The cinematography was fantastic, and the black and white instantly builds the setting. Dafoe has a tremendous performance, and Pattinson is great although his accent is hit-or-miss.

From the opening minutes it felt like the tension was building and building, but in the end the payoff wasn't quite there.

I'm all for films being creative and open for interpretation, but this felt like style over substance. It wound up being too mysterious for its own good.