Its not as bad as 1/10 or as good as 10/10.

good parts: henry cavil, fight choreography and lot of locations are really good. dandelion is funny :D

bad parts: writing and character building is mediocre. wish they didnt cram so many major plot lines just in 1 season and took time in world building. (this is my major gripe and i am sure this why lot of people are having issue with the show )

also show never tells how witchers and magic users dont age like normal people in the starting episodes but they use timejump story telling where henry and yenn looks the same in both the timeline. i think newcomers to the show will get confused.

They did not do a good job with Yenn + geralt plotline. i never bought any of it and most of it makes no sense if u think in geralt's perspective in this show. they could have spent more time on it developing that arc as its really important. as a result there was no chemistry between those 2.

costume design and CGI is mixed bag for me. nilfgardian armor is pretty much a joke and might annoy lot of people. sword fights and simple human battles are really well made but monster fights are hit or miss.

i honestly thought they could have avoided lot of spectacle and saved budget in 1st season and setup the world lot better than this.