I really wanted to love this film, and I do feel guilty rating it at 6/10. All 6 points are for the cinematography. Visually it was a stunning film, the scene with George MacKays character running through the ruined town was breathtaking, a real triumph. But in my opinion the acting from the two main characters let the film down. Both were just a bit flat, and when things happened to each it was difficult to connect and empathise with them.

Maybe my expectations were too high. I would never tell people not to watch 1917, I just can't imagine I'll go back for a second try.