Imtiaz Ali did a very good job both in the concept and the direction. It is not often hard to find editing or concept flaws in Hindi movies. This one surely was an odd case. Many instances one would feel that Karina's character was over acted and some qualities exaggerated but in fact the story *is* about a character that odd.

It's a fun-filled movie. Some jokes, some situations and most characters fit in well with the story. If you are kind who likes a decent movie unlike the item songs types now-a-days, then this is for you. Also, if you like movies that have a little bit of both comedy and melancholy at the same time, then this is for you. If you are the kind who like family oriented movies with a touch of Indian culture, then this is for you. It's worth giving a try - sober yet entertaining.