Its a solid movie but certainly not a material for an Oscar award. The crowd who was exhilarated are nothing more then a Gagas fans. She didnt show any acting skills and she sang one song over and over again. No chemistry, zero emotions from her. I gave 2 stars just because of Bradleys performance which was ok. If there wasnt for him, i would give 1 star. When you sum up its nothing more than a bland and extremely overhyped remake.