desire they have.  Nobody rides for free.