Pros: 1. The score is utterly magical with its quintessentially Italian feel which adds so much depth to the film. 2. The movie does a masterful job at creating a stifling atmosphere of tension and suspense, even with just the long silences and dialogue. 3. The set and costume design is brilliant, especially Michael Corleones' (Al Pacino) suits which just scream power. 4. The production is mind-blowing, particularly considering the scope of the film. 5. The transitions between the past and the present are perfect as they never miss a beat. 6. The violence feels incredibly raw and grounded in its execution which serves to harden its impact. 7. The scene where Fredo Corleone (John Cazale) comes clean to Michael Corleone about his betrayal is amazingly acted, particularly in regards to John Cazale, and it's exceedingly emotional. 8. Robert De Niro (Vito Corleone), Al Pacino, and John Cazale give phenomenal performances. 9. The ending sequence, like the one in the first film, masterfully ties everything together.

Cons: 1. The movie skips over Michael Corleone's first 7 years as the Don, but it would have been great to watch him in action after he took up his father's mantle.