Zippy 
2006 Toyota Corolla Sedan XRS 4dr Sedan (1.8L 4cyl 6M)
Over 3 years and I'm still giddy
 I test drove the Civic and the Corolla, and the Corolla was faster, tighter and got better mileage.  I still wanted something quicker and tried the XRS.  It was WELL worth the extra money.  I LOVE driving this car!  That said, the power curve is not at all smooth and I've adjusted how I drive to compensate.  You almost have to plan ahead.  I put a graphite gear shifter knob on it which really improved my ability to "feel" the gears and shift with accuracy.  The car pushes a little around corners, but I guess that's safer than the alternative.  I didn't know it only took premium until after two tanks of regular.  I don't like paying more for gas, but it's still worth it.