For me, why it got so high of a review when others considered it an average film, was because I didn't compare it to the first knives out movie. Instead of considering whodunit, just enjoy the film! Go along with the plot where Rian Johnson takes us, writing by writing, each shot by each shot. If not, you'll never enjoy the film as it is. And after watching the film, you'll probably enjoy the whole ride and forget that you're supposed to find the murder HAHA. Hope you'll sincerely find it enjoying. If you don't well, it's an acquired taste. I find this film to be a truly mind boggling film I watch in awhile :) Hope this is helpful.