Liz H 
2010 Nissan Versa Hatchback 1.8 SL 4dr Hatchback (1.8L 4cyl CVT)
Picked after trying all the others!
 My husband and I tried every other hatchback and station wagon under $20,000 (including some used) before deciding on the Versa. We tried both the S and SL hatchback and chose the SL because it has much smoother acceleration, iPod hookup, and VDC and stability control (great in the snow!).  So far, the car has been a joy. Handling is responsive  but not too stiff.  Some of the other hatchbacks felt like "kid cars" to us, but the Versa is roomy, with the most backseat space for a carseat to fit if needed.  If you get the hatchback, make sure to purchase the $130 cargo organizer for a level load floor with bins below.