To continue... they like a movie if a reviewer has given it 5 star and dislike if a reviewer gives it 1 star. Don't you guys know professional reviewers have to survive in the industry they cant afford to offend a big shot director, even if he make a crap like this.

So the review starts The movie is trying to make a point that a person will get more satisfaction if he comes back to his "Motherland" and help poor people. This is absolutely wrong message. A laymen will like it because he will get one more scientist burning his nights for his benefit in his Mother India but the argument is flawed

1. Scientists are a citizen of the world, they are the torchbearers of a generation.Politicizing them on the basis of country is like politicizing elections on the basis of religion

2. Indian scientific community is in the trap of bureaucracy. a person who wants to make some real contribution to science and concentrate solely on his work rather than politics will never come back and should not come back to India (especially if he is in one of the worlds greatest institution like NASA).

3. The direction is lackluster, no grip, no anticipation, everyone knows this loser will come back to India from the very first scene of the movie ( it is obvious he doesn't have a life in the states, here in his village people gave him some attention, and he is so desperate to get it that he leaves everything. Not to mention the girl probably the only one he ever and will ever touch )and still it , drags on and on for unthinkable point of time.

4. This is a cheap, no, pardon me, a cruel attempt to play with the emotions of naive people. not to mention the pain it causes the Indian scientific diaspora and their family members who are actually making a real contribution to science abroad.

5. The emotions of Shah Rukh are not as good under the direction of Asitosh Gowariker, as it were under Bhansali, he can not even touch his performance that he gave in Devdas

Pleas people apply some reason and logic instead of emotion to judge an idea. As for the movie, don't go by the name but by the performance