loyal_driver 
1999 Toyota Corolla Sedan LE 4dr Sedan
can't go wrong
 Bought mine as a left over in early 2000 -- somebody had returned it with about 2,000 miles logged and traded up.  Has nearly all the options except (alas) ABS.  It now has close to 80k miles on it and nothing has ever broken.  I love this car, and it has convinced me that when the time comes that I have to pry myself away from it, only another Toyota (Lexus/Scion) product will do. 