1 star: Visually, very interesting.

1 star: Thing

As narrative, it's a train wreck, in three parts.

Character: No character, student or otherwise seems to have any genuine motivation or development, other than tired TV-14 teenage angst versus hormones. There are no shades of gray here, only giant strokes of good or evil (eg, normies versus outcasts). The one exception I'd say would be Thing - admirable projection of emotion and agency.

Story: a good mystery should have enough clues presented slyly enough for a clever viewer to engage and ask questions. None of that is here - it's just baffle 'em with BS and hope no one asks too many uncomfortable questions. Truly some head shaking moments in the last few episodes.

Credibility: build a world, play by its rules. Is Wednesday a mini-sociopath, or just a misunderstood girl? Is this a world in which murder is a thing to be admired, or reviled? Is Wednesday really an anti-hero?

I endured this with my GF, who enjoyed it. Wednesday doesn't know what it wants to be.

Final thought: