There are too many reviews on this film that either hate it or love it. I don't agree with either.

Direction and Cinematography: Very good.

Music and sound effects: Very good.

Story and plot: Good, suspenseful but with flaws. This type of film could have gone for 100% realistic and strive for perfection, rather than try and be 50% realistic and 50% Hollywood-fun-but-fake, so as to try to allure audiences from both sides.

Acting: I have to say mediocre. I can't but compare Sandra Bullock to Sigourney Weaver in Alien. A strong female battles for survival. Well let's just say I wish this film was made back in the 80's.To be fair Bullock is very good in the movement part of her role.

P.S. No way is this the best film made in space Mr Cameron!