Good story that is fun to follow - 1/2 Star

Memorable dialogue - 1 Star

Feel a pull to watch it a second time - 0 Stars

Music/Score stands out - 1/2 Star

No noticeable plot holes - 1/2 Star

Story gets resolved in some way - 1/2 Star

I personally like the story - 0 Stars

Memorable likable characters - 1 Star

Most things about the story are believable - 1 Star

Doesn't get boring - 0 Stars

This is a really cool time piece that seems extremely accurate and is loosely based on the actual tragedy back near 1900. It is shot in a very unique eye catching way with Pattinson and Dafoe really getting into the spirit of their characters. Sadly for me the story was extremely hard to follow at times, and the lighthouses secrets are never really revealed which led to the score above.