1. never compare 2 shows, they are totally different, the story is different, different feeling. 2.all toughts about a perfect show are irelevant and relative based on our capacity of thiniking and base of knowledge. 3.a 10 star show doesn t reflect a perfect show, perfection doesn t exists, or it s something totally different from what we belive it should be. 4.I like the show, the actors have good acting, especially Geralt and Yen, less the bard. 5.what i think it s missing from this show are the special effects used in fights against monsters...it really doesn t give you any feeling at all, also it misses the plots found in game when Geralt is investigating a crime scene, finding the guilty..etc. They are focusing only on main story, but they shortened it. 6.No thunderbolt, no ridding Roach, no Gwent..., no driniking.....it s like the show it s a compilation from the books which shows only esential story, that s bad. No gathering ingredients, I think because they don t have good graphics at creating monsters, they avoid presenting contracts that must be solved by Geralt. They could have done 1 episode where he went to a crypt, fought some Alghouls, maybe finding better equipement,,,only 1 from the 8, and it would have made a huge difference. Overall it s a good show but it s missing a lot from what the game had.