The only persons rating this high are Gaga fans happy to hear & see her. And for those who like me see Gaga as just a continuation of artists like Spears and Madonna, we can't see what the big deal is with the music either. The movie is in a category similar to The Bodyguard from 1992, but the older movie has much better singing and acting and story. Still The Bodyguard has only a 6.2 rating. Go figure.