Producers have acknowledged they stole the whole idea for this episode from a short film called Noah. So what's the shouting about? It was a cliché-filled story (she was in the basement all along, but no one thought to look thereHER ROOM!) in a shiny package they stole. And brought to you by Apple! This is the all too sad pattern of most good shows. They start believing in themselves after a point and think they can serve any old thing up and we will love them. Yes the package here was a keen one, but credit there goes to some filmmakers from Oregon who came up with it. The writing here, which used to be the meat and potatoes of this show, is very weak. Sorry to see a good show resort to gimmicks instead of hard work.