After watching the show I can understand and appreciate why the critics are divided on this one. The writing is generally good but inconsistent. The storytelling varies from fascinating to convoluted. Characters often behave in nonsensical ways. Several the details of the plots are rushed or glossed over which can add a feeling of contrivance. The time-jumps can be confusing at first, although it is unavoidable given the season was based on collection short stories. The world building, while groundbreaking by the standards videogamers are used to, is rather simplistic compared to the giants of fantasy literature.

But whatever flaws it has, is redeemed by excellent production values, endearing and outstanding performances by the cast, and the fascinating central premise of the mutant-monster-hunter-investigator.

Henry Cavill has permanently become Geralt of Rivia. If being Superman was not enough, this performance should ensure that Cavill remain an enduring beloved icon among the nerds. Veterans like Burring or May are as good as one could hope. Anya Chalotra, however, is the breakout star. Much like her character, she displayed charisma, ease and nuance worthy of someone well beyond her years. It is pretty ironic given a small-minded subset of the fanbase tried to get her removed from the cast because of imaginary skintone mismatch.

While the overarching plot is good enough to be invested in, it is the monster-hunter bits that I found most fascinating. There is a lot of potential there for mixing elements of folklore, fantasy, horror and mystery in the vein of classics like X-files, and for some philosophical musings about the definition of a monster. I would love to see a few self-contained episodes each season dedicated to the monster hunting.

Ultimately it is a question of whether one would like to see more of this show just as it is? I most certainly do. With the evident success of this season, I am sure the show-runners will be more confident at telling their story at a more consistent pace, introduce more popular faces, and do even better.