Yes, the plot was weird (but I actually think it has more to do with the cutting than the plot itself) And yes there were lots of things totally absurd that made my inner potterhead cringe. But I found the cast (especially Johnny Depp and Jude Law) really good and the soundtrack was dazzling. I liked the fact that it was dark.

It made me want to see more of it. Can't wait for the next one (but hope it will clear things a little because this one raised many questions.).