While Lady Gaga's singing is better-than-ok, her acting ability leavea much to be desired. That being said, this 2018 version can't come even close to the original with Judy Garland, or the first remake with Barbara Streisand (which many feel was between than the original). While both Garland & Streisand were excellent in BOTH their acting AND singing abilities, Lady Gaga should consider sticking with just singing.