First of all, I love Robert and William and their ability to infuse into their roles.

Several moments in the movie, I forgot they were actors.

Insanely good.

I love the black/white since it can make movie somehow deeper and/or more gritty.

Great stuff!

With that said, I think reviewers have given the film a good rating so that they do not look stupid or unintelligent.

Same thing with Us but that's another review.

The movie is not one of the greatest movies ever, it's medicore and could have been so much more; The string of HP Lovecraft could have been imfused with much more delecaty and it's a shame.