It's 2-3 out of 10, and that is because of 2 or 3 good original songs with solid performance from Gaga. I am surprised at the fractured plot, just badly written dialogs and simply awful work with the camera almost half of the film - one-handed camera wabbling al the time ( who uses that 2019 ). And many scenes where camera is positioned directly in front of a window and you can hardly see the actors - this is pure amateur stuff. Bradly Cooper didn't convince me as an alocholic. His job in The Hangover was far better and this is not joke. If someone can edit out all except singing scenes, it will be far more watchable.