We watched this evening and were stunned by how below average the film was. Shocked given the reviews. I think we watched a different movie or the reviewers are all trying to be nice. Big fans of Lady Gaga and Bradley Cooper we are but this was slow, uneventful predictable and not even with good costume design and choreography. While we are sympathetic to the creative process, this seems to us to be uncreative and marginal in every way, sad to say. So this is all show and no substance