Season 1: 8.5/10 Season 2: 8/10 Season 3: 6.5/10 (but that may be too harsh, I seem to be in the minority)

Season 1 was great; it had heart, good pacing, and showed a lot of potential. You cared about the characters, and the show took risks that I've never seen other shows pull off. Mostly intense violence, but also the impact that the violence caused on our characters. It wasn't senseless violence; but forewarned, there is plenty of it in this show.

Season 2 was good, but it's rating is likely inflated because it was coming after a good season 1 and it didn't fall flat. There was still promise and potential within the show.

Season 3 was overly stale and formulaic. Here's the formula: shocking gory scene; shocking sexual scene; Homelander acting crazy but never even doing anything; redundant friction between Hughie and Butcher; and on-the-nose attempts at portraying woke BS as satire, but it fell real flat for me. Pacing was off, it was often boring, and honestly nothing really even happened. We are nearly in the same place we were at the end of season 2. A big MEH for season 3.