Disney gets a little too goofy for my tastes. Depp's lines weren't really all that funny and niether was a lot of the other unnessecary comic relief... that is unless you were 12 year old or younger. Which is really what this movie is meant for anyway, the kids of summer looking for a good swash buckling Disney flick so they can play pretend pirates in the back yard with their friends. Nice special effects, decent plot, bad characters and couple of decent fight scenes make for a 6 outta 10 in my book.