You can just tell from the second half of this film Rian Johnson is the kind of guy you would HATE anyone uncovering his mistery so he can shove us how "clever" he is, and in order to do so while subverting our every expectation of the whodunit genre he bended my suspension of disbelief so hard it broke into little pieces, like my initial enjoyment. The plot is so overly contrived it REEKS of tryhard.

The point of a mystery is to be solved or at least attempted to be solved. It makes the viewer interact all the more with the movie. This is possible when the clues are not too much for it to be too obvious or too scarse to be impossible. Then he goes to foreshadow the guilty person but nope!, guess what, that mystery is already solved within half an hour and, wait a minute, another mystery is rising!, wait, now?, yes, and it's impossible to solve but hey, good detective that seemed useless 90% of the movie turned out to know everything from the start, well how good is that.......

This is anything but a whodunit. I felt cheated. 6/10