I'm one of those viewers who tuned in for the cast. The first trailer looked fun and promised nostalgia. If you loved Murder She Wrote, they claimed, you would fall in love with OMITB, too. And the first episode really did it for me, it sparked an interest. The rest of the season then and its conclusion was often a bit too much for my taste. And yet I tuned in for season 2. The cast, you know... and an initial plot that had me hooked once again. Funny enough, as I'm typing this now, I don't actually remember what the story or who the culprit was in the end. And there's a reason for that: the way that season ended. It really left me wanting more. And the way they wrapped up that new case in season 3? Absolutely fabulous. That season is truly my favorite! The cast (as always with some wonderful additions to the main trio), the setting, the songs, the humor and yet another finale that has me waiting for the next season with glee. Such a slow burn sensation for me. For others it was an immediate hit and I'm truly grateful for that.