I hate to be so negative about this film, but actually I think this is so overrated. This is probably because everyone focuses on Lady Gaga the first time as an actor in a big movie. Her performance is good, yes, but I think, we all expected that. But anyway, fairly said, she is the highlight of the film, but only a mediocre one. The story isn't surprisingly new, what is no wonder for a re-re-re-make. Bradley Cooper is perfomaning well, as always, but his role stays very one-dimensional. Him directing as well surprised me though. The movie has no dynamic, as a viewer you don't no where it's heading, and the only music is on-stage which is slowing everything down even more. I'm sorry to say, but one of the films I regret seeing in 2018.