Overrated is my opinion. Yes, aspects of the film are good, especially after you make it through the first hour. Al Pacino is easily the best thing about it, making the most of his role and the way he delivers his dialogue. But the film wasn't something that kept my interest (in fact, I found it difficult to get into and stay into). I understand the contrast they were going for with going out with a bang vs. going out with a whimper, but that isn't exactly something that entertains me.

That being said, I did find the first hour of this film unintentionally hilarious, and a perfect demonstration proving the argument that the whole de-aging fad that's going on now, even if it was done flawlessly from a special effects perspective to where you really can't tell that it's CG (and I'm not going to say this film succeeded on that, it was very hit and miss), you cannot have an old actor play as a young person (or even middle-aged). How DeNiro was always walking and moving stiffly, and that absolutely hilarious sequence where he beats up the deli worker. I haven't had such an unintentional good laugh at something so sincere in a long while. Hence to say, this film isn't fooling anyone when it comes to be convincing with these 70+ year old actors trying to play guys in their 30s-40s.

If this is to be a send-off film for these actors and the major films of the past they've been in, at least it's sent off and done with.