Many people here giving 10's did that based on 1 or So episodes.

Mine is based on the first 6 episodes.

Im a big fan of the games. And I while I had slight hope after episode 1, the differences are just too much.

I love episode 3 as a standalone episode for the Walking Dead, but it does not fit in a small season with so much to tell, Bill was a 10 minute character in the game, afterwards we do not hear or see anything of him, just like in the show. But still we spend a full ep on him.

In general the world is empty, lack of feeling in danger.

You did not have to take every action scene of the game, but you left out so much of them. One would allost forget they live in an infected world!

Bella is great, not as Ellie tho.

Pedro is great, but his Joel isnt that cold as Joel was in the first game. Certainly seeing the dinner with Bill in a flashback. No way!

I fear next week episode will not give me the evolution Ellie is about to undergo. But we will see.

6/10.