It was a 9 star rating for me with Season 1, but after watching season 2 it went down to a 6 for me. It seemed like I wasn't watching What if? Season 2, it felt like I was watching the Peggy Carter show... like what if Peggy Carter did this, then this, and this, this too, also this... it was nice and all but like there are thousands of other characters with a multitude of possibilities and you choose the same Captain Carter do several things in a row... it wasn't "what if", it was more like "and this". Aside from that, the stories weren't too bad, but it had advertised as a what if show, and it wasn't for more than half the season.