I read the books and finished the game 4 times... Yes, I am not happy that Cavil exited the show. Yes, I think something is dubious there and that is NOT Cavil. I read all the bad reviews of the 3rd season and I thought it would be bad.

It was not. I actually thought it was the best season so far. I really enjoyed mostly everything about it. It was trilling, it got emotional and everything was really well implemented from writing, acting, special effects, the witcher monster thirst was also satisfied.

It is an absolute shame that Cavil will not join the 4th season, but it would also be an absolute shame if the show would be cancelled at this point.