Season One hits a 7 or 8 as fans of the books and games get to see the Witcher on screen. Superbly cast by Henry Cavill. Soundtrack, cinematography, cgi, atmosphere etc all appeared to be nailed tight. I questioned some of the casting decisions which becomes more of a hinderance as the seasons progress.

Season Two becomes above average at a 6. You could see the gradual distance growing from the source matter. Poor casting of Triss and Jennifer starts to become glaringly obvious.

Season Three was atrocious. No wonder Henry wanted out. Script was woeful and the show tries to be too clever than it is at times. Theres an episode where they play the same scene from the view of about 7 different people and another episode of siri alone doing monologues. Just draws out the season and leaves the viewers dumbfoundingly bored. 2 out of 10

I wont be watching season 4 unless I hear that it has truly progressed beyond the drivel i just watched.

With all seasons combined you'd struggle to give this beyond a generous 4.