This is basically a remake of the far superior Barbra Streisand version with a few little tweaks and changes but it relies heavily on the aforementioned. They did a clever job hiding Lady Gaga's so-so acting capabilities by cutting away from the heavier emotional sheets and using a lot of wide shots. Her scene in the bathtub is downright awkward and I found myself almost laughing out loud at her delivery. Incredibly overrated. There were obviously incentives given for the over the top reviews it received.