"Only Murders in the Building" embarks on a delightful journey, blending fantastic writing, surprising chemistry among the leads, and well-developed supporting characters. With high production values and witty dialogue peppered with slapstick humor, it promises an enjoyable watch.

Season 1 introduces us to a trio of murder-podcast aficionados investigating a homicide in their upscale apartment building. Steve Martin and Martin Short shine with their comedic prowess, complemented by Selena Gomez's refreshing performance. Despite Gomez's nasal voice, the trio's dynamic keeps viewers engaged, making the series binge-worthy.

The first season captures the essence of New York City with its quirky characters and witty banter. It's a light-hearted romp with a sprinkling of mystery and drama, reminiscent of classic comedy-mystery series like "Monk" and "Jonathan Creek." While not groundbreaking, it offers good, honest fun that earns its 9-star rating.

However, Season 2 struggles to recapture the magic, stumbling with clumsy humor and a jarring guest appearance by Amy Schumer. Although it eventually finds its footing, it treads familiar ground, failing to match the originality of its predecessor.

Season 3, unfortunately, sinks further, losing its charm and coherence. Steve Martin's character becomes caricatured, and Selena Gomez's performance lacks the spark of earlier seasons. The once-engaging mystery devolves into nonsensical motives, leaving viewers disappointed.

Despite its uneven trajectory, "Only Murders in the Building" remains a commendable effort, buoyed by its standout first season. While subsequent seasons may falter, the series' initial brilliance ensures it's a must-watch for fans of comedy mysteries, offering a tantalizing blend of suspense, humor, and quirky characters.