So where to begin? Let me start off by saying that the 1st 2 episodes were very solid and I had the show rated at around a 9 or 10 based on those. Then they decided to add a supernatural element to the show which defies all logistics and takes away the mystery and suspense from the audience. I enjoy it when we, the audience, get to be involved in the story and play detective just like the lead characters. Based on what I've seen so far, there is no way the show can deliver a reasonable and logical explanation at this point. So instead of playing detective, we now have to put our tinfoil hats on and guess at what kind of demon or ghost or entity this thing is. The reason why I'm slightly disappointed and shocked is because this is unlike most gritty HBO crime dramas (True Detective, The Night Of, etc). It seems that the book readers are pleased, but people who just want a good coherent story, at an appropriate pace, are a bit displeased. I felt that this show was on the right track by throwing us off with "conflicting evidence" and flashback reveals, but I was still expecting an end result within the realm of reality. Now that I can assure you that this is out of the picture, I personally can't give this show anything more than a 7. Cheers