Well, this was at least something different. The Lighthouse surely is quite original and I understand if some people love the visual style and atmosphere. But also if some will find it unpleasant and too strange.

What I first noticed is the picture aspect ratio. It's shaped like in old tv's, almost like a square. I found this detail both creative and annoying, feeling as if something is blocking the view. Also the characters and the setting made me feel uncomfortable, almost depressing in the beginning. I thought the whole film is going to be just a pain to watch.

Then I started to enjoy a bit because the characters started to unfold a bit and the acting was so good. I loved the weird rants and monologues the characters occasionally threw against each other. That was the best aspect of the film. And Willem Dafoe is a perfect face for a bearded old sailor! (Perfectly creepy that is.) And of course the visual side was quite nice. The lighthouse in black and white gave quite eerie feel, and the directing camerawork was quite good.

The weakest part was maybe the story. Is there a story? Does it mean anything? I didn't really understand the ending which was a bit disappointing. More than a traditional story the whole movie was more like an abstract series of scenes. I was also deceived a bit because I expected a horror film. Well, it can be vaguely put into the category of psychological horror/thriller but even that feels a bit stretch. I'd say it's just a weird artistic psychological (supernatural) drama or something.

Not entirely my cup of tea but I some give credit for trying something wildly creative.