Jake 
2008 Nissan Frontier King Cab SE 4dr King Cab 6.1 ft. SB (4.0L 6cyl 5A)
Hot Rod Nissan
 Just like almost everyone else writing here, it was between the Tacoma and Frontier for me.  Always wanted a Tacoma, until I drove the Frontier. More options for $2000 less than the Tacoma, more interior room, bigger engine, 4-wheel discs, and traction control.  The engine revs like my dad's G35, I had to get out and check under the hood to make sure it wasn't the same engine.  Nope, just the same technology.  The truck also rides much sportier than the Tacoma, again, makes me feel like I am driving that Infiniti again.  I am getting between 17-18 MPG around town going from work and back, but I also don't hammer on it.  