This movie sucks, and here is why:

1. The dialouge sucks: When the characters talk to each other it is difficult to hear what they are both saying. Is it an attempt to make it more realistic? Maybe, but if so it failed because people do not have full conversations on top of each other without stopping to let the other person finish.

2. Random nude scenes Lady Gaga is naked twice in this movie, fo no appearent reason. There is a full body shot of her naked body. Why? This isnt game of thrones, no one needed or expected nudity, its very out of place for a movie like this.

3. Plot is inconsistent It is hard to explain, but the movie makes no sense. When does this all take place? How many years, months or even weeks have passed? And the storyline about Bradley Coopers family is just barely explored. I would have felt much more compassion if I copletely knew the relationship between his brother, father and him. But they just barely talk about it, so it makes no sense and adds less than it is supposed to to the story.

4. The ending is weird and out of place The ending is a "plot twist" of some sorts, but it just happens. With no build up, no real reason and no explanation. What the hell?

5. Cringe moments Dont like romantic cringe moments, dont watch this movie